during the porajamos/holocaust the old camaraderie between jews and roma that thrived during the middle ages re emerged. the gypsies saw it all coming and wheres their Israel?
@swastikausa Problem is that Gypsies didn't and still don't want a land for themselves. India gave them the rights ages ago to immigrate back with full citizenship but most of them weren't interested.
but don't you see that's where the real beauty lies. Us Roma don't linger on nationality.Were out camping on the moors. Were too busy on establishing our own value in Europe ,south America any continent you care to name. We gypsies come out on top no matter what. you should check the global economy. your gadjo law benefiting you is it?
@swastikausa First of all, I got nothing against Gypsies. Believe it or not my neighbor is Romanian Gypsy but his family's religion is Judaism. Either way, all I was saying is Gypsies didn't want their own state, while Jews did. So if you don't want a State then why do you complain about a homeland for the Jews? I think every group desserves to have their own land, including Gypsies.
Can someone tell me anything about what the man is doing from the begin till 0:43? Is it a way of playing violin, and if so, does this technique have a special name or term? Thanks in advance.
@ilvegio Thank you so much, I shall look for this movie, it does seem to be very interesting. I've read that the Jewish Klezmer musicians used to live side by side with Gypsis and this scene seems to reflect this situation, but then, I must watch the film first... Thank you again.
@jewamen Yddish and Gypsy music have shared a lot of music from the Balkan region for al looong time. We should not use the word Klezmer here, because it refers to modern New York Yiddish music from New York (USA).
Isn't it ironic that two of the most persecuted people the world has seen can sit together in peace and share music and culture with each other. Notce how the musical syles are similar? I vote for the Rom. They're more active and enclude women in the festivities.
@esentiaal Not a surprise : Gypsies in Romania are used to play romanian music, and more generally to play the traditional music from the places they live (as in Bulgaria or Turkey, Spain ...). But they generally add a special flavour (gypsy spices) to the local music.
@Nizlopi2 The first one is they are both just vocalizing to the music in their different styles. The Gypsy is using some common vocal percussion found in Roma music
@Nizlopi2 They seem to speak Turkish!! ?? I know that there's a Jewish group that speaks a Turkic language very close to the Turkish in Turkey (I've been told) but this sounds like clear Turkish to me! :O
Primul, lautarii erau ROMANI nu Gipsy sau Tigani iar Melodia este "Cine iubeste si lasa" chiar si acordurile de inceput ale evreilor sint chiar maramuresene. Doar dansatorii au fost tigani!
pe cine o intereseaza draga,esti in trecut,pe mine in norvegia nu ma intereseaza,,ramii asa ca si ai fost pe comunistilor daca asa gindesti draga,,vino mai aprope de azi!MMUZICKA ne intereseaza!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I have had several interestin experiances with Neopolitan Gypsies. It seems they allways want to tell your fortune. So I said that I didn't want them too, they'd reveal my hidden secret and I'd have to kill them. That shut them up.
@BlueSatin84 That's right, they are very mixed, very ancient. I don't think anyone knows from whence they came! You'll find them as Sephardim in Spain, as "gens de voyage" in France, Turkey, New York . . . I am "pure Aryan" according to a DNA test, and there seems to be a link, but prehistoric. Who knows? I'm Köprülü, too. It gets really zany! How could this be? Peace.
@slobomotion Judging from the Romani languages, the Romanis originate from somewhere in northern India. Their languages are clearly Indo-European though.
@OnkelMickwald Yup, that's what I've read, too! Rom hasn't even been written down until recently, from what I gather. I find all this super fascinating. It is said that all humans can trace their DNA ancestry back to something like, what, six or eight individuals? TOO TRIPPY!!!!!
i'm gonna get smacked for this but seriously, ppl: unless you wanna get into fiddling little microdetails, THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE!!!! it's all great music designed to make it impossible for the listener to stay still! sheesh.
this is romanian music PLAYED only by gipsies(cine iubeste si lasa..see Maria Tanase's romanian popular songs- which are classical)-the beginning of the clip that is..anyway amazing music
Radu Mihaileanu (this movie's director and writer ) said: "If Hitler were alive and would see all dull and dark television broadcasts about the Holocaust, and he could hear all the Jews weeping and mourning, he should be happy. The only way WE can to humiliate the Nazis who still live in South America, to make them mad, is to show them that WE are still alive, that they have not destroyed us, that our sense of humor was not killed by their barbarity!"
