It's clear you're really playing it, but the recording is just too polished. I think I've heard the exact same recording before, same cadence and style. Sorry bro, I'm guessing you tried but weren't satisfied with the results so you dubbed it. Fake.
@dejota2991 it's not fake. I can tell. it's not hard to tell if you know how to play it. he plays it pretty well, but there are a number of (a few really) mistakes, and he forgot to play the trill in the second part. overall not too bad. he totally jacked the ending with crecendo, but he just needs to slow down and make sure his hands are well coordinated. a bit more practice, he's got the general feel there though.
I like it! How's the keyboard? how's the hammer? I saw someone selling this piano that's why I find your video to feel how it sounds like. Thinking of buying it...because it sounds great.
The hammer action is really nice and responsive, you get a good feedback from the bed. Piano sound is also good if that's what you are looking for. It sound better than this recording, this video is not very good quality, i must post some more soon.
Great! How did the left hand chords ope for you?? I am playing this piece at the moment and the left hand chords are hard! ANY tips on playing this ???Reply back when you can! Thanks!
Hey i just thought i would say this was great. It's definately NOT fake. So sick of people who think they know everything about something being fake. If some of you actually UNDERSTOOD music and KNEW what you were talking about, it would actually help before you insult people's skills. Great Job Craig Adam.
Brilliant. I enjoyed that all the way through to the end. I saw a river at night with a bridge with gas lamps reflecting off the water. The rippling water was like liquid gold.
yo man,i hear that song before 10 years ago when my friend play this on cd !i remember the melody and then i watch dexter i can't believe what i hear!I can't wait for dexter season 4!bye
Congrats on the emotion. The feelings are all there...which is hard to find nowadays. It's especially difficult to convey that thought on an electronic keyboard. I would just suggest some more dynamics and variety to perk up the performance. Crescendoes would definitely add more poignancy to the piece.
P.S.: Don't be nervous. We're willing to hear you play! Keep it up!
fucking awsome, god bless you...
SupaMutant 3 weeks ago
It's clear you're really playing it, but the recording is just too polished. I think I've heard the exact same recording before, same cadence and style. Sorry bro, I'm guessing you tried but weren't satisfied with the results so you dubbed it. Fake.
mrsbutterfields 7 months ago
@mrsbutterfields Right, and it doesn't sound like the Roland FP3 sound. I can see that you're playing the right notes, but it doesn't sound right..
sorenpg 6 months ago
How could those people just believe in this "FAKE"??? Funny really funny
dejota2991 9 months ago
@dejota2991
Your not the first to say it fake.
I will post a more recent recording made with a better web-cam, this should put the debate to rest.
craigadam 9 months ago
@craigadam I watched more closely and found that It really isn't fake. Sorry.
dejota2991 9 months ago
@dejota2991 LOL why would this be a fake? It's not even Grande Polonaise, or a sonata, this is the easiest work from Chopin.
hellboyreloaded 9 months ago
@hellboyreloaded I thought It was fake cuz the movement of his hand wasn't in tune with music
dejota2991 9 months ago
@dejota2991
Have a look at my - Chopin Nocturne Op. 9 No. 2 is it Fake Reply video. Is it or isn't it fake?
craigadam 5 months ago
@dejota2991 it's not fake. I can tell. it's not hard to tell if you know how to play it. he plays it pretty well, but there are a number of (a few really) mistakes, and he forgot to play the trill in the second part. overall not too bad. he totally jacked the ending with crecendo, but he just needs to slow down and make sure his hands are well coordinated. a bit more practice, he's got the general feel there though.
suitabledude 4 weeks ago
I like it! How's the keyboard? how's the hammer? I saw someone selling this piano that's why I find your video to feel how it sounds like. Thinking of buying it...because it sounds great.
tonywaiting 1 year ago
The hammer action is really nice and responsive, you get a good feedback from the bed. Piano sound is also good if that's what you are looking for. It sound better than this recording, this video is not very good quality, i must post some more soon.
craigadam 1 year ago
Great! How did the left hand chords ope for you?? I am playing this piece at the moment and the left hand chords are hard! ANY tips on playing this ???Reply back when you can! Thanks!
