Added: 3 years ago
From: xporkeypigx
Views: 92,199
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (128)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • eh, it's okay... I like Linkin Park's version, no, original better.

  • Chester is the best vocalist in the whole world . This song is belong his voice. But I like cover too. And as a huge Chester fan Chester is way better. Chester is incomparable

  • Ooh wow...a spectacular cover of an amazing song...

    Okay Linkin Park, now it's your turn.

  • Wonderful rendition! I would love to hear him sing "Live and Let Die"

  • Considering Chester wrote this as a tribute for his mother, who had passed away in Dec of 2002 or 2003, LP's version has more meaning behind it.

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE!!! i LOVE Josh!!

  • Thanks for uploading this....good song!

  • his voice is amazing and he is sooooooooooooooooo adorable and unassuming.

  • I think the Linkin Park version is much better.

  • Linkin park wrote this song!

    I like Chester's voice more.. i get the feeling of december, by listen to his voice.. 

  • I love Lp's version better!!!

  • I'm a big fan of both artists and I really can't decide which one I like better... but Josh has definitely done a good job....

  • i dont get any emotion, when i hear this version. Linkin Park is better. It isn't Josh's Song

  • Ahhhhh this amazing man's coming to Atlanta....seeing him in concert will make my life complete XD

  • Josh Groban is a great artist, but I'm sorry, his voice is way too deep to do this song effectively. It overpowers the whole thing, and pushes the music to the background, whereas, in the Linkin Park version, Chester's voice syncs up perfectly with the music, as he is wont to do. Plus, the music is a, I guess you could say, "remixed" version, it sounds almost nothing like the original track. I love this song, but Josh kinda dropped the ball here.

  • @ChidoriTsurugi Agree 100% way to deep for this awesome song! lol LINKIN PARK FTW!!!

  • @ChidoriTsurugi

    I like both but I can see your point of view. Some songs have different centerpieces: voice, instruments, production. For this song you're favoring the production aspects which I can agree with. I probably wouldn't like Josh singing "Personal Jesus" or Barbra Streisand singing "Edge of 17". It probably wouldn't work.

  • 8 People don't appreciate good music.

  • thanks Josh, I just love all your music... you are so gifted!

  • I hate it when people say that this is their song because they are born in December... or that it moves them because its December when they listen to it.... December is a metaphor in this song people, jesus!

  • where can i find this song to buy

  • thumbs up for LP & Josh version

  • I like Linkin Park Version more.

  • What's the original? Lp? They are both perfect!

  • @89Coa yes LP did the original , this is a cover

    and i agree , i'm a hardcore LP fan and i love this version a lot too n_n

  • I love this song.

    LP's version gives you a sense of sadness.

    Josh's gives you a sense of longing and hurt.

    This version moved me to tears. It is amazing.

  • @Sephylover14 agree with you 100 %. Amen to that. This song describes and is soothing to my pain.

  • this is so my song. i am a December baby

  • with Josh's version of My December it's hard to stay loyal to Linkin Park

  • Josh OWNS!!

  • His version is horrible and annoy me very much. He can´t sing so feelingly as Chester and his voice drives me mad. I love original version and I love Linkin Park too. They are the only way.

  • great version, little bit of a different mood but i really like it. i prob prefer lp's version because its a little more complacent and desolate, does a great job of capturing the feeling of a quiet wood in the winter with snow on the ground and trees. but this is great too, josh groban is phenomenal

  • Chester or Josh?

    Chester for sure! Chester can play with his voice easly!

    And Josh is good but not like chester!

  • chester bennington of LP wrote the song after him an his wife divorced!!!!

  • @minitruck8608 wow never knew that, and this is one of my favorite LP songs too! haha go figure, but now that I listen to it closely it does coincide with divorce.....I can relate since my parents are in the current process of divorce as well

  • Josh has added more effects and instruments to make it sound better.

    But to be honest , chesters voice sounds better. Josh has got a strong voice but this song needs a sober voice like chester's.

    And 2ndly , Josh SUCKS when singing this song live (I'll not generalise all his live acts coz i've jus seen this 1) . Just see chester singing this live and compare.

    And the main thing , the original is always better, let it be any artist who made the original.

  • @REVANdaGod Linkin Park is the officla owner of this song

  • Love Josh's version of this song. His voice just takes me away with the lyrics. So beautiful. Josh has the voice from the Angel's above.

  • So who song is it? LP or Josh Groban?

  • love it he can sing like an angel ,i just love him his voice is the greatist,,thanks for uploading

  • hello! thanks so much for posting this! I love this song-Groban did a great job with it! Do you happen to know which album this is off of? I'm having a hard time finding it.

  • josh has an awesome voice i wish i had one like that

  • I have loved this song for yeaaars now. My favourite part's the violins from 4:20 on... *sighs*

  • I like both versions of the song, but I give the edge to LP because you can understand what's being said during the elongated notes in LP, I agree that Josh's voice is better, but I like those other words in the song, it gives the song more depth

  • From Linkin Park <3333

    Realy nice song.

  • I'm not sure which version I like better, Josh's version or Linkin Park's version. Josh's voice is just awesome...I can only dream of singing that good

  • @trainhater14 No need to be an ass

  • drool! i loooove josh groban!

  • oh yea,,not to forget,,,he suck while singing this song live

  • this is good........but cannot beat LP's version....

    yeah,i know he has added many effects , computerised beats , extra instrument , backing vocals to make it more glammy n catchy,,,

    but the original, softer version does justice to the lyrics....

    just keyboard , drums , guitar , violin n yea,,not to forget turntables , sounds more versatile than this .....

    and josh's voice is strong and good,,,agreed,,,but doesnt match this type of song,,,

    chester's vocals is what this song deserves :)....