@FreckiFrack: I think is Yiddish (Jewish), but I'm not sure. Anyway, the most spoken language in this movie is French (it is a Romanian - French co-production), but if you want, there are many subtitles in English or German, and other europeans languages...
@AlSibsu: As far as I understand it, the language they are speaking is Turkish, possibly because the clip has been copied from a Turkish synchronized version of the movie. In my version of the movie (I live in Germany) they speak German ...
Supposedly in reality jewish people from eastern Europe would have spoking Yiddish (a language using some German - with a strong accent - and Hebrew words and some others)
@ganjaganja879 this movie is about a jewish people who lisent to the "crazy" of the village, who hear that the nazis are coming, and they star a grat adventure...great things happend..is one of my favorites movierrr ever...i laught and cry...!!
@830026: Many of Bregovici's songs are not original, he mixed and re-orchestrated Balkan music from the Balkan's countries (Romania, Serbia, Bulgaria etc etc etc). That's why his music is wonderful. In fact, this is a Romanian - French movie, and the song in the begining of this clip (played on violin) is named "Cine iubeşte şi lasă", or "Who loves and than abandon it", a very old Romanian folklore song. The first two lyrics are Who loves and than abandon it / God has to punish him/ her
@830026: there are also traditional Jewish music. But all you have to know is this film is a masterpiece, and if you didn't saw it till now, I strongly recommend you to look for it. It is about a fake deportation train, organized by the inhabitants of a small Jewish village in Eastern Europe, adviced by the village fool, for escapeing the Nazis and flee to Palestine. It is a good comedy, finished in a drama... I'll not tell you more, I'll let you see this movie.
@830026 Bregovich has nothing to do with this one. First one is an romanian song and then it was mixted with some klezmer music ( klezmer music borned in XIX century as a mixt between jewish hasidic music and romanian traditional music from Basarabia / Moldavia )
Comment un peuple aussi cultivé et musicien que les Allemands ont pu essayer d'érdiquer ces "undermensh" si sensibles à la musique? Le chant des sirènes? La peur?...
Miss PamAnn, Are you for real? Do you even have any idea what you are talking, sqauking, sounding off about. Where do you live dear, In Dachau Concentration Camp Internment Office with the other retired, conscienceless guards and Nazi's and of course your favourite of all the Arabs. Or perhaps you live in a flea ridden, bedouin tent - hopefully you do and of course hopefully you will never never need an organ transplant from one of your favourite jewish donors they wouldn't give u one ever
@KazakhPaliFriendship I can ask what is wrong with you? are you stupid or pretend to fool? Yet the Jewish government was elected in a democratic way. So it supports the majority of the population. Jewish and therefore the government came from outer space or reflect Jewish views on Palestine? telling stories for retarded children.
@Camdentown100 The question is, why are you racist and disgusting. Zionism and Judaism is different concept. Zionists are racist Nazis like you, true Jews against the occupation are good people. Those retarded stories you call are also mentioned in the Quran, so respect what is from Allah. What Zionists forget is that they are forbidden by Allah to come back to this land because they are exiled for their sins. Any Jews who supports Israel is not Jewish but Zionists.
@Camdentown100 You don't fool me, I know who you are since I have seen you write crap about Arabs too in Sudanese videos, you are probably working with Mossad to make Palestinians look bad. Chomsky are Finkelstein are real Jews and they say they are Jews NOT Zionists.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
JEWS MURDER & SELL ARAB ORGANS!
ORGAN TRAFFICKING IS NOW a multi-million dollar business. Couple this with the Zionists having an obsession for self-preservation and the Jewish Talmud’s view of Arabs being sub-human, Israel is a leading trafficer in the organ transplant business.
The University of Tel Aviv’s Israel Institute for Forensic Medicine, operating under the cover of DNA profiling of “criminals,” (murdered Arab Palestinians), is the prime operator in the organ transplant business.
@MsPamAnn why should they use parab organs? what pussiness if they can have about 6 zillion for free?ze the ant(ip)arctical? they don't need no organtransplant....they need to have a pipe line a blood donation from germoney ;-)
Questa è una delle scene piu belle mai viste! e oltretutto è impossibile nn sorridere e lasciarsi trasportare dalla melodia! sfido chiunque a riuscire a stare fermo!impossibile! Film indimeticabile.
