beyonce and ashanti sing silent night

[Mrz143Perez]

Both Yall Are Fucking Haters!

[nightopian2010]

Beyonce wins on tone alone. And she's not "trying to hard" she's just capable of vocal tricks Ashanti can't pull off in her wildest dreams so pairing her with someone with such basic vocal skills would make Bee seem to be doing a lot in comparison.

[aussiechic06]

Ashanti sucks.

[TiondriaC]

Now y'all are just wrong for 1:05!!! LOL

[dionasberry]

@TiondriaC Lololololol. Aint it?! Too wrong. But if the two do a song together, it just might be like that. Lol

[cyndyluro]

Ok first it didnt say shan vs bey it says shan and bey sing beyonce is a good singer ashanti gives me life ashanti aint no average singer if she was diddy wldnt had looked @ her ass nd fat face wldnt signed ha but bey be puttnin a lil 2 much emphasize on da song anyw) my point dey both did good ibet most yall aint even look @ da vid we need positvity and nt no hating hos

[destined4directn]

Is this a joke? Ashanti has nice songs, But if she could do what Beyonce could, then she'd be still doing music right? LOLOL

[carolinehp2159m]

tell u the truth i think ashanti sound better im srry if i make u mad if u a beyonce fan but im a ashanti fan

[as3ha1ti]

ashanti all day every day

[gypseyes]

I don't understand the comparison. Beyonce is a professional singer who uses different notes and has power in her voice, while Ashanti isn't quite as talented in that sense. Let's be honest, no comparison here.

[MsLeeny91]

Beyonce all day everyday

[princesol29]

ashanti is better

[TheBerrylicious]

Queen Bee.

[jasonvandermeulen]

ashanti i have respect but dang girl you cant sing like the queen BEYONCE

[sexytbc]

B try 2 hard

[cantlivethisway]

@sexytbc she sure in the hell do try too hard

[Wakyfan]

beyone

[MsSELfan]

Nice!!!!!!

[DOMINIW5]

theres a diffrence between going over the top messy and sounding good going over the top

[kei27isblessed]

Beyonce....

Ashanti can sing but not on Beyonce's Level. Beyonce sounds great singing in 1 note or doing runs.

[Beyoncefan1000]

ok ashanti, now let a REAL VOCALIST(BEYONCE) tackle that song the way it's supposed to be!!!

[PeaceLoveJustify]

Beyonce!

[CocoaBFly]

there is no competition for Beyonce with Ashanti. Ashanti has the same tone for every note. Beyonce could outsing her on her worse day : )

[Kacyification]

ashanti took a breath in the middle of the word peace:/ it sounded bad

they can both sing tho

[kmielle]

You're right !

[delocollier]

ashanti can sing she dont have to do all those common runs

[LUDA567ify]

this is a mix up...these are different songs...lol...u did good on the mixing

[22pineapple205]

beyonce to over the top and shanti is flat wish they both would do a better job

[lakesha93]

ok eww ashanti is sooooo flat (underpitch).

[MszOutstanding425]

ashanti's voice is bubblegum pop. beyonce is soul and r and b. not even on their tones of voice alone..beyonce has more range n betta vocals.

[TheTalentScout100]

ashanti fucked this shit up

[adriancaaa]

ashanti has a very young voice.. beyonce is something very very special ..

[intelly08]

Beyonce and ashanti cannot be compared ashanti has a normal voice like my lil sister of something and beyonce is in a totally different class than ashanti it isnt fair to compare them atleast not fair to ashanti

[cmorryx07]

They both have very beautiful voices. I think Beyonce has more of a mature womanly voice, where Ashanti has a sweet sounding voice, very soft. but I believe they are great.

[ashantithegoddess]

Ashanti is a GOD...she's gorgeous, articulate, intelligent...etc. she's an amazing person.

[buddsta05]

@ashantithegoddess dont compare her to good

[lilpelmer1207]

man ashanti beyonce don`t think who sing better they care about the carrer and they money so stop hating

[nikkie355]

ashanti has a beutifull tome but it terms of the complete voice i.e. control vibarto runs ad pitch she is million miles ahead of alot of singers and i think unfortunately ashanti is one of thos!!

[Youttubi]

Ashanti wins.

