Added: 4 years ago
From: teuba
Views: 580,704
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (825)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • That guitar solo sucked. Im sure that if that solo were played by gilmour, this song would be incredible floydian. play together again roger an dave!

  • Ontas mi amor

  • MI AMORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

  • This song is amazing. I dont get why people say : floyd song with a touch of roger... in the end... They are 1 ! Until they broke up? :P

  • when i hear roger, i enter in an incredible peace...

  • yeah pretty good movie and this sounds like some pink floyd type song

    is their anybody in there

  • This isn't pink floyd, it's Roger. Roger is wonderful, but he isn't Pink Floyd. That's why they broke up in the first place, it's insulting.

  • sounds like a floyd song

  • compare this to australian idol or x factor and u have 2 differents ends of the universe; a real man, a real musician a real etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc

  • Hello I love you

    Is there anybody in there?

  • Hello Roger.I Love You♥

  • Comment removed

  • I just love Waters, period. He's a genious for me!

    But I'm really pissed with him, he leaved PF in 85, and in almost 30 years he just recorded 3 solo albuns (that are amazing, 3 of them) and 1 Opera, fuck, I want to listen another album, this song is a proof he still can be fucking good, and yet he still doing Dark Side and The Wall :(

  • @progshine you fuckin right

  • I love studio videos!

  • he did this with howard shore, the genius behind the lord of the rings soundtrack :D

  • Is this a new song? because if someone told me this was from barrett era i would believe them ; well done roger

  • I love his voice.

  • try to sell that rog!

  • i found it by tapping ''i love roger'' :') <3333

    and i meant THAT Roger! ROGER WATERS!!!

  • This song kinda creeps meh out at the end of the movie with the pictures of dna

  • KURWA , waters powrocil !!!!!jest znow wsrod nas 

  • I love love PINK FLOYD AND ROGER WATERS. They both give me GOOSEBUMPS every time I hear there songs.

  • Roger waters is an ass hole and a genius

  • quien me puede traducir este tema? no encuentro la traduccion en ningun lado, desde ya muchas gracias!

  • This song, more than most any other from Waters' solo work, screams for Gilmour on the electric guitar. Think how fantastic it would've been with his contributions. I don't feel it reached its potential in its current state. That said, it's a terrific song as is. I stumbled on this by accident and like so many others here I find myself wanting to listen to it over and over again.

  • Waters was a great lyricist but only fair in the vocal department. Water's voice waivers too much when he tries to belt a tune out. Unlike Brad Delp who was absolutely brilliant vocally.

  • @RickJLV ...yeah Boston vs Pink Floyd...that's like Submissive, yet popsy Corporate Rock vs. Rebellious, yet Legendary Corporate Rock. I'll take "Comfortably Numb" over "More Than A Feeling" any day of the week.

  • I was watching "The Last Mimzy" and this song started playing and I thought to myself that it sounded a lot like Roger Waters...lol

  • I don't really care about what other haters say about this song we all know it's really good you don't have to be a sore punk about it thats not at all as far as i know what song are even for.My personal opinion is that this an awesome song and people shouldn't be mean about because they are just jealous.

  • This song ties in with my life. I grew up in Seattle and longed for it when my family moved to California. I've since moved back. My future was my past. Alot of people also called me "Pink Floyd" and "Roger Waters wannabe" It's funny how this video touches on this theme.

  • Kind of a tribute to the old songs he did . Just my opinion, nice to hear just the same.

  • Waters return to Argentina¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ WE LOVE YOU¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ REALLY

  • lol this song sucks, all of you people who say think its brilliant are sorely mistaken. He did some awesome work with Pink Floyd yes and he even did fine on solo stuff. But this just sounds like a mash up of multiple different songs that he did with pink floyd even down to lyrical content sometimes. You people don't have to like something just cause someone who made good music at one point is still grasping at making new things.

  • @thirdechelon I'm a huge fan of Waters, but I have to agree with you here.

  • @thirdechelon Hey, I'm 16 and a few years back this is one of the first songs that turned me on a musical path to Pink floyd, and later Led Zeppelin, The Doors, The Who, The Beatles, etc. Roger Waters was and still is an amazing musician, don't be a hater.

  • Comment removed

  • @thirdechelon waters is writing reflectively, and that's y it seems like a 'mash-up,' but this in no way constitutes 'sucking.' there's raw, complex, thematic emotion explored throughout; time passing, distances between 'frequencies' widening inevitably, acceptance but the pain of such acceptance as can be felt in building crescendos. and what makes it most waters-esque is that there's more to explore in it; i can't fully decipher it all just yet. try reading it from a different perspective.

