Added: 4 years ago
From: heartofsnow23
Views: 22,150
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (360)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think it would be pretty cool to see built replica of Titanic, however I can see why some people would be against the idea due to the life's that where lost during the sinking of Titanic not to mention the people that died making those ships i.e. Oylmpic - Titanic - Britanic, I'd rather see a built replica of Oylmpic - why? because the legacy of the Oylmpic was far less tragic. When I think of the Titanic or Britanic the first word that pops in my mind is tragedy.

  • rebuild her because it will be very amotinal to see her at last

  • no point rebuilding the titanic there was only 1 titanic that sank

  • Trust me people, it will cost ALOT of money...

  • if a new titanic would be builded the grandstaircast (dunno how to spell) would be mordern and the ship will be differetnt looking and looks mordern.

  • I'd say REBUILD HER!!!! i used to be a ship fan i still like em but im a guitarist now, i say rebuild her

  • more lifeboats new technology THE LONGEST SHIP IN HISTORY

  • I say rebuild!

  • REBUILD

  • Dude that ship killed over 1,000 people. No one is going to be enthusiastic about rebuilding the exact same ship. However I would also love to see it going again but your petition won't get the ship going again no many how signs you get.

  • @YouCanSeeYourFace exact same ship? 100 years of technology later? Wouldn't quite be the SAME ship....

  • I feel we should not rebuild titanic, it is underwater and a gravesite for all of those lost on that horrific night.

  • i think if we rebuild it it be cool i also think the only reason it snake was cause we said not even god could bring it down so he did

    so we should damn him this time

  • Comment removed

  • It would be a several Hunderd Million Dollar mistake !

  • the thing that the titan has is that it never came to NY if it did its just a ship, and the world never rememberd here

  • I am a Titanic buff and it would nice if they did rebuild it. The only thing is the people will not be the same.

  • what a power this song have....o.O

  • aculy a ship pronouced as titanic 2 will be sailling in 2012

  • @titanicboy477 Sorry, but your incorrect. The ship your thinking of is Balmoral. It is taking the same route as Titanic on April 10, 2012. I ve studied this ship for over 20 plus years.

  • @quinlanguy101 look it up and you will see you dont study!!! modern world!!

  • @titanicboy477 Sorry kid your wrong. I have the popualar mechanics mag dated Dec 1998 when they started talking about it. Never went through. In 2006 the Replica Titanic project was scrapped due to high costs and a low amount of support for the project. The last Titanic survivor Millvina Dean was against the Titanic II ship. Kid, like I said, 20 plus years of reseach under my belt. Sarel Gous was the guy that was going to do it.

  • @quinlanguy101 no im not your just stupid haha

  • Lets rebuild Titanic and sink it again and let Bear Grylls show us how to escape and survive a disaster like it. I reckon it would make a wonderful TV show.

  • I saw it on nat geo that they are rebuilding titanic. I just hope that when it's completed they did sail from and to they were suppose to sail.

  • Yeah would be cool and I have a relative that was on it (And lived) and a friend that was one of the many that built it but there a a lot more ship disasters with a larger loss of life and its well over time to let it go. Sorry David but it is time to put the "Souvenirs " in a maritime museum where they can be apprieciated by all.

  • if i was rich i would rebuilt an exact replica of the ship. if only i was rich

  • @nicothegreat795 what woulld be better if you could lift up the titanic and take the part ana use some of the peaces

  • they are rebuilding her=)

    national geographic has plans and has started construction on an exact replica ....not shure what they plan to do with her yet?floationg museum id bet or for cross sea tours

  • @chrisproblade hope it dose not cross the atlantic

  • you bet dude I'm with you all the way

  • yep rebuild the titanik i agraa efrene wanna get this thing to rebuild i realey think we all need to get t etchater and fot for the titanoc efryone wo want teh titanick rebuild we open en bank acound and ask for sposers we need to rebuild it evryone want the titabnick rebuild

  • a lot of peepl,e wanan sponser for teh rebult i thing i wil start looking aroun vor the building sctect i want to rebuild this i am from holand do u have an build map becous i mak the rebuild happen do u wanna help

  • If RMS Titanic was Re-built, It would be a very Emotional event for everyone of the world. It would be very thought-raising and memorising all the people who were lost whilst it was being built (8 people to be prescise) and also on the fateful day that the ship sunk with many hopes, dreams, new lives and life itself was dragged under the Ocean, because of one terrible Ice-berg.

