Added: 4 years ago
From: jimmart32
Views: 119,917
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (487)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this murder was more than likely was commited by someone in organized crime, miss smart double crossed someone or knew or saw something she wasnt supposed to and the person decided to make an example out of her, the reason she was dumped out in the open was that someone was sending a message out someone a warning.

  • I feel so sorry for Elizabeth shore just watched American horror story ad is creepy how much she looks like her !!

  • R.i.p Beth

  • Her destroyed body was found on Jan. 15? That's my birthday!

  • L.A Noire. Thats where I got the name of the case from. I just typed in the black dahlia and I didn't realise that it was a true crime case.

  • @deathmetalbunny58 im surprised you havent heard about it before hand, its a very well known case

  • @knights4379 I have heard of it, I was reserching it for a project once, but after that, the only time I ever heard it again was on L.A noire

  • O my god

  • The Why will be the Who wanted it done! The will be the responsible! The killer new her!...Boss

  • HOW IS THAT SEXY?!

  • @xLoliXKittyx It’s not the murder part that is sexy, it’s the icon she became because of it. Sexy women of yore become even sexier in the collective mind when surrounded by tragedy. They remain young, eternal beauties... The Marilyn Monroe image we were left to remember is a shining example of that.

  • Oh my god.

  • Hey, she got to be famous right? She got to famous at the cost of her own life....R.I.P Beth

  • l.a. noire & american horror story. ♥

  • American horror story did an impeccable remake of this tale.

  • Crappy Movie by the way...Waste of time. I guess that's obvious, since it was a flop....

  • When I see the actual photos of her autopsy, I noticed a wound above her Vagina...I think she was a Hermaphrodite, and the person cut off and destroyed her penis.That explains all the rumors of her not having sex with her many partners and one of the last men to see her when they slept in that motel. I think the person that killed her was in love, and when he finally got her to have sex, he became enraged...My book will be out in 2013.

  • @DannyBruiz But isn't the wound a little too far above her vagina for her to be a hermaphrodite? Really good theory though.

  • @TiffyBear I was just noticing that the distance from her vagina would be pretty close to where a man's testicles would be. And the wound on top would be pretty close to where a penis would be. Also, if you look at the facts that she could not have vaginal sex might be because she had a penis. Actually, in many pictures,she does look a little masculine. Just an observation. I was raised in the ghettos, and there were a lot of transvestites....I swear, you couldn't tell they were men.

  • Hi la noire

  • im here beacuse of AMERICAN HORROR STORY, she was played by mena suvary

  • the mouth wasnt cut in a grin it was cut straight back not upwards.Where did the grin crap come from

  • Read, 'Black Dahlia Avenger' by Steve Hodel. wwwstevehodelcom for information. Very respectful of Ms. Short.

  • Bitch please, I've solved this.

  • I believe that this was a ritualistic, sacrificial killing to satan. jack the ripper's victims too.

  • @BlissfulMary

    Can you explain how? I'm not trying to start anything, I'm just curious.

  • @reesescupbrandy1 It's ok to start something, I usually never finish it anyways LOL. I have woke up to the existence of many "secret" societies and their activities. In certain religions that are demonic in nature...one of the requirements is a blood sacrifice. There will be torture marks on the body and puncture wounds. If I can remember correctly, in some ancient cultures the sacrifices hair was died blond or red...my memory is off these days. adults and children go missing every year,why?

  • Keep your eye on "the synagogue of satan". this current world we live in is in darkness and in the hands of the wicked but things will change soon....and they know it.

  • this is so sad :'( makes me devistated

  • Comment removed

  • Oh god... Who would do something like that?

  • @VampiraSlayer George Hodel probably could, you need a surgeon namely and I've seen hella sick doctors close-up. I went to med school a few semesters here in Sweden and it was the scariest single place I've seen and I've been in over 20 countries, and I've seen more than I should. There was a similar dismemberment case at that exact place in the 80's which I actually did not know when I went there 2003 because they had covered up that it was the spot!

  • @VampiraSlayer Well.. This world doesn't lack psychos, soo

  • This case wasn't solved because Cole Phelps was in Traffic Department...

  • what the fuck is la noire ...

  • @esrapk a video game

  • i heard she was meticulously tortured foran 3 or 4 hours by her captor without empathy or anesthetics

    how was she tortured :/ im scared

  • I KNOW WHO KILLED HER! his name is Garret Mason!

  • @12Jakeyboy Very funny...

  • Oh fuck, that is horrible, I can't finish the video.

  • Lets put a smile on that face.