  • sound like pink floyd

  • i love this song i have the dvd :) but i sumtimes hear it while playing computer games

  • So who are the 37 dislikes ???? Are you people def ???

  • When I went to see 'The Last Mimzi' in the movie theater, I had no idea Roger had scored the theme for it. What a treat hearing his voice after years of no new material.

  • When I went to see 'The Last Mimzi' in the movie theater, I had no idea Roger had scored the theme for it. What a treat hearing his voice after years of no new material.

  • Jesus, that little girl is so lucky. Actress, AND singing with ROGER WATERS. I mean I freaked out when I saw him in concert (I'm 15) because I knew I was in the same general area as him!

  • hermosa cancion

  • lookin up hello i love you(by the doors)facts and saw roger waters made a song called hello i love you, this is a classic-psychedelic roger waters sounding song

  • huh, I thought he'd covered the Doors' song

  • @PadraigMou me,too

  • the last mimzy was a great movie

  • Makes me shiver ever time,Rogers voice is beautiful..

  • Excellent song. I sing it all the time at school.

  • Great tune!!!!

  • What a really good track:) i like this

  • This species has amused itself to death.

  • This song could have been on The Wall.

  • This song so didn't need to be related to this movie, it stands out so much beyond it.

  • Roger misses Dave....he practically gives himself away..Dave, make peace with your brother, Roger, he love you....

  • how could someone not like this song?? its awesome

  • Somehow this afterthought of a song has failed to prevent the progression of technology.

  • Wow this is great, i thought this was gonna be him doing a Doors cover when i clicked on it haha.

  • This song is incredible, it gives me shivers <'3

  • Probably my favorite post-Pink Floyd Roger Waters song, it SO makes me think of you <'3 Hello I love you Is there anybody in there? The ghosts are walking by my side I feel their love I feel their pride For I have built a bridge or two Bridges between me and you Hello I love you Have you heard It was on the news You can make your peace On the dark side of the moon I'll see you there We can rock 'n' roll We can make our choice Hello I love you
  • the solo would me better if it was Gilmour doing it...

  • So did he borrow the title of this song from Jim Morrison? Waters and Morrison are my two biggest inspirations

  • the greatest

  • I can not stop listening to this song, it is PF, but also has the touch of Waters. It is very good, it is inexplicable.

  • Actually it is NOT Pink Floyd at all...this is 100% Waters...SOLO...with the help of Andy Fairweather Low and produced by James Guthrie...2 long time co-horts of Rog's. Waters has not collaborated with Gilmore or the rest of PF for 30 years...

  • @TheAlienProphet He last worked with Gilmour and Mason as Pink Floyd on record in 1983 for The Final Cut. I'm sure you know of the collaborations they've had in concert in the last 10 years, though.

  • @frankiiyoo i'm having the same problem, i cannot stop listening. it's eerie, fateful music that submits u to accept an eventual reality u have to face. and it is very Pink Floyd

  • @frankiiyoo It's very Roger Waters with a touch of Pink Floyd

  • Morgan, you're in every note of this song, baby girl. You amaze me. Love you, mom

  • This could be a Pink Floyd song. 

  • hello, is there anybody in there ? ...

    that remember me something, but i don't know what...

    Waters rules xD

  • @elpayot pink floyd comfortably numb is wat it made me remember

  • @elpayot how about the entire album "The Wall"?

  • i love this song. it sounds like classic pink floyd

  • Its all Roger, Writting the music is what the music is... Rog made Gilmour.

  • nothing better to do but write opinion? This is a very interesting yet juvenile song

  • Too bad Waters and Gilmour don't see how awesome they are together. Too many big egos.

  • @schultz970

    they did play in july a few song at Hoping Foundation's annual fundraiser. Some of its here on youtube.

  • @Ozzhead42  Thanks!

  • me.

  • fascinating works...

  • as i show off real nuke labs an places with the first walk around xray was made with a chip yet human memory fore sight or memory, i say evil gave them the party as i the warning for crime lord was god less skilled as race an place no so as american been missed schooled no best safty ways, yet at an end on the report an requsted safty of us all shure some things are linagae still the crime must be nocked on it ass for they have made first a few are past the law rangeing

  • it was no easy to do get harmed by some bands an stop the juges of at no same persons an still makeing worse lack of woman self control i file my paper work for shows 20 years pre some places are part of pre ww1 science done as safty past the crime still see the nasa ghost seen in the harry potter an other magic boxes as wire made of labs not american or europen still , will they prove honest an get the old age money part the test greed is not quailty of life i see an walk for miles took time

  • hello band seems the toys worked well to make the hart jab, same place the harrypotter box i fixed a working as a child still gov can find whom comes no back science medical no best law human fight rf sciences mind my warnings 20 years on ten to heal as the band hears light stage an sound as a gov helped child still real fall out science older then usa some the rules the tool shop country ask of my 30 year to make report on crime by shows real what was done most the shows josh k h palmer eric

  • I love the hateful snarl on his face when he utters the word "TV".