“A KIDNEY BY ANY OTHER NAME WOULD SMELL AS SOUR,” can be said of the recent organ-trafficking and money-laundering FBI sting operation which implicated five Talmudic rabbis from New York and neighboring New Jersey. This international rabbinical operation spanned from Jewish-entrenched New York to the Jewish state of Israel.
The FBI used an informant, a Talmudic Jew named Solomon Dwek, to approach the rabbis.
Both Gyspies and the Jews are singing Romanian music. This shows, how great the Romanian culture is..But, bless those two folks. For having Romania in their heart.
Jews and Gypsies in Europe have suffered together and have endured similar stereotypes. Jews have since become far more successful due to the far greater number of diaspora and successful assimilation into the general structure, while gypsies have lagged behind and remain unnoticed. But their music is similar for a reason.
I'd also like to mention that my own ancestors on one side were Irish "travellers", which is really just a shite euphamism for gypsy. While I'm only related to my Jewish family members by marriage I like to say that I embrace both cultures, because they're almost exactly alike. My point is, the gypsy culture encompases a broad scope and can be found almost anywhere amongst anyone, and isn't limited to Romani, Jewish, Irish, or Arab culture.
@FrowningGORILLA Jews and Gypsies are not related, two different groups who didn't mix from other sides of Asia. Gypsy come from North India, Jews come from Levant which is Eastern Mediterranean/Middle East.
@PILMAN We all know where they originated from, but it's a definate fact that when Jews were kicked out of communities all across Europe over and over again some of them developed a nomadic lifestyle and became, drumroll please..gypsies! You're confusing an ethnic group (Romani, who may have just as likely came from Egypt as Northern India or, like most "Romani" themselves claimed, from all over) with a long-lived tradition of human adaptation to undesirable circumstances by gettin the fuck out.
@FrowningGORILLA Your confusing the term Gypsy, Gypsy means "traveler" and they were nomads like you said, they didn't settle down or contribute anything to economies, basically would take their caravans where ever. Jews on the other hand came to Europe long before Gypsies and actually assimilated and settled down in countries and were borrowing money to the kings, they contributed to other countries "look up shetls and farming communities" and served in countries military. Some were involved
My ancestors could have been gypsies and Jewish, funny thing my sisters and I adore the violin. Ignore the piano part in my username c(:
piano37924 6 days ago
hassktr lan adamlar türkçe konuşuyo
opciga 1 week ago
Where do I sign up to go into one of these..?
grendle7 1 week ago
Marie José Nat at 0;29 ?
edelahaye 3 weeks ago
what's the really difference in musical terms between klezmer music and gipsy music ?
apart from that obvious.
ANTONIOFACONDI 3 weeks ago
where the hell the nazis come from
carthag 3 weeks ago
@carthag They have dommed both jewish and gypsy people ... I guess, it's a sort of eye blink ...
edelahaye 3 weeks ago
@edelahaye I meant doomed, of course ...
edelahaye 3 weeks ago
It is beautiful how in the very essence, different cultures share the same happy spirit
ihvela 4 weeks ago
Well, wouldja look at that? Music and boobs unite two peoples!
ricaard 4 weeks ago in playlist Itzhak!!
does anybody knows the title of the music played in this video?
marazzqtd 1 month ago
@DrSunshineAOD The proper response is "Oy."
vect0rwolf 1 month ago
Comment removed
ilkayatay87 1 month ago
during the porajamos/holocaust the old camaraderie between jews and roma that thrived during the middle ages re emerged. the gypsies saw it all coming and wheres their Israel?
swastikausa 1 month ago
@swastikausa Problem is that Gypsies didn't and still don't want a land for themselves. India gave them the rights ages ago to immigrate back with full citizenship but most of them weren't interested.
AynurBazayev 1 month ago
but don't you see that's where the real beauty lies. Us Roma don't linger on nationality.Were out camping on the moors. Were too busy on establishing our own value in Europe ,south America any continent you care to name. We gypsies come out on top no matter what. you should check the global economy. your gadjo law benefiting you is it?
swastikausa 1 month ago
@swastikausa First of all, I got nothing against Gypsies. Believe it or not my neighbor is Romanian Gypsy but his family's religion is Judaism. Either way, all I was saying is Gypsies didn't want their own state, while Jews did. So if you don't want a State then why do you complain about a homeland for the Jews? I think every group desserves to have their own land, including Gypsies.