  • i just realized i live tn the 3rd house on the left lol

  • pie faced??? really never thought of here as pie faced

  • check out my evp session we did on ghost box scanner we got great evidence wich was sent to lapd already we got a first name and last name:)u could trell its her becuase of the accent.

  • too much of this no-name dude

  • @sownzgr8 uhh... that's called a best selling true crime writer. ever hear of that specialized career? prolly past your intellectual abilities. who do you think is better qualified to tell the story? a mechanic?

  • @pewsterbaby the story

  • @sownzgr8 dead men tell no tales, junior.

  • @sownzgr8 dead men tell no tales, junior.

  • @pewsterbaby boring grandpa

  • 6:38 - Cole Phelps!

  • 2:52 harvey dent!

  • I'm glad I killed the mother fucker in LA Noire...

  • OMG LISTEN TO THE SONG CLOSED CASKET REQUIEM FROM THE BLACK DAHILA MURDER IM PRETTY SURE ITS BASED ON THE CRIME

  • i tried to look for the black dahila murder

  • circumstantial. 

  • Worst movie ever made; has zero to do with the BD and everything to do with two idiot fictional detectives so the film title is misleading and so badly written and badly acted I was stunned. Horrible waste of time. Dreadful.

  • i'm here because of the band

  • Wow. They did a great job recreating this in l.a. noire!

  • Why so serious?

  • Only Cole Phelps and Rusty Galloway will know who it really was.

  • L.A. Noire

  • My friend is telling me about this crime from La Noire

  • Thumbs up if you knew about this BEFORE LA Noire :P

  • i knew about this BEFORE playing la noire

  • If you want to know who did it, play LA Noire (Facts not included but you'll catch the guy)

  • Wtf this was in LA NOIRE :/

    I'm here cox when I was live 5 or 6 I saw a doc about a murder like this and I found it interesting ( no I'm not going to turn into one of these sick fucks ) and the guys who mother was murder seems pretty similar does and one know who he is ? And is LA NOIRE based on true story??

  • @WarpGam1ng some murder cases were real in LA Noire.

  • @WarpGam1ng

    L.A Noire cases are loosely based on real life homicides :)

  • I'm here because of the movie.....fuck u pop culture fucks

  • phew! im not the only one here cause of L.A. Noire!

  • LA NOIRE!!!!

  • im here because of la noire

  • @superzip42 same i just wannted to see if the cases wre true lol

  • @superzip42 me tooo great ;D

  • @superzip42 yeah,LA NOIRE gameplay made me search up this 3 months ago and im still thinking about this murder.

  • @superzip42 im here becuase of the movie black dahlia

  • Do they know if it was done by one or more persons?

  • The guy at 0:03 has the most scariest, murderding voice that I have EVER heard. It's the kind of voice that when you go into a REALLY dark living room to make sure the door is locked, and then you hear: Hello, you really didn't think you could lock me out, did you?? YIKES!!! Then you break the windows trying to get out!!

  • THIS BLACK DAHLIA CASE IS GOING TO BE IN THE GAME LA NOIRE. ICANT WAIT FOR THE GAME AND ILL BE THE COP INVESTIGATING HER MURDER ILL FOUND OUT WHO IT WAS GUYS!!

  • How could any body have the stomach to do this???? I hope whoever did this is dead

  • at 8:26 is that her??...because if it is where are the gashes from her mouth to her ears??

  • @robsmith000 That is her, That is the photo that the news people but in the newspaper in 1947 when they found her, they cleaned it up. By fixing it so that they could publish it without Children seeing the gruesome crap that psycho did to her.

  • "maybe he had his reasons." really? so do you think that just because some psycho might have had a "reason" to viciously murder someone that it makes it ok, or that they should get away with it? i'm sorry, but there's no reason to chop someone in half at the waist, disembowel them, drain them of blood, cut their mouth from ear to ear, make them eat feces, and cut a chunk of their leg off and shove it up their genitals...

  • @belladonna4577 Maybe, it was a vampire..

  • dude , her pictures of her murdered scared the poop outta me!

  • i hate it when i hear people say maybe he had his reasons or they had a reason come one really a reason doesn't mean you can take someone life away just because how heartless can you be?

  • i've got pictures of her death in my phone, and it scares me.,

  • how could anybody do this

  • atleast shes famous now that's what she wanted right

  • @Kronikwisdom -.-

  • sucks to be her lol

  • Was she Joker face'd or was the Joker Black Dahlia face'd?

  • Cant wait till we nuke each other, no more sick freaks roaming free in this life.

  • @viktortsoi2 But people wishing we'd all die is okay.

  • @BLHLF Yup, cant wait.

  • @viktortsoi2 So you wish to kill thousands more people like her? And all the children? But the children are our future.