  • coon

  • can we ever get pass it all.? cool....verse bridges.....make sence now dude!

  • roger arent we supposed to pass on the past? remeber that time in scranton when lighting made the best show of montage ever.........u might have been scared bit? but show must! go on!

  • On jest Geniuszem

  • i really love this song.

    i hope there are no more.........games/ make your peace up to the darkside of the moon. Human kind......ness..../ full of love....not loveless. learn please

  • This sucks! a composite of crap! or a polished turd.

  • What everyone has missed is that this song references Live8.

    When he talks about the ghosts by his side and their love and pride he is talking about Pink Floyd members.

    Likewise the make your choice say goodbye or say hello.

    It's a message to Gilmour.

    As is the making peace on the Dark Side of The Moon line.

    I guess Gilmour heard it. It's a plea.

  • Anyone who wrote such an heart-achingly beautiful song deserved another reunion with Gilmour nothing more nothing less. Now I'm satisfied!

  • Whoever it is , Waters or Gilmour, who is NOT or is REFUSING to work with the other is SELFISH and should tear down that wall that is preventing you from doing so !

    Pink Floyd is enjoyed by so many , please think of us too when you decide not to work with eachother.

  • Waters and Gilmour are so talented. It's a shame they don't play together any more. They were a great musical team, like Lennon and McCartney.

  • they were 29 times better, lyrically.. and for guitar.. haha, no contest.. gilmour ran circles around anything they put our.. hell syd was better than them.. they are the most overrated band of all time..

  • @acousticsoul26 If you're saying Syd wasn't any good, I'll have to disagree with you. Syd was amazing, and so is Roger.

  • @RickJLV Rober Plant and Jimmy Page too

  • ...or Simon and Garfunkle. The meshiing of the great talents. We crave what you can do.

  • @RickJLV NOT ANYMORE! :D

  • @RickJLV estos son mejores papa! y te olvidaste de wright... y de harrison

  • love you Roger

  • for i have built a bitch or two, bitches between me and you! =]

  • One of the most beautiful ballads by Roger Waters...a genius of music he is.. :)

  • Gilmour is such a bastard unfortunatly he's a talented bastard who desperatly misses his friend. When Roger talks about a Pink Floyd concert being fun he means it cause we fans are missing alot more than our friend. Something we barely glimpsed at Live8.

  • I LOVE THIS SONG AND THE LAST MIMZY

  • @marie1w EXACTLY, i went to watch it for my 11th birthday when it came out and i loved it so much. great movie, awsome song.

  • Roger never disappoints!

  • love this song--- great voice :)

  • cover total de los grandiosos the Doors en cuanto al nombre, ojala se te hubiera ocurrido un nombre diferente.

    Influencia a leguas de The Doors.

  • pinches viejiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iiitosssssss!!!

    mataron la canción con este ritmo tan de viejitos,

    chaz

  • 3:19 Is this James Guthrie?

  • @nutzergeloescht01 Yes, he is!

  • @Herod9 He must be younger than Roger. Or he has dyed his hair.

  • @nutzergeloescht01 Indeed he has aged quite well ;)

  • ....won't you tell me your name!

  • @snoogans999 jajajajaja i thought the same!

  • his voice sounds better than it did in the 90's... Great song...

  • This song blows me away!!! Best i heard from him in a long time. This is better than most of his solo material in my opinion. This is the Roger Waters we know and love. I love it when he write dark stuff like this.

  • @bassmanjoe Have you listened to Amused to Death? That entire album is far better than any album put out by Floyd/any Floyd member since The Final Cut

  • The last mimzy made me understand who I am more then I did already!! It was an amazing movie!!!

  • awesome tune and awesome movie

    soo happy it is one of my 3 year olds faves cuz of the sounds or whatever peaks a 3 year olds interest

    this movie and song never gets old

  • i just figured this is floyd singing

  • Nah just Roger Waters who used to sing for Pink Floyd. He went solo back in the 80's

  • sounds like pink floyd

  • @hallma50 yeah cause he was in pink floyd and sang occasionally

  • isnt this the same as Comortable Numb?

  • How has this song not had more views ? Without sounding like a sham, this is the type of music Floyd would be making these days if they were still together.

