@THEAWESOMETACOPERSON Did you know laughing reduces the chances of cancer? i did.Theres nothing we can do about it so why not make light jokes about it.If people laugh, people won't be that scared of it.Its how they dealed with hitler.What i am trying to say is stop whining , who said it was a joke anyway? cancer is found as a tender lumpling so i was just stating fact.
@MrMiltonius Yes, it's originally from the movie Nightmare Before Christmas, the song written by Danny Elfman whom does most of Tim Burton's movie scores. This version appears on the original soundtrack as a bonus track alongside Danny Elfman's and the movie casts'.
@MeIsSmarticle in the real one its "Tender Lovelings" even thought this is a Covor you still have copyright rules to follow so they had to change lyrics a little lol
Surely, it had been said before, if you don't like Panic(!), or the song, no one is forcing you to listen to either. Instead of picking idiotic fights, click away, it really is that simple! No one cares to hear you opinion on the song, especially if you don't like it. It's a waste of your own precious time, don't you think?
I love what he does with his voice, I can't explain it. His voice like, jumps around while his singing. It's really cool and it gives this song the extra that makes this version better!
I love how people will sit here and argue about covers of songs. If you don't like it, fine. If you do, that's fine. Everyone can have their own opinion, now just stop the bickering and enjoy the music!
Okay, I like...excuse me, I meant liked Panic at The Disco; but this....this is shit. He gave no effort whatsoever to change the sound of his voice and he didn't put any backbone into any of the lyrics! There's no change in character to match the multiple characters from the film who sang and he was just boring!
This isn't sexy, this is wrong!
Marilyn Manson did way better because he actually put effort into changing his voice. Panic, write originals, don't do covers...ever.
@DamonandSky shut up. maybe he didn't want to make it sound like the original. Every person sings things differently. Not all covers have to be sang the same way as the original....so just deal with it mkay?
@crazycow0119 Hey don't get offended. I think you missed the issue entirely. When someone remakes a movie but the movie is crappy then does that make it right? I'm not going to stop them from making the movie and I won't stop people from watching it but I sure as hell will speak my mind; just as you are.
Anyone who responds with "shut up" is an ignorant individual.
I don't like this piece because he doesn't give it any effort; and there are no character voices. In my opinion, it's shit.
@dragonwhisperer6 Oh boy; call out an artist and the die hard fans creep out from the corners of youtube. He didn't put any effort. There is little pitch change, the synth is most of what makes up his voice, and he is hardly audible at all. Do you know anything about music at all? I've done two musicals and a whole shitload of choral concerts, being a singer myself I KNOW this isn't good at all. Ask any music instructor and they would tell you there isn't any effort at all.
@dragonwhisperer6 Also; this sounds exactly like any of his other songs anyway. I like panic, but this song is crap. Don't tell me I don't understand effort; it takes no effort whatsoever to be seductively low in pitch and not sing out. It takes all the effort more to do the different voices and takes far more effort not to use a synth in recording. This is neither new nor well constructed; the style is a repetitive garbage sex driven vocal used to entice a audience. Gimmicky, that's all.
@DamonandSky No, I'm not saying you don't KNOW what it is. I'm saying that you don't know, because it could take ages to get his voice to sound like that, or it could take minutes. Only BRENDON knows how much effort he put in
@dragonwhisperer6 That's...just the exact thing I argued against. It takes no effort to change your voice and HE USED A SYNTH!! I have no problem with synthesizers, but let's face it; this is still crap. Also; you're last arguing point isn't a valid point at all, you're just repeating the same garbage. This is gimmicky, it has no effort, and that's his natural voice plus a synthetic input to make it creepy.
@DamonandSky I at least understand what you're saying. I do think though that the song serves its purpose quite well and thats what makes it epic. Have you heard Blood by MCR? It's a short ditty, if I may call it such, that's more of a short nonsensical bit, but it's awfully good. Synth and repetition don't spoil a song. Clearly YOU are not his intended audience. That is all. And the fact you have done how many ever musical, choral performances really doesn't say much (not that its not impress
@daleesaramsden Thank you. This really is the point I'm trying to get across. As I said synth doesn't spoil a song, it's just I'm not interested in this. And the only reason I mention the musicals was to try and prove I have some knowledge of how song making works and how to tell who is good at what. I don't mean to brag. And if you read all of the argument you'll see I don't care if others listen to this. To me it is garbage, but that doesn't mean some other person will like it.
