I love it =) the onnnly thing that I don't like is when the trumpets long agate a part of the main melody in the piece - it makes it seem too smooth/slow, when compared to the original. Whoever composed the piece should had kept it at the rhythm as the original. But very - very nice, I really love it :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Oh this is poor. It's just the midi with a slightly better instrument set, but still absolutely piss poor. It even has all the faults found in the common midi versions. Aw man. My ears bleed!
I... uh... this thing is good, but there's a PILE of notes that are just OFF.
Gets a litle repetitive around the third cycle through as well. Could you not have shifted the melody to the woodwinds or something?
You need to go back and finish this thing. If you do NOTHING ELSE, for the love of God, sharp the last G on the end of the trumpet / brass melody before I choke your whole brass section!
Yeah but then again, I'm not Sonic The Hedgehog. He's pretty much calm and collected in the face of any danger. Even if he's plumiting thousands of feet from an exploding air-ship.
@throathero I like the zone. I like the original music. I don't like this. I like other orchestral arrangements of other video game music, but this one does not sound right.
@throathero I did. This was listed as a related video and since I like other orchestral arrangements of other music, I figured I'd give this a listen.
my god, they should remake sonic 1,2 and 3 into todays standards (3d and what not), with similar level layout, make it much harder, and remix all the old games music
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
holy shit that actually would make the sonic the hedgehog franchise a hella lot more popular and would put be a bunch of nostalgia for everyone you know and you know i would totally buy that in a heart beat also
this may sound weird, but don't you think a galaxy could have been made out of the marble zone stage for Super Mario Galaxy; with this remix? give me your thoughts.
Fire Bubble? The Fire Sheild wasn't in the games until Sonic The Hedgehog 3, are you sure your talking about the right game? Or are you talking about a hack of it?
*later discovers by READONG THE DESCRIPTION lol that this was user made*
Sorry for insulting the excerpt it's just that I forgot to read the description that says ir used orchestral like instruments. So I wouldn't have expected top of the range like music, though what you did made is way better than I could ever remake on software ever! I'm only good at playing my instruments, not converting it into software on the computer. Keep it up!
Oh I see. What software did you use if you don't mind me asking? If it shows notes for MIDI and MP3 files I'd find it most useful! Pretty smart idea mind you having just changed the instruments but surely the tempo is different too?
Hey, I actually played the game a few days ago, and I'm pretty sure that the note on 1:09 is about a half step off. Check it out?:) other than that I have no real complains to make, other than one mentioning that the notes between 0:05-0:09 (and repeatedly during the song) is a little slow (I think?).
Don't have the willpower to get out of my sofa and fetch my guitar to tell you the notes so you can understand what I mean:P
I let the keyboard play the midi ;) I dont play it :) Look at my "Weird World" and "Reality vs Imagination" Those are played by me... you can notice it by errors I did while playing ;)
Oops, I acidentally removed your comment instead of clicking on REPLY..lol
Well, you have to connect your keyboard to the computer using a MIDI cable or a USB(if possible) Then you have to set the keyboard as a default MIDI player or use Music maker like I do.
thanks for explaining, I will try to make that,because I have a keyboard,what I need is the program Magix and a way to connect the keyboard to the pc.
a valiant effort dude. but i had to stop after the first 10 seconds. one of the notes in the pickup is incorrect and the first string run that seperates the phrases uses the incorrect chord. just something to think about.
I do. But it's just the phone or computer
sonicthehedgehog2021 2 weeks ago
dont anyone else see that the picture is moving
mousee12345678910 3 weeks ago
@mousee12345678910 yes
tistifli 2 weeks ago
Bring so much memories
Mr2dnoodle 1 month ago
this should have been in sonic generations
sonicfanboyee 2 months ago
Sonic's expression is priceless, and it goes well with the music. Nice vid : )
flameringstudios 3 months ago
Much better then the old *tingle down spine* dumb version
DudeCrafter 3 months ago
Congratulations, loved it
SuperWorldQueen 4 months ago
Wow this is EPIC
SuperWorldQueen 4 months ago
i...i...i...i just...I JUST CAME
fccoper 4 months ago
Awesome remix
zombiefighter5 5 months ago
Epic.
PikachuDaBest 5 months ago
Needs piano
:)
JackATTACKss 5 months ago
@caasi91 this picture is originatly by Deviantart :D
DarkSpin777 5 months ago
not bad I've certainly heard worse on here.