  • @BLHLF Well with enough nuclear power, destruction by nukes would be virtually painless. It's either ending the agony now, or live with thousands of more years filled with sorrow and hatred. Like a great man once said: "No man, no problem."

  • @viktortsoi2 Yay Hatred!!

  • I have a very stronge stomacha dn I have never beendesterbed by grussom photos, but i had to stop this vid....very disterbing!

    RIP

  • mouth staged ear to ear= chealsy smile used by the mafia

  • They say reality is biger then fiction.

    Very true and very horrific.

  • 2:01 gives me the creeps.

  • @sw7ng i know she looks like joker not to be humorous but yeah that did scare me the first time i saw it. now i feel Tempted to go to google and look up her pictures but im alone rihgt now and im not so sure

  • @SuperAchievementHelp You're alone? Where did you say you live? Do you like scary movies?

    LOL...Just kidding!!!

  • @418sadeyes well now im not alone so i think im gonna look at the pictures and comment back on u

  • @SuperAchievementHelp Yes, please do...Did you say you live in the third house from the corner, on the left? The two-story white with yellow trim? Sorry, but I couldn't help myself...LOL!!!! Your turn.

  • @418sadeyes i watched the movie " the last house on the left" is that what u meant because u really made no sense and im hard to scare so..

  • @SuperAchievementHelp No, sorry I was just trying to scare you...Guess it didn't work. I never could tell a story or joke correctly....

  • @418sadeyes wait wat was theme of your scare thing two comments before??

  • @SuperAchievementHelp Because to another poster, you wrote "I feel tempted to go to Google and look up her pictures but I'm alone right now and I'm not so sure" So, this seemed perfect when I posted to you. You see, I'm such a joker, but as you can see, I NEVER can tell a story correctly or tell a joke either. Now, I know I can't scare anyone for that matter.

  • @418sadeyes oh yeah my bad i forgot or didnt notice WOOOW

  • @SuperAchievementHelp Ok, Are you scared now?

  • @418sadeyes no rry but keep on trying ull get there:)

  • I can't wait till the killer burns in hell! What an asshole!

  • dude who ever did this must be crazy:|

  • who could do something like that to someone

    you gott to be messed up in the head! she was gorgeous

  • 70 or 80 murders in Los Angeles a year.

  • i once was the black dahlia killer, only on the fourth tuesday of 1974

  • i was bored so i looked this up to see how the band black dahil m,urder became the band

  • holy crap tht was a very brutual crime her body parts were every where and her cheeks split open ear to ear. just horrible. i thought at first tht she got split down vertical not horizontal.

  • thats just fuckin' sorry

    she should've just lived

  • there was a tale that she got the name black dahlia becuase they didnt know who she was at first.. they had a camra shot of a lady dressed in all black in a elevadtor, they never saw the face but wen they examinded her they figured that lady in the video and the lady on the road were the same... she is the most famous unsoled murder.. and the one murder that one day i hope to know who did it....

  • @BlackDahlia2110 Did you see the actually camera shot? and do you know if i can find it?

  • @LoveAj03 Oh I was so grossed out by the pictures, it is awful!

  • @OZZYloveBRITNEY aw i know it was at first 4 me too but i have known about Elizabeth since i was 11 and never had a nightmare from it, i love her... lol

  • @LoveAj03 i saw it on a show about three years ago, ill do some research for you and see if i can find it.

  • @BlackDahlia2110 Aw That is great thank you!! :D

  • From my hometown, my aunt new her.

  • @420HBK420 Seriouslyyyy???? I love ELizabeth short, I wish she couldve lived. :(

  • @LoveAj03 SHE WAS BEAUTIFUL

  • @thoostorm4 She was beautiful very gorgeous woman indeed. So no need to yell at me! lol hahaha

  • @FLYGON1998 They also cut one of her tits off ans stuck it up her ass. Who the fuck does something like this? The only thing thats anything like this is when Cattle mutilation occurs which many believe is the work of aliens and the evidence seems to back that up. Also a barazilian man was mutilated the same way as cattle. look it up Alien human mutilation

  • They say to always close the eyes of the dead....

  • @FLYGON1998 also when you look at the body it appears she was cut in half while in a sitting or slouching position. She was believed to be died when she was cut in half. Also when the lower body mutilation happened. she was tortured probably to death and also after death. The pics are quite haunting. i had to do a report on this. I showed the pics in class and a few people began to tear up at the horror.....