  • I would love to see the ship of dreams RMS TITANIC rebuilt!

  • yh i want the titanic to be rebuilded. it should be in the original version!! Cant wait to get this started!! Bring The TITANIC Back PLSSSSSSSSSS

  • yh i want the titanic to be rebuilded. it should be in the original version!! Cant wait to get this started!!

  • If the Titanic Is gonna be built again, It should be built as big as modern Liners today. It should have the same look and the Grand Stair case and all that, With some plenty of up grades.If your a car fan mustang Camero and Dodge, Retro Is the new thing and It wil work and sell tickets. BRING BACK THE R.M.S TITANIC PLEASE

  • I signed this like 2 in a half years ago lol.

  • I would like that, but the only reason I don't think it would happen is because the Titanic has become a symbol of tragedy. However, with luck on our side, it will happen.

  • I signed the petition!!! I hope it becomes a reality!

  • My name is Russell Anderson. And I LOVE THE TITANIC I want the Titanic to be rebuilt. I want to walk her halls.

  • i sign this petition! i don't wanna out my actual name on here but my username is annabaz16

  • ...I hope you do rebuild Titanic (Snakeuserorochi)...only with a few more Lifeboats...a good pair of Binocculars and with Plenty of Pot Noodles onboard...I love em....

  • THE TITANIC WELL BE BETTER IN THE FUTRUE I PROMIES SOME DAY I WELL FINE A WAY TO MAKE IT

  • Seriously I AGREE i would sign your petition nd i am irish so it would mean a lot to me to

  • last time i heard of this a south african man was planning to do so at the total cos of 900 million dollars so its not gonna be cheap and with solas regulations if it was done no one would be able to capture the true beauty of the origanal

  • I have so amazing news to tell: An shipyard in Argentina is involved to rebuild Titanic's sister ship, Olympic! That's not the only news, if the Olympic (in cruise and 1920's style) has a good and successful maiden voyage. The Titanic and Britannic will glide from the slip way into the water!

    Bon Voyage! peekarica com/replicaolympic

  • Sad thing is, no matter how hard we try, we could never rebuild the Titanic exactly, and if we did, she would not be permitted to sail, and would be relegated to the role of a hotel or museum ship. Several major structural changes would have to happen to make the ship seaworthy, such as a full double hull (as opposed to double BOTTOM), revised rudder, engines & propulsion, full-height bulkheads, revised interior due to the raised bulkheads and double hull, the list goes on.

  • Rebuild the Titanic!

  • Rebuild the Titanic!! Please!

  • A better way to turn titanic would be bow thrusters

  • You might want to look at the spelling of petition at 1:|29.......I was under the impression that petitions were aimed at local councils/governments to get laws overturned/passed...who exactely is this petition going to be sent to and just who will finance your petition?? It aint ever going to happen my friend....would be better off petitioning the worlds leaders to end third world suffering/debt etc...at least that would be more worthwhile. What next..rebuild the twin towers to relive that??

  • The cruise is going to be great, my grandparents and I are going, first class room on the ship, all together it was about, $7'550 for 3 people.

  • And I sign it for you right here and where ever else you wish me to sign. I will not how ever sign it on my face or your face or any other faces of any other persons living or deceased.

  • in a news report I had read that the titanic memorial cruise is nearly full for the trip 2012 it will take the same route the oringal titanic did ,,,now I dont think its a duplicate of the titanic or perhpas it is ,, not sure,,,but I know the memorial cruise is nearly full for 2012

  • Is it really worth the $450 million (cost to construct the boat) for one cruise? And the ship wouldn't be allowed to sail, the design is against todays health and safety laws. So by law it cant happen.

    Nice video anyway.

  • they shouldn't rebuild her, thats disrespecting all the people who died or suffered on their. Its like another "grave yard"

  • If I become a billionaire...its happening...and the "Historic White Star Line" will be in operation...