CAM8689 6 months ago
VERY clever
PufflePower 6 months ago
very goooooooooooood
herrerorodriguez 6 months ago
I gotta admit... it sounds like you sucked out all the emotion from the song :(
thedonofnapoli 7 months ago
Sounds very good.
NonstopRam 7 months ago
Dude, You're not doing the main melody correctly.
PoLLasQuE 8 months ago
Gosh! it reminds me of The Legend of Zelda for sum reason..
AniseTheBloody 8 months ago 2
so many bum notes!
TazBuckfaster 8 months ago
Where did you find the music to this? I too want to do my own little transcription.
ThePoliticalMusician 8 months ago
Haha. This uses that old shitty MIDI with incorrect scale.
RAMPKORV 10 months ago
Awesome!
epicbunnystudio 10 months ago
this is most splendid
matchbox555 10 months ago
This has no life to it. Yuck. Still better than I could do though.
DopeteK 11 months ago
this is a fantastic remix
awesomeianTV 11 months ago
Sounds like final fantasy.
TheMarioluigifans 11 months ago 19
What orchestra vst did you use?
ZidaneTilAlexandros 1 year ago
This pic makes it look a bit more like a factory than ruins.... Oh well. Still a good pic with a great orchestrated rendition.
ultimateanimefighter 1 year ago
the timing seems rather off
tiftmasta 1 year ago
I like it has a groovy base line daddy-o
Earthium 1 year ago
That picture really brings to life just how insane riding a block on a sea of molten lava really is.
SeanNelsonIsTheBomb 1 year ago 36
I'd like to see the entire Sonic 1 & 2 catalogue done orchestrally. Love to see how Chemical Plant Zone would be interpreted.
ViceyThaShizzle 1 year ago
a bit flat, but you could make this really epic, I mean for a song this good people expect THE BEST.
bristles1000 1 year ago
lots of wrong notes...
morphender 1 year ago
@morphender yeah. that's awful to hear.
gokudomatic 1 year ago
nothing wrong with the taste, its could much be better
Sapov 1 year ago
ends kind of fast......
DrArchibaldo 1 year ago
38 people couldn't get past The Marble Zone when they were 8 year olds!
chrisreid1 1 year ago
Gee so many dislikes, what is wrong with the taste in music on lots of people? Great remake anyhow dude!
sybnios 1 year ago
I really enjoyed this version. I think you made it yours. This just goes to prove that video games can have enjoyable soundtracks.
ELOfan1982 1 year ago
This is beautiful!
metaldragon3303 1 year ago
The music is so beautiful!
I used to listen to classical music when I was little.
=D
CrnSal 1 year ago
what program did you use?
MetalSonicDash 1 year ago
I know it's a remake but you're missing some sharps here and there, it should be a harmonic minor key.
twiddle7125 1 year ago
legend of zelda much?
chiporskip 1 year ago
@chiporskip not really
metalsonic641 1 year ago
@metalsonic641 to me kinda
chiporskip 1 year ago
Beautiful !!!!!! Almost makes me want to cry ! SO many memories !
XjyujX 1 year ago
@XjyujX i no exactly how you feel!!!!!!!!!!!
reggin121 1 year ago
whats the name of the rapper who used samples of this theme for his song?
SalemJeanetteful 1 year ago
@SalemJeanetteful Charles Hamilton November 10th
ZerolockXXX 1 year ago
Your making me want to play the genesis games again!
dbzlotrfan 1 year ago
nice re-arrangement , used Fruity loop on the Midi file ?
Atrosincity 1 year ago
Indiana Sonic and The Lost Rings?
prinnyXdood 1 year ago 2
I love it =) the onnnly thing that I don't like is when the trumpets long agate a part of the main melody in the piece - it makes it seem too smooth/slow, when compared to the original. Whoever composed the piece should had kept it at the rhythm as the original. But very - very nice, I really love it :)
Castgurl101 1 year ago
@caasi91 YO MOMMA
LatinaAmante 1 year ago
this is kick ass and nice picture
SasukeDTA 1 year ago
Congratulation for your exelent job my friend ...parabéns ^.^
glaucowong 1 year ago
Sounds kinda like a Mario Paint Composer song
Nojical101 1 year ago
el tema de marble zone se tiene q toca rapido sino pierde la gracia, suena muy bien, pero lo malo es q es un poco lento.
