@odnoforpb If every singer were required to sing all pieces in the original key, it would disqualify many singers,- some of them great vocalists - from singing pieces they could otherwise deliver beautifully but for the lack of possession of a note or semitone at the top or bottom. Personally, I would far rather hear them sing it than be too precious about expecting them to over stretch themselves. Singing shouldn't be an exercise in athleticism.
Good job, but why the transposition a fourth down? Either sing the piece in the original key or not at all.
odnoforpb 5 months ago
@odnoforpb If every singer were required to sing all pieces in the original key, it would disqualify many singers,- some of them great vocalists - from singing pieces they could otherwise deliver beautifully but for the lack of possession of a note or semitone at the top or bottom. Personally, I would far rather hear them sing it than be too precious about expecting them to over stretch themselves. Singing shouldn't be an exercise in athleticism.
hiyadroogs 4 months ago