  • Wow thats odd I thought of this tonight. Did a search and you seem to have the same idea. Although I can tell you for sure. Even if funding was in place, 2 years would not be enough. The hull is only 30% of the work. I imagine weld it instead of the hot rivets. The interior would be the thing. Plus all the new regs needed to make this a ship legal to carry these days.Not to mention the history this particular ship has. Largest I've been involved in has been 220' Titanic was what? near 900

  • I would love to see a Titanic II rebuilt. If it is built, I would love to ride it! But I think that guy who dreamed this up might have been smoking! It could be a copyright infragment. Plus, thanks to politics, some historic things on the ship would have to be altered such as diesel rather than steam and the elevators would have to be automatic rater than manually driven elevatos with the pretty gates because of OSHA!!!

  • Start rebuilding now so it can be completed by the 100th anniversary!!!! what i would give to see that sight. the feeling of being on the titanic crossing the atlantic through its original route 100 years later

  • they are not aloud to rebuild her iff you want information about it why we cannot please email me on ethansm@hotmail.co.uk

  • hello my name is ethan and i have been designing and condtuction of ships,cruise and containers for 48 years now. i would like to inform you that we can not rebuild the titanic. the risks are way to high. and also its copyright. sorry but we cannot not me and my company have already tried sorry.

  • I wish the technology was so strong that they sprayed a protection thing on the Titanic wreck that it wont get eat away. So she would still lay there even if an meteor ended humans lives. I think that Harland and Wolff is still a little bit involved with 60% of the world to rebuild the steamships and let them run on diesel from cruise ships.

  • i think there are gonna rebuild her in 2012

  • rebuild TITANIC!!!

  • Build another one, complete in EVERY detail.

  • a replica maybe but you couldnt rebuild her now shes got to much damage and has been under water for to many years plus every year shes getting weaker from the riseicals eating her away but by all means have a dream

  • Some people think it is easy to build the Titanic. It isn't, the material which the Titanic need is over 600 million dollars, also an millionaire made an company White Star Line Ltd in 1998, he tried to rebuild the Titanic but some months later he quit at working at it. Many Replica Titanic foundations collapsed, because it's impossible to rebuild her. At least with cruise-ship material and cruise-ship interior.

  • @Abricialio what are you going on about? rebuilding the titanic or any Olympic class ships would be less or the same that a new cruise ship would be today. remember, they are still small compared to current liners, they are less luxurious due to technology of current times, and all additional safety equipment is now standard. also it would not be as labor intensive as back then due to modern welding. after 3 years of engineering, its possible with little hassle if you have a company to build her

  • well its never guna happen lmfao i love the titanic to my favorite movie but i dont think it would ever happen

  • i love your video about the titanic to rebuild her this moves me so much rebuild the titanic everybody we can make it happen yes would allso love to see her sail across to new york that would be wonderful

  • hello i would love to see this lovely ship rebuild too a very nice video

  • if you were to rebuild her use the original plans make her live on make her the exact same as she was 100 years ago. Who ever you sponsor this would make 10x more profit. The shit would not even have to move, it would be a museum in south hampton or wherever and then just push that titanic museum out of the way.

  • Comment removed

  • But one thing is Titanic is sunk and break into two

  • omg i luv titanic!!!!! did u knw they r building a half model tht u can go inside of, down in gatlinburg Tn? its kool i seen it last year, tho they were still building :D

  • fine go ahead and build it then, you ll be waiting more than two years just for funds and permission then theres all health and safety rubbish to get through. I just thought, to be able to see and photograph and remember the wreck of the original is a monument to all who perished being enough to honour those. if the world had more money then I agree it would be a great idea. but the world in some areas is in major debt as it is, the UK ll never payback what we should never have borrowed.

  • Comment removed

  • titanic has been my life long dream to be on the magnifisent ship, im hoping that they are rebuilding the titanic, it would be unbeleivible to be on the ocean liner

  • i love the TITANIC

  • There are presently two half scale replicas of Titanic...both museums, owned by John Jocylyn, of the Titanic Historical Society.... one in Branson, Missouri and its 'sister ship ' in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. Look them up on your browser!

  • I would love to see the Titanic rebuilt, though we would have to have the backing of a very rich person to provide the cash, as well as maybe trying to raise some money for this wonderful resurrection of that famous ship.

    It would be marvellous to see her rise again to be rebuilt and sail !

  • @ilikemario8 Quite right, there has been a replica bulit of a steam train, and it cost millions, but was worth it. What a fantastic dream to see another Titanic built, without the setbacks and errors of last time's disaster in 1912.