AynurBazayev 1 month ago
are they waiting their turn to be gassed?
jradetzky 1 month ago
@jradetzky YOU should have been have been gassed.
theshugchannel 1 month ago
@theshugchannel Nope. I would have been the gasser. LOL
jradetzky 1 month ago
@jradetzky rot in hell you sick bitch
theshugchannel 1 month ago
@theshugchannel I'm writing this from my hot spot in hell, next to Hitler
jradetzky 1 month ago
Why does the old man speak turkish
canik96 1 month ago
Can someone tell me anything about what the man is doing from the begin till 0:43? Is it a way of playing violin, and if so, does this technique have a special name or term? Thanks in advance.
R1S9S9R1 1 month ago
anyone know what the instrument with the hammers on the stings are?
alexie28 2 months ago
@alexie28 hammer dulcimer...a very well worn one!
NoSheep2 2 months ago
@NoSheep2 Now I know what that weird thing my mom has hanging on the wall is!
LaikaCameBack 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
@alexie28 Psalterion, tympanon, zybalum, hammerd dulcimer ... It's a wide-spread instrument ...
edelahaye 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Am I the only one that thought about System Of A Down (SOAD ftw) at around 1:35?
nave111 2 months ago
oh lordy
yesoroui 2 months ago in playlist Jewish klezmer vs Gipsy music - Train de vie
SuperFilm!
abdonHD 2 months ago
no wonder the germans wanted them on trains as far east as possible....state of them, fun music tho
rickenbackerlawlor 3 months ago
anyone got the lyrics? :D
snasske 3 months ago
Which film is it, seems to be in the WWII?
teresavivarium 3 months ago
@teresavivarium it's "train de vie". one of the most beautiful movies i've ever watched.
ilvegio 3 months ago
@ilvegio Thank you so much, I shall look for this movie, it does seem to be very interesting. I've read that the Jewish Klezmer musicians used to live side by side with Gypsis and this scene seems to reflect this situation, but then, I must watch the film first... Thank you again.
teresavivarium 3 months ago
Bando de loco!
dermaschool 3 months ago
Isn't Fantastic that music can be bring two completely different cultures together?
jewamen 3 months ago
@jewamen Yddish and Gypsy music have shared a lot of music from the Balkan region for al looong time. We should not use the word Klezmer here, because it refers to modern New York Yiddish music from New York (USA).
edelahaye 3 weeks ago
This looks fun
TheDoctorGrenade 4 months ago
indeed.. ghetto mashups...
wizzzer1337 4 months ago
Well i guess when i go to romania next year im going to be doing this..
DaRomanian0 4 months ago
Isn't it ironic that two of the most persecuted people the world has seen can sit together in peace and share music and culture with each other. Notce how the musical syles are similar? I vote for the Rom. They're more active and enclude women in the festivities.
bheadh 5 months ago 2
@bheadh too bad it's not like that in real life...
UrrTheWise 4 months ago
SO STOP PRAY TO THE KING OF THE JEWS THEN EACH SUNDAY,
Orbitson1 5 months ago
the hitler´s dance
Gukumatzkukulkan 5 months ago
and girls with giant tits..
guadalupejoe1 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the deliverance dueling banjos :D
CO2isNoFun 5 months ago
then perlman comes in and plays bazzini's dance of the goblin.
Vesivian 5 months ago
je pleure toujours
orsogrigio1949 5 months ago
FUCKING GREAT SEX MUSIC!!!!!
Maestro218 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thumbs up if you like the jewish man face impression when he sees boobs shake :)
yayabo100 6 months ago 4
Comment removed
yayabo100 6 months ago
2:12 the German soldier enjoying the music around him lol.
grobo11 6 months ago
@grobo11 The guys dressed like german soldiers were also jewish.
bragunovskoie 6 months ago
is not gipsy music.is romanian traditional folclor music your mourones!
esentiaal 6 months ago
@esentiaal Not a surprise : Gypsies in Romania are used to play romanian music, and more generally to play the traditional music from the places they live (as in Bulgaria or Turkey, Spain ...). But they generally add a special flavour (gypsy spices) to the local music.
edelahaye 3 weeks ago
lol
couilkirit 6 months ago
maravilloso............. wonderful !!!!!!!!!
cybermatufia 7 months ago 3
Bellissimo!!!
friendlymonk 7 months ago
MAGNIFIQUE....
TheMilagros59 7 months ago
On 0:31 there is a Hipster, did you notice it? Thumbs up if you did!
