Dance With My Father

[tkgawa]

Okay...Luther Vandross and FMA, fitting together pretty nicely. I love your choice in song and its all so much more meaningful because of Al's dislike of his father and the latent need for him, just like his mother. When he finnaly does die...is this how they felt?

[JustLivingMe]

it was Ed who hated their father btw...but i understand what ur saying

[tkgawa]

Thanks...I've had no FMA since the finale... so thats why.

[fraioch]

this song is so meaningfull.i lost my dad to cancer when i was only 10.i would have loved him to see his 7 children and grandchildern grow up and have a dance with him.

[thebulletalchemist]

This song makes me cry so hard because my father really did leave my mother, my brothers and me, and my mother went through pretty much the same things poor Trisha did, but because of how she coped, my mom is still alive(thankfully). But she really misses him so much. It's heartbreaking.

[SasukaUchiha202]

I used to cry whenever I heard this song. It's one of my song choices for my father-daughter dance during my 18th birthday.

Love your vid. 5 stars!

[malucsad10]

wat a nice song it ddcate to all who lost someone in life......... it me cry..... this song is ddcated to my grandfather who past away.....

[princesstarika]

okay when ed went our world the first time his body was stuck in the gate but his mind and soul went here and automaticly went to the body that was just like his. the second his mind, body and soul went to across the gate so if he dies that is it.

And no that was al's real body, which got stuck in the gate but luckly end saved al mind and soul you get it

[princesstarika]

today my dad got got into a car accindent and broke some ribs so this song makes me cry even more

[KyoSohma221]

Anytime ^^ Sorry it took you so long to get an answer though, lol.

By the way, the video was adorable. :3

[KyoSohma221]

When Alphonse brought him back to life, he used the Stone, which was inside of him, thus sacrificing himself as well. When he revived Edward, he also completely healed his body, including the wound that Envy inflicted on him. Not to mention, for a moment, Edward was completely human. When he sacrifices himself for Alphonse, he loses his limbs again and is thrust back into our world. The first time he was in our world, his body was separate from his mind and soul. This time he was complete.

[christopherscross]

I never really knew my father but my mother told me that he dead and i don't even know what he looks like.

[Alchemist2099]

Oh, sorry, I see

It's better no think in that :P

just enjoy

[Alchemist2099]

With the philosopher's stone you can have a new body

[xosweetesquexo]

this was great!

[animequeen86]

*Spoilers*

Yes, Ed does get crushed by a zepplin, but as he's dying, he transmutes his soul back across the Gate.

He gets back, only to be killed by Envy.

Al uses the Stone to bring Ed back to life, getting sucked into the gate again.

Ed transmutes himself to get Al back. This tosses him BACK into 1921 Europe & sets up everything for the end of the series & the movie

I'm sorry if this is confusing. It's pretty hard to explain. makes more sense if you watch the last 3 episodes together

[animequeen86]

Umm.. Yeah.. that's how the "Ed" in our world dies...(Episode 49 "The Other Side of the Gate") & how Ed gets back to Amestris

[JUNEORJUNE]

VERY NICE

[melenchantress]

naks nman...touch ako dun...

[maxineluva]

o thanx 4 thT IT mADe me cry but relise to luv mi father

[Kiarrens]

Not bad, but lose the subs.

[pl0xownage]

man i love this song, i even know every single word.[in the song]

[xneverendsx]

man thanks for it its an awsome video

i cant wait to dance this song wit mii dad on mii 15th birthday.

i love it n it totally describes life.

i love mii dad

thanks 4 uploading

[coramunroe]

I think this is a great video =)

[zombiekiller2045]

edXhomenhine

weird...

[Alchemist2099]

why???

[zombiekiller2045]

just a weird copule that's all

[coramunroe]

It's not a couple; don't you people realize that love comes in all forms? *idiots*

[zombiekiller2045]

w/e jesus freak stop spilling us that crap

[allamko]

...='[

[evilchain21]

my god it's a nice song ...makes me cry

..really miss my dad

[NekoKisshu]

T.T

It's.. it's... beauty...

[Alchemist2099]

Thank You =)

[Tragiclullabyoflife]

you are great at amvs! hey where did you get the clips?