  • It would be a fantastic dream to rebuild this magnificent ship, I saw the film 8 times before buying the video, and I have watched various documentaries, on Titanic, and love it.

    There are a lot of reasons for the foundering of Titanic on that fateful night, and if the clock were to be turned back maybe things would have been handled differently.

  • @josparkes1 omg i did 2 it so cool uhhh send me some mail

  • I always liked the idea of putting the actual wreckage in a huge reinforced glass box and raising it because theres this big scare that if we raised the Titanic then it would fall part so if we raise the ship and the environment its in then it would be the same as if it were on the bottom but it's on surface. Of course thats impractical in too many ways to count, but it's just a thought.

  • restore the real one

  • Do you know any knowledge of the wreck of the Titanic? It's collapsing and may be gone in 2040. Building an replica of the Titanic with cruise-ship material will make the Titanic costs around 30 million, but with the normal material of golden age it would be 430 million dollars.

    Anyways, if they build a replica they will build a museum will all pictures of the lost people aboard of Titanic.

  • @liten48 impossible, too much damage.

  • BUT..... I'll say back then attention to detail and the ideas were fantastic! unlike some of the shit I've seen built these days, and also we have all kinds of gear to protect and make engineers lives easier. back than then had fuck all!!!! and just check out the size and engineering and furnishings, never see that again :(

  • I'm sorry to say this, and even though I agree she was a great vessel. Whats the point in building a replica? mainly cause 1.Money? wheres that coming from? tax payer had to bail the banks out this century already! 2nd whats wrong with just photos videos and memories of the ship? I'm sorry peoples but it would be a waste of time and money. Also the bloody health and safety twats would have to be involved in every thing.

    No hard hats safety specs, ear defenders or hi-vis in early 1900s :)

  • @Blaken81 the point is that we wont to honer the people that past away on that vessel.

  • I'm not exactly sure if a full-size replica would be allowed to be built due to the stringent maritime Health & Safety regulations. It is a dream many before you have had, like me.

  • Titanic making Port... one day I know it. That dream will become a reality some day, I know it!

  • If the Titanic is going to rebuild.. the Olympic and Britannic should be rebuild also. Britannic never carried any passenger and was in war service directly after her launch w hen WW1 started and sunk in 1916. And Titanic never reached the beautifel city New York.

  • Take away the required email attachment in the petition, and you will see it spike.. I would like to sign, but you won't get my email..

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • god dam, your a real downer huh? The SS united states is an original, it's not a replica. Just take your dope pessimism somewhere else please.

  • Not really, i'm just stating the facts. you must have a hard time dealing with facts with a reply like that. keep dreaming.

  • obvious troll is obvious

  • sorry, i've got no idea what that means.

    thanks anyway.

  • Comment removed

  • that has been my dream forever. i wish to rebuild her. as i am studying to be a maritime engineer, i would upgrade her hull to a double standard hull and bottom, as well as new engines and full watertight compartments. but she will be a perfect image of how she once was. nothing changed other than safety requirements and propulsion systems. she WILL live again i promise you, its when thats the question.

  • @Snakeuserorochi cool i love the TITANIC 1912 to 1912

  • @Snakeuserorochi Don't forget that 1,500 lives were lost on the name Titanic. See also my website Replicaolympic us tt

  • @Abricialio no, no. history is not forgotten.

  • @Snakeuserorochi The plan is too rebuild the three sisterships but renaming Titanic to Malantic. So you get (Olympic, Malantic, Britannic). Millvina Dean, the last survivor that died on May 31, 2009 said she would never take a step aboard an ship named Titanic 2. And to respect Millvina Dean we shouldn't use the name Titanic anymore. Also many Titanic survivors were against an replica Titanic, and if you build the ship with cruise-ship material it will be completed in ONE and a half year.

  • @Abricialio so you took it upon a small committee to rename her after the last survivor?. and what plan? any plan that would have funds sufficient enough to build her would be notable and i would have known. by 3 years of engineering i meant the time i have been an engineer, not that it wouldnt take shorter or longer to build a new ship. take into account designing, drafts, structure, safety, materials, workers, and sponsors. that, my friend is not one and a half years. im not opposing you.