Elqno 7 months ago 35
@Elqno ahahahah!
cynderpunk 3 months ago
@Elqno Loool
1986BJK 2 months ago
@Elqno Jews, hipsters, same thing.
OldSchopenhauer 2 weeks ago
What language are the 2 men speaking?
Nizlopi2 7 months ago
Yiddish
OomYaaqub 7 months ago
@Nizlopi2 The first one is they are both just vocalizing to the music in their different styles. The Gypsy is using some common vocal percussion found in Roma music
MrViola94 6 months ago
@Nizlopi2 They seem to speak Turkish!! ?? I know that there's a Jewish group that speaks a Turkic language very close to the Turkish in Turkey (I've been told) but this sounds like clear Turkish to me! :O
moshmoon 6 months ago
@moshmoon I think it's just a voice-over in Turkish.
Ninotjuh 6 months ago
поздравляю! 71 people should sort their lives out.
vl4ndo 7 months ago
does anybody know what is the name of that hungarian song? leave a comment or a message with the answer, thx
morticiusvlad 7 months ago
: )
piazzola08 7 months ago
AWESOME.
CimpoIlRozzo 7 months ago
Movie: Train de vie or english Train of life. Mazal tov everybody !
Naglfar6666 7 months ago
je.....lets have 3th world waar like this........and let it never stop
nilkamalini 7 months ago
Gut Shabbos. I just saw this movie, very great, love it. Thanks for the upload.
Typhoon7SSBN 7 months ago
hahah nice mix lol just jews and gypsies!!!!!!!!!!
geva90 7 months ago
what movie is this taken from?
koshevatsky 7 months ago
This is like watching my conception.
0AmyK0 7 months ago
xD it is funny .. but the story is very beautiful and sad :')
LeLollose 7 months ago
The best :))))))))
ViaRomen 8 months ago
shalom
YosefLevi87 8 months ago
What movie is this from. Looks very good
Dylolg 8 months ago
@Dylolg train de vie
abc12349014 8 months ago
This was good.
Livsangel 8 months ago
/watch?v=OPNcGKNcz_o
9ziggystardust9 8 months ago
Dragi copii, vreau sa precizez cateva lucruri:
Primul, lautarii erau ROMANI nu Gipsy sau Tigani iar Melodia este "Cine iubeste si lasa" chiar si acordurile de inceput ale evreilor sint chiar maramuresene. Doar dansatorii au fost tigani!
digimagefoto 8 months ago
pe cine o intereseaza draga,esti in trecut,pe mine in norvegia nu ma intereseaza,,ramii asa ca si ai fost pe comunistilor daca asa gindesti draga,,vino mai aprope de azi!MMUZICKA ne intereseaza!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
routila 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what garbage.
The096757 8 months ago
Love it!
mickeydougal 8 months ago
man.... this is great... never heard anything more beautiful... so human...
donlaszloo 8 months ago 2
Jewish bećarac
argentinobeast 9 months ago
0:31
Seth Rogen?
Ovaloe 9 months ago
so methaphoric that its amazing...i'd call this : "all together" and i'm glad there are no weapons
mamurny 9 months ago
so methaphoric that its amazing...i'd call this : all together and i'm glad there are no weapons
mamurny 9 months ago
Two great music forms together, yay! Greetings from France via the USA!
slobomotion 9 months ago 2
Interesting...
ChavivLazar 9 months ago
judio y gitano finalmente y al principio son la misma familia y la misma madre
jewish and gipsy are finily and at the begining same family and same mother
vicharaca 9 months ago
East European dueling banjos
wwmadi 9 months ago 23
I have had several interestin experiances with Neopolitan Gypsies. It seems they allways want to tell your fortune. So I said that I didn't want them too, they'd reveal my hidden secret and I'd have to kill them. That shut them up.
igratkransy 9 months ago
@igratkransy Lol you're a fuckin beast
isolateslowfaults 9 months ago
hm... Romanian music vs Gypsy music????? :))
Search for
Maria Tănase - Cine iubeşte şi lasă
NSAnegrean 9 months ago
a lot of gypsies were jews,and we are good people
BlueSatin84 9 months ago
@BlueSatin84
Like me!
