Percy's Predicament

[username5515]

amazing vid mate! this deserves a sub!

[1986zls]

good crash!

[Lightninging63]

Great remake, loved the 'breakable van'..

one question tho- There's a van behind Toby @ 3:06.. i'm wondering where you got the face from, or if you did the cookiecutter effect and put it on there? i am curious

[Robtheredengine]

@Lightninging63 Thanks

cookiecutter? sorry but I dont know what that tool is, if its on vegas then I dont use cookiecutter i cut the faces myself

[soundedsilence32]

u should make more vids.... since these ones r already great, if u do the new ones would be evan better

[Robtheredengine]

@soundedsilence32 Sorry I dont know what you mean

[GZA92]

What was the exact model you used for Daisy?

[Galacticmaster]

i like watching these

[Robtheredengine]

@Galacticmaster Thanks

[TheSuperdude827]

Dude did you break the caboose/brake van

[JerryTheDoc]

Love that face trick! Do you want to join or partner up with my corporation? You'd be our 7th member and your face skills could make exellent Thomas fan shows. (if you can do that trick with real faces too)

[Zorran202]

hehe, you even got weathering on Percy! nice touch of detail :)

[ZBot316]

that was a neat little trick the faces. well done.

[Robtheredengine]

@ZBot316 Thanks

[MrNnacheta]

@Robtheredengine i know right good job

[Bunker0224]

It would be cool if you make a remake of "Daisy". It is between episodes "Thomas Comes To Breakfast" and "Percy's Predicament". Do you think that you could make that one if you get the chance?

[Robtheredengine]

@Bunker0224 ¬¬ yes i DO know it is between the eps and I am planning to do it in future.

[Bunker0224]

@Robtheredengine Alrighty then :)

[PokemonWhite2011]

Awesome face over man. : )

[bluecoatscheesypoofs]

amazing! Where did you get the coal hopper at 1:22?

[simierski]

Not bad at all! The choice of shots and how you did the crash were impressive.

[Robtheredengine]

@simierski thank you dude^^ glad you found it impressive

[thomasandfriends1000]

that brakevan got OWNED!

[CousinsOfTheCorn4]

Hornby or Bachmann?

[andersinnevada]

great remake. love the daisey model. what did you use for the dust on percy?

I also had another crazey idea to tell you but I dont want to over work you. neither do the rest of your fans.thumbs up! 5/5 I wish I could rate then I would give you that.

[Robtheredengine]

@andersinnevada thanks

[jamesstarkey]

PLEASE SEND THE ADUIO mate and good job on the video

[Coffeeshop246]

Such a great remake! The crash scene was very good!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man^^ yeah it took some time to get the scene flimed

[ANOTHERNIGHT17]

that's an awesome daisy

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Dustehue928]

your remakes are the best!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[ScottishRails]

How did you make the brakevan break?

[SkarloeyFan]

Grandpuff,

Sleeping Beauty,

You Can't Win,

Four Little Engines,

Home at Last,

Passengers and Polish.

They are the 6 Narrow gauge Stories I'm hoping to make in the Summer hoildays to show here on youtube. Hoipe you will like them.

[Robtheredengine]

awesome man really looking forward to them

[SkarloeyFan]

I still do have my BoCo I have been working on making a MUCH better verson. you will be the first person to get him.

[Robtheredengine]

=O really man, I can have your updated boco.....if so man thank you soooo much now I can do some remakes Ive always wanted to do

[Robtheredengine]

please get back to me on that man^^, I'm really really looking forward to getting him. I was wondering when will he be done.

also your a really good freind

[SkarloeyFan]

@Robtheredengine I will be able to send him to you on Friday 19th. I will need your email address please send it to my via here on youtube. and I can't wait to see the next remake with BoCo but don't forget to credit me in the video.

[Robtheredengine]

=D yayy thanks man, SO i guess it will be ready today, thanks man your a great friend.

and don't worry of course I will credit you for it, everytime I use it, I promise you

[darthwinsor]

I know you got it from a model shop, just which one? any sites? links?

[SkarloeyFan]

Another GREAT remake very amazing great work. Can't wait until the next one now. In June I will be uploading 4 maybe 6 Narrow gauge stories.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man^^ looking forward to it man.

say dude can I ask do you have a boco body like your flora one, I really i wanna do remakes like edwards explot.

Please get back to me man ^^ thanks man

[thomasthecpguy]

how' d you make daisy

[Robtheredengine]

i didnt, i just put a face on

[andrexiostudios]

A-W-E-S-O-M-E

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[andrexiostudios]

your welcomez. It is too awesome to ignore.

[Cybusmaster92]

Where did you get that stone hopper at 1:21?

[Robtheredengine]

I made it from a kit, its not done yet

[darthwinsor]

where can i find this kit you speak of?