[crazyphillygirl]

Beyonce is better ! It's not rocket science !

[LDcool]

its mean to compare beyonce to those non-singers....beyonce is so much better....ashanti needs to jump off a cliff

[A31319]

ashanti dont have nothing on beyonce but ashanti do look better than beyonce on that picuture she look like the real diva beyonce just look to plain beyonce dont look right in that dress

[ROBINxXLACHELLE]

beyonce is da fuckn best..ashanti has nthn in dis possible world on B ...sHUT DA FUCK UP AND ALL BOW 2 DA BADDEST BITCH/ DA FUCKN QWEEN...

[GAVINLUVSBEYONCE]

wow umm we all know The Queen slays..Beyonce will always slay Ashanti in singing...Ashanti is like an average singer at best(not really best tho..lolz)

[09876tl]

BEYONCE WINS AS ALWAYS DUHH

[Breegurl13vegas13]

they were both song well in the song..... but beyonce did give better vocals.......):

[Beyoncefan1000]

comparing Beyonce to ashanti is like comparing a Tiger to a little cat!! beyonce has always been a better singer than ashanti!

[streetboycaiocesar]

Beyonce and Ashanti are great singers,and,ya'll shut up,shit. ¬¬

[gamerguy769]

thank u

[laffy]

ashanti is not a vocalist

[1hotandsmartman]

@streetboycaiocesar ( Beyonce is the best "Vocalist) Can you hear that?

[Chiney2oo7]

ashanti is shittttttttttttttttttttttttttt­ttt

compared to beyonce

[guschdel123]

Beyonce is SOO Much better :)

[Beyoncefan1000]

I'll put Beyonce up there with all the Legends because she is just that awesome!!!! I can't say the same thing about ashanti,monica,aaaliyah,brandy­, nor alicia!!!!!!!!!! Im not hating none of them either, it's just the truth!!! Beyonce is multifaceted while the others just stay in their own little comfort zones and that's why alot of them will never reach the apex that Beyonce has reached!!!!!!!

[llaimix]

They both did a beautifull job

but you no.. Queen B is Queen so she´s not to compare with anyone.

[stonexmen]

beyonce is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay beta than Ashanti and Whitney houstay................lol!

[0bsessionMuch]

Beyonce did it better for me. Ashanti wasn't bad either =).

[streetboycaiocesar]

Guys, don't compare Beyonce and Ashanti, plz.

[utubmyfoot]

Both of them ruined this song. It's a song of relaxation, not a song of showing off your voice with stupid runs. I will never listen to these two singing silent night ever again.

[JHudNumber1Stan]

Beyonce.

[Beyoncefan1000]

BEYONCE OF COURSE!!!

[BEYONCEvolve]

nobody sed ashati cudnt sing.........but honestly she kant compared 2 beyonce

beyonce iz in vocal comparison w/ whitney

howeva bey beatz jhud by far n mariah also kuz in natural tone mariah kant sing........litterally mariah soundz like ciara in natural tone but mairiah only soundz gud if she singz in a whistle regista......face it bey iz betta den evry1 out dere.....n ashanti jus haz a staggerry wafferry voice n itz weak az appozed 2 beyonce haz a powerful husky loud hi voice

[KeepTrue56]

beyonce is not on the level of whitneys vocaly.

beyonce best voice can not beat whitney best voice.

jhud mariah!? oh wait i just saw ur prof and username, ofcourse u will something absurd like that.

jhud will kill beyonce vocaly which is why her and xtina have been named vocalist of the decade.

and which is why jhud was the presidents original pick for first dance and her voice was all the rage. beyonce voice never gave anyone goose bumps or was the rage. just listen to "hello" annoying!

[0bsessionMuch]

Are you serious? Mariah can't sing?

[captivating07]

mariah CAN SING ..LOL Y THEY HATIN?

[0bsessionMuch]

Exactly, I don't know why they even mentioned her in this video. People just like to randomly hate LOL!

[sparklemp]

LOL @ "People just like to randomly hate" LOL

[AaliyahBrandyMonica]

ummmmm im not a fan of Beyonce but she sang better then Ashanti. Anyone with hafe a brain knows that. But lets have Beyonce and the grate AALIYAH sing thats a hole nother story

[Tschaia]

Beyonce is much better

[lilbrenth89]

its too many haters on ASHANTI...She wears that dress better than B and she is not trying to overdo the song unlike some ppl...why cant she just act human and not in charge for once! lol, yal stupid if yal think she is killin Ashanti, but she really aint!