Bakhtale and B"S.
stinsens 9 months ago
@BlueSatin84 That's right, they are very mixed, very ancient. I don't think anyone knows from whence they came! You'll find them as Sephardim in Spain, as "gens de voyage" in France, Turkey, New York . . . I am "pure Aryan" according to a DNA test, and there seems to be a link, but prehistoric. Who knows? I'm Köprülü, too. It gets really zany! How could this be? Peace.
slobomotion 9 months ago
@slobomotion Judging from the Romani languages, the Romanis originate from somewhere in northern India. Their languages are clearly Indo-European though.
OnkelMickwald 9 months ago
@OnkelMickwald Yup, that's what I've read, too! Rom hasn't even been written down until recently, from what I gather. I find all this super fascinating. It is said that all humans can trace their DNA ancestry back to something like, what, six or eight individuals? TOO TRIPPY!!!!!
slobomotion 9 months ago
Nagyon tetszik...kérek valakit írja meg, miből van ez a zenei betét?????
Köszönöm!
MrLina52 10 months ago
Ez egy francia filből van, amelynek a címe: Train de Vie
attila183568 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ez egy francia filmből van, amelynek a címe: Train de Vie
attila183568 9 months ago
If you want to see fat gipsy tits press 8!
0mriphone0 10 months ago 2
I think this song is funny... I like the music.... :)
1ladyslugga 10 months ago
Thumbs up if you did the same thing with your hand like the jews did.
0mriphone0 10 months ago 59
@0mriphone0 actually i did it after reading your comment, its really fun tho !! lol
mqther 4 months ago
Is it from movie? What is the name of this movie?
natashashowgirls 10 months ago
@natashashowgirls its from "Train of Life" - a fucking grat movie! - very sad AND funny...:)
PrimeKind 10 months ago
i'm gonna get smacked for this but seriously, ppl: unless you wanna get into fiddling little microdetails, THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE!!!! it's all great music designed to make it impossible for the listener to stay still! sheesh.
threenorns3 10 months ago
Óriási
ivanyipe 10 months ago
Its stuff like this that makes me want to convert into Judaism :)
tomoyboy 10 months ago 2
@tomoyboy
why not to "gypsiism"?
vocam12 10 months ago 2
There needs to be more Train de Vie clips on YouTube.
MagicSomething 10 months ago 2
this is romanian music PLAYED only by gipsies(cine iubeste si lasa..see Maria Tanase's romanian popular songs- which are classical)-the beginning of the clip that is..anyway amazing music
taliayu 10 months ago
Radu Mihaileanu (this movie's director and writer ) said: "If Hitler were alive and would see all dull and dark television broadcasts about the Holocaust, and he could hear all the Jews weeping and mourning, he should be happy. The only way WE can to humiliate the Nazis who still live in South America, to make them mad, is to show them that WE are still alive, that they have not destroyed us, that our sense of humor was not killed by their barbarity!"
AlSibsu 10 months ago
Comment removed
FreckiFrack 10 months ago
What language are the jews speaking in the beginning of the video?
FreckiFrack 10 months ago
@FreckiFrack: I think is Yiddish (Jewish), but I'm not sure. Anyway, the most spoken language in this movie is French (it is a Romanian - French co-production), but if you want, there are many subtitles in English or German, and other europeans languages...
AlSibsu 10 months ago
its not yiddish.
doritela2008 10 months ago
@doritela2008: in fact it is a Jewish slang, used in the eastern european countries.
AlSibsu 10 months ago
@AlSibsu
I know what yiddish is... I am a jew myself
doritela2008 10 months ago
@AlSibsu: As far as I understand it, the language they are speaking is Turkish, possibly because the clip has been copied from a Turkish synchronized version of the movie. In my version of the movie (I live in Germany) they speak German ...
Supposedly in reality jewish people from eastern Europe would have spoking Yiddish (a language using some German - with a strong accent - and Hebrew words and some others)
DonQuijoteDeLaSelva 10 months ago 2
That is out Latcho Drom, documentary, not directly but in spirit
valvetrom 11 months ago
what movie is this? im guessing it has something to do with ww2 because of the random nazi's at 2:47
ganjaganja879 11 months ago
@ganjaganja879 this movie is about a jewish people who lisent to the "crazy" of the village, who hear that the nazis are coming, and they star a grat adventure...great things happend..is one of my favorites movierrr ever...i laught and cry...!!
Enaguiss 11 months ago
ahhh jaja me encantóooooo!!
nadyvina 11 months ago
Bregovic is The Best!