  • @Snakeuserorochi But the problem is the ship doesn't have any of the SOLAS rules. That is why I choose to give the Olympic an more cruise-ship style but she still looks the old Olympic.

  • @Abricialio what? it has to have all of the SOLAS rules. they may be under different names but ultimately that was what was created by the titanic and for future ships.

    and my opinion, is making the titanic, not the olympic. even though she lasted longer, she was not widely known. and she too killed people in war and peace. oh and make her a transatlantic ship, not a cruise ship. that would be horrible.

    like i said im not opposing you, id love to see this happen, and would help as best i could

  • @Snakeuserorochi She killed only an Germany submarine U-103 with one of her shafts, that was all she had killed. The Olympic 3 will be an transatlantic liner like the Queen Mary 2 does, but I mean she will be fully made out of cruise-ship material. I don't see the point of rebuilding an very old ship.

  • @Abricialio ah, look up the lightship Nantucket. im not sure on the people that were killed but i think it was like 8. and no dont rebuild an old ship, use modern techniques so mimic a great era.

  • @Snakeuserorochi If you have any stuff like messenger, we could talk further about this. Because the current new ships needs: Bow thrusters, luxury interiors, lifeboats with a shaft on it and a motor. And much more.

    Also the collision with the lightship Nantucket was an accident.

  • @Abricialio yea those would be needed, and no, im currently using ubuntu and trying to re partition my computer so its all a mess.

    yea it was an accident, funny how it took one of the best pictures of the olympic just years earlier.

  • @Snakeuserorochi It was from the Replica Titanic, if you didn't noticed the B-deck is fully open in the picture on Replica Olympic site.

  • @Abricialio what do you mean? what was from there? the pic from the lightship nantucket? it was of the olympic in 1934.

  • @Snakeuserorochi Oh I thought you were talking about the Replica Titanic from an African Millionaire of 1998.

  • @Abricialio oh, no haha.

  • My dream is to rebuild her almost as she was only difference if fully water tighe compartments, not open on the top like they were.  Her large steam engines and turbine will stay.

  • is* and tight*

  • @Snakeuserorochi i really want to see that happen i heard it was a bad idea but if you do that then itll be excellent!

  • @Snakeuserorochi i couldnt agree with you more m8 i love titanic

  • Comment removed

  • I think they should rebuild it but to match modern days in a way. For example I did a drawing depicting the Titanic then another of an identical version but twice the size with 6 smoke stacks. I think they should do that because it looks as good as the old one and it would be a remarkable achievement in size just like it was back then.

  • i would sign 347563489765798324659834265792­348569832456983247petitions to get the luxury liner back on the seas...... away from icebergs.. hopefully

  • Rebuilding the Titanic with modern day Safety an design Features would be a Fantastic move. It would be a " Theme" event. It would also give today's people the experience of seeing where and what we came from. It was a tragic Mistake why all thre original sisters were wrecked and or torn down. Those ships are and were History, Not just Financial Considerations.

  • sorry for the  bad commenting R.I.P titanic

  • don't get me wrong, i love the titanic. and i would love to see it in person and walk her decks. But part of me thinks that it would be taking something away from the real titanic. The new one would just be a cheap copy. I would give just about anything to see it. But some how it just seems wrong to me. Anyone else feel this way?

  • well if they build the titanic im preety sure they wont make it go near any icebergs

  • Comment removed

  • are you sure i bet they wont

  • ok so what you got a billon dollars

  • Actually This All Stupid Comments Must Be Deleted, The Good News Is They Gonna Rebuilt The Titanic At The Same Time They Started To Build It At 1909 And At 2012 It Will Be Ready To Sail At The Same Time It Sailed On 1912, Everything Will Be At The Same Time For Memory And It Will Be Inside The Titanic 2 Same As Titanic 1 And Outside Too But The Different Is It Will Be More Stronger And Very Strong It Could Break The Iceberg With Out Titanic 2 Gets Hurts... Thanks For Reading.

  • no i bet they wont but maybe but i,ll be 12 so dont come cryin to me

  • lol

  • imagine if they rebuilt titanic and it set said from southhampton to new york at the same time as the original did, would you go on its maiden voyage? lol not me!

  • If Titanic 2 gets built, and it sails, I hope I get to room with Leo and Danny and get to ride the elevator with "Dawson" and/or "Mr. Ismay".

