COOK OFF TO THE DEATH!

[bubblepug22]

Cheater!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­! : P

[stunner4lif]

Pizza

[2468bed]

i would think...... SHAYCRAL is the best!

[TotallyLavaTV]

i WOULD TOTALLY CHOOSE PIZZA!!!

[ignasx41]

i like pizza more than icecreams

[KDC1200]

he don't cook that

[copyninja1]

LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[xchubbybunnyxx]

i like pizza better! :)

[StephanieBermudez139]

my hamsters name is buttercup.lol

[OMAJgaad]

I WANT PIZZA

[niseniarrol]

cooking contest, shay, not cheating contest.

[bamigogy12345]

Shay looks soooooooo much better nowadays, slim.

[TH3b3st7]

Olo

[SareMinz]

omg what if his name was like ree? i would be reetard :P

[katbear11]

I wouldve chose mommytards pizza over shaycarls icecream

[imnotkoolss]

They need to do another one of these series :)

[imnotkoolss]

Omg! I can't believe how skinny shay is now :O

[littleharleygirl101]

i soooooo think you cheeted im on mommytards side if the battle:)

[MrUlrich792]

WOW SHAY! 178 now, you look so much better. :D

I'm so proud of you :D

[T1027Production]

Daamm i never realise Shay was that fat bacck then :/ He lost soooo much weight!

[cmanclan101]

idc what anyone says.... shay was funnier when he was fat.

[melanieemelaniee]

REMATCH FOR ALL OF THESE! xx

[ErickaMaeC15]

Shay kind off cheated, because he had to cook the meal and not buy it and plus ice cream is not a meal it's a dessert.

[seahdon]

@puppygirl29 I agree me too

[omgkristinaishere]

how many kids you have????

[joqqe93]

@omgkristinaishere 4

[kierannet]

tottaly cheated

plus im lactose in tolarance screw ice cream

[PuppyGirl29]

I would have ate the pizza over icecream

[Pinoys12390]

shay cheated! Well, he cheat at mostly everything

[ymcmbswag123]

@Pinoys12390 you have bad grammar

[Tjquinn95]

shay you cheated

[lilbiGpena]

shay reminds me so much of my uncle lol

[xirawrryoux]

wait shay didnt go to college right?

[MissNikkiNeko]

Ice Cream is not a meal... but it is to kids so its cool :)

[Rubix4Life]

look how much weight he lost

[madirocks227]

He cheated katiette took some time and effort on her pizza

[ManiacalMaster]

holy shit look how fat shay was i didnt remember him as this fat

[itssofluffy555]

Shay TOTALLY cheated like ice cream is PART of a meal NOT A WHOLE MEAL!!!!!!!!

[Firesale5]

I found this by typing "fat guy on youtube" be proud, be fat.

[harvestmoonchik890]

cheated

[dad3332211]

He definitely did not cheat. I know kids looooove ice-cream and it is counted as a meal. How do I know? I'm kid

[Greenflare400]

cheated

[krisybell314]

complaining's not gonna help, muffin top! hahaa best line

[Bleach18Angel]

i would of chosen the pizza

[patrickthePEZ]

well shay ice cream isnt basicly a meal......its a snack so...:/

[cloXandXem]

Shay Didn't cheat. For a kid Ice Cream IS a meal. I know that because i'm a kid.

[MrPopbottlepop]

cheated



[queenlolamuffin]

i have tht shirt mommytards wearing go girl

[TutandGaming]

Thumbs Up if u agree if shay is a big fat cheater

[Jigglypuff879]

cheater shay

[therarechloebug1]

cheater!!

[cutiemunchkin1]

well,i think SHAY CARL IS RIGHT becuse 1st of all hes AWSOME! 2nd of all she didnt say you cant buy food she just said u have to make it.anyway i think he TWISED THE RULES TO HIS ADVANTAGE.

[ThePopTartCatlol]

@cutiemunchkin1 Making it means preparing it. All he had was a bucket of ice cream and bowls.

[iCarly422]

i rather have mommytard's pizza

[TheGingersnap26]

I'd kill my bf if he gave me a hair bump.