MusicClassical1 1 year ago
Hey i just thought i would say this was great. It's definately NOT fake. So sick of people who think they know everything about something being fake. If some of you actually UNDERSTOOD music and KNEW what you were talking about, it would actually help before you insult people's skills. Great Job Craig Adam.
yew2533 1 year ago
Bello wonderful!!!! I'm italian, iwant to say about the digital piano, but it's the fp4???
1090800 2 years ago
Nice playing :) too much reeverb :(
Bionuker 2 years ago
It's fake, it sounds like the John Odgon version. His hands arent even doing anything near what is actually being played
NiCkCO111 2 years ago
Did a wonderful job, makes me think of memories both sad and happy, intertwined.
Thank you for sharing this.
HESHtheforth 2 years ago
Comment removed
Cheydow 2 years ago
Brilliant. I enjoyed that all the way through to the end. I saw a river at night with a bridge with gas lamps reflecting off the water. The rippling water was like liquid gold.
artberry 2 years ago
you play it so slow that why yours is my favorite version of chopins nocturne.
I think even Yundi Li plays a little too fast.
Ryogakun666 2 years ago
YOUR SMile
It made me smile
And I admit I said hello
Because - I've trying to find out what song this is, I know the tune and want to learn it, but didn't know what it was called. And finally I found it.
You'd think these classical guys would name their songs normally wouldn't yoU!?
JameseesDt 2 years ago
your playing makes this keyboard sound better than most grand pianos on youtube.
Gel1ebtedesregens 2 years ago
beautiful. my favorite piece and you played it wonderfully.
swimaholiccl 2 years ago
ahaha your smile :)
beautifully played!
Randomllama180 2 years ago
Comment removed
Ryogakun666 2 years ago
absolutely beautiful! I needed a weighted keyboard
JuliaMRProductions 2 years ago
It's a Roland FP-3
craigadam 2 years ago
Good work man! I first heard this song on 'Dexter' my new favorite show.
teeelo 2 years ago
yo man,i hear that song before 10 years ago when my friend play this on cd !i remember the melody and then i watch dexter i can't believe what i hear!I can't wait for dexter season 4!bye
zgboy23 2 years ago
Beautiful.
The quality of the sound surprised me. I'm usually a bit hesitant with syncs but this one was awesome. :)
Eudokia 2 years ago
Buonissimo, Bravo!
rogerbillau 2 years ago
nice job... i just watched 6 other versions, u r by far the best. Nice Smile ;)
newvisionwriter 3 years ago
Played beautifully and you're hot!
Lol
x
SimonGriffindor 3 years ago
you could use little more rubato/shape in your playing. but im amazed that you never had a lesson
caarox 3 years ago
thanks
loneus 3 years ago
wow brilliantly played well done
piapiapiapiano 3 years ago
You did a really great job. I am learning this song right now. I just hope I can play as well as you did. Nice work :)
emnems1991 4 years ago
Comment removed
sprsm 2 years ago
You owe me a trill on the first beat, 7th measure. Other than that, good job!
movesguy 4 years ago 2
great job! this is my favourite nocturne.
elinzme 4 years ago
very nice, my only comment is to buy yourself a grand piano, you can put much more emotion in a piano like that :)
sgtghst007 4 years ago
excellent!excellent!what else do you play?BE
elmorekbren 4 years ago
Congrats on the emotion. The feelings are all there...which is hard to find nowadays. It's especially difficult to convey that thought on an electronic keyboard. I would just suggest some more dynamics and variety to perk up the performance. Crescendoes would definitely add more poignancy to the piece.
P.S.: Don't be nervous. We're willing to hear you play! Keep it up!
MusicalConnoisseur 4 years ago
you played this beautifully thanks for posting :D
ewiekeu 4 years ago
this was fantastic! I enjoyed it very much i must say.. this is my favorite piece by Chopin, so beautiful...
dollifjoll 4 years ago
I think you have a nice feel for this Chopin piece. :) I have not studied this piece yet, so I can't help out with technical issues.
ailecec 4 years ago