you guys are all freaking amazing! were putting on theis production at my church, and I got the role of pirate king. Let me tell you, this guy, whoever the pirate King, is my inspiration!
You have to remember that "operatic singing" didn't happen because people thought it sounded better. It was the natural outcome of having to project into large houses in the days before mikes. Whether mikes are an altogether good thing is another matter...
I dont understand why all of these g&s operas ive seen online have singers that sound like theyre from broadway...this is still an operetta and should be done with classical voice!
@adamskyb - Why? If people enjoy it more and it's more accessible with a comprehensible, contemporary singing style, why should one stick dogmatically to a style imitative of the late 19th century? G&S isn't sacred. To treat it like a revered relic of the past, rather than a fun, silly romp that everyone can enjoy, is to miss its point completely.
@PuissantAlgernon I don't see how it makes it less accessible. people these days just dont know what talented singing is. It would be rediculous to sing other operas this way, just cause it's comedy doesnt mean the skill has to be down graded.
@adamskyb - Because people associate operatic singing with a certain style of music and tone of theatre, and switch off. Also, the operatic style is more musically interesting, but harder to comprehend. I've been to see this production in both an operetta style AND a musical style, and the audience comprehended the latter far more readily. Finally, the modernised, pantomimic presentation of this particular staging of 'Pirates' would make operatic singing feel completely out of place.
I saw this (not this exact night) Australian production of it when I was three :)
And I'm not kidding, I started crying when they were tlaking about baby farming because I wanted to go on stage and sing, and Jon English stopped the show and asked if everything was alright - then they lost the plot!
u are gonna have soooooooooooo much fun!! I didi this play 2 years ago,,,I was Ruth,,,,I loved it!!!!! so much fun! specially if u are the pirate King!,,,My brother was the pirate king so we HECKA had fun together since we ar best friends!!! ahahah
I have to play Samuel in a few weeks time. I'm desperately watching this over and over again, trying to learn it!
TheLOLturtles 1 week ago
And im THE PIRATE IN THE BACKGROUND oh yeah you know ur jealous
Voba1000 3 weeks ago
you guys are all freaking amazing! were putting on theis production at my church, and I got the role of pirate king. Let me tell you, this guy, whoever the pirate King, is my inspiration!
The16thPun 4 months ago in playlist The Pirates of Penzance Playlist
@andyowens01 I was Samuel in a production of this and trust me, I sounded worse than Marc James.
MrSamHargreaves 5 months ago
@MrSamHargreaves I was also Samuel, and after hearing this, I had a breakdown
MrJumpingdude 1 month ago
You know you can get amateur rights to this version. Personally, I think the Essgee one is only good when Jon English does it.
MrSamHargreaves 5 months ago
John English makes this a beauty to watch and enjoy!!!
gypsydog24 5 months ago in playlist The Pirates of Penzance Playlist 2
THATS RALPH AND DEADEYE FROM THEIR PRODUCTION OF HMS PINAFORE!
Julianumbah27 6 months ago in playlist The Pirates of Penzance Playlist
You have to remember that "operatic singing" didn't happen because people thought it sounded better. It was the natural outcome of having to project into large houses in the days before mikes. Whether mikes are an altogether good thing is another matter...
Pathtith 10 months ago 2
Mullett..... :/
tomaswolstenholme 11 months ago
I dont understand why all of these g&s operas ive seen online have singers that sound like theyre from broadway...this is still an operetta and should be done with classical voice!
adamskyb 1 year ago
@adamskyb - Why? If people enjoy it more and it's more accessible with a comprehensible, contemporary singing style, why should one stick dogmatically to a style imitative of the late 19th century? G&S isn't sacred. To treat it like a revered relic of the past, rather than a fun, silly romp that everyone can enjoy, is to miss its point completely.
PuissantAlgernon 11 months ago 2
@PuissantAlgernon I don't see how it makes it less accessible. people these days just dont know what talented singing is. It would be rediculous to sing other operas this way, just cause it's comedy doesnt mean the skill has to be down graded.
adamskyb 11 months ago
@adamskyb - Because people associate operatic singing with a certain style of music and tone of theatre, and switch off. Also, the operatic style is more musically interesting, but harder to comprehend. I've been to see this production in both an operetta style AND a musical style, and the audience comprehended the latter far more readily. Finally, the modernised, pantomimic presentation of this particular staging of 'Pirates' would make operatic singing feel completely out of place.
PuissantAlgernon 11 months ago 3
i can't find this version anywhere online and i really want to see the full play, not just the songs. it's pretty good.
Gargos98 1 year ago
you'll never believe this, but my teacher was in act 2 of this. We are watching this in class now.
Gargos98 1 year ago
@Gargos98 Who's your teacher?
MrSamHargreaves 5 months ago
I like this version more than others. It's very, very funny.
hardsixteenyeah 1 year ago
Saw this onSky Arts recently,absolutely brilliant version, loved it.
wenshadow1 1 year ago
I saw this (not this exact night) Australian production of it when I was three :)
And I'm not kidding, I started crying when they were tlaking about baby farming because I wanted to go on stage and sing, and Jon English stopped the show and asked if everything was alright - then they lost the plot!
kiaralouisee 1 year ago 2
Australia is just filled with really tall men with long, spectacular legs, isn't it?