@daleesaramsden OH MY GOD!!!!! Sorry, I'm just such a huge MCR fan and that popped out at me! And I've liked MCR since before Danger Days even came out, so I'm not some poser person... I know so many people like that though... They know one song and say that they're MCR's biggest fan, just, no... go listen to Bullets and Cheers albums then come back and say that... AND I LOVE THIS SONG!!! I like Marilyn's version, too, and I love P!ATD!!!
Respond to this video... ive) but you have not stated what kind of productions you have been involved in (classical modern contemporary etc) so I don't really think that's relevant for you to make that statement. This would be so freaking epic sung live by a choir it's not funny.
@daleesaramsden Yeah, the song would be awesome, but not with this writing script. If this was how the song was song there would be no differentiation between pitches and there would be no major differences between harmony and melody. This piece would be wonderful with a clash and twist to it. Like I said, the cover is what bugs me, I like the song when sung by other artists. Also reason for not explaining is I don't want to reveal my personal information. Welcome to the internet.
Sorry, but i prefer Marilyn Manson's, I think it gives a better 'Halloween' feel, whereas this reminds of a story like Disney, no offense to all the PATD fans, i like them too :P
who here knows every dang word to this song forward and backward????
indigail123 1 week ago
I prefer the marilyn manson´s version
isxbel1 1 week ago
That moment when you're really into the song, and your mother walks in with a more or less horrified expression.
Fantabulous10121 1 week ago
Even though the meaning behind the lyrics are slightly disturbing, this is definitely on my favorite songs list!
wolfmeowwarriors 2 weeks ago 5
Favorite cover of this song. <3
HannahIsLaame 2 weeks ago 3
A lumpling: a young innocent child who must be informed of the world;
cattakins 2 weeks ago 4
I love this so much. It makes me smile for some reason...... 😌❤
anlbtp 3 weeks ago
i dont know why but this song makes me so happy.
DaniBananaFanna 1 month ago
What is a tender lumpling???
paramorepokefreak 1 month ago
haha begining .... This is Hallowee
200Kat 1 month ago
His voice makes me melt lol
HunterCDkk 1 month ago
THIS IS EPIC!!!!!!!!!!! i love this song especially the way PATD does it
astonishingbigc 1 month ago
hehe...weird me listening to Halloween music :)
awsomestar4567 1 month ago
Lets be honest
I used to have a crush on Jack Skelekton
Nomonyourcookiez 1 month ago 3
@Nomonyourcookiez :O i have a crush... people in star wars
awsomegirl260 1 month ago
I'm just taking a guess here...but, I think this is Halloween.
happy4prez 1 month ago 2
Hey dont dis on the song Dx i am married to this song! Yes say I don't have a life but i am married to this fuckin song
Ronnirok14 2 months ago
I see a very angry kitten under my bed...D:
WolfOfTheBeyond 2 months ago
I LOVE this song, but it makes me feel like stabbing something... or better yet, someone! :3
milkweed332 2 months ago
EFFIN AWESOME VIDEO!!!! love this song anyways but you just made it better!! ^.^
EmoChick4500 2 months ago
@THEAWESOMETACOPERSON Did you know laughing reduces the chances of cancer? i did.Theres nothing we can do about it so why not make light jokes about it.If people laugh, people won't be that scared of it.Its how they dealed with hitler.What i am trying to say is stop whining , who said it was a joke anyway? cancer is found as a tender lumpling so i was just stating fact.
ellikwl 2 months ago
its "till the neighbors scream and die of freight." :/
THEAWESOMETACOPERSON 2 months ago
Tender lumlings xD
raestarr13 2 months ago
TEHY ARE AWESOME
apleltyecyat7 3 months ago
i love this song. it sounds creepy and awesome.
bellaswan840 3 months ago 2
i love this and the marilyn manson version,i hate the original though for some reason
themadhatter10771 3 months ago
Love it, but what the hell is a tender lumpling?!?!?