  • and if they do rebuild the legendendary ship they should build it were the ship was built originally and have it as a museum not an actual cruise liner

  • It should be the ocean liner, but than before the grand staircase a brand beautifel museum where people can see the old ship interior!

  • i think they should make an exact replica of the titanic so people can actually see what it was like back in the days because i would love to see wot it looks like would love to go on the new one if they build one

  • They can't build an exact replica for the ship(If it was used as an ocean liner)

  • kutzak, you are right about that. The exterior of the ship could look exactly the same, but in today's world and the laws we have in place today, The engines today would have to be diesel powered, and the elevators would have to have regular doors of today, but they could cut windows in them and weld a gate to the outside of the car door and have the car door be glass though.

  • Your right, and if they wanted to make one.. who's gonna give 400million?

    PS: New titanic museum will be opend in 2012 (thats what i heard)

  • there already is a titanic musuem dumb ass, its in Bronsen Missouri, its the front half of the ship

  • Learn to ready dumb ass, a "new" titanic museum. I hope you feel better now.

  • well y do we need a new museum? the 1 we got is enough, what they need to do is build a new ship, Titanic ll

  • Don't complain to me, wtf lol?! i am not the one building a fucking whole museum... and they can't build a new ship so they open a new museum for her 100th birthday.

  • well it will be

  • if i sign it will we all be able to rebuild it agian?

  • I signed the petition. With me having a part time job working only 2 days a week, and if I was on my own, I would be classified as a steerage passenger. If this ship gets built, I want to ride with DiCaprio and Dan.

  • I would love to see a Titanic 2. There was an article in Popular Mechanics one time about a building of a Titanic 2. There are some things that have to be built differently than the old ship. Such as the elevators and the engines. The one on the old one was steam driven with the center propeler being turbine driven. The elevators can't have the pretty gates like the one had because of OSHA. I would add more lifeboats because of marine law requires them.

  • Yeh with original disiign

  • Guys sign in to my petitiononline to rebuild the RMS Britannic!

    Go to petitiononline [dot] com/britanic

  • no titanic 2 this is too expensive and uneconomical

  • not rly old titanic cost 36million dollars to build. Much bigger liners today cost 300m etc...

  • that is the worst idea I have ever heard. if they would do this then build it the same design but do not give it the name Titanic I think that would just be bad taste.

  • what they should do is build another titanic same design same length although change the 3rd class rooms to fit passengers, have the ship take the same original route in april 2012 and stop at the sinking of the original on the 14th and 15th to remember the terrible tragedy of the sinking,

    the 100th anniversary is gonna be BIG, movies about the titanic will be playing, news people will be talking about it a moment of silence has to be done

  • I swear, by every member in my family, and all my closest friends and on my life. i will rebuild this ship, and i will be damned if someone tells me i cant, cuz i can and i know i have support from people like u to have it happen

  • It would be a beautiful dream ... sure if now would be rebuilt everything technological. but there is still furniture. Reviewing the great staircase, the officers' accommodation and all rooms for dinners, the room to write ... pay gold to see it rebuilt and make a trip.

  • I too have the same dream. to rebuild the Titanic would be lengendary however could we the people of tomarrow ever capture the original beauty of this magnificent ship? I my self have dreamed many many times to actualy walk down the grand staircase but never the less we will never be able to capture the beauty of her never im affraide

  • it would be awesome if they could rebuild the Titanic I actualy wrote a story about a Titanic 2 which sailed and actualy reached newyork all though it had a little twist..

    That is my dream to rebuil the TItanic I heard there will a replica built in Belfast in 2012 but it won't be the same it won't sail for a start oh such a shame :(

    Liked the music and pictures you used btw

    RIP TItanic

  • My dream is TITANIC will once highlight.

  • My too!  :)

  • i can see rebuilding the titanic as a museum, but as a ocean liner no because of today's codes and everything.

  • Rest The Souls of those who rode on this beautiful ship...May they always be remembered.

    ```````who doesnt love this song`````````

    "Power is not in numbers or strength...but wisdom"

    -Me

  • Where do you know that from?

  • it true it was in the papers to build a Titanic 2

  • It's true. It's going to sail at April 12 2012

  • Not yet nothing happend