Personally, I find Bowie's version to be horrible. Musically its great, but his singing is so over the top it cancels out anything good about it. Sad really.
I'm a huge Televion and Tom Verlaine, but in reading the comments...man, TV fans are a different breed. No flaming, debates actually resolved. As opposed to Metallica video comments usually consist of ridiculous comparisons like, "Who's the better guitarist, Kirk Hamment, or Chris Broderick."
Both Verlaine's and Bowie's versions are great, but Bowie is Bowie, after all, and it's very hard to surpass The Gentleman. So, yes, Tommy V is a talented fellow, but Bowie is the Emperor -- the Thin White Emperor -- of all Male Rock and Pop Stars, and its very hard to surpass an emperor. So, this version is excellent, but I'm afraid I'm going to have to say, Team Bowie.
I was wrong about Verlaine, but you are wrong about Fripp. Fripp plays on "Fashion", "It's No Game", "Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)", "Kingdom Come", "Up the Hill Backwards" and "Teenage Wildlife
if i'mnot mistaken, verlaine played on bowie's version. verlaine was originally supposed to play on the whole scary monsters album, but it didn't happen
@realghengis 1979 on Tom Verlaine's eponymous solo debut. I seriously recommend you check him out, as well as his band, Television. He is probably the most unknown guitarist of his caliber of all time.
@realghengisThis is from before Scary Monsters. Tom wrote it. Bowie liked the song, got permission, and did a cover. Tom Verlaine and Television are musician's musicians. This is Tom Verlaine's song. It is from around 78 or 79. I remember when it when I was a teen. Google it and find out.
The comparison of the Bowie & Verlaine versions really misses the point! Bowie wasn't trying to out-do Tom Verlaine - he was paying tribute to him. I'm sure Bowie, modest as he is, would find the original to be the best!
Personally, I find Bowie's version to be horrible. Musically its great, but his singing is so over the top it cancels out anything good about it. Sad really.
CaptainCorpulence 2 weeks ago
jeez,,,,i dont know what to say , i love bowies version , but this,,,,this sounds like a sunday morning, i love it
namordespuesdelnamor 1 month ago
I'm a huge Televion and Tom Verlaine, but in reading the comments...man, TV fans are a different breed. No flaming, debates actually resolved. As opposed to Metallica video comments usually consist of ridiculous comparisons like, "Who's the better guitarist, Kirk Hamment, or Chris Broderick."
TedPalen 9 months ago
Both Verlaine's and Bowie's versions are great, but Bowie is Bowie, after all, and it's very hard to surpass The Gentleman. So, yes, Tommy V is a talented fellow, but Bowie is the Emperor -- the Thin White Emperor -- of all Male Rock and Pop Stars, and its very hard to surpass an emperor. So, this version is excellent, but I'm afraid I'm going to have to say, Team Bowie.
Sparkina 10 months ago
I was wrong about Verlaine, but you are wrong about Fripp. Fripp plays on "Fashion", "It's No Game", "Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)", "Kingdom Come", "Up the Hill Backwards" and "Teenage Wildlife
paulwhitberg 1 year ago
@paulwhitberg Thanks for the correction!
epweissengruber 11 months ago
Well, at least Bowie has a good voice :P
tehverybestcomment 1 year ago
if i'mnot mistaken, verlaine played on bowie's version. verlaine was originally supposed to play on the whole scary monsters album, but it didn't happen
paulwhitberg 1 year ago
Robert Fripp plays on the Bowie version and the rest of the album.
epweissengruber 1 year ago
I've known the Bowie version since I was a kid. Always loved it, but I think this is even better. Anyone know what year this is from?
realghengis 1 year ago
@realghengis 1979 on Tom Verlaine's eponymous solo debut. I seriously recommend you check him out, as well as his band, Television. He is probably the most unknown guitarist of his caliber of all time.
SirPwn4lot 1 year ago 2
@SirPwn4lot Thank you for recommending him that great band.
JaackPat 1 year ago
@realghengisThis is from before Scary Monsters. Tom wrote it. Bowie liked the song, got permission, and did a cover. Tom Verlaine and Television are musician's musicians. This is Tom Verlaine's song. It is from around 78 or 79. I remember when it when I was a teen. Google it and find out.
loudenblogger 1 month ago
Comment removed
realghengis 1 year ago
Thanks for posting this concert video, this has always been a Verlaine favorite of mine. Does anyone know when this was recorded?
poopologist96 1 year ago
Liking the beret
oogie11 1 year ago
Hmm, Bowie's version is way better
LornaEGL 1 year ago
And what does the spanish say at the bottom?
DeeDeeVerlaine 2 years ago
Tom Verlaine kicks ass!
He's the reason I have a beret and the coat I have. He's one of my heros.
DeeDeeVerlaine 2 years ago
@DeeDeeVerlaine Mine too... He and the two Richards he's worked with are coming out in my music a lot these days...
desasterz 1 year ago
Tom Verlaine...one of the best :)
oogie11 2 years ago
The comparison of the Bowie & Verlaine versions really misses the point! Bowie wasn't trying to out-do Tom Verlaine - he was paying tribute to him. I'm sure Bowie, modest as he is, would find the original to be the best!
DailyBrusher 2 years ago 6
the original ... and the best
silvanski 2 years ago
Amazing lyrics, - reckon the bowie version is way better though.
EDPLASTIC 2 years ago
davie bowie does a good cover, but i actually prefer this version
windmills20 2 years ago 7