[Alchemist2099]

By ares, that's why it contains subs =(

But now I have the torrent with english dub and no subs =)

[MissUzumaki94]

xdxxi love itxxdx

[AniIsRaeli]

More comment for you.

When i hear that again and again, i just want to cry.

So sad, I realy feel scared now.

[niganae]

*(´¯´••.¸☆•¤¤•FABULOUS VIDEO•¤¤•☆¸.•´¯)*

L♥Ve Dis Song Memories Of My DaD.. AWESOME CLIP.

[cookielvr621]

omg when im like mad or sad or sumthing i listen to this song and everytime it makes me cry...it soooo sad

[afifa1989]

i love it thank yout

[naruto03hinata]

i realy realy love this song and video... my taers fol while watching... thks

[leaderako]

yah,.,my tears also fell...

[kimlei16]

advence happy father's dya to all ho listining to this video...............

[xXsammyjoeXx]

really good..tres bien

[getmered]

Great job, well done 5* from me & thanks for checking out my version of this song. Chantelle xx

[RocketOfDesire]

LOVE :-)

[carlsonf]

R.I.P Hohenheim and Trisha.

[Alchemist2099]

T_T

[dark7lady]

woooo k cool se ve ^^

buen trabajo >.<

[Alchemist2099]

Gracias Primor! :)

[orangejuicealchemist]

wow! this vid is so good but so sad... it really reminds me of how much i miss my dad.... but good job

[madmariahmwah]

It makes me upset sometimes cos' Luther was like a charming lad <<3 I feel sorry for some people who loose there dads over divorce or they die..

[ebilfluffysquirrel]

Love the song and love the video :) Nice job ^__^

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks a lot, I did my best :)

[leekongchianscholar]

Dude, u did great!! I loved d song..it's d best song in my life..n d video...it just suits so well with the song...well, since our fathers are still her, let's make them happy n proud of us in their lives!!

[Alchemist2099]

I'm completeley agrre with U, and thanks for watchin'

[Fugzy68]

Beautifully done!

[Alchemist2099]

Two months without comments... Thanks a lot, Glad you like it :)

[ARNESTO84]

I love the show and the song.thanks for postin dis buddie dood.

[Alchemist2099]

thank you for watch, btw glad you like it

[vitrosex]

thanks for uploading this video, my dad's b-day is coming up, but he is not around anymore to celebrate.

[Alchemist2099]

I'm sorry to hear that. I don't know what to say.. life goes on, and try to be happy

[vitrosex]

Just wondering,did you lost your father too?

[Alchemist2099]

No, my father is alive. The song is only for the anime, and my father like this video a lot, so it's for him

[vitrosex]

hey its me again, i just have to listen to your video once again. by listening to your video it helps me ease my pain.

[Alchemist2099]

I'm happy to read ur message, glad you like my video

[shadowthebeast]

"sob" beautiful, a great anime with my favorite sad song

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks a lot, I did my best

[brens1]

so so sad

[Alchemist2099]

Yes, Hohenheim is my favorite character.

I see his life in this way

[SilentAvera]

I'm balling like a baby now, dangit, i hate showing my soft side T^T

[Alchemist2099]

It's ok, there's nothing wrong with that, and by the way, glad you like it

[brens1]

which one is for me

[XxDanniGirlXx]

I love your vid. <3 Sometimes it just makes me cry^_^;lol

[Alchemist2099]

Lad you like it ^_^

[XxDanniGirlXx]

Yuppers^_^ I loved it^_^

[quietandshy13]

I luved this video...it...reminds me so much of my grandfather...even though he wasn't my father...hearing my mother cry still tore me apart and made me pray for her more than me. Everytime i sing this song i have to cry and remember all the sad things in my life...but i always try thanx to everyone around me. thank you...this video made me happy. 5/5 great job

[FullmetalElla]

I loved it, it reminds me of my dad.

[THECOLORER]

I just want to say that this video moved me to tears. My dad commited suicide when I was ten. He would dance with me so it was hard to watch this video (if I miss type somthing its because my vision is blurred!) Thank you. You have made my day!