830026 11 months ago
@830026 : and what have Bregovici to do with this? This is NOT Bregovic music...
AlSibsu 11 months ago
@AlSibsu I think he has made music to this film ;-)) His style is unique and every Bregovics's fun must know his in this film.
830026 11 months ago
Comment removed
AlSibsu 11 months ago
@830026: Many of Bregovici's songs are not original, he mixed and re-orchestrated Balkan music from the Balkan's countries (Romania, Serbia, Bulgaria etc etc etc). That's why his music is wonderful. In fact, this is a Romanian - French movie, and the song in the begining of this clip (played on violin) is named "Cine iubeşte şi lasă", or "Who loves and than abandon it", a very old Romanian folklore song. The first two lyrics are Who loves and than abandon it / God has to punish him/ her
AlSibsu 11 months ago
@830026: there are also traditional Jewish music. But all you have to know is this film is a masterpiece, and if you didn't saw it till now, I strongly recommend you to look for it. It is about a fake deportation train, organized by the inhabitants of a small Jewish village in Eastern Europe, adviced by the village fool, for escapeing the Nazis and flee to Palestine. It is a good comedy, finished in a drama... I'll not tell you more, I'll let you see this movie.
AlSibsu 11 months ago
@830026 Bregovich has nothing to do with this one. First one is an romanian song and then it was mixted with some klezmer music ( klezmer music borned in XIX century as a mixt between jewish hasidic music and romanian traditional music from Basarabia / Moldavia )
AndreiM999 10 months ago
Comment un peuple aussi cultivé et musicien que les Allemands ont pu essayer d'érdiquer ces "undermensh" si sensibles à la musique? Le chant des sirènes? La peur?...
ANTOONMAKA 11 months ago
Miss PamAnn, Are you for real? Do you even have any idea what you are talking, sqauking, sounding off about. Where do you live dear, In Dachau Concentration Camp Internment Office with the other retired, conscienceless guards and Nazi's and of course your favourite of all the Arabs. Or perhaps you live in a flea ridden, bedouin tent - hopefully you do and of course hopefully you will never never need an organ transplant from one of your favourite jewish donors they wouldn't give u one ever
rainbowsim 11 months ago
Jews and Gipsy have alot in common
hannahr77 11 months ago
I love this movieeeee is excelent is sab but i lovee this film..!
Enaguiss 11 months ago
@Enaguiss hi!!! how called this movie?
nadyvina 11 months ago
@nadyvina its call train de vie. directed by Radu Mihaileanu 1998
Enaguiss 11 months ago
@Enaguiss thanks!
ganjaganja879 11 months ago
@Enaguiss Thanks for answer!
nadyvina 8 months ago
iof u really want to meat culture star from their musiccc..u gonna found a lot of sorprises, story, fear,s all!!
Enaguiss 11 months ago
@KazakhPaliFriendship I can ask what is wrong with you? are you stupid or pretend to fool? Yet the Jewish government was elected in a democratic way. So it supports the majority of the population. Jewish and therefore the government came from outer space or reflect Jewish views on Palestine? telling stories for retarded children.
Camdentown100 11 months ago
@Camdentown100 The question is, why are you racist and disgusting. Zionism and Judaism is different concept. Zionists are racist Nazis like you, true Jews against the occupation are good people. Those retarded stories you call are also mentioned in the Quran, so respect what is from Allah. What Zionists forget is that they are forbidden by Allah to come back to this land because they are exiled for their sins. Any Jews who supports Israel is not Jewish but Zionists.
KazakhPaliFriendship 11 months ago
@Camdentown100 You don't fool me, I know who you are since I have seen you write crap about Arabs too in Sudanese videos, you are probably working with Mossad to make Palestinians look bad. Chomsky are Finkelstein are real Jews and they say they are Jews NOT Zionists.
KazakhPaliFriendship 11 months ago
@Sche13e
You should totally watch the film: those are not actual German officers, but Jews in disguise! :)
SuperflickaSPB 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
JEWS MURDER & SELL ARAB ORGANS!
ORGAN TRAFFICKING IS NOW a multi-million dollar business. Couple this with the Zionists having an obsession for self-preservation and the Jewish Talmud’s view of Arabs being sub-human, Israel is a leading trafficer in the organ transplant business.
The University of Tel Aviv’s Israel Institute for Forensic Medicine, operating under the cover of DNA profiling of “criminals,” (murdered Arab Palestinians), is the prime operator in the organ transplant business.
