♥ 10Rose | My immortal ♥

[DalekEmeror]

Absolutely fantastic! Very touching

[cupidsheart1936]

I saw this one after Seduff's one (I know, how many times has her name been used in this commenting?) and I had HIGH expectations for this one... you met them. Not only did you meet them, you soared beyond and higher... great work! :D

[DewTheDewNow69]

I must say that it is VERY well made. i love it <33 Very good 5*

[soapsrock678]

amazing

[efatarocks]

This video is very good but I like the way that Seduff edited hers better. Yes, I do know hers is inspired by this one.

[PrettyFascinated]

gave me shivers, amazing!

[xTimeLordessx]

I like the way you had the beginning and the ending with the same clip :D

I actually prefer this to seduff's but I suppose everyone had their own opinions :)

[BonesBuffyFan]

OH MY GOD. This vidio is amazing. I almost cried! I live in amarica so Rose isn't coming back untill nex weeks episode. :( I can't wait to see what happens!

[jeviennis]

my god.

what software do you use?

i love your videos!

[THEpowerOFme]

Brilliant, really enjoyed it! Fantastic choice of clips! 5*

[ilovemugglenet]

AHHH THIS IS SO AMAZING!

I Agree, one of my favorite show and song. XD

Ashley :) :)

[efatarocks]

bah, the vid isn't loading for me. I'll add it to my faves and try after I get home

[efatarocks]

I finally got it to load. This one was really good but I liked the one from Seduff better, sorry :/

[THEpowerOFme]

You do realise that the one made by seduff was actually inspired by this one, and I can see why, personally I think this was brilliant! :P

[efatarocks]

I know, Seduff put it in the opening for hers. This video was well done but in my personal opinion Seduff's was better done

[TangledInspiration]

Yeah but talking into account Sarah(Seduff) is older, more experianced and has qualifications.

I think this is brilliant!

(:

[efatarocks]

I don't know the age of anyone here except the people I know.

You're right, this video was really well done, I just liked how Seduff did hers better, this one seemed to use the zoom in/zoom out too much

[Nov3mberMist]

I can see why it was an inspiration. very nicely done, I appluad you *claps for emphasis* Kinda teary-eyed over here.. although, with the affirmative that Rose Tyler is indeed coming back (and the fact that Doctor Who is supposedly going to start airing soon)seems to keep my tears at bay. *rambles on into oblivion* anyway, nice vid, yes, ^^

[cazzykay23]

i love this vidoe it so cool

[CrazyBoutBillie]

i love this! amazing, i love this song too! good job!

where did u get these clips from?

[chaosangelalchemist]

Now I've gone and smudged my homework from crying... I heard this vid had a rep and had to check it out, it most certainly did NOT disappoint. *sigh* Again, wonderful job!

[scufflerz]

Any way of getting the embed code? o.o

Just that this video would work well with a myspace page Im thinking of changing.

-Still can't get enough of this vid. So well done.

[scufflerz]

Sorry, just have to say that was bloody amazing! =D

[bedfordgirl]

I'm in tears now... So beautiful and so sad, of course this song and Doctor Who are really great, but the way you put it together... The fabolous editing... I'm really crying and that doesn't happen often. Brilliant video.

[kryptonitegrace]

Beautiful! One of my favorite songs for my favorite show!

[pammcasso]

That was so beautiful and so sad it was just...fantastic!

[wytchlet]

I love the Doctor and Rose (Doomsday made me cry) and I love this song (the message behind the song makes me cry), both together and the tears are neverending.

Great Vid

[seduff]

So great. That song has been overused in the past, but your video uses it beautifully. Great work. (nice use of the monitor) he he... ;) xx The peak of the song suits the doctor and rose being torn apart perfectly. As the Doctor would say... "beautiful!"

[wytchlet]

Brilliant, I love Evanescence and THAT song is my all time FAVORITE, it's just the best and the video...I'm just speechless over the video, well done.

[Piczipower]

fabtastic

oh my god i love it

the song fits perfectly

[lovertojackharkness]

OMG I LOVED IT!!!! I can't belive how close I just came to being put into tears. I wrote a reunion story and the title came from that song. I've always said 'My Immortal' is great for them!!!! Oh my gosh...I wanna cry now!!!! GREAT JOB!!!!

[lostinaheartofwordsx]

Absolutely amazing. Great editing =)

david tennant is FIT. lol

[HogwartsHonorRoll]

Definatly one of the best Doctor/Rose videos...ever.

I showed it to a mate who doesn't even watch the show, and even she was a puddle of tears :D

This is brilliant.

Seriously.

Definatly one of the absolute best.

[hermionetheknowitall]

Brillant editing,I thought it was very good.

[fanbosh]

wow

nicely done

love this video

[XxJesseyahxX]

Would Be Soo Much Better If David Was Good Looking.

[xxelm0xx]

This is Amasing :):) Best Doctor who Immortal Video Ive Seen and Probley the best Doctor who Video Ive seen :) Amasing Effects and has inspired me to carry on with my Editting lol I probley sound like a fan but i Love your videos very muchh and PLease doo more ??? xxelm0xx

[takeabananatoaparty]

This is amazing...I love the effects and the editing.

[Lilmizzposh]

lol i love him come in ma room everything loks like doctorwho even ma doors like the tardis doors lol posters everywhere bed sheets computer screen everything lol im mad

but hes HOT damn

[Padme0]

one of the best versions I've seen so far. Lovely, again... I guess I have to subscribe to you xD

[YoursSinsIntoMe]

ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!

*Cries*

Brilliant editing too =) 5/5!!!

[xXEmOrOcKeRsXx]

I've already replied to this, but oh well. I thought I would just congratulate you on the effects and how many hearts you have broken. Go you!

[xXEmOrOcKeRsXx]

I love it. It made me cry. I just... I love evry second of it. Rose's memory shall linger on!!! Martha nor anone shall replace her! EVER!

[hippogriffs95]

Oh no - wait.I know I've replied before,but I thought I'd just tell you that you made me cry watching this!

[Meowzer1188]

This was AMAZING!!! I love the effects! ^_^

[Kobrakias]

This is an absolute masterpeice, I simply adore it, it genuinly made me cry. No video has ever made me cry before, you've touched my heart. Thank you so much.

Saph x

[HogwartsHonorRoll]

*cries*

you killed me. that was too brillliant for words. especilaly with all of the effects and everything. I loovoed it sooo much.

*happy/sad dance*

[hippogriffs95]

>is gobsmacked< WOW! All I can say is - >favourites<

By the by,very very clever editing.Well done!

[ShadowDemonrage259]

This is the best fanvid with this song on this whole fucking site (if you'll pardon my terrible language), and that's saying a lot. Absolutely fantastic editing, perfectly twisted into a tear-jerker. Well done!

[starrysara123]

omg this video is great . . . i love the dr hes faf lol

brill vid xxxxx

[Sweetpal]

I LOVE this couple, it was so sad when rose was cast off, I'm still crying!

[FaiSchlechterWolf]

Oh wow. That was beautiful. My heart broke at about 0:30 seconds. So many people have used this song, but yours is by far the best I've seen. <3

[Scarlett1972]

This is a beautiful, beautiful piece of video. Truly, the editing and music choice are simply inspired. Wonderful job and thank you for sharing this with us.

[salienne]

Oh my... That was SUCH amazing editing. Seriously the best DW vid. I've seen to date. Absolutely absolutely fantastic.

[docwho06]

All i can stay is brillant. The best editing iv'e seen her a doctorwho vid. The video works perfectly with the song and the editing of the doctor watching rose on the screen is so cool. I like the part when the doctor is touching the wall and you edit some of their good times into the scene, well done

[labpup106]

Dude, that editing was brilliant! That was quite possibly the most amazing music video I've ever seen!!! Great job!

[elisepato]

Good job mate... You mixed my two favourite things into one and made me cry :')

[laurenadair123]

this song is from buffy

[Sparksalot2213]

scuse my french but u are bloody fantastic. that actually made my cry! u have gr8 editing skills by the way loved every second of it. sorry im babbling lol bye!! xxx

[SexieEstie]

wow. Just wow. Brilliant video editing. I feel like crying now!

[hollowing]

he can't say it, WHY CAN'T HE SAY IT? bastard...

I'm only joking ;) no, I love it, I love him, I love them...

and I thought your 'my last breath' one was great, this is just frickin' fantastic. thank you so much :)

[HermioneWeasley02]

Oh my god that was FANTASIC!! I love your editing, it's so moving and believable.

[ThisIsNotHappening]

The editing is amazing on this!! I love the bits where it looks like the Doctor's watching the scenes of him and Rose on the computer in the TARDIS...it's amazing!! :D AND the song is fantastic :D

[elliebanana]

that was absolutly brilliant. Love it so much!

[JediLeaf]

That was so amazing! Really well made.

How did you get that song? Did you mix it? It's different from the album version I think. Any chance you could give it to me or something?

[irisxeyes]

Thanks :]

The version I used was the full band version, I think it has more beats to it..I can upload it later for you if you want?

[JediLeaf]

That'd be great, cheers. :)

[badwolf9]

Love the bit where you put the forever scene in the Doctor's monitor and how it looks like Rose entered the TARDIS and...and...the 'too much that time cannot erase' bits :D

Sorry...I know too many comments but I love it :D

[irisxeyes]

Aww, thank you! =]

[badwolf9]

Aw it's so perfect!!!!

Love it lots+lots+lots+lots+lots+lots+­lots+lots+lots+lots.

So sad! Please keep them coming :D

[desertrose9]

I might still keep him:P

You know I love this! Still makes me cry:P

Chellexxxx