Emarubygrl 3 months ago 2
@Emarubygrl a small child, i'm guessing?
animegirl271 3 months ago
that awkward moment when you realize that the top comments are about someone under you bed
LiveLaughLove9999997 3 months ago 19
Comment removed
xSexbombSuzukix 3 months ago
hallowee never knew i was spelling it wrong :I
princessmuze 3 months ago 3
shit guys! if you like marilyn mansons better go watch his! your getting annoying...
RellaLovezKandy1 4 months ago
Comment removed
marie3031970 4 months ago
- whoever
AlwaysSmilingLove96 4 months ago
@EmoLuvv04 ikr! I'm sorry but however did this is like super slow. -ijs
AlwaysSmilingLove96 4 months ago
I love listening to this............during christ,as morning
Pikana225 4 months ago 3
is this a cover??
MrMiltonius 4 months ago
@MrMiltonius Yes, it's originally from the movie Nightmare Before Christmas, the song written by Danny Elfman whom does most of Tim Burton's movie scores. This version appears on the original soundtrack as a bonus track alongside Danny Elfman's and the movie casts'.
ferntailwp 3 months ago
What exactly is a "tender lumpling"? XD
MeIsSmarticle 4 months ago 59
@MeIsSmarticle cancer.
ellikwl 2 months ago
@ellikwl thats not funny. my friends little sister died of cancer.
THEAWESOMETACOPERSON 2 months ago
@MeIsSmarticle its like a small, delicate, tender child.
SuperSweetinnocence 2 months ago
@MeIsSmarticle in the real one its "Tender Lovelings" even thought this is a Covor you still have copyright rules to follow so they had to change lyrics a little lol
TheAnnalea10 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
@TheAnnalea10 Ohhhh that makes more sense.
MeIsSmarticle 1 month ago
@MeIsSmarticle Its meant to be kids,,, :/
rookieroo1 1 month ago
@MeIsSmarticle i always assumed it meant plump children
TomRiddleMeThisSpock 1 month ago 2
TENDER DUMPLINGS EVERYWHERE
awsomegirl260 1 month ago
Happy Halloween to all! ^-^
onilink422 4 months ago
The original is better...as always...XD But I have issues with this version it's just...calm and monotone. XD Good nonetheless.
YunaLover212 4 months ago
Happy Halloween >:D
passsiero 4 months ago
i sang this for my talent show this year....
RellaLovezKandy1 4 months ago
Yes huh they did @zariagoesrawr in the very beginning:0
AlwaysSmilingLove96 4 months ago
am i the only guy that likes this song?
kyuubisharinan3296 4 months ago
AHHH im trying to learn the lyrics for halloween any tips for memorizing the lyrics? :/
zariagoesrawr 4 months ago
@oolongfoo thank you! :D Are you a vocaloid fan too?
vocaloidlover98 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
SHUT UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC!
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
liv4music6 4 months ago
Is anyone aware that they spelled Halloween wrong?
AlwaysSmilingLove96 4 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@AlwaysSmilingLove96 no they didnt :S
zariagoesrawr 4 months ago
I love both this and Marilyn Manson's version. Marilyn's version scares me, and this one intrigues me. :)
vocaloidlover98 4 months ago
@vocaloidlover98 i love ur username
oolongfoo 4 months ago
i like it .... did i just kinda you know :/ hahahaha
minimaddy1 4 months ago
Surely, it had been said before, if you don't like Panic(!), or the song, no one is forcing you to listen to either. Instead of picking idiotic fights, click away, it really is that simple! No one cares to hear you opinion on the song, especially if you don't like it. It's a waste of your own precious time, don't you think?
Fans, enjoy. <3
GetAGripGetOut 4 months ago
I love what he does with his voice, I can't explain it. His voice like, jumps around while his singing. It's really cool and it gives this song the extra that makes this version better!
chocochipcutieX3 4 months ago
This is probably one of the most epic things I've heard.
MorningDisturbance23 4 months ago 2
I love how people will sit here and argue about covers of songs. If you don't like it, fine. If you do, that's fine. Everyone can have their own opinion, now just stop the bickering and enjoy the music!
Candichaos6 4 months ago
I think 20k of these views are mine.
