the concert is from Venice, check similarity with cellphones recordings. I don't know why he released this mess, even if it must be on the 5cd edition: he really missed the lyrics AND he plays the worst solo in his career, trying to tune his strat all through the solo. Should have started it all over, just like Macca does. It must be the only fair performance in his life, he's so great, what a feeling what a voice.
@ridendo2003 Well considering this was the first time he'd played the song in over a decade, I'd say it's pretty good. The solo isn't his best, but cut him some slack. If I remember correctly from the behind the scenes look at this tour, it was rainy and humid that night. If you know anything about the guitar, you'd know that humidity absolutely kills your tuning.
Ten kawałek nie był na playliscie koncertu, gilmour zaśpiewał go pod wpływem chwili i trzeba było ciągnąć dalej :) Zagrany zupełnie bez przygotowania. Miazga
I listen to this because of the laughter, and how he must have smiled at Rick, who was alive at the time. He is amazing, but not perfect. I wouldn't care if his broke voice all through a concert. I would totally pay for it regardless. I never noticed on my gdansk discs that the crowd clapped. Only a TRUE artist, and one that loves Rick Wright would add this to his album.
""On the turning away" played by David Gilmour. The song is one of many others included in the "Live in Gdañsk" 5 disc box. Note: this song is not from the concert in Gdañsk, but from one of the other concerts David and his friends had on their tour.
Feauters also a tribute to Richard Wright"
See any interesting in the text? Read before you comment things..
He doesn't forget the lyrics, this is the rick wright tribute i think he crys because you can hear his voice at 1:05. Love Pink Floyd they're amazing !
LOL! No it's not crying, and it's not a tribute. Richard Wright was still alive at the time, and he completely forgets the two lines; it's NOT intentional!
I love this version on Live in Gdansk. It shows that although David is not really God, he is still human. I love his laugh when he cracks and forgets the words.
Go out and watch/listen to other live takes of this song and you will see that Gilmour forgets the words to the song on that same part quite often. Goes to show that even for the artists remembering the words isn't always the easiest thing to do. The pure brilliance of Gilmour/Wright, Pink Floyd makes up for it though. Personally I could listen to Gilmour play his strat all day long and never get tired or bored.
probably the first time I heard Dave mess up, so cool to laugh it off, that's what music is all about having fun. Superb musicianship
TalkToTheBody 4 months ago
even david's screw up is charming
Obelisk2290 6 months ago
"plad ewid e fla da la".... Classic Gilmour
floydfan831 7 months ago
a great voice and guitarr playy , david gilmour
big david , and not to assimil of the big what is david gilmourrr
dabus90 7 months ago
Comment removed
papounetdu83 8 months ago
One of my favorite music of Pink Floyd. I find this very moving version .
papounetdu83 8 months ago
at 1:46 lol ;-PPP
i've listened to this song hundred times and i like it every time i listen to it.
Saryna85 10 months ago
haha i always giggle with joy when he misses the lyrics
TheNight3434 11 months ago
One Guitar.......One God..... One David Gilmour
innovativemgm 11 months ago
the concert is from Venice, check similarity with cellphones recordings. I don't know why he released this mess, even if it must be on the 5cd edition: he really missed the lyrics AND he plays the worst solo in his career, trying to tune his strat all through the solo. Should have started it all over, just like Macca does. It must be the only fair performance in his life, he's so great, what a feeling what a voice.
ridendo2003 11 months ago
@ridendo2003 Well considering this was the first time he'd played the song in over a decade, I'd say it's pretty good. The solo isn't his best, but cut him some slack. If I remember correctly from the behind the scenes look at this tour, it was rainy and humid that night. If you know anything about the guitar, you'd know that humidity absolutely kills your tuning.
daviddet 7 months ago
2 dislikes? wtf is wrong with you?
swingo5 1 year ago 2
superb mate , great post , one slip. and down a hole we fall. not dave he is god, just a man with more talent than the rest of us,
ljwjfac110369 1 year ago
Ten kawałek nie był na playliscie koncertu, gilmour zaśpiewał go pod wpływem chwili i trzeba było ciągnąć dalej :) Zagrany zupełnie bez przygotowania. Miazga
Klimatou 1 year ago
Merci pour ce vidéo.
merlinchanelle 1 year ago
I listen to this because of the laughter, and how he must have smiled at Rick, who was alive at the time. He is amazing, but not perfect. I wouldn't care if his broke voice all through a concert. I would totally pay for it regardless. I never noticed on my gdansk discs that the crowd clapped. Only a TRUE artist, and one that loves Rick Wright would add this to his album.
misredkimmy 1 year ago
David Gilmour, to On
roberthodd 1 year ago
thanks for posting this, it sounds so human.... the little vocal imperfections, the emotion, everything.........
MrCouldbeakiller 1 year ago
This is from Venice perfomance, not Paland...
andrepompeu 1 year ago
@andrepompeu
""On the turning away" played by David Gilmour. The song is one of many others included in the "Live in Gdañsk" 5 disc box. Note: this song is not from the concert in Gdañsk, but from one of the other concerts David and his friends had on their tour.
