Added: 2 years ago
From: johnpmc22
Views: 112,269
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (183)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • to listen to Noel's cover... well, the pleasure, the privilege is mine :-)

  • Love Noels smooth voice!

  • Great version. Noel is an incredible talented guitar player... while his brother has the voice. Man... I whish they just could behave like brothers. I don't even hope for a Oasis reunion or whatever, I just whish they both could play acoustic tunes like this from time to time, Noel using his guitar skills and Liam his voice.

  • Amazing cover. With all props to Morrissey and Marr, I actually like this version better.

  • Fuck, this is heavenly.

  • if you cant do it then dont.

  • Hey_Ì_fÊÊl_so_l0ñelý_tÔÐAY

  • find a wall, Gall, and run into it at full speed.

  • really beautiful wish he'd tour.R!

  • Such a beautiful performance. Would love to see Noel live again.

  • i am young and alive and its not too bad at all. luvin this cover. GANGSTA VOCALS

  • @alcoz1brown Gangster? No, shut up you faggot.

  • I miss you, Noel:-( Come up with a CD, please! We all miss your voice! And speak to Liam, it`y always the older brother taking the first step, believe me.

  • A brilliant cover version!. The Smiths version can never be beaten, but this is one hell'uva cover!!

  • @niederdonau I hope you die in a fire

  • god damn!

  • anything oasis sing is fantastic...:)

  • No other word for it. Outstanding. Everything a cover version should be is right here.

  • He's got soul. This man is my own light that will never go out.

  • @Kowalski88

    Been 13 years and counting for me. Ladies and gentlemen... MR. Noel Gallagher!

  • I love the original song but I have to say this is an excellent cover.

  • I prefer Noel's voice to Morrisey's

  • fucking awesome

    

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Oasis are the last Manchester group. After that nothing happened - perhaps we all became too middle class.

  • great version timeless and the fact it was played at the teenager cancer trust is even more moving ( there is a light that never goes out) SO TRUE

  • @RICHIE69841 totally true

  • this needs to come out on a EP so i can stick my cock in the middle of the CD

  • @kildunne hahahahah

  • noel is the tits

  • if bands were people, oasis and the smiths would've been best friends.

    and we need you both back

  • @Rowaaib Well Noel and Johnny Marr are freinds in real life so that's close enough :)

  • noel's voice is far better than liams. why he just didnt sing for oasis... ill never know. maybe he just thought liam's image fit better as a front man.

  • @talktal He isn't though. Liam's is a lot more unique than Noel's and altogether better. Noel's a god, don't get me wrong and has a mint voice, but Liam does stuff to songs that no other guy can.

  • GOD!!

  • Comment removed

  • Anybody who claims that this is better than the original is possibly the most uneducated moron alive. Even Noel would admit that Morrissey is where this song is all at.

  • @Usernameunavailablu I wouldn't agree with your statement at all, you're being a musical elitist, The Smiths are an acquired taste and Noel's sound is much more accessible, so I would not say they were the most uneducated moron alive at all, that fact that they enjoy the song to begin with is a good thing

    P.S. I do prefer The Smiths version, The Smiths are my favourite band

  • @Renegademaster15 Thank God, someone with a bit of sense. I reckon The Smiths to be eternally great than Oasis, but Noel Gallagher is a fantastic songwriter, a top bloke and a very intelligent one at that. So what is he's no Morrissey? He's Noel Gallagher. The single reason I listen to The Smiths and the vast majority of bands I love. He is the leader of a generation. Like it or not. Long live Noel and The Smiths!!

  • Better than the original without a doubt :)

  • i wanna be .. i wanna be aaa gallagher!!!!

  • noel gallagher is just surreal. i would give up one of my balls to have his voice and when i have children, id gladly give up the other.

  • super amazing

  • love it

  • jesus. that is quality. end of.

  • .....Wow....

  • Noel Gallagher is god...

  • Noel gallagher is god

  • Best cover of that classic song hands up,

  • wow noel fucked this one up big time.

  • @UC567 How did he? It's a cover and he did this song it's deserved justice.

  • I'm sorry this just doesn't cut it. You can't sing There is a Light as if it was a radio ballad. And this comes from a Noel fan.

  • @Yeaahright From one Noel fan to another: get ur hear out ur arse.

  • @Yeaahright Radio ballad? Stop talking nonsence mate!

  • and i meant as a cover... not comparing it to the smiths or morrisey.

  • anberlin´s version is way better

  • @xathosx Is it fuck! I've just heard it, and quite frankly it was rather shite. Besides American's have no right in covering great English music. That anderlin, or whatever it's called have nothing on Noel/Oasis or The Smiths.

  • @bradhatesmanu

    Could not have put it better myself!

  • the smiths did t so much better

  • This just proves that  Noel was the brains behind Oasis.

  • morrissey.

  • *sigh*

    My sweet Noel singing my favorite song of all time:)

    LOVE HIM!

  • this song is so beautiful, i cried all the way through it once, but it was a very bad day

  • This is a rarity. My favourite artist covering my favourite song.

  • this is probably the best version... i mean, the smiths did it a million times better, but still this is very good...

  • @Snakeyx

    Noel grew up with this song as i did. And he would definitely recognise that this is Morrissey's song.

    Great version but don't lose sight that this is a Smiths song.

  • @MrPge1970 And you're telling me this because?

  • @Snakeyx lol

  • morrissey would be proud

  • TO DIE BY YOUR SIDE, THE PLEASURE. THE PRIVILEGE IS MINE.