  • Threre is a place for sick people who do things like this...HELL but Im not the judge of that

  • over 60 people said they committed the murder, the police knew this would happen so they kept some of the details, only the real killer would know secret...one convict (who was in prison at the time of the murder) gave the police detail account of the murder...details he says his former cellmate told him about; he's cellmate was a sex offender, when police went to arrest him they found he died in a house fire...

  • how scary is it to know that a human being can inflict that kind of horror on another soul?

  • some people are willing to die to become famous

  • omg this makes me cry its so scary

  • the camera noise gives me a fright! :)

  • THE JOKER!

  • James Ellroy's voice sounds surprisingly like Harold Schechter's

  • theres an interesting theory involving ben seigal-abortion rings-prostitution-corrupt cops-vip's

  • Jesus he gave her a freaking Chelsea smile... Oh but they think they found who did it. I forget his name but he was a good surgeon so he was able to make a perfect cut as not to harm the vertebrae (sick bastard) and met the victim at a party one day. He went tard phsyco tho so he got what he deserved.

  • ...suicide

  • @levanyzzuf

    Please tell me how to bisect my own body in half, with enough strength to do several deep cuts into my bot, as well as a Glasgow.

  • dude holy shit!! that maniacal grin she had was fucking scarier than anything that i've ever seen in my entire life oh my god i will never forget that!!

  • @IrishEntertainment WHOA, SHIT !! i saw that too 0.o that nearly scared me to death !!

  • @IrishEntertainment what manical grin u talking bout i wanna see it

  • @chakal619ph

    Go to the 2:00 mark.

  • @UofLCardFan08 That's..... slightly disturbing.

  • 8:16 "searching for the language that illuminates the bestiality of this crime".

    I think the person who did "it" maybe wanted to play with the minds of the police, like "what could I do that would be really bizarre?", and that she was already dead when he found her.

  • why did this happen to her, so sad?

    ):

  • i looked up the black dahlia out of curiosity and a lot of pictures of her glasglow cut face popped up, it scared the shit out of me.

  • @zitalee2 I saw it too It scared the shit out of me

  • @zitalee2 oh i did, alright. it's fucked up O_o both the glasglow smile and everything else altogether

  • @zitalee2 well duh that kind of murder would scare anybody.

  • I believe that someone does have information about the Black Dahlia, i.e. grandfather or father has pictures or notes of some sort, but the person who has said information burned the evidence, not being able to bring themselves to be known as the family who kill Elizabeth Short. The man who made those false accusations was probably just a guy looking for attention.

  • She has never been an actress in reality. There are rumours that she had an affaire with a director, that`s all.

  • when i was watching a documentary on this in school....they showed that picture......

    of this girls arms sowed onto her head to make it look like horns of some type...

    and i think i remember hearing that they never even caught the person who did that to her....thats the part that scared me the most....

  • this is horrible the poor girl didnt deserve this the way her mouth was cut reminds me of the japanese urban legend the slit mouth woman its a weird case and i pray to god it gets solved and the killers will be punished by god worse then what they did to the porr woman

  • I find this case fanscinating probably because it happened so many years ago. If they haven't discovered the murderer already, they likely never will since evidence would be too old.

  • the thing is, is that when you think about it she had rumored romances with many people and so you think that somehow one of them could have been related to that. And did anyone else notice that the way that someone cut her from each edge of her mouth towards her ears was kind of joker-like?

  • reminds of jack the ripper

  • @SuperBullygirl i was just thinking that!

  • this is pretty graphic @_@ this is my favorite murder mystery. such a tragic story.

  • A guy thinks he has solved this actually. He says his dad did it. He found a lot of disturbing stuff in his dad's things when he died. Like pictures of her. He was a doctor. There was a documentary on it. His dad was weird.

  • @sdavenport1981 : I'm currently reading The Black Dahlia Avenger and firmly believe that yes , Dr. George Hill Hodel killed the Black Dahlia . The Franklin House of Horrors *chills*

  • I've seen alot of stuff in my life and this is the only one that scares me!

  • @MrGibert0  Same o . O it's always the music...the music just makes it even worse

  • He did

  • I hope her killer had very much of pain in his life.

  • Maybe he had his reasons.

  • In life, Elizabeth Short wasn't much more extraordinary from todays youth. In death, The Black Dalia is absolutely infamous. Looking at her pictures (Which is quite shocking, to say the absolute least) I get the vibe that her ghost will always haunt the human mind. I'm sure she would have never thought in her wildest dreams 63 years after her death, she would still be in the minds of most people worldwide, and told as gruesome reminder of how inhumane people can actually be. Very sad.

  • Who watches this crap!!!!!

  • is 2:00 (the chelsea grin on her face) is that an actual photo of her, or is it a painting? i cant really tell from the video