[Robtheredengine]

i'm getting annoyed with question like that.

Where else would you get them from, A model shop

[TheTrainFan12]

this is really good rob keep up the good work :)

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[mulfred100]

Great remake. Love it, can't wait to see what you will do next. I fully suoport you wanting to redo your page and eps. ;o)

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[TheBlueE2]

Another nice job :)

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man^^

[contestar5]

this is a good episode

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[darthwinsor]

you always make great renactments

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[camscott]

It is my firm belief that this is your best yet 8D

The crash was nicely done, and the dust on Percy afterwards was a nice touch.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man XD thanks for commenting and yeah I wanted the dust to give the affect the broken breakvan.

thanks again.

[Mrthomaas689]

Nice remake and great crash. :]

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Stackhouse421]

awesome vid..i think this is probably one of my top 10 episodes and i think the next one after this episode too.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[bornrocker95]

very nice job especially with the crash

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Zorran202]

Well done!! :D

You should be the new director of Thomas and Friends (a compliment by the way)!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks XD and thanks for the compliment would love to then I can bring back the old thomas

[spyfox14]

Very good work!!!!

The crash was so cool!!

5 Stars!!!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[ttcgeek]

FANTASTIC!!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[peaceemerick2]

NICE!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[SodorGr]

Fantastic work just like watching the original 5/5!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[couchpatatoo]

You fit the footage faces perfectly on the trains!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[cyberworrier94]

Lovely, and flawless my friend, can't wait for the next remake :D

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, glad you are looking forward to the next remake

[frozone9344]

great job again rob looking foward to more to come keep me posted. when did you find out that bachmann is making donald and douglas

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, I found out months ago.

[SaltyFan12]

great remake

love the crash

what was Percy covered with?

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, it was a grey pencil that I was cutting to get the dust affect.

[oricalcross]

Another awsome remake the best on youtube :) keep it up 5 stars

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, I will

[NemesisHero123]

Nice :D

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man =D

[RobertMProductions]

Great remake. That DMU makes a great Railway Series Daisy.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, yeah it is that is why I got it, it was the best DMU that looked liked daisy

[badboy417]

AWESOME!!! That was so cool!!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[cybermurph04]

Nice work. Good Daisy Model. I have a homemade model too. :D

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, but mine is not really home made, it just has a face on it

[x00001]

great loved the crash Percy had

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[RobertHew]

great job on the newest remake, the crash is very well done, especially the destruction of the barke van

as well as all of that, the yard and quarry set looked very proffessional

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man

[1f5sda]

I love it!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[1f5sda]

You are welcome!

[Tomthetrainfan]

This-has-got-to-be-the

GREAYEST PREDICAMENT REMAKE ON THE WEB!!!! 5 STARS ALL THE WAY!!!

Love the crash- that breakvan got majorly pwned!!! XD

[Robtheredengine]

XD thanks man, glad you think so

[517wiiface]

This is so awesome!!!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Trainsforlife286]

great daisy good to be the RWS version

[Robtheredengine]

yeah it is, thats why I got it

[Klurty34]

Awesome work here :) I loved the masking and effects :) Loved the crash :)

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[trainsandfigers]

well done!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Headbanger142]

I love when you do these remakes and this one is just brilliant! Nice crash!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man

[SCRuffeyfan]

Wow, this is very good, my friend! ^^

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man

[UnluckyTug06]

Superb remake, you handled the crash scene very well.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, I wanted to try and do a good job at the crash scene

[SAErocks5y1]

y did u skip Daisy

[Robtheredengine]

if you had botherd to read the info when you watched my vid you would have found out y

[ThomasandTigger99]

One of your best remakes. Good job. Alos, I just noticed, STH is so hard on the engines in these old episodes, but he hardly talks to them in the new ones. (e. i. Maybe it"ll teach you to be more careful with trucks). What do you think?

[TrainManiac1]

Totally Brilliant!!! 5/5

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Graemenumber1]

best remake to date keep up the good work =)

[Robtheredengine]

thanks I will

[1000guy1]

cool remake

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Sodoradventures]

the vans you used in the back at 3:04 behind toby is the oxide vent by hornby thomas range, if it is, did it already come with the face?

[Robtheredengine]

no your wrong the van is a cattle truck of the hornby thomas range and no it does not come with a face I put it there myself

[Bunker0224]

Wow this remake was really awesome!

Is that the Daisy for Bachmann or did you make it yourself?

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, its just a diesel railcar that I got that looked like daisy and all I done was stick the face on.

[Bunker0224]

@Robtheredengine Oh. Well, it was cool anyway =)

[Sodoradventures]

Cool! Great Job at the footage!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[ThomasandDBZ2010]

That was really good.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks