Added: 5 years ago
From: Carriefan40
Views: 813,753
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (870)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • love this song

  • god, brad is out of tune like 75% of the time. but carrie is amazing

  • Comment removed

  • I got chills listening to this song :)

  • I want her shirt! <3

  • omg they are great together

  • somrtimes the hurt can be this bad been there great song

  • Carrie doesn't hold a candle to Alison Krauss.

  • @DashingAmerican agreed. not even close!

  • @DashingAmerican No. She holds a bonfire :)

  • Carrie is amazing, but for this song I pick Allison Krauss as the best :-)

  • i love carrie but allison nailed it!!

  • This date makes me think American Idol is fake. Her finale was may of 2007, this is in December of 2006... Maybe I am having the dates wrong but if she was appearing in Concerts singing with country stars before becoming the winner of American Idol what was the point of her people on there? Can someone help me with this. Did they just start putting new artists in the American Idol to make them more known? Something to think about.

  • @31JHart Oh!! You didnt know that American idol was corrupt?? SHOCKING!!!!

  • @KreigsMarine2 I don't watch the show... so no I didn't.

  • @31JHart maybe the person who posted this video got the date wrong.

  • Comment removed

  • @31JHart Her finale was 2005, actually...

  • @31JHart Get your facts straight before posting anything !

    She won American Idol season 4 (which was ended on May 25, 2005).

    In short, yeah you got your date wrong (2 YEARS wrong, that is)

  • @RainHNg Yeah, did you not read my last comment. It says that the other video I was looking at was the wrong date. Asshole! Read the whole thing before you try and say something...

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Allison's voice is way softer and subtle, better suitable for such a sad song. Carrie has that powerhouse voice. Still good though.

  • CARRIE IS GREAT..AND WELL..BRAD'S GOOD TOO..LOL...WATCH MY CHECKOUT MY NEW SONG-"LADY ACROSS THE ROOM"-CLAY MYERS...THANKS SO MUCH-

  • Carrie is WAY BETTER!!!

  • @mcbrideurbanfan Carrie is way better.....

  • No disrespect, but Allison Krauss is better.

  • carrie has one of the best voices of any female singer. period. boom.

  • Carrie tries to turn everything into vocal calisthenics.....Carrie will be long gone and Alison will still be making great music, flying under the radar, not selling out like almost everyone else. Carrie is a good singer, but Alison is a fantastic musician.

  • @KNT0791 no she won't

  • This version is better! Carrie's voice is angelic!

  • @PlayOnBT umm shes good but no alison krauss! 

  • @scooterdod you're right she isn't alison krauss, she's waaaayyyy better!!!!!!!

  • @forevercute241 I like carries Music too,,,,She is doing alot for country music.. But like I said she is NO alison krauss.. I am a Fan of All country,Bluegrass, outlaw country,,Etc,etc Alison has been apart of all genre's I mention,, So i have listened to alison mor then carrie, plus alison's voice is way better! And that's why she's trying to sing in a Higher key then she Usualy does!!!! To sound Like Allison!! song is good tho!

  • I like this version wwwwwwwaaaaaayyyyy better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I LOVE CARRIE BUT SHE CAN'T HOLD A LIGHT TO ALISON KRAUSS.. NO ONE CAN TAKE ALISON'S PLACE IN A SONG......

  • 53 Alison Kruss fans were here

  • i like carrie bettterrr:) lovve thiis song, carrie sings it much better in my opinion:P , brad paisley nd carrie always sound awsome singing together<3

  • I like this alot more with Carrie Underwood in it. Maybe it's just because I love Carrie & Brad duets..

  • Carrie, I love you...but that's Alison's part, so get of the stage, toots.

  • Oh my God. My dreams have come true. Best song. Best singer. =]

  • she is so HOT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I agree that that Alison Krauss has a softer voice, the kind of voice that brings this song to the next level. It makes her seem like the girl in the song and it makes it THAT much mor sad. Carrie's voice, however, is stronger and does in fact give the song a change, a good change at that, that because everyone fell in love with the song with Alison, it's just hard to adjust to Carrie.

  • This is nice, but the think that makes the original so stunning is how vulnerable Alison sounds. Like she is the girl in the song. Carrie has a hard time putting emotion into her voice, and emotion is what makes this song. If you had never heard the song before, you expect a voice like Carries, not something so different like Alison.

