Added: 3 years ago
From: RealIdolFans
Views: 170,979
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (217)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • goes off on 1:39

  • he is soooo hot!!

  • this is good version . but no one can beat the real rock n' roll " Aerosmith "

  • Compare to Aerosmith version, this is so gay

  • its a aerosmith song and please le aerosmith be the ones to play it 

  • i can't believe he wrote this song wowwwwwwww

  • @robinjbr He didn't write it. It's Aerosmith

  • @robinjbr noooooo just no

  • but there is kinda a difference between aerosmith and D.Cook on this song. with aerosmith you get like those kinda desperate feelings of love that makes your heart and souls crying inside and out. D.Cook rock the hell of this song and i like it. but still i personally thought the aerosmith is better.

  • wow!!! why on last 3 years I thought David A better than him???? David Cook so gorgeous. Fortunately he won!!! yes!!! yes!!! yes!!!

    Unfortunately 2 best judges (Paula & Simon) has gone,1 suck judge still there now

  • wow i like his voice. just wow.

  • I MISS SEASON 7 SO MUCH. AND I MISS THE ORIGINAL 3 JUDGES. I MISS PAULA and SIMON. :((

  • @hughiegrant season 10 came close

  • AEROESMITH!!!!

    

  • @antiometro Aerosmith*

  • Great performance! Great voice! That's why he won! Besides, no matter what Achuleta would have done, he couldn't beat him! It was impossible for Archie to win, just impossible. Cook, you rock, guy!!

  • Mark Chestnut country version of this is the whip So so so so good

  • I still think Archie should have won!!

  • meee maatooo.

  • 1:27 he has the goofiest face lolz his mouth is funny there

  • The guitarist, omg, he's fo fu*** goodddddd!

  • @cucsac LOL , Amateur :)

  • papasote! I love him

  • He's my favorite singer. he did a great job with this song!

  • I wonder why Simon favoured Cook so much. I bet it was because of some financial negotiations behind the scenes where other semifinalists refused to make a deal.

  • @MrJudube or maybe simon just knew that david cook was by far the best out of all of them.

  • i love his voice !! :)

  • oh my. he's so amazing. love himmm <3

  • the set is oh so good..i love DC <5

  • its too fast with the violins i thought...it doesnt have the same emotion as aerosmith does

  • terrible

  • @eye777eye stfu

  • Bad arrangement. Violins were really interesting addition though.

  • Comment removed

  • That was an half way decent  performance but David A. could of done better even though neither can compare to AeroSmith.

  • WOW. This is amazing.

  • Cook ma d@#$ -_-... muaahahahahaa

  • ya know when 2 kids ask u who's better n u say both even if ur lying...

    during this season i believe both davids were the best... i just think it was unfair to choose one of them. archuleta performed a flawless campaign but cook performed a perfect final.

  • It was such a toss up.......they were both so good. I loved how they supported each other in the last vote......they both really meant for each other to win.....dramatic, touching.....awesome.......THI­S is how IT should be!!

  • awful performance .. is not the kind of songs he can sing ..

  • i performed this really well but Steven Tylers' voice was made for this song so unfortunately for me..theres no comparing the two :/

  • Yeah.... I actually thought he butchered the song, but I'm also a diehard Aerosmith fan. I love Steve Tyler singing this song and I don't like how he changed it. Should he have won? Probably. He certainly won the crowd, so I would say so. But I don't like his version of this song. lol

  • This made my skin crawl. In a good way. Made me tingle all over. His voice is so compelling...He's so deep and honest when he sings....I love it....

  • man i kept sayin Archuleta schould've won and i didn't even watch the show but this is my first time ever listenin to Cook and now i see why he won. i love Cook's voice!

  • Ahh,, the beginning of his reign! And NOW David "owns" the Idol Crown!! Super hot rock god is what he is!! I dont ever WMAT!! ( Dc kicks Aerosmith's version out of the park!) xoxo

  • he needed to do it rougher. more like Steven Tyler. i totally agree with @dstnyisurs

  • I loooove david archuleta such a sweet voice. But i have to admit. David singing this song is AMAZING. His voice is PERFECT FOR IT!!!!