  • @trollfinger Absolutely agree..this song should AT LEAST be on a Waters' solo album, and not some forgettable movie soundtrack, though this isnt the first time Waters has written great songs that barely got noticed (When the Wind Blows & Music of the Body) But yes, if Pink Floyd were still making music, this would fit great..great lyrical references to earlier work, and the a very "Gilmour-style" guitar sound..its just has that Pink Floyd sound overall..great tune.

  • *.*

    2:42 <3 (L)

  • You just You.....

    you are the best musician with the best of lyrics ever on earth

    Make the greatest show on earth.... please....

  • ooohhhhh...So beautifull..

  • Very beautiful song

  • probably... no absolutely the best song of last 10 years!

  • the lyrics have references to the wall

  • from which album is this track

  • It's only available on the original soundtrack, and very limited as a single. Probably download too, But Roger hasn't done a studio album since 1992.

  • god loves us all .. ..

  • This song is new to me. When I read the tracktitle I thought: "huh, Roger goes The Doors?", but the song and text is very Roger, even with references to old PF texts (is that even english?).

  • rodger waters is my shit.... huge floyd fan

  • This is the best thing that happened in our time! "cries"

  • Why do people give thumbs down whilest i give roger a compliment.

    Waters/Gilmour/Wright/Mason/Ba­rrett

    Are Floyd.

    No Competition.

    Pink floyd for life!

  • you lot dont get it, roger is taking the piss out of gilmore,lol,

  • Roger Waters , one of the greatest song writers ever ....brilliant !!!!!!

  • AWESOME! Listened this album the whole day through and i thank my lucky stars that i found this full album for free download at DownloadMusic/./im ,remove the slashes .

  • as roger always did

  • Hello I love you..Is there anybody in there

    just fucking brilliant......

  • che bella canzone

  • I'll never understand how they got one of the greatest song writers of all-time to write a track for this shitty movie

  • well i mean he's gotta have like no money left

  • is their anybody in their? we can rockn roll on the dark side of the moooon. SHINE ON

    YOU CRAZY DIAMONDS

  • @75pounder In their what?

  • waters is and always was floyd ,cos he was there with syd! gilmore is a great guitarist but thats all ,i love the way roger looks at the cam at the end? beat that dave,lol,

  • Comment removed

  • I agree.

    The band is just fantastic, that is really what I think. Oh, by the way, which one's "Pink?

    Roger

  • i know the last mimzy i have a cd of that my little sisters like it

  • a great song from one of the most talented musicians ever

  • @fruitloopz4eva ya he is fantastic but I think he has MAJOR issues with letting go...I mean despite the fact that this song is FOR the Last Mimzy i think its relly ABOUT Syd Barret

  • It's a fantastic song and the film is wonderful...

  • I just read on the internetS that it is Steve Gadd!!

  • Is that Steve Fucking Gadd on drums???? Man!!! You pretty much cna't get anyone better than that!!!!

    I don't know about this "re-hashing old lyrics thing" PInk Floyd without rogers sucked because it lost his amazing lyrics, but has he run out of things to say?

  • I wouldn't say he's run out of things to say, it's just a device, that's all. The Beatles sang "she loves you ya, ya, ya," at the end of Hey Jude - same device. My humble opinion. Have a sweet day!

  • Nice song from the genius. But, we need a new album. But, good news folks....he is going to tour the greatest album of all time, The Wall in a year or so. That will rule.

    Maybe you Gilmour nerds can convince fat-boy David Samson to go tour On An Island again....YEEEEEECH!!

  • dude Dave did the EXACT shit on On An Island.older Floyd is represented in new Floyd allll the time.

  • i though he said look at the gras i thought he was gonna say you got to keep the lunaars on the grass lol

    SHINE on

  • lol this song makes me laugh

  • roger is the poet of the new century....this song is great......sure he uses his own words a few times.....but all of his fans use his words in every day life....when i leave my friends i tell them "ill see you on the dark side of the moon".....it has more meaning than just being words in a song....way deeper and philosophical are the word in any pink floyd or roger waters songs.....go listen to any of their albums....listen to the words...and let yourself go with them.....youll thank me later

  • Look, this isn't a bad song. And who cares if he borrowed around 15 words, from 2 albums? It really makes no difference. And the kids who heard this wouldn't have gotten it, it's just there for the "diehard" fans. Just get over it. If you hate this song, before you came here, why did you come here?

  • danlett97 you are so lame if someone uses i love you alot you would say the same? is there any bodty out there is not even in the same meaning as it was in the wall and the dark side its not stealing from himself..dude you are just pathetic

  • well i like it im a big Pf fan and this is good