[harleyluigi1]

There kitchen looks just like mine

[fffffffffff31]

shay won

[LoaFrz]

well she never said COOK and the definition of prepare is to cook or get ready. so if you see him getting ready the icecream then you could say he won but for the love of these videos we can say he cheated so there are more of them.

[Brittanyyyyify]

is she pregnant?

[footloopsrock44]

CHEATERRRRR

[ally14899]

he looks so different but when i tihnk of shaycarl this is what i think of lol

[krumpstamama44]

oh my god shay looks so different!

[cheer123ezzy]

you cheated shay you said you have to make a home cooked meal and someone else made the ice cream

[hotdog12370]

Now i hate you Shay >:|

[hotdog12370]

OMG DON'T CHEAT SHAY!!!

[rcchms]

he cheated

[MichaelMania123]

@LivingRobotFlims Um, What?

[halofreackonly]

he didnt cheat



[spenserellen]

mommy looks soooo beautiful pregnant!!

[kotsujin]

ohh he cheated lol

[BeautyLifePeace]

Anyone notice the tag Lmfao ?! " thanks for watching my videos will make out with you"

[MissStalked]

"alright get this disgusting pizza out of the way.."

LMFAO Shay your so mean it cracks me up!!

[ItsMonicaaaaaa]

Omg , SHAY lost so much weight!

[Creepingonmichelle]

i <3 fat shay. hahaha.

[WeasleyIsOurKing5]

Wow he lost a ton of weight

[calberkeley7]

dang you lost so much weight

[Cabage4ever]

Omg i just watched the vlog from today and shay you look so much better now !!! Ur not fat anymore lol

[triplehhh478019]

can i haz that fat shirt

[edkingofnarnia]

shay you were so fat congrats on loosing the weight

[elana0808]

I know this is an old video but you did cheat and Mommy tard looks so beautiful prego.

[BJ219]

Wow, look at how much weight Shay's lost!

[TailsBit]

Thumbs up for rocktard.

[BigShaytardsFan123]

CHEATER haha im sooo late

[KimberlyDawn2727]

LOL that was hilarious

[akwolfsong]

Icecream is not a food.. :P

[fcmmysterykitty]

shay YOU TOTALLY CHEATED! that was not fair.

[junbev]

he soooooo cheated!!!!!!!

[mgkcheer29]

he cheated

[PuRpLeGiRlZrOcK31]

you cheated

[MaeganLovesYooou]

the NEW SKINNY SHAY would NEVER have ICECREAM for DINNER! nope!

not hot sexy skinny SHAY!

[letsamario]

Well he cheated but he is a better cook

with 2 eggs a sausage and a bit of milk he filled her stomach for NINE MONTHS :)

Like if u get it

[MissStalked]

@letsamario stop that's not funny that's disrespectful

[pups123ism]

@MissStalked oh my god! u do know it's all just rehersed!

[MissStalked]

@pups123ism um wtf i dont give a fucking shit? that has nothing to do with rehearsel? he was being inappropiate? fucker.

[me69fine]

you did not cheat i would have rated 20 submarines out of 10

[kammieekam]

Shay really has lost a lot of weight :o I didn't realize how big he actually was before.

[kuppykate]

omg shay lost so much weight now wow

[apbunny2511]

I didn't see Babytard scream for icecream....

[StaMiiLoVeR]

Cheater;(

[12345doggydiggy]

SHAY YOUR A BIG FAT (not overweight fat but fat as in very big) CHEATER!!!!!!!!!!!

[cicialex4ever]

u cheated

[EvaMarie12599]

Cheaterr! It wasn't a meal and you didn't cook it !

[awsomenoobpwner]

rule twister (richard gere approves :OLOL)



[Blackhearts60]

pizza was better cheater!!!!

[philliem0812]

thumbs up if you think they should do this again but for real, not rigged planned out stuff.

[SkitttlezStarz]

did shay just call her wife muffintop?



[basketballpro66]

Shay didnt cook it

[helly7766]

Yeah you cheated... but it was really clever I must admit!

[FreerunnerDave]

Yeah I agree you cheated

[Go0os1]

@FreerunnerDave lol just asking .... are you a girl ... ? XD

[FreerunnerDave]

@Go0os1 Lol man you have no idea about genders hahaha

[MultiCassie123456]

Ice cream!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[1ThingIsToBeHappy]

i'd eat the pizza x)

[MegaDonKai]

awsome



[Element095]

hahaha this is hilarious. i love these videos wayyyy more than the new ones on this channel

[JPLarkin01]

you just twisted the rules

[bryanred79]

is cook



[angie171210]

cheated!!!!!!!!