TheVilla78 1 year ago
I feel like it loops way to much... well, still is a cool tune
Reuleu 2 years ago
Lol, sonic looks loke "Oh crud..." XD
TheSpriternumbertwo 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh this is poor. It's just the midi with a slightly better instrument set, but still absolutely piss poor. It even has all the faults found in the common midi versions. Aw man. My ears bleed!
satansam 2 years ago
0:24 - 0:25 way off key.
kingben821 2 years ago
And the accompaniment ?
That makes a huge terrible GAP...
Else, that's not bad.
jik7864 2 years ago
I... uh... this thing is good, but there's a PILE of notes that are just OFF.
Gets a litle repetitive around the third cycle through as well. Could you not have shifted the melody to the woodwinds or something?
You need to go back and finish this thing. If you do NOTHING ELSE, for the love of God, sharp the last G on the end of the trumpet / brass melody before I choke your whole brass section!
cabbitsd 2 years ago
Sonic looks pretty freaked.
millgiass 2 years ago
@millgiass Wouln't you be, if lava would almost cover your ass?
MrSambaboy 2 years ago
Yeah but then again, I'm not Sonic The Hedgehog. He's pretty much calm and collected in the face of any danger. Even if he's plumiting thousands of feet from an exploding air-ship.
millgiass 2 years ago
@millgiass You got me there. :)
MrSambaboy 2 years ago
You totally missed a note
sacredbanana 2 years ago 3
I love this!!!
japstoryeditor 2 years ago
Okay remix, but awesome picture.
MuhMuhMamaLuigi 2 years ago 31
This is terrible and I'm not really sure where to start.
jontycoleman 2 years ago 18
@jontycoleman u do better.
125sonicboom 1 year ago
@jontycoleman
It sounds like if it was being pumped out of a SNES.
heilong79 8 months ago
a bit too simplistic for my taste, but good.
that picture wins though XD
sonics all like "WTF!"
MischiefMeerkat 2 years ago 4
lol i cant even see what my comment was with all those thumbs down. i must have been drunk that day or something.
Mofoe2001 2 years ago
Not very good sound quality at all. This is orchestrated through a crappy General MIDI module. This sound is so 1994.
vstman 2 years ago 4
@vstman
That's why you download it.
iwoalolai 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
first - it sounds like some crap general midi.
second - you did no orchestral arrangements as well.
bottom line - not a remake and not orchestral.
just crap.
bombur792 2 years ago
I googled it :D
phoenixstorms9 2 years ago 12
@phoenixstorms9 most people thumbs down this video because they didn't like that zone good job on the video it's cool.
throathero 1 year ago
@throathero I like the zone. I like the original music. I don't like this. I like other orchestral arrangements of other video game music, but this one does not sound right.
Qaddosh 1 year ago
@Qaddosh then watch the original music.
throathero 1 year ago
@throathero I did. This was listed as a related video and since I like other orchestral arrangements of other music, I figured I'd give this a listen.
Qaddosh 1 year ago
the only thing about it i dislike is that it wouldnt be fast paced enough in Sonic xD
I have to agree with jrocker - It would work so goddam well in Skies of arcadia xD
iluvmaburaho 2 years ago
love it!
:-)
CaramelMamiChula 2 years ago
Sounds like Skies of Arcadia :3
jrockerkei 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wtf what a SHITTY mix! everybody knows those horns outta be replaced with an accordian. sounds horrible.
Mofoe2001 2 years ago
lol, I could rerely GET to that zone. I know, I fail.
SeveralBlueYoshis 2 years ago 4
i agree with Lyf3isM1s3ry
dak689 2 years ago
woah this is awsome!
I really like the picture you used! where did you find it?
Luigifan66 2 years ago
Very Good....Kind of makes me feel like i'm there
Happygogocheese 2 years ago 2
i like that play vidoe game orchestras version they did it perfectly =]
StMuttley 2 years ago
SWEET :D
MetalSonicUnleashed 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This sucks =/
Fond3ll 2 years ago
Well, it depends on what you like, but I think Lyf3isM1s3ry 's idea is a nice idea! Flute could be very nice for this one. :)
phoenixstorms9 2 years ago
you suck Fond3ll
figaro589 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah,and you're ugly, hehe
Fond3ll 2 years ago
This is amazing! If only the main instrument would be replaced with a flute, now... 6/5, amazing.
Lyf3isM1s3ry 2 years ago 2
absolutely fantastic!!, it make me recall those times!
grate job indeed!