PleiadesSeven 1 year ago 4
samuel has a terrible voice?!
andyowens01 1 year ago
LOL, this by far is my favourite version. Nothing compares, I grew up with the recording.
katieannexx95 1 year ago 2
Gosh this must be an old clip if this is the origional cast.
musicalsnclassics 1 year ago
The Pirate king looks like Mick Jagger...
tessamri 1 year ago
My school is doing this play. I'm in the orchestra! All YouTubers in Townsville, Australia, buy tickets!
SpeedsterXS12 1 year ago
we are doing a play on this at school and im in the chourus
SPEEDSTER7201 1 year ago
my school just got done doing this play
LadyEaglestar18 1 year ago
im pirate franklyn :(
Sharpiemantv2 1 year ago
is there a better way to start a show?
Fishstixj4l 2 years ago
Awesome, this is my song that I have to perform as an audition for my schools musical!
Lightzeaka 2 years ago 2
This Australian company's Pirates is the BEST I have ever seen. G & S would have loved it, it is so very funny.
yumyummoany 2 years ago 32
I agree, I LOVE this version of it. It's amazing! :D
JosieThom 2 years ago
Im Mabel!im doing the show nxt wk!
selenagomez28 2 years ago
I'm sameul at my school in june
legostarfreak 2 years ago
im samuel in this with a thetre group! go meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
wertywertywerty4686 2 years ago
i have to SHARE samuel it SUCKS show tonight
measuringtap3 2 years ago
I'm seeing this at my brothers college May 1st!
smileyroxyfox 2 years ago
I'm doing this play at my school.
I'm the pirate king. XD My friend is samuel.
awsomewolf244 2 years ago
u are gonna have soooooooooooo much fun!! I didi this play 2 years ago,,,I was Ruth,,,,I loved it!!!!! so much fun! specially if u are the pirate King!,,,My brother was the pirate king so we HECKA had fun together since we ar best friends!!! ahahah
blueicefairy11 2 years ago
im doing this play too at school i want to be samuel
measuringtap3 2 years ago
cool!!,,,,,did you get the part or they haven't told you??
blueicefairy11 2 years ago
i havent auditioned yet im still practising hoping hoping i get it
measuringtap3 2 years ago
good luck hope you get the part you want :)
4n5w3r4 2 years ago
Comment removed
measuringtap3 2 years ago
MAN TIGHTS!!!!!
Pandabear6612 2 years ago 16
my god Fredrich is SKINNY!!! but i love him and the show none the less!!
MagicalMistoffolees 2 years ago
I'm doing this show for my school in 4 weeks. I was originaly ensemble but then a boy quit so I became Samuel.
WamsWarrior 3 years ago
i just got cast as Ruth in our school show! im so excited!
agmrobo 3 years ago
Our school was going to do this play and was in the 'final' stage of production when the lead (for Fredrick) quit :(
violetwasp 3 years ago
Dude, what theatre group is this? I know it's been asked, but I can't find the reply.
Toothpicklvr 3 years ago
It's a troupe affiliated to Essgee Entertainment.
trajan231 3 years ago
it's an Australian production headed by Simon Gallagher (Frederick)
theboxofchocolates 3 years ago
I was going to be Samuel but I got a promotion to Ruth lol
LiddolFaye 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow im a pirate i hate drama its an ok play ok no offence u kinda nerds here
novian1010 4 years ago
talk about uncultured.
xxNenekoChanXX 4 years ago 3
@xxNenekoChanXX, who? The pirates? XD
Kari166 1 year ago
@xxNenekoChanXX
Yes, OK. Shall we start with you?
TheLoadedDog 1 year ago
hehe i like our schools version of this pkay better :P its still awesoem tho!
sweetandsour12 4 years ago
oh dear god! the electric music! the pain! The inhumanity!
wdstick 4 years ago
AGREED!!! It's painful! Better than none though...
webgoof 3 years ago
I personally would rather have no G+S than absolutely butchered G+S, but I can see where you're coming from.
wdstick 3 years ago
I personally would rather have no G+S than absolutely butchered G+S, but I can see where you're coming from.
wdstick 3 years ago
This is a great show - saw it live in Melbourne, the whole crew are fabulous, Simon Gallagher and John English are the best!!!
ggripper 4 years ago 3
"Pour, O Pour the Pirate Sherry!"
I love this play!! It is my all time favorite play!!
atheatergeek 4 years ago
Got the DVD of this Friday (Feb 2. I have watched it about 4 times already. I just love this.
jennjenn24 5 years ago
Mine's due to arrive any day, I cant wait! Im also auditioning tonight for the role of Samuel, so Ive been watching this clip a lot!
TRWolf 4 years ago
That's cool.
jennjenn24 4 years ago
haha i got the role of samuel in my schools version.
linklarkin07 3 years ago
You're so lucky to be able to get the DVD of this! I'm not sure it's available here in the US. It looks like such a great production. :)
Lissical 3 years ago
Im in the UK, its not available here either, I had to order it from Australia. Look it up online.
TRWolf 3 years ago