[Alchemist2099]

I don't know what to say, I'm sorry for your father and I hope you'll be fine, and thank you, your comment is very important to me

[snowbunny0405]

This was a very touching video. It made me cry.

[vienniey8]

wow luved it....so sad T^T

[tracey8606]

like this song m grandads song love it lots xx

[evilchain21]

nice video

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks =)

[tracey8606]

This song was played at my grandads funeral in july 2006 love this its so amazing thanks good work xx

[Alchemist2099]

Thank you. Glad you like it

[pissedatyou2]

i love you *sob* thankyou so much. oh man...

[Alchemist2099]

Thank you for watchin'. Glad you like it

[nestaamin]

I always cried when i see this amv :(

A perfect amv

[Alchemist2099]

I tryed to make it sad

Imagine me doing this AMV T_T

[ChetoSanz]

Muy bueno

[lizziw]

heya

this song reminds me of my mom and her dad we sit down and listen to this song and have a good cry :'( its very touching i need some tissues x x x very good video x x x x x

[Alchemist2099]

Aww, glad you like it

[tottyxtina]

Its a cool video!!!

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks, Glad you like it

[kapassikey]

i was just thinking about making something like this, somehow i know i'd find it. your awsome, man

[Alchemist2099]

Wow, Thanks that's nice of you.

btw, I'm glad you like it

[Maps2099]

Aww, it's so sad =(

Hohenheim is one of my favorites

[Alchemist2099]

He's one of my fav characters too

[charlotteLoves]

WOW. i love it, keep up with the AWSOME work.

[Alchemist2099]

Thank you, I'll do it ^^

[TigeressRavenShai]

I love that Song it reminds me of my father. You did a great job. keep up the great work.

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks so Much ^^

[fuji1chan]

very touching, i almost cried

i dedicate it to my father too :')

[Alchemist2099]

I'm Glad that You Like iT, I tryed to make it sad

[Fletcher605]

i liked it!!!

[Alchemist2099]

Glad you like It =P

[sushiland]

Hoy ^o^

^^ I looked at your amv and it is really great good job ^w^

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks! Glad You Like it ^^

Hohenheim needs more fans

[camigirl00]

hey chulo i really like this ur really good at doin these lol im not

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks primor, that's why I Love you, LOL

[hamanokumiko1212]

Awww... this is so sweet!!!

BTW, I'm from Gaia, saw you on there.

[Alchemist2099]

Ok, Glad you like my AMV

[MajorKris]

Loved your AMV, it was so sad yet so cute. Well Done!

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks, Glad you Like It ^^

[rjofthe4]

Thats so beutiful. Its sad and yet happy all in one:)

5/5 keep it up!

RobynRJ

[Alchemist2099]

I'm very Glad that you like it

[delovely4]

this video is very sad and i love this song and this for u dad u r the best man in my life

[melai021]

very inspiring and sad song

[melai021]

I love this song also!!! and nice video! I love you dad you're the one of the best man in my life!!!

[ryuuseicha]

If I didn't know that it was completely inappropriate for the feelings of the characters towards one another, I'd say it was an awesome video except for the subtitles and some of the timing.

[Alchemist2099]

it wasn't completely inappropriate for the feelings of the characters. You must put attention, Ed didn't love her father at the beggining because he left them when alphonse was a baby; later, knowing his reason, Ed changed the way to see his father

[Alchemist2099]

and this AMV was the first I did, I think is good, and sorry for the subs, but I didn't have the raw version. Sometims is difficult to find the raw version

[evilchain21]

i really love this song it reminds me of my father whan his still alive...nice video

[HaradaTwins]

wow.

[Alchemist2099]

=0)

[TheShortAlchemist]

Great job... very moving 5/5

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks so much, and I'm Glado You Like It too ^^

[dragnslayer]

Great job. Extremely moving. I always dedicate this song to my dad.

[Jomac5922]

wow...that was great...5/5

Blaze

[Alchemist2099]

Glad You Like It =o)

[bokusenou]

Very, cute and ..sad. Good AMV.

[henryarthur]

Esta Chido!