Alueckard 2 years ago
nice song and nice picture
TheInferno313 2 years ago
another good song for Brawl :D
TheLonelyredfox 2 years ago 2
This rules.
tulsatrash 2 years ago
Sonic: *almost falls into lava* ahhh.....that was close....something tells me Robotnik REALLY hates me.
SonicPorcupine 2 years ago 5
sonics thinking: "robotnik REALLY doesnt want me here..."
b0w5er 2 years ago
my god, they should remake sonic 1,2 and 3 into todays standards (3d and what not), with similar level layout, make it much harder, and remix all the old games music
dunno bout u, id buy it in a heartbeat
MichaelUifalusi 2 years ago
they'd most likely phuck that one up too
thekingofreyes3 2 years ago
man i knoe, sega just isn't doing things right since after SA2 :(
MichaelUifalusi 2 years ago 4
true dat
thekingofreyes3 2 years ago
Even SA2 was a bit crappier than SA1, it just went from stage to stage instead of being able to explore.. But overall, good game too. =)
ReapLight 2 years ago 2
I think in sa2 (dreamcast) they re-did the first level of sonic 1 in 3d, unlockable when you get all the embelems
but that's just one level, I'd love to see them all in 3d too
overswordcamb 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
holy shit that actually would make the sonic the hedgehog franchise a hella lot more popular and would put be a bunch of nostalgia for everyone you know and you know i would totally buy that in a heart beat also
klunkxd 2 years ago
Good god no, every time they've tried to make them 3d, suckage happened
skyrobotv 2 years ago 4
very nice pic
pjcrew7 2 years ago
Not really orchastral, might better be labeled "synthesized"-- good nonetheless
StarkMessanger 2 years ago 2
this shit is pretty good man!
fennerman 2 years ago
pretty sweet! i really like the synths, where did you get those?
1duhface123 2 years ago
1:14 eeeeeeeeepiiiiiicccc
LatinaAmante 2 years ago 2
I always wonder if the Marbel Zone like the Marbel Garden from Sonic 3 may have been remnents of the Echidna civilization.
NUTCASE71733 2 years ago 2
You might be onto something here
agaifi 2 years ago
I like it a lot. :-) If only you'd held out the notes with the trumpets/horns that play the melody between violin interludes.
--Fx
DragnusShock 2 years ago
this may sound weird, but don't you think a galaxy could have been made out of the marble zone stage for Super Mario Galaxy; with this remix? give me your thoughts.
ccucino10 2 years ago
I "suppose"...? Yea I guess it would work.
HEY... It might be the best in the game!
RoboCommander 2 years ago
thank you for your thoughts RoboCommander.
ccucino10 2 years ago
cool
good image
good music
elirom92 2 years ago
Where is the Picture from?
Cause IT'S AWESOME!!!
RoboCommander 2 years ago
i remember struggling in this zone because the lava.
ClubPenguinScatman 2 years ago 6
I was fine because fire bubble.
Also, I never got beat Robotnik, he suck because super easy...
Nah, I'm kiddin...
EvilWireman 2 years ago
Fire Bubble? The Fire Sheild wasn't in the games until Sonic The Hedgehog 3, are you sure your talking about the right game? Or are you talking about a hack of it?
RoboCommander 2 years ago 4
"CURSES!!! MY BLUFF WAS CALLED!!!!"
*flees to the escape Airship*
"NYAH-HAHAH!!!!"
EvilWireman 2 years ago 4
bad notes, alot
xsicmetalx 2 years ago 2
This one and Labrinth zone song rocks. I LOVE Marble Garden act1 from sonic 3.
Jeikoh85 2 years ago
I just love how with sonic's melodies are so unique. Playing this game younger really influenced my choice of music today. lol
I like the Neptunes cause I swear is sounds alot like it.
missfluffysama 2 years ago 11
Love your song. It's has a majesty tone to it. : D
arvelous 2 years ago 4
Wow
4n63Lous 2 years ago
these tune you made are good and clever however i detect a few bum notes and they sound fairly artificial
WilliamGrantham 3 years ago 3
yeah...
SuzakuFinix 2 years ago
Has an old style japanese sound to it, like what you'd hear in Lupin the 3rd or some shit like that.
Respect.
Jayhawker30 3 years ago
Oh y'know... marble zone suits being made slower, with less going on and some minor(ly mayjor) misteakes.... yeah.... *shoots the conductor*
This doesn't sound like it belongs in sonic 'fast' world... it's ok but I prefer the original for this excerpt.
Changes to make...