  • @swizzleflip10 you are on shit if you think Carrie has a "hard time putting emotion" in her voice, she does it while still singing. unlike Taylor Swift.

  • i like noth versions a lot. her voice is a nice change to the song and she is absolutely gorgeous. <3

  • krauss is better i like carrie tho 

  • this song always brings tears to my eyes....:'c

  • Love this video but wt type o camcorder do u have!!!!!!!

  • i want carrie's shirt!!!(:

  • luv this song

  • New Carrie Brad duet single coming up end of May :) "Remind Me"

  • @clpnyc2 Their upcomning REMIND ME duet will be a radio juggernaut.. The sample sounds amazing, wow, Carrie really helps Brad take his stuff to the next level, but we know she's one of a kind talent. Here's to #1 song.... Carrie needs to drop a more pure country 4th album, she would clean up on awards & silence her critics. Its her choice to play da game a bit more.

  • @morgan101967 I agree with that. But may not happen this time. She has Kara as a co writer again and someone from a pop-rock band with a co write.

  • No matter how many times i listen to this song, it will give me "goose-bumps" every time....

  • Love the Blue Jeans and Brad Paisley tshirt!!

  • @zthumper021 yeahh, she and brad sound so perfect today. allison was good but carrie is just like WOAH! =]

  • @HippieChild93 today meaning together

  • lol, <3 countrymusicCC's imagination......

  • The two best singers today, on one stage. Had the pleasure of watching this show in Baltimore!

  • Guys.. when carrie first comes out thats when its her.. and thats at like 2:00 god.. its not important is it!?

  • Comment removed

  • ffantastic

    

  • Country Music is fantastic. I liked seeing the video of Brad Paisley the most, although others are good too.

  • Country Music is fantastic because the wording sung is understood. I enjoyed seeing Brad Paisley although others are good too.

  • Carrie Underwood and Brad Paisley should had been the one to sing this song instead of Alison Krauss!

  • I will be damn that Carriefan40 must realized it too and fix the video, because when at the time you said at 3:11 when Carrie paused then it the video actually her voice, but before it was Allison, you may still disagree but that's ok. You and I will just have a disagree, no problem there.

  • wouldnt it be cool if GH or RB had this song:)

  • That isn't Carrie singing, that's Allison Kraus, somebody goofed.

  • @row759 .. uhh, that is carrie... i think u goofed

  • @carriefan0001 , no, I didn't goofed, I know it looks like Carrie, but that isn't Carrie sing at all, that is definitely Alisson Kraus's voice on the video. If you are Carrie's no. 1 fan, you definitely should Carrie's voice. I definitely it's Alisson's voice. Listen to Carrie singing Mama's Song and listen to this, you will see I am right.

  • @row759 ... say what u want, but thats carrie... alison doesnt look like that at all, pause the vid. at 3:11, or 4:08.... and that is carrie singing... i know her voice

  • @carriefan0001 , I know that's Carrie, I am not questioning, it just the fist part of the video isn't Carrie singing it is Allison singing and then at 3:11, it is then Carrie singing.

  • @row759 Nah, it's just Carrie trying to sound like Allison. You can hear the power in her voice that Allison doesn't have - as well as on some bits of sentences, you can hear the real carrie sneakin threw.

  • @ItsBrandonSinging , I still the person who was video taping this video goofed and put Allison's voice and realize part way and change it to Carrie's voice. I know the difference between Carrie and Allison and the first part was definitely Allison's voice and then they realize their mistake and correct it.

  • @row759 I know Carrie's voice as well. I know Alison's. This is Carrie the entire time. She is talented enough to change her vocals depending on who she is trying to sound like.

  • @ItsBrandonSinging sorry to say this, but if that's the way you are thinking then you don't know Carrie's voice or your hearing is way off. Because at the start when Carrie first appears, it isn't Carrie's voice, it is Allison and then about maybe a minute and a half, then it is Carrie and only Carrie's voice, not a mix.

  • @row759 All right, whatever you say... lmao..

  • @ItsBrandonSinging oh, well, we are going to agree to disagree, which is fine by me.

  • @row759 - Nope, no goof. It's Carrie alright. :0)

  • @icyblue1975 , I know that Carrie, there is no doubt that's Carrie on the video, that isn't it's just not her voice in the beginning, not until 3:11 in this video that's when it's Carrie's voice. That is my only problem.

