Added: 2 years ago
From: misskathryn17
Views: 11,814
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (62)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • <3 Thanks Kathryn

  • Meats is way better.

  • James can sing check out Sixx AM and ur so schooled

  • To those complaining that James can't sing. Do a quick search for Sixx:AM and be schooled.

  • Super!

  • James Michael can't even fuckin sing - its like talking... Meat's has so much more passion and feeling in the music

  • Anyone know where I can download James Michael's version? I definitely prefer this over Meat Loaf's version any day.

  • I like Meat Loafs version better it is just Rock n Roll to me this is... I don't know what this is.

  • This is only a demo version, but I like it more than Meat's and it is only my own opinion. Arguing which version is better doesn't make sense. Just for the record, James Michael is a great producer, player and also singer and if you don't know him and his work, don't publish your stupid comments about him. If you think he doesn't have good vocal skills, just listen to Sixx: A.M. and you will be suprised.

  • Comment removed

  • Best Version! ^___^ James is AMAZING <3

  • u stupid ppl james wrote/produced the damn song FOR meatloaf. ITS A DEMO. look into it. apparently the loaf dnt even write their own songs?

  • smoke a spliff then listen to this....way better than the over produced meat loaf track...which btw i also love

  • finishing my point. I love Meats version by far over James. That being said i also love James version. It sound like a college frat band from the 60's. THAT IS COOL! Great Job James. Also goes to show you how great a song this really is. Prime example George Thorogood, has covered over 100 songs of old time Blues and R&B artists. Their songs are the original but GT adds a slide guitar & sax. Makes those old songs even better since Chuck Berry did not use slide or sax. Same songs different sound

  • WOW i cannot believe all the negativity towards James. Of course this version is not as polished as Meat Loafs. Meat loaf is big time muscians, and vocalist. James version is right out of his garage with his frat sounding buddies chiming in the background from the couch. That is the way he meant it to be. NOT RIGHT NOT WRONG. Just different. Look at how many songs the Beatles or Stones covered that are way better that the original Blues & R&B artists. Not better just polished.

  • This was actually painful to listen to. Meat Loaf was by far much better.

  • Sorry there James but Lou Reed already cornered the market on the monotone speaking vocal style. Better luck next time. Meat's version blows this one out of the water!

  • I hope meatloaf used some lube because dang he raped the crap out of this guy

    this is horrid

  • all one tune in the voice.......what a bad version zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzz

  • @youngelvisnightowls how can it be a "bad" 'version'....when this is the Guy who WROTE it... yes it's not as polished as Meats...but Meat can afford much better producers ...WHAT this shows is there are plenty of GREAT writers out there....this version has SOUL.but maybe not POP.but it took a good producer to recognise the tune for what it IS....and took it to Meat.....who made a Classic out of it..for me....I LOVE meats version.......but I also LIKE the original......it's RAW,an IDEA...:)

  • @WillCrazie Its not that James can't afford the good production, he just recorded this as a demo for meat loaf and produced, recorded, mixed, and played all the instruments for the song on this demo. and he also produced meat loafs version. so no matter what the version of the song, james gets the credit cause he wrote it.

  • @youngelvisnightowls James Michael recorded this song in his home studio, it was probably just a rough version to send to meat loaf. James wrote the song...he gets the credit for both versions!

  • @misskathryn17 dude (or dudette) how can you say Meat's version is awful, its way more better then this, james micheal sounds like a robot. Meatloaf (like any old singer) is a legend, more proof listen to bat out of hell. i dont think ukiki11 need their ears checked, i think you need a history lesson.

  • omg this is shite. meat loafs is way much better. least meat loaf gives it his hart n soul, this guy sucks big time ewwwwww enough after 1min bye sados

  • Meat Loaf's version is a lot better. He actually sings it whereas this guy is just blandly saying it... and its a lot more groovier than this one. Good move, Michael, giving it to Meat

  • please please please tell me meatloaf wrote it because this guy sucks and meatloaf is the man

  • is this a joke version or is this the actual James Michael version? Either way this is absolutely awful, you may not like Meat Loaf's version but you can't change the fact Meat Loaf actually sings on his version rather than talks and also Meat Loaf's version sold more. Usually I'm very open minded to other versions of songs as everyone puts their own interesting spin on things but this will be my first and last time listening to this.

  • @RockOn164 Meat Loaf's version sold more because James Michael never officially released it. It's also a totally absurd argument because James Michael wrote, sang and played on both versions. This isn't James Michael's unique spin on the song, both versions of the song are James Michael's spin on the song. Meat Loaf is a good singer, but he doesn't write his stuff.

  • @GuyWith2HazelEyes Not this song maybe, but he does write his own shit, and having heard both i like Meatloaf's better, it has that classic rock feel i like so much. This isn't bad though.

  • @GuyWith2HazelEyes Meat Loaf has never written his stuff. Hes always been about the singing and not the writing, and nobody has ever had a problem with that before. So why now?

  • how boring! meat rules :)

  • I cannot fathom how anyone can say meat loafs version is awful. I cannot understand that it is not even close to being awful. Actually it is amazing. This is just an original garage type version that is all. All Meat Loaf did was make it big production with many pieces louder guitars and great background singers. Same song different sounds. Actually as much as i love Meat Loafs version I still love this one it is a raw version. And there is something to be said about a simple raw version.

  • @LesSmith45 Isn't the background for Meat Loaf's version James?

  • @DrLtColPage Actually james is singing the background vocals for Meats version. If you listen to James background version he has different lyrics. Something about paying back but being to lazy. I love james verson too. It has the rough edgy sound.

  • Im sorry. But hes right. Meat Loaf is better. Check my acount for the song.

  • wow Meat's is soooooo much better

  • @ukiki11 you need to get your ears checked. JAMES MICHAEL is a MUCH MUCH MUCH better singer than Meat will ever be.

  • @misskathryn17 too all their likes, eh?

  • @misskathryn17 You have Got To Be Kidding, Meatloaf Is The Best.

  • @misskathryn17 I hate to rain on your parade, but for most of this song James Michael isn't actually singing. He's just talking, rhythmically. So if he's going to compare to other singers, he should probably try singing first.

    Just sayin...

  • @misskathryn17 that is a stupid statement. Come back to me when James has the fifth best selling album of all time like Meat Loaf has. I bet you can not even name one song the meat loaf does.

  • @misskathryn17 fucking bullshit... Meat Loaf's sounds like a song, and not like some redneck talking

  • @misskathryn17 You need to check your ears man :))

  • @misskathryn17 and @ukiki11 James wrote the song. I think that's the point here.

  • @misskathryn17 lol. how'd you work that out?

  • @ukiki11 First of all. James wrote the song and then sold it to Meatloaf, so it's not actually Meat's :P.

  • @ukiki11 It's spoken more than sung but there are aspects of both which are better but on the whole I think meat loaf's is better but I like the deaper tone to this one.

  • @ukiki11 james wrote it and did Backing vocals on meats version.

  • meats is way better

  • @TheLoosemen Agreed

  • where did you hear meats version!?

  • @preecejon

    It is on Meat's offical youtube page..

  • urgh! heard it. not v impressed and im a huge meat fan. loved bat 3...just hope the rest of teddy bear is better than this rubbish!

  • @preecejon totally agreed! I just listened to Meat's version and I was disgusted.

  • @misskathryn17 everyone seems to love it! i think its the totally wrong direction for meat to go in

  • u seein macca at IOW!? lol

  • I can't wait to see what Meat Loaf does with song...he's so amazing:P

  • hey how r you grt pix of james hes so fit lol xx

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more