MsPamAnn 11 months ago
@MsPamAnn why should they use parab organs? what pussiness if they can have about 6 zillion for free?ze the ant(ip)arctical? they don't need no organtransplant....they need to have a pipe line a blood donation from germoney ;-)
remindbender 11 months ago
hope we can all get along like this...
p5rov 11 months ago
film stupendo visto l'altro giorno xD
xxmirymiryxx 1 year ago
Questa è una delle scene piu belle mai viste! e oltretutto è impossibile nn sorridere e lasciarsi trasportare dalla melodia! sfido chiunque a riuscire a stare fermo!impossibile! Film indimeticabile.
MadelyneLyne 1 year ago
@Sche13e
Meschiggene Nazis!?
stinsens 1 year ago
“A KIDNEY BY ANY OTHER NAME WOULD SMELL AS SOUR,” can be said of the recent organ-trafficking and money-laundering FBI sting operation which implicated five Talmudic rabbis from New York and neighboring New Jersey. This international rabbinical operation spanned from Jewish-entrenched New York to the Jewish state of Israel.
The FBI used an informant, a Talmudic Jew named Solomon Dwek, to approach the rabbis.
MsPamAnn 1 year ago
That has little to do with the movie...
Although money laundering is a bad thing... is this the best place to bring it up?
MelissaTicky 11 months ago
Yeah, right! Except that this is Romanian music. Not Jewish nor rroma(gipsy).
firethenrain 1 year ago
Both Gyspies and the Jews are singing Romanian music. This shows, how great the Romanian culture is..But, bless those two folks. For having Romania in their heart.
SteauaBucuresti 1 year ago
@SteauaBucuresti Yes. I mean look at all the contributions by the Romanians. HA!
asherologist 1 year ago
@asherologist//
We´ve been contributed as much as the rest of European countries.
SteauaBucuresti 1 year ago
Jews and Gypsies in Europe have suffered together and have endured similar stereotypes. Jews have since become far more successful due to the far greater number of diaspora and successful assimilation into the general structure, while gypsies have lagged behind and remain unnoticed. But their music is similar for a reason.
Ermal8711 1 year ago
@Ermal8711 "Their" music is similar for a very simple reason : they both sing the folk music of their host-country.
MrCraiessou 1 year ago
I'd also like to mention that my own ancestors on one side were Irish "travellers", which is really just a shite euphamism for gypsy. While I'm only related to my Jewish family members by marriage I like to say that I embrace both cultures, because they're almost exactly alike. My point is, the gypsy culture encompases a broad scope and can be found almost anywhere amongst anyone, and isn't limited to Romani, Jewish, Irish, or Arab culture.
FrowningGORILLA 1 year ago
Comment removed
FrowningGORILLA 1 year ago
GREAAAAT:)
tocsika1990 1 year ago
2: 20 Oy dose goyuim gozongaz!
FrowningGORILLA 1 year ago
what is that old guy trying to do? he has a bow.
flyingspacepotatoes 1 year ago
My family is jewish, but is orignated from a Romani clan. I'm sure my grandmother would have loved this video...
anat1917 1 year ago
@anat1917 never heard of a Jewish Gypsy...
PILMAN 1 year ago
@PILMAN Seriously?
FrowningGORILLA 1 year ago
@FrowningGORILLA Jews and Gypsies are not related, two different groups who didn't mix from other sides of Asia. Gypsy come from North India, Jews come from Levant which is Eastern Mediterranean/Middle East.
PILMAN 1 year ago
@PILMAN We all know where they originated from, but it's a definate fact that when Jews were kicked out of communities all across Europe over and over again some of them developed a nomadic lifestyle and became, drumroll please..gypsies! You're confusing an ethnic group (Romani, who may have just as likely came from Egypt as Northern India or, like most "Romani" themselves claimed, from all over) with a long-lived tradition of human adaptation to undesirable circumstances by gettin the fuck out.
FrowningGORILLA 1 year ago
@FrowningGORILLA Your confusing the term Gypsy, Gypsy means "traveler" and they were nomads like you said, they didn't settle down or contribute anything to economies, basically would take their caravans where ever. Jews on the other hand came to Europe long before Gypsies and actually assimilated and settled down in countries and were borrowing money to the kings, they contributed to other countries "look up shetls and farming communities" and served in countries military. Some were involved
PILMAN 1 year ago