[waterbabydoll]

*wipes eyes* (saw ur post on gaia) ur right this is making me cry

[digitamer247]

Hey, it's Ryuu from GaiaOnline.That really was an emotional amv. I couldn't cry though, because I never knew my father, so I wasn't really affected by it =P. But I like the clips, and the timing and effects you did were anywhere from great to perfect. A wonderful AMV in my book =D. Good job. Keep them coming.

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks so much, I'm Glad you like it

[Edfullmetal15]

Its cool.

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks, Glad you like it

[chacarron2]

Esta chido cabron

[Fananim3]

*o* re linduuuuu, *o* y muy triste!, 5 stars!!

[Alchemist2099]

Me alegro que te haya gustado

[inuyashadaioh9]

this video was so good...i'm adding it to my favs XD

your timing and the effects were just so perfect,

and that pic at the end just killed me! >O< so beautifullll! Believe it!! >O<

[Alchemist2099]

Aww, Thanks so much.

I'm Very Glad You Like It

[Arbeks]

So emotional and sad..

:cry:

[Alchemist2099]

That's Right =(

I cried when I was doing the video =P

[kenHagane]

lol ed kinda hated his father a little bit for leaving him and al and his mother....

[Alchemist2099]

Yes, but he didn't know his reason. Then, vs Envy he couldn't punch him

[kielolsem]

i think tamyra's version of the song is more moving, touching and better.... but nice video though!...

[Alchemist2099]

I never heeart it, but I think I prefer this one by Luther, the original version and I have a lot of memories of him

[luciousladylucius]

this video makes me cry so much

[Alchemist2099]

Imagine me doing this video :(

[ElricKyra]

It looks great

[Silverdragonbluemoon]

awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww so sad yet so good 5/5

[Alchemist2099]

I'm Glad You Like It :)

[EvilPowerDrill]

Thats amazing! Keep up the good work!

[ANBUoftheAkatsuki]

this is pretty good but too slow for my fancy....... but that doesn't matter, its still pretty good!!

[Nanniechan]

This is sooo good

:):D I really like it ^^ !! You did a great job on this video ^^. Keep on the good work. And thank you for your comment on my video, I'm glad you liked it XD

[Alchemist2099]

I'm Glad you like my video too ^^

[luciousladylucius]

Wow THIS IS AMAZING

I LOVE IT

HOHO ROX!!!!!!!

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks. I'm Glad you like it

[lomas]

Felicitaciones por el video, está muy bueno!

No pude ver la serie completa pero igual me

gustó mucho lo que ví de FMA.

Saludos!  Cristian!

[duttywinegal]

great job!!

[Alchemist2099]

thanks! ^^

[XxRentonThurstonxX]

great work on this amv

[Ranblingnakuru]

Woaaaaa que genial... me gusto mucho... si un AMV muy lindo... te felicito, me encanto... en especial por que es inspirado de una de las mejores series Anime que he visto, =D "FMA" grax. por compartirlo ^___^

[tennisgirl11392]

aww i love this! there aren't many hohenhiem tributes it's great you made one. 5 stars keep up the good work

[Alchemist2099]

Thanks! and Glad you like it ^^

[Rhettus]

Te quedo bien el timing de las imagenes y la cancion. Te quedo cabron, pero te falta un poco de maestria para llegarle al gato volador. Vas bien!

Vas por buen camino.

[FMALoverNiisan]

Good job you don't see a lot of Hohenheim tributes out there!

[Bravlin]

Ahora debes de editar videos con los escupe sangre, ya sea en una orgia, o de vampiros, este fue como la incursion a la edicion de video, ¡¡¡CONGRATULATIONS!!!

[Alchemist2099]

Pues ya va a haber tiempo el semestre que viene, jajaja

[levyweasley]

Hey andy marandi you relly did it knowing the limitations of the internet speed jaja, marvelous effort (y), keep on with the good work, I'll have to show it to my old man, by the way

Arriba el Gato Gaudio!!

[Alchemist2099]

Me tuve que ir a dormir y cuando desperté ya lo había subido, jajaja

[CaitlinNeko]

I really liked this one! <3

The part I liked most was how you did the thing with the hand clapping, when it said that he was 'praying for much too much' =0

[Alchemist2099]

Glad you like it ^^