  • That is awesome.

  • UNREALLLL......

  • I love this. i wouldn't imagine who would dislike this video. It's simply heavenly.

    

  • amazin. noel Gallagher - LEGEND

  • noel gallagher does justice to this song, i absolutely love it

  • Ya the one with the monkey on it, got it at the slane, ireland gig ..

  • @johnpmc22 thank,s 4 putting this up class noel at his best

  • @johnpmc22 Yeah, me too! What a fucking gig!!

  • lo amo

  • Such a great cover

  • super!!

  • A "million views," or maybe, like, 30,000.

  • genius.

  • The BEST cover of The Smiths ever made.

  • i love this!

    

  • brilliant song sung brilliantly by noel. still love the original more tho

  • the words to this song are pure beauty

  • better than the original!!!!! noel is a class act!!!!!

  • I've had this on loop for over a year, and still not bored of it. Can't say that about ANY other track!

  • What a fantastic cover, well done Noel!

  • wow!

  • Holy shit, this IS brilliant! Noel Gallagher IS brilliant! I really would love to meet the guy, he's awesome, he blew me away when I went to see Oasis live in 2009 on the 7th of july at the ricoh arena!!

  • Absolutely class cover. From a big Smiths fan!

  • (L)

  • LEGEND

  • one of the beat cover versions i've eva heard. he didnt copy d song, he made it his own. noel is god

  • fuuckkk woooww celestiel

  • Awesome! My two great loves together: Noel Gallagher and Morrissey :)

  • Can't believe I've only just found this, amazing!

  • love it

  • For the longest time I thought he said "And then a strange bear gripped me and I just couldn't ask"

  • I dedicate this to 'My Sky'. I love you, Tj.

  • That picture's taken from your Dig Out Your Soul tour poster. I have the same one on my door

  • simply amazing, so powerful

  • FANTABOLOUS

  • oh how beautiful

  • AMAZING !!

  • I never thought i would say that but, oh God im out of words, all hardcore fans of the smiths can kill me but this version is better than the original

  • Noel does a good job of this i reckon,..he's got a real honest voice,.

    not the strongest but he's got some soul when he sings....

  • @carlos7217 This is true, he makes this cover his own, and thats what a cover is suppose to be. Love the smiths and oasis, both Legendary bands.

  • awesome!!!

  • The most beautiful track, with the most beautiful voice. There is a light that never goes out.

  • tcant wait for his solo album

    everyone knows the last 5 years have been about noel at oasis gigs

  • Longer even. Since SOTSOG, Noel's been the dominent of the two, and that was ten years ago now.

  • @craignuste

    the last 16 years for me. Liam is talentless, and owes his career to Noel. If not for him, He would still be on the dole. Liam has a decent voice, but its really just lennon/lydon. Nothing original or good about him. And to top it off, hes an absolute cock.

  • Comment removed

  • Its allmost as if noel wrote it, i mean the way he sings it sounds like he means every single word, noel is a legend GODLIKE!!!

  • Of course he does......it's Noel :) ...the best song writer and person !!

  • how good,does himself and the smiths justice...love it

  • wow! amazing! all the thanks to Peggy and Tommy Gallagher for bringing such a son!!

  • okay... now you're overdoing it. :p

  • Great cover. The Smiths deserve it.

  • bloody beautiful! i cant believe i like it i think its the strings!

  • OOoh my I love this!!!!!!!!!!

  • To be quite honest, I never thought any cover for The Smithes would be good. But I mean.. Well.. Noel never disappoints me.

  • Grow up! Class cover

  • Yeah this is a nice cover indeed!

  • strike me down for this, and don't get me wrong i love the smiths, but i think this version is dare i say better

  • i agree, i really like the original too. but there's something about the way noel sings it that i think makes it better... i got like chills haha

  • yeah noel did this smiths song alot of gd with this cover

  • noel gallagher is a genious

  • Not by any stretch of the imagination.

    It's spelt genius.

  • well then hes a genius lol

  • More of a genius!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I play this for people who claim Noel is talentless, needless to say they feel quite foolish once it is over. Love you Noely, solo album by April please...

  • This is just spellbinding!

  • lots of love. thanks Noel

  • noel is god

  • fuckin 'ell

  • mind blowing

  • awesome

  • Oh my god, how beautiful is this! *-*

    Noel Gallagher is god!

  • Agreed, proof he can go it alone, this is sheer brilliance, addicted!

  • one of the best cover songs ive heard! cant wait to hear noels solo album

  • One of the few smiths covers i like!

  • Fucking brilliant¡¡¡¡ Noel is GOD

  • Where can I find an mp3..song of my life...

  • brilliant cover, it puts a totally different spin on the original.

  • is there somewhere we could download or buy this version?

  • iTunes ... search for Noel Gallagher - The dreams we have as children

  • isnt that fade away ?

  • it's a lyric of fade away, but also the name of the album which contains this concert :)

  • noel gallagher has such an incredible voice.

    i love it and this is the best version of the song ever!!

  • Wow, I just keep coming back to this version, seriously I'm gonna get it to 1 million views all on my own. Noel's voice has so much emotion, you can tell he really loves this song. What a gifted man. I even like this better than the original. Is that sacrilegious? Ahhhh shoot me shoot me.

  • i totally agree!

  • @suim2007 jajaja (hahaha)

  • erm this song is originally by the smiths for those not in the know!

  • ya I know I was just suggesting a tune like this could fit on an album