[Ttizzle3000]

Cheated completely. Its a COOK off. You have to COOK

[parkourpower97]

shay is way skinnier now

[hamburgare1000]

twisted the rools

[Saarbe]

Wow shay have lost so much weight!! good job Shay!

[G0dizl0v3]

TEAM MOMMYTARD- SHAY YOUR A CHEATER FACE

[G0dizl0v3]

SHAY YOU CHEATED

[sexysheerel365]

Shay u didn't cheat.that's what your kids really loved. Katilette like she was going to win.I knew she was going to lose hahahaha I'm so happy that your the winner!!'' YAY 4 SHAY!!!!''

[19donutluver]

lol look at mommytards face @ 1:06

[krkatelyn]

Dude like not trying to be mean... But... Ya u so cheated... It was a cookoff dude u were supposed to cook!

[Titus0RA]

pizza should have won the challenge said cookoff and you didnt cook

[whiteboyfollower]

WHO WANTS ICE CREAM!!!!!

[virgilwilliams777]

shay you won fair and square :D

[Nicki6321]

cheater!!!! lol but it was funny

[MrMikeProductionz]

you didnt cheat

[MrBloodFight]

i loved this channel way more when it was pretty much improvised and not using a script... Still good though:))

[MatthiasYoung]

this guy's life? My dream.



[ngkfssd]

oneadayporno(dot)com - free porn!

[ShadowKunaiStorm]

@ngkfssd you're the second one thats said that already! :(

[hamsterlover20011]

hey shay what ever your a big fat cheater she tried way more than you and heres was better than icecream at least she has sence of humor go mommy tards

[darkvash12346]

@hamsterlover20011 ice cream is better and shay is better then mommytard

[chaoscompanion]

my dad i mean

[chaoscompanion]

lol y dad and shay would be o good friends

[Shanburrtaay1025]

yus, i know it's WAAAY late, but shay cheated !

TEAM MOMMYTARD ! :D

[JimmyGameVloger]

i though shay was making ceareal

[2081coolgirl]

omg shay reminds me of my dad so much like hes personality its so funny cuz my dad would do that

[tickytoky123]

Cheater!!!

[justducky722]

Cheater!

[1mapleandoak]

i like pizza more than ice cream u should of bought a food critic or something, shay CHEATED, CHEATER CHEATER PUMPKIN EATER!

[emomazing]

I've never bought premade pizza dough...We always make it ourselves :/

[MonkeyGirlRulez]

He twists and breaks the rulez!:(

[manutdmas]

i like pizza more than ice cream...

[Mrdeath111558]

he twisted the rules

[lp7460isfunny]

he twisted the rules,I would've made whipcream come out of a can into a bowl but you know not my battle.

[TheMagicMan410]

Dude I would have eaten the pizza

[therock7047]

Shay, Yes you ARE a fucking genious! LOL

[HoggyMyHoggy]

Muffin top? you jerk Shay :D

[BritishHedgehog14]

You big fat cheater, your mean!!!!

[Erppah]

Shay you are mean.

[SuperGeekandGF]

cheater!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



[rosetta10010]

Cheater cheater ice cream eaters!

[sebytz92]

This dude is the living proof that fat men can have beautiful women! keep it up!

[niseniarrol]

shay you didnt COOK you just TOOK

[stardust562]

ur wife is a milf

[goldenchocobo2070]

I WANT YOUR PIZZA KATILETTE! CAN I HAS SOME?!?!?!?

[itsgeorgetime]

LMFAO SHAY!

[ArielsaNinjasaur]

He called her muffin top! :O Katilette should automatically get that point. Shame on you Shay!

[halokiller10101]

who wants ice cream yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaay XD

[hannahwestbrooks]

i dont think he cheated becuz she said the kiddies just have 2 like it

[tinocosam831]

I dont care I just want ice cream!!!!

[Super04Evan]

shay cheated cuz he didnt make the ice cream

cheated cause u didnt make it