[FawnBeecher]

how can ashanti wear that dress better than B. they are wearing two completely different dresses. since they are different tones of red and different styles of dresses so you cant say which one wears the dress better because they are two completely types of dresses! god!

[phswildcat2008]

the whole point is to stick out

&& that's what she's doing.

i mean, you don't wanna hear

the same ol traditional song

like some people sung it

[[lmao]]

good job to both ladies

but

BEYONCE' DID IT BETTER!!!!!

[[lmao]]

[sassyladi01]

BEYONCE

BEYONCE

BEYONCE!!!!!!!!

[54spiritedwill54]

Beyonce sounds great And ashanti

[lilhotbeauti]

yy u ppl hattin on ashanti she looks fab! beyonce voice aanoyinnn butt its ok... ashanti is good...

[smarthafsa]

BEYONCEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE is awesome, ashanti is full of shit, she suckz, she sounds like michael jackon hitted on da nuts.........

[streetboycaiocesar]

fuck all americans ¬¬ . Shut up and no compare Ashanti to Beyoncé.

[phswildcat2008]

so should we all be insulted???

[[lmao]]

[foxiroxi5]

kiss teet!!!! Fair is fair!!! Beyonce kills it!!! Ashanti sounds like sh*t!!!!

[tis4tasty]

You sholl do kno u must buy your dresses 4rm wal-mart o and don't get an attitude with me "honey" stay in yo lane now what that tell you

[MiztaBeyonceHimself]

OKAY ASHANTI RETIRE EARLY...

[dcj1623]

i think both artist can sing..its clear that beyonces vocals are stronger..alot stronger...ashanti just has a softer vocal than beyonce...just because she aint yelling dont mean she cant sing...she sounds fine to me...she just aint doing a whole lot of runs and what not

[elmerthugg]

U see how Beyonce gotta prove her self lmao sad case of I want it all me me me syndrome .

[tis4tasty]

Beyonce look so damn po in dis pic ashantis dress looks better on here

[MiztaBeyonceHimself]

Armani vs Wal-Mart daring please... BEYONCE'S DRESS IS FIERCE

[KADESIA19]

Beyonce Sounds Way Better;;

Ashanti Aint Got Shit On Beyonce's Voice!

Go Bee!!

[tonysatchel]

ashanti

[DanityKaneRulz]

beyonce looks and sounds like something i would pull outta my ass on the toilet

she suckz

bitch with no talent

[BEEIZDABEST]

they both sounded gr8..... ashanti can do way better

[imanirw]

i love them both but i think ashanti's voice works better with this song because its softer

[gayleayesha]

Beyonce is a much better vocalist......Ashanti cant really sing to tough.....she ayt though.... x x

[Bey0nceSUCKSASS]

beyonce just good for shaking her ass

bitch lives to copy off other artists and shit

beyonce looks and sounds like something i would pull outta my ass on the toilet

bitch with no talent

she is worse than any other female singer i've seen

stop sucking beyonce's dick you fucken stans

I HOPE THAT HOE DIES ONE DAY

[chickengoodt]

Beyonce sounds great

And ashanti

[bowwowomarionusher]

BeyonceSucaksass wats ur problem! obviously Beyonce means something to you for you to comment 400 times after every uploaded video with her in it! psycho bitch get a life...a bet ur a lesbian cauz only yall talk abt good looking people and hate

[Bey0nceSUCKSASS]

ashanti IS THE SHIT

beyonce is old and tired

[CHEETAH69]

Let me correct you: Ashanti IS shit! She's no vocalist by ANY standard.

[flag4eva]

What is wrong with singing the song, why do singer always do this and sing something else. This is a hard song to sing, and I think they both did bad. It onlky sounds good when a real soprano or tenor sings it and sings the song!

[Bey0nceSUCKSASS]

ashanti is way classier than beyonce

beyonce spreads her pussy to the world when she on stage

[DanityKaneRulz]

beyonce looks and sounds like something i would pull outta my ass on the toilet

she suckz

bitch with no talent

[CHEETAH69]

this comment from a Danity Kane fan! LOL. Sit down.