Nickii890 4 months ago
whoo! :3
SilentHillEmzie 4 months ago
I think whenever I scream "BRENDONNNNNN!" When the wind blows, my friends think I'm mad...
dragonwhisperer6 4 months ago in playlist P!ATD
I like this version better!!! Manson's version is just too creepy to me!!! This one is more like the original!!!!
annalucianavarro1234 4 months ago
Okay, I like...excuse me, I meant liked Panic at The Disco; but this....this is shit. He gave no effort whatsoever to change the sound of his voice and he didn't put any backbone into any of the lyrics! There's no change in character to match the multiple characters from the film who sang and he was just boring!
This isn't sexy, this is wrong!
Marilyn Manson did way better because he actually put effort into changing his voice. Panic, write originals, don't do covers...ever.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
Comment removed
crazycow0119 4 months ago
Comment removed
crazycow0119 4 months ago
@DamonandSky shut up. maybe he didn't want to make it sound like the original. Every person sings things differently. Not all covers have to be sang the same way as the original....so just deal with it mkay?
crazycow0119 4 months ago
@crazycow0119 Hey don't get offended. I think you missed the issue entirely. When someone remakes a movie but the movie is crappy then does that make it right? I'm not going to stop them from making the movie and I won't stop people from watching it but I sure as hell will speak my mind; just as you are.
Anyone who responds with "shut up" is an ignorant individual.
I don't like this piece because he doesn't give it any effort; and there are no character voices. In my opinion, it's shit.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
@DamonandSky Dude, you don't KNOW if he put effort into it, he sounds different here then in anything else.
Thats called effort.
dragonwhisperer6 4 months ago in playlist P!ATD
@dragonwhisperer6 Oh boy; call out an artist and the die hard fans creep out from the corners of youtube. He didn't put any effort. There is little pitch change, the synth is most of what makes up his voice, and he is hardly audible at all. Do you know anything about music at all? I've done two musicals and a whole shitload of choral concerts, being a singer myself I KNOW this isn't good at all. Ask any music instructor and they would tell you there isn't any effort at all.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
@dragonwhisperer6 Also; this sounds exactly like any of his other songs anyway. I like panic, but this song is crap. Don't tell me I don't understand effort; it takes no effort whatsoever to be seductively low in pitch and not sing out. It takes all the effort more to do the different voices and takes far more effort not to use a synth in recording. This is neither new nor well constructed; the style is a repetitive garbage sex driven vocal used to entice a audience. Gimmicky, that's all.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
@DamonandSky No, I'm not saying you don't KNOW what it is. I'm saying that you don't know, because it could take ages to get his voice to sound like that, or it could take minutes. Only BRENDON knows how much effort he put in
dragonwhisperer6 4 months ago in playlist P!ATD
@dragonwhisperer6 That's...just the exact thing I argued against. It takes no effort to change your voice and HE USED A SYNTH!! I have no problem with synthesizers, but let's face it; this is still crap. Also; you're last arguing point isn't a valid point at all, you're just repeating the same garbage. This is gimmicky, it has no effort, and that's his natural voice plus a synthetic input to make it creepy.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
@DamonandSky I at least understand what you're saying. I do think though that the song serves its purpose quite well and thats what makes it epic. Have you heard Blood by MCR? It's a short ditty, if I may call it such, that's more of a short nonsensical bit, but it's awfully good. Synth and repetition don't spoil a song. Clearly YOU are not his intended audience. That is all. And the fact you have done how many ever musical, choral performances really doesn't say much (not that its not impress
daleesaramsden 4 months ago
@daleesaramsden Thank you. This really is the point I'm trying to get across. As I said synth doesn't spoil a song, it's just I'm not interested in this. And the only reason I mention the musicals was to try and prove I have some knowledge of how song making works and how to tell who is good at what. I don't mean to brag. And if you read all of the argument you'll see I don't care if others listen to this. To me it is garbage, but that doesn't mean some other person will like it.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
@daleesaramsden OH MY GOD!!!!! Sorry, I'm just such a huge MCR fan and that popped out at me! And I've liked MCR since before Danger Days even came out, so I'm not some poser person... I know so many people like that though... They know one song and say that they're MCR's biggest fan, just, no... go listen to Bullets and Cheers albums then come back and say that... AND I LOVE THIS SONG!!! I like Marilyn's version, too, and I love P!ATD!!!