Feauters also a tribute to Richard Wright"
See any interesting in the text? Read before you comment things..
leif3n 1 year ago 3
@andrepompeu Poland***
guitar4098 8 months ago
Hello RIchard!
It's 'just me.
So often do I see your face, even when they say it's not time for me to join all of you.
Someday as it seems so shall be, I saw Johnny the other day, as he was hoping for Chocolate Cake.
Seems as tomorrow will have to wait again.
And if you didn't hear me say so, "Thanks For Being Part Of the Magic!"
Dexz9 1 year ago
Is Rick in this with him?
kennyscotten 1 year ago
@kennyscotten
Rick was with him
leif3n 1 year ago
He doesn't forget the lyrics, this is the rick wright tribute i think he crys because you can hear his voice at 1:05. Love Pink Floyd they're amazing !
XxdolanxX123 1 year ago
rick was alive at that time
flurubis 1 year ago
i say that for those who asked
flurubis 1 year ago
@XxdolanxX123 rick wright was alive at that time
flurubis 1 year ago
@XxdolanxX123
If you listen, you can hear Rick play as well. It's not crying. It's laughter.
leif3n 1 year ago 4
@XxdolanxX123 its not a tribute, rick was there playing next to him, he laughs not cries
dogg111222 1 year ago
@XxdolanxX123
LOL! No it's not crying, and it's not a tribute. Richard Wright was still alive at the time, and he completely forgets the two lines; it's NOT intentional!
Carlibengarli 11 months ago
an from my favorites
1980lemasi 1 year ago
PINK FLOYD NUNCA MORIRA.!!!!!
bassdiegofloyd 1 year ago
Lol some1 forgot the lyrics, hear the audience support them.
einarabelc5 2 years ago
He always seems to forget the lyrics in this song, haha
(Live versions)
GeorgeC2009 1 year ago
1:43 a 1:50 RULES!!!!!!!
=D
optimalbass 2 years ago 10
... però rick si può vivere senza e che caspita è troppo l'ovazione daltronde a tu tradisti il buon sangue 333 paradise.
abcmatrix 2 years ago
Sorry Pink Floyd Fan, this is on the Live in Gdansk live discs.
misredkimmy 2 years ago 4
David has not played On The Turning Away in Gdansk. This soundtrack is from the Venice concert.
pinkfloydfan1989 2 years ago
61 anni buona pensione EDEN ERI UN EDEN PER LE DONNE IN TUTTO CHE CAPELLI BIANCI MA X I FIGLI????.
abcmatrix 2 years ago
Per i figli che suonano la chitarra un esempio da seguire!!! GRANDE DAVID!!!!! :-))))))
Liveranix 2 years ago
in your life you're god of music now you're possession in life do you remember games play off
abcmatrix 2 years ago
listen to that guitar...epic!
FunkeeDonkee 2 years ago
That first photo with Rick is fantastic..great solo!!
claudiowrc1 2 years ago
Comment removed
claudiowrc1 2 years ago
that last photo of Rick makes me sad. RIP and SHINE ON. Great version, killer solo. =)
quincyq03 2 years ago 2
I love this version on Live in Gdansk. It shows that although David is not really God, he is still human. I love his laugh when he cracks and forgets the words.
misredkimmy 2 years ago 2
HAHA it was so funny when he messed up and laughed :D
Rozq87 2 years ago
Rick will always live on in our memories, RIP without you there can be no floyd, we will miss you.
gameplayco 2 years ago
Gilmour didn't performe this song in Poland.
He did it probably in Venice.
benoslaw123 2 years ago 4
yeah this is from the bonus disk with other songs performed on the tour, still awsome though
gameplayco 2 years ago 2
you are the best RICK and DG
sgtcupcake31 2 years ago
This song missed hte female vocal choir at the end.. For me it was one of the greatest part of On The Turning AWay
andresihotang 2 years ago
Go out and watch/listen to other live takes of this song and you will see that Gilmour forgets the words to the song on that same part quite often. Goes to show that even for the artists remembering the words isn't always the easiest thing to do. The pure brilliance of Gilmour/Wright, Pink Floyd makes up for it though. Personally I could listen to Gilmour play his strat all day long and never get tired or bored.
ccbunn19 2 years ago 19
@ccbunn19 Me too. I listened to this song about a million times when I was working out how to play the guitar solo and it still gives me goosebumps.
tubbybasset 1 year ago
love the bit at 1:40 when they cus of struggling with the top notes, but even the crowd cheers as they recover.....pure brilliant talent!
m1kew8e 3 years ago 3
haha it's even better than that... listen carefully, they forgot the lyrics! That's why Gilmour starts laughing!
crk1121 2 years ago 3
We love you RICK!
Take Care!
YGibsonY 3 years ago
Quality .
gonightboat 3 years ago
we will miss you Rick.
zeitesixx 3 years ago