[DanityKaneRulz]

make me sit down bitch

[CHEETAH69]

LOL. what are you? 7? I'm not interesting in making you do anything. I just think that before you proclaim yourself a danity kane stan, you should probably check your Beyonce digs at the door. And just so you know, anybody who holds Danity Kane in HIGH regard, probably isn't in a position or place to critique ANY artists who actually is making hits and is still relevant in music.

[ilovecliffordjoesph]

fa all u dumbassses thats tlkn bout ashanti bein older yall aree fckn twistin up myy words i said old as in shes been out longer than ahanti;;damn if u gon get at me on my shit makee sure that yo ass understand wut im sayin&if u gon come ,come correct u dumbassess

[Bey0nceSUCKSASS]

beyonce sounds horrible

bitch cant sing or act

she suckz

bitch with no talent

[hotboyeazye]

Beyonce sounds better and thats the bottom azz line so comment back on me hatin azz bitches

[glennsofly]

ashanti sounds like rihanna with a cold

[DOMINIW5]

i's funny because beyonce sounds like a grown woman and ashanti sounds like a damn kid i love ashanti but it is really true she gets no buzz about her voice

[ilovecliffordjoesph]

92shay-well it sure look lyke u missed understood it;but anyway yeah beyonce's a good artist but ilike shanti becus her voice is better[well on this song]ashanti c.d was good unlike that i am..sasha feirce shxt i need to thro mine awayyy;

[ilovecliffordjoesph]

uhm....92 shay who asked yuh??andi dnt mean in age i meant like she came out befo ashanti so dnt twist my words uhp;;;

[92Shay]

i didn't twist ya words up maybe i took them the wrong way.... but n-e-wayz beyonce doin her thang what can u say about ashanti her cd wasn't all that...dont get me wrong all beyonces songs arent gold but they worth listenin to as well is ashantis but beyonces version was way better...simple as that

[BeyonceIsACunt]

beyonce looks and sounds like something i would pull outta my ass on the toilet

she suckz

[Jennein]

You a dumbass

[JohnnyCadesChick]

ok listen, they both are talented. Both of them to me are amazing. They both can sing really good so jus leave it at that.

[ilovecliffordjoesph]

okaye beyonce u okayy but u gettin old so move aroun and let tha yung girls skool u;;;ashanti all tha way

[92Shay]

if the old need to get out the way then ashanti need to gon head and give it up cuz shes older than beyonce...ashanti born october 13 1980...beyonce september 4 1981

[browneyez1012]

tell it like it is! lol thank god for beyonce. beyonce to this generation is like tina turner for the last generation. have you heard what they put on the radio now days also it seems like they pick anybody to be a singer. like i said thank god we have a moral raw talented artist around still. shes a great example to woman. u don't see her clubbin and drinkin or doin drugs and goin to rehab or jail like these other singers

[baglady26]

ashanti is older than beyonce u dumb ass.lol

[dOthefadeaway1x]

loooove ashanti!!!!! shez gorgeous all over...luv bee too but ashanti is sooo the top bizness!!!

[BeyonceAintSHIT]

beyonce can go suck jayz's dick and choke on it

whack ass vocals

[1solvemymystery]

i agree

beyonce can go to shit

[brenden718]

ashanti=baby beyonce=woman

[miggle15225]

They both did good.

Its a tie.

[1solvemymystery]

beyonce is garbage

end of story

all beyonce does is yell

[rendition55]

It takes everything in me not to just go off on you right now. If Beyonce is so garbage then why is she and Jay-Z the top paid Hollywood couple and why does she have over 60 nominations and over 50 trophies? And why is she at the top of the billboards. And why is she... I could do on all day, but to someone like you who doesn't think before they open their mouths, it wouldn't change a thing

[1solvemymystery]

lmaooooooooooo

ashanti beats that bitch

[rendition55]

In what way?

[domin89]

what?!!!!!!!!

[electone7]

Both can sing. But Beyonce' does not need to do all the voice shaking she does on such a sacred song.

[blakbarbi4]

ashanti sound like a talent show version of the song. medicore Beyonce over done it too much. i dont like neither..