squirrelyMCRfanatic 4 months ago in playlist squirrelyMCRfanatic's favorites
Respond to this video... ive) but you have not stated what kind of productions you have been involved in (classical modern contemporary etc) so I don't really think that's relevant for you to make that statement. This would be so freaking epic sung live by a choir it's not funny.
daleesaramsden 4 months ago
@daleesaramsden Yeah, the song would be awesome, but not with this writing script. If this was how the song was song there would be no differentiation between pitches and there would be no major differences between harmony and melody. This piece would be wonderful with a clash and twist to it. Like I said, the cover is what bugs me, I like the song when sung by other artists. Also reason for not explaining is I don't want to reveal my personal information. Welcome to the internet.
DamonandSky 4 months ago
omg i love it
annabellleming 4 months ago
This is sexxxyyyy! <3 ;3
christeneisabelle 4 months ago
Epicness X3
NinjaZombie4 5 months ago
Jasmine You pic at 0:14 FTW!♥
GraceTheEscape 5 months ago
Brendon Urie, you make this song even MORE perfect.
NaomiSatoism 5 months ago
*looks under bed* Pffft.... Your not brendon, Your a zombie. Wait... O_O
cici7008 5 months ago 87
@cici7008 Keep it as a pet ^-^
Nomonyourcookiez 1 month ago
This version is even better then Marilyn Manson's
TheJKMFilms 5 months ago 3
omygoshhh!!!! cannot wait till halloween... gonna be a wizard from harry potter... but a zombie, too XDDDDDD Cant wait.
greenjazm1n 5 months ago 2
He is awesome
BigKidParodys 5 months ago
@EmoCharity i must have the picutre at 0:16, i need a new poster
chatzoo12 5 months ago
I can't wait for Halloween :3
XxSpazzmaniuhxX 5 months ago 2
I love this song a whole lot better than Marilyn Manson's version! <3 Panic! At The Disco
crazycow0119 5 months ago
"I am the one, hiding under your bed."
Me: Really?!?!
*Goes rolling under the bed and gets a spider in my mouth.*
paveepavee 5 months ago 4
The start is so creeper xD
I like Marilyn Manson's better though :3
KaylerhhBeKhaaotic 5 months ago
Panic! At The Disco <3
babygirlsgp10 5 months ago
i wish brendan urie was under my bed ;D hehe
XxDangerDaysxX 5 months ago
@XxDangerDaysxX *cough* BrendAn?! The right name is Brendon.
TheTrecoollover 5 months ago
@TheTrecoollover People spell it "Brendan", "Brendon", and "Brenden". Get over it.
sailorxlee 5 months ago
me and my friends are gonna parade down my street scream/singing this >:)
xXbvblurverxX 5 months ago
Well... This ruined halloween for me... just so EMO :)
LittleBro31x9 6 months ago
"I am the one hiding under your bed.." *looking under my bed*
" OMG!! HI BRENDON!! oh...he's not there."
BellaGinnyGirl 6 months ago
I love this version :)
iJustice100 6 months ago
im going to there concert at the ritz in october and i cant fucking wait cuz im gunna meet him!!!!!! :"D
kaitlynandsydney 6 months ago
Brendon Urie is under my bed???!!! :DDD *gets up and checks* dammit he lied :'(
kaitlynandsydney 6 months ago 72
Idk why, but I absolutely love this song.
Fantabulous10121 6 months ago 3
october is coming soon people >:D
DarkAngelOfTorture 6 months ago 4
Altho mansons does have more a halloween vibe
liv4music6 6 months ago
Lol i like this one better cuz i love the band and i wouldnt want marilyn manson under my bed
liv4music6 6 months ago 4
esta cancion es genial para cualquier epoca del año! n_n
panchebriopolita 6 months ago
Sorry, but i prefer Marilyn Manson's, I think it gives a better 'Halloween' feel, whereas this reminds of a story like Disney, no offense to all the PATD fans, i like them too :P
VegetaYaoiAddict 6 months ago 2
:] tee hee i luv this..