  • This version is not bad, it's pretty good, but LP's original version of "My December" is the best because I mean it's Chester, he's the original. Oh yeah, too the person who said this is Josh Groban's song is terribly mistaken. Yes I know how you meant it, but this is LP's song.

  • This is much better than LP in my opinion. :)

  • Any song Josh sings becomes HIS.

  • awesome cover,it`s so relax ^^

  • I LOVE THIS SONG THIS IS MY FAVOURITE!!

  • Groban may be a bible-humping, cultist, weirdo, but he's got a great voice for sure.

  • Don't be a jerk

  • @zolotierney

    Sorry if I offended you, but how am I a jerk? For having a different life-outlook or opinion on a person than you?

  • You can disagree, have your opinion, etc. However, is it really necessary to throw around discriminate terms like 'Bible-humping' or, in my own opinion, immature name-calling?

  • @zolotierney

    But that IS my opinion. I suppose, though, youre right about bible-humping. I could have said cultist and left it alone. Point taken.

  • Badass -.- LINKIN PARK RULZ

  • Gotta say... LP's version is way better. I like Chesters voice much better, it's way more powerful

  • @Melondrage You trollin' dawg.

  • it's from Linkin Park lol, but this song is great too!!!

  • Josh Groban have a very nice voice...his song´s have power...

  • I like Josh Grobans version better than LP's just cause I'm not a huge LP fan. But the song is great either way!

  • IMMENSOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful song....carnt see it on i tunes...where can i download it?

  • I like LP, but I think this version is much better !

  • does he cover song from linkin park?

  • yes he does

  • I like this version, hes an awesome singer, but I honestly like the LP version better..

  • I like this verson but I prefer lp's version because chesters voice is raw and that matches the emotion of this song more to me... but I do love this guys voice, it's amazing...

  • I disagree, I think Josh's voice being crystaline (a bit nasal live perhaps, but not here) and much darker reflects the spirit of the song perfectly.

    But then again everyone is entitled to their opinion of course.

  • yeah brutal death metal!

  • Josh Groban is amazing, but nothing can top LP

  • And i and i and i and i LOL

  • and thats funny because.....???

  • not really funny. ps did you mean to misspell spartan*

  • 5/5 although I'm a Linkin Park fan.. but this version is way better.

  • i love chesters voice because its so much fitting for the song..

    this version is awesome but does not catch that feeling what linkin park gives in their reanimation and the original versions..

    awesome version though

  • Dudes LP version is COOL! but Josh Groban verision is AWSOME! Josh's voice connects more to the feeling of the song! 5/5!

  • @TheRedsai2004 How? haha I don't like.

  • @FreshNapp well i gess thats your opinion.

    respect!

  • @FreshNapp when i meant respect, i meant i respect your comment.

  • Linkin Park's version in my opinion is soo much better! And i'm not saying this because i'm a huge fan of LP.

  • Good song! Great artist

  • I'm a huge LP fan but i think josh's voice really fits this song better.

  • josh groban is so amazing.

  • What an incredible and powerful voice...

  • Very Powerful!

  • This is really good, but the Linkin Park's original version is better ;)

  • I'm not going to lie, I like both versions...

  • @ErikismyAngel5 ditto

  • Yeah Both are REALLY good!!!

  • Both versions from LP and Josh are great it just depends on ur taste of music. One is not better than the other. Its ur own opinion and u have the right to it.

  • cover original who gives a fuck its all about the music... both are excellent tracks ... amazing

  • This guy is much better than Lincoln Park. His voice is unmatched

  • I always heard this song with my ex-boyfriend but the Linkin Park version. I must think at him everytime i'm hearing this song

  • I like this version better than Linkin Park

  • I also... don't like Linkin Park version :))

  • what????? Linkin Park - My December - track15 - july 30 2002. lp was first.

  • cause this is a fucking cover... geez :/

  • Linkin Park did this song first because it was on the Bs-side of one step closer that was released in Europe and then they did a remix on reanimation

  • nice nice nice :)

  • Comment removed

  • Not at all dude...

  • umm actually this is a cover..Linkin Park originally did this song.

  • Who ever wrote this comment knows nothing about Linkin Park...Mike Shinoda wrote this song. And Linkin Park recorded it with their first single, One Step Closer...Linkin Park leaked this song all the way back when they released Hybird Theory in 2000, and my december was the 13th track on Hybird Theory when Linkin Park released the special edition on March, 11 2002...Groban is an excellent singer but you are a naive fool if you actually believe this was orginally Groban's song

  • -^.^- tihihi sorry you're right

  • Yeah, you are completely correct. And clearly Groban is covering it for a reason. My December a ballad of sorts for LP, Groban knows how good LP is. He did an excellent job on this and both versions are exceptional.

  • beautiful :')

  • whooo Josh, only one word : SUPERB !!!

  • Groban > Linkin Park. Enough said.

  • Lilmomob is right. This is actually a song by Linkin Park. I prefer the Linkin Park version better, but this one is good too!

  • i agree! although Josh Groban does it nicly as well. Linkin Park is still better though.

  • One of my favorite songs Josh does.

  • This is a Linkin Park song covered by josh groban but it is still AMAZING

  • beautiful eyes and a great smile! lol nice video =]. josh groban looks so much like this guy i know..curls and all

  • Wow, this an incredible video! Where did you find all the pictures?

  • ohh erm thank you glad you like it x and i have no idea it took me so long to find pictures i just went on google and typed in so many things like josh groban photos etc.. hope that helps you x and thank you for watching x

  • gdd video init pooks lol love yoo xxxx

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more