[tweetie35]

OK I'm going to start off by saying Beyonce is the better performer and she uses a more verity of vocal range and pitch....BUT!

On this video Beyonce is just harmonizing more and did to many runs were they shouldn't be. y'all got Ashanti fucked up cause her ass can harmonize but chose not to on this song on this video.

[Mynef93baby]

Beyonce sounds better!!!

[1QTMOM]

I like ashanti dress in the picture and beyonce look pretty as always.

[MissLady21488]

Ashanti's vocals have gotten better than they use to be, but I know damn well that somebody should have told her NOT to sing with Beyonce!! Beyonce made Ashanti sound horrible compared to her. Ashanti sounded like a bad American Idol audition...B;).

[biboi90]

Ashanti can sing but Beyonce can sannnnng and act and dance...oh and Ashanti can sing....sometimes

[miszdigga]

There is not a comparison. Just listen to Beyonce's ability to rip and run. She shuts Ashanti down. Although, I've never been an Ashanti fan.

[deek912]

ashanti is the best

[abynice90]

beyonce is the best girl in the wold

[cheesepuff1029]

i love it!

[grobinson20]

beyonce sounds classic and ashanti sounds like a school concert

[theelitemusician]

hahahaha U RIGHT!!

[DJChucky05]

they both can sing

[beyonce170]

beyonce sounds great

ashanti sounds kinda like michelle williams for a minute dont u think so

[o0Tatifbabyo0]

I think so too...but are they singing together..why would Ashanti and Beyonce Sing Together...that's another reason I believe it's Michelle

[okebaram]

Weere they singing together? Because if that's the case, they werent blending with each other.

[deek912]

and why does ashantis voice sound different from what it does on the video when she didi this performance! i think someone has been doing some audio editing

[deek912]

ashanti hands down

[maurisheldon]

listen to the pitch and texture of the two voices. the runs and how they pronounce the words. beyonce has texture and fullness you her voice and understands pitch and runs. any one who knows anything about voices and singing and not who they like and who looks better can hear and understand that beyonce is way more skilled.

[DOMINIW5]

right i understand exactly what you saying i mean beyonce tone is better than ashanti i mean that alone is better than ashanti's but i mean beyonce is with the greats now

[princessbabe100]

Beyonce over does her voice way too much, in every song she sings. It get to be annoying after a while. She draggs the songs on too long.

[1shida1]

BEYONCE BABY!

[dede2122gc10]

Ashanti sucks ass and will alwasys suck, she cant hold a note......not one

[bombelona]

that's unfair.......

u can't put them 2gether and compare, of course Shanti's gonna loose.

she can't reach higher tones......

[GangGreen555]

Ashanti is so fine. She looks 10000 times better in that pic. Beyonce is wack. She over doing her voice. She aint got shit on Ashanti.

[kyla2cutie]

beyonce dats all i gotta say

[doiloveu]

boyonce@ladiesamira01 but whateva was the best shyt ask bout her.....

[whoney1919]

GO ASHANTI U ARE STILL MA PRINCESS

[maurice20048th]

Beyonce hands down!!!

[NMJRB]

you dumb bitch beyonce smoked her ass dat bitch sucks beyonce surly does like ova doin things just like she ova did her non singing ass

[missbabyface25]

beyone wants to be like every body even rihana that just come in the business. i think shakera tired of her now

[biboi90]

how is beyonce being like rihanna didnt beyonce come out first

[asdersincan]

gooo beyonce i love you sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooo

[quintinlovesmuzic21]

Beyonce!!!!!!!!

[lildre96]

OH H3ll NAW..B3YONC3 FUCk3D DiS All UP..

BUT HA PART WAS GOOd TO BUT d3M TWO AiNT M3Nt TO GO TOG3TH3R!!..

[LadieSamira01]

boyonce is a hootie & is she pregent by jayz

to boyoce with boyonce's hot single profromer's

[zingizfresh]

R u freakn serious how could u could u compare that thing 2 beyonce?

beyonce killed ashanti and brought her back to life again

be is tha queen

[Jagyrl]

Ashanti is aweful. Bey sat her down and brought her hat to her. Ashanti messed up the song, thats real talk!

[Spyder246]

beyonce messed up the song with all that faux sexuality and vibratto on a simple xmas song. Sometimes its ok to sing a song straight.