THEemmadream 6 months ago
how dose the other vidios with mest up stuffin them get more viwers then this good one
killme711 6 months ago 2
I didnt think it was possible to love Panic! even more!
EmoNinja1313 6 months ago
Is it weird its summer yet im listening to this?
eevee02espeon 7 months ago
this eats dick compared to manson.
childrenofthecorn666 7 months ago
My favrite part was when he said "i am the who in the call whos there?"
emmafighter 7 months ago
thumbs up if its summer!and your still listening to this song!!!
ThescarletFreak 7 months ago 15
@ThescarletFreak Nope, it's Autumn and I'm still listening.
dragonwhisperer6 4 months ago in playlist P!ATD
This Song Is Addicting :3
zombieslayer799 7 months ago
best movie EVER!!!!! and i love the song too!!!!
screamoLover97 7 months ago
i am sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo walking through my town and singing this with my friends >:D seriously awesome song. P!ATD ftw!!<3
DaNacker497 7 months ago
Marylin Manson's version scares the hell out of me, this one is just sorta hottt lol X3 I love themm :D
prettypurpleponiez 8 months ago 2
oh how i miss Halloween and its mischievous appearance >:D
TacoMan4561 8 months ago
the ppic at 19 scared me
Imabeastlynommonster 8 months ago
OMFG!! was that Jasmine You at 0:14 ?? OMG ONE OF MY FAVOURITE BANDS IS MIXED WITH ANOTHER OF MY FAVOURITE BANDS!!! :D YAY! (R.I.P Jasmine You!)
stormkid199 8 months ago
I love how its sounds like a music box tune at the begining and ending. I would so buy one if they actually made those ^-^
HartofDarkness4U 8 months ago
Another reason why Halloween is my favorite holliday, even above my birthday<3
HeatherXKaname4Ever 8 months ago 7
People who boo are soo Morons this is a great song theres no chances its not
MuSiCpuff12 8 months ago
omg this song is creepy yyet hot lol
iheartmesomeadam 9 months ago
i prefer this cover over Marilyn Manson's i also like the original tho :)
iizlawliet 11 months ago 76
@iizlawliet dude Marylin Manson is like a GOD in this song! its more scary makes you feel slightly....insane :3
DrumBass4ever 9 months ago
Is it wired that it's almost spring and I'm listening to this song??
MusicalJaime 1 year ago 99
@MusicalJaime lol not even, i was singing this full out all day today... XD
vampiregirl777nl 9 months ago
@vampiregirl777nl Haha...great to know that there's another person out there who scares people by singing creepy songs! ^-^
MusicalJaime 9 months ago
@MusicalJaime no, It's May and I am
SparkliPrincess1000 9 months ago
@MusicalJaime of course not, great music has no time limit :P
XxLeaveMeXx 9 months ago
@MusicalJaime
No, cause I'm listening to it in the summer!
xXSpiritDreamerXx 8 months ago
@xXSpiritDreamerXx
Oh, and did I mention it's the 4th of July as well?
xXSpiritDreamerXx 8 months ago
@MusicalJaime i'm listning to it in the summer :)
PunkyScarlett 6 months ago
ummm marilyn mason didnt write this song its from a movie although ppl do good covers of it
TeamJacob4everable 1 year ago
cute, not bad but i prefer marylin manson version, and original song of course
xXDanteskXx 1 year ago
God, every time I hear Brendon's voice, I get goosebumps! ((In a good way)) Good job!
hannahmontanachickyo 1 year ago
best song EVER
cuddlekinz 1 year ago
This song is so quiet!!!! I had turn the volume up REALLY loud just to hear the words!!!!!!!!
daisylil2 1 year ago
I like Marilyn Manson's version better...
daisylil2 1 year ago
nyaaaah i love it! panic at the dicso can make the soft parts sound totally erie and the louder parts seem totally perfect!
LizziBabi110 1 year ago
=^D....great song always been one of my favs...and i love the pics u put on it
jewfish95 1 year ago
awesome.. really awesome .. :D
the video will look good, I love this song!!!
(;
electrikful 1 year ago
heard this in the london dungeons in 2008 :)
JemIsANinja 1 year ago
WOOT WOOT. :3
xoktqt 1 year ago