FASTER (by about 20bpm)
Have more instruments play STACATO (short and detached notes) not legato (weaving notes)
Don't ever make a misteake of a note like at 0:28 again.
findlay27 3 years ago
*later discovers by READONG THE DESCRIPTION lol that this was user made*
Sorry for insulting the excerpt it's just that I forgot to read the description that says ir used orchestral like instruments. So I wouldn't have expected top of the range like music, though what you did made is way better than I could ever remake on software ever! I'm only good at playing my instruments, not converting it into software on the computer. Keep it up!
findlay27 3 years ago
No prob. Thanks anyway ;) I just used a already made MIDI file, I did not compose the song in itself. Just let my digital instruments play it :)
phoenixstorms9 3 years ago
Oh I see. What software did you use if you don't mind me asking? If it shows notes for MIDI and MP3 files I'd find it most useful! Pretty smart idea mind you having just changed the instruments but surely the tempo is different too?
findlay27 3 years ago
Hm... this doesn't sound Orchestrated in my opinion, it sounds like fairly high quality synths, but the trumpets really give it away.
Maybe add some/more reverb?
Hatokman 3 years ago 2
It would have been better using accordion instead of trumpets.
Blurns 3 years ago
Kind of reminds me of the Video Games Live rendition. This sounds good!
sonickchri 3 years ago
This actually sounds good.I do like the picture.Its creative.I like it!
GoldFantas14 3 years ago
I have to say, that's quite a lame and empty arrangement. :\
Almost not orchestral at all. The original piece has four tracks, this seems to use less.
JoonasD6 3 years ago 3
kinda reminds me of something you would hear on hokuto no ken
kufismcka 3 years ago
Good sound. A few of the notes are off here and there but one of the better remake efforts on YT for sure. :)
GMCMusic2008 3 years ago
I enjoy the Sonic 1 Marble Zone song, and I enjoy this also. Good work and very nice music. :)
ClayDT 3 years ago
I like the trumpet. Sounds like a Rocky movie.
Link4587452 3 years ago 2
Sounds good but a lot of wrong notes. Have a listen to the original again and have a play with your composition. Great start, though.
dummeh 3 years ago
It's a little slow, but still very good.
TwinUzis 3 years ago
It's the same tempo.
Link4587452 3 years ago
Actually, I just played them side by side; this one is considerably slower.
I still like it, it's just slower.
TwinUzis 3 years ago
this is obviously slower...
hyperhaman 3 years ago
LOL I love how you made Sonic's expression. Nice job on the song and picture!
devonjames10 3 years ago
Hey, I actually played the game a few days ago, and I'm pretty sure that the note on 1:09 is about a half step off. Check it out?:) other than that I have no real complains to make, other than one mentioning that the notes between 0:05-0:09 (and repeatedly during the song) is a little slow (I think?).
Don't have the willpower to get out of my sofa and fetch my guitar to tell you the notes so you can understand what I mean:P
anyway, great job. 5-star:)
check it out and message me, will ya?
CreepyNymoen 3 years ago 2
Cool music and picture.Well done!!!
NVR1800 3 years ago
fabuloso
LHammerding 3 years ago
What program you use to build a orkestra??
Lusitanus 3 years ago
Magix Music Maker + My Keyboard :D
phoenixstorms9 3 years ago
thanks for replying
but how can you know the notes and/or the melody?? you play as you listen??
Or the program open the song and then we can change the instruments/sound??
Lusitanus 3 years ago
I let the keyboard play the midi ;) I dont play it :) Look at my "Weird World" and "Reality vs Imagination" Those are played by me... you can notice it by errors I did while playing ;)
phoenixstorms9 3 years ago
Oops, I acidentally removed your comment instead of clicking on REPLY..lol
Well, you have to connect your keyboard to the computer using a MIDI cable or a USB(if possible) Then you have to set the keyboard as a default MIDI player or use Music maker like I do.
phoenixstorms9 3 years ago
thanks for explaining, I will try to make that,because I have a keyboard,what I need is the program Magix and a way to connect the keyboard to the pc.
Lusitanus 3 years ago
This is a truly wonderful remix. It captures the feel and ancient look of Marble Zone. Fantastic.
Cubivore10 3 years ago
a valiant effort dude. but i had to stop after the first 10 seconds. one of the notes in the pickup is incorrect and the first string run that seperates the phrases uses the incorrect chord. just something to think about.
djsaltycracker 3 years ago 2
kool picture and nice song
ikemarley1 3 years ago 3