  • @row759 I'll admit it sounds *very* similar, but I'm 100% sure it's Carrie's voice. There would be no reason for it to be Allison's voice. It's live and there are *slight* differences between this interpretation, and Allison's interpretation.

  • @icyblue1975 I think that allison's vocals were prerecorded for this song and carrie was just seeing backup until 3:10. why would carrie's voice sound like allison then at 3:10-3:14 ? we finally hear her voice (seeing the melody) AND overshadowing allison's at that point.

  • carries voice is flat.

  • I love that Carrie's in Jeans and A T-shirt, not to menchin the fact that it's a BRAD PAISLEY T-shirt!!!!!!!!

  • wow he sounds so similar to the recorded version, but just different enough you can tell hes not lip synching.

  • @ThePrincessk29

    he just doesn't do a lot of voice editing on his albums. that's all

  • Alison Krauss did it way better.

  • @BFMV108 hellz yeah

  • @BFMV108 I agree 100%

  • I love Brad Paisley, I love the version of this song.. I can't wait to see her in Chicago in 2011.

  • Yabbadabbaduh ... these guys up there have fun and ... excellent singer job

    Greetings from Germany

  • I was surprised how close this version is to the orginal. WOW this girl can sing anything! Brad and her have such amazing chemistry. They need to go on tour again. Love to see retro clips like this

  • i like carrie, but i prefer alison kruss better...carrie is an amazing singer, don't get me wrong, but alison's is softer for this song...this song is purely sad, so it needs a soft voice...carrie's is strong and hopeful...perfect for HER songs...i admire all three people because they are all talented and all work hard...people who bad-mouth these singers who have the guts AND talent to go up there like that and make it are just jealous, so do not bad mouth, please just be polite and considerate

  • @xXxKatalynaxXx I disagree and love the emotion that Carrie puts into this song.. it seems like she really knows how it feels.

  • @xXxKatalynaxXx I think Carrie has a good voice for this song. I'd choose her or Alison. guess it just depends on y'alls opinion. :)

  • Tack Carriefan04.

    Ett fantastiskt framträdande och vilken ståpläls...när fröken entrar scenen:D

    Grattis till er alla som var där och fick ta del av detta live.

    //Pontus

  • Comment removed

  • i love it but think the orginal version better

  • carrie is so cute

  • fucking people need to shut up!

  • Amazing... Carrie sounds SO much like Alison.

  • i just had an eargasm ...

  • CARRie +THIS SONG=LOVE

  • AWESOME job!!! That sounded amazing!! Love the original but I love this one just as much if not more just cause I love Carrie :) -3

  • GOOD WORK! BUT I STILL LOVE IT WITH ALISON...

  • LOVE THAT SONG :)

  • to - justkeepsmiling02-on the back of her shirt it says " Thanks for Riding! "

  • carrie does a better job at this song

  • so so so amazing. love you carrie! what does her shirt say on the back?

  • LOVE that she has on a "Brad Paisley" t-shirt!

  • brad paisley is hot back off he's mine lol i loved it carrie sounded great they both sound great who cried when they saw the video what is sadder soldier or girl i think it's the soldier that's when i cried and willow tree is my favorite

  • i dont think alison sounds whiny at all!

  • HOT BRAD PAISLEY!

  • ok this was good but i still think the real song is better

  • I personally think both Carrie Underwood and Alison Krauss are amazing singers (:

    and this song is good no matter whose singing .!

  • Damn man, there must be something in the water in Checotah Oklahoma!

  • I think Carrie did a much better job then Allison Karuss

  • somehow i think carrie's voice sounds different from her usual, but just as great :)

  • @takethewheelJESUS She is holding back and sounding more.. like Allison.

  • good seats! ;)

  • It's live... it'snot going to be as good as the studio... as for comparing allison Krauss and carrie underwood... two completely different sounding vocalists. As for allison Krauss being whiny sounding... seems carrie underwood has the more nasel tone.

  • They sound awesome together!!!

  • uuh its kind of sad u say that the original artist is better and u dont even know who it is.its allison krauss

  • Carrie is so pretty and talented:)

  • i lovd this song

  • @lmarkerful  idiot she is amazing.

  • That was awesome!! Great video!!!!!

  • Oh my gosh i got chills ... i love this song sooo much and carrie underwood is my favorite country singer so this combination is amazing !

  • carrie and uhh the original sound alike

  • @monkeyleaves45 Carrie and Allison Kraus dont sound alike. lol.