  • he ain't got nothing on Steven Tyler. He did as good as anyone could, but should have just let aerosmith sing it. (:

  • thats my brthday

  • yeah! love the song! " David wins tonight"

  • Aerosmith's is waayyy better D=

  • He did miss something, there's something in Steven Tyler's voice that fit perfectly the song. I do prefer Aerosmith version, so awesome !

  • GUD ,, JUST LOVE HIM

  • ooh! I LOVE him! He's AWESOME!!!

  • I prefer Aerosmith's o.o

  • so do i XD

  • Me 2 LOOL but he did pretty good i think :p

  • this guy is AWESOME!!!

  • dude i like david cook's version better than aerosmith's haha

  • yeah...It`s better when you look at David instead of looking at Steven Taylor`s mouth :D:D:D

  • yeah right... NO!

  • is he know how to cook??heheh

  • WOW

    he has a great voice!

    <3

  • Liked the violins. wasn't so hot on the guitar. but who am i to judge?

  • @again748 yea i agree it kinda killed it

  • @again748 you're just again748

  • I had no idea he could sing o.o, Can He cook to?

  • maybe eheheheh =P

  • @FirePingwin no he cant, but i hear David Sing is a great chef.

  • @jolderon2 ahahahah! XD

  • @FirePingwin hahah Nice one

  • @FirePingwin kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk .. GOOD ONE, vey good.. !! David Cook ( too ) !!!

  • @FirePingwin so what ? Do a singing contenstant have to write his/her own song to sing for a competition ?

  • Ê lá em casa!!!hahahha...LINDOOO...

  • such a close competition.

    both boys were so gooodddd. (:

  • True true (Y) :)

  • i looooove this song so much. i keep listening to it

  • I kinda agree about the violins ruining the song. :/

  • here's another david i soo love ♥

    david cook! the best

  • how did he ruin it? Explain one thing he did wrong.

  • he is just amazing.! everything about him

  • He has a super-beautiful voice. I could listen to him all day.

  • 1he aint singin it right like it better when steven tyler sang it

  • i think that he sings it fine its the violins that screwed it up

  • He's good but i prefer some of the other songs he did. And also, he doesn't have a rough enough voice to do that song as well as it deserves. Him doing Billie Jean was amazin tho.

  • Fantastic :******

  • omg i melted :D

    his voice is sexyyy lol xx

  • i dont like how he changed the song and he messed up that treasure part, but that being said no one should sing this song but aerosmith because during the passionate parts only aerosmith can pull off the intensity and still keep the tone he does. plus his forehead is quite large.

  • it dosent matter if he sucks or not (cuz he is wayyy bad ass!) but you cann always agree that he is makin way more money then us haha

  • awesome

  • Respect.

  • for any one who says he's suck

    i have a question can you do better than him??

    he is great i assure

  • no i cant do better but i still dont like his voice very much! Archuleta for life!

  • what the fuck does THAT have to do with anything?! none of us goes out auditioning for american idol, he sucks comparing to many other performers on this show and in the showbiz in general. it warms up my heart to hear you assuring us he's great, but he still can't sing very well. like when he sang "is a moment i treasure", the syllable "trea" was completely off note, like in many other parts. archuleta SO should have won.

  • He's got power... he's a singer you can be sitting in the least acoustic room and still be able to hear him... he can hit the long soulful notes and even when he gets loud he's still very listenable... I personally think that seasons finale was one of the best... but Cook had it from the beginning... He won where Daughtry didn't... and that's personality and stage presence...

  • Fantastic point! The answer, for those of you who are wondering, is no.

  • My favourite song of all time and I think David Cook is great but the arrangement I thought was just shocking. This song belongs to 1 person and that person is Steven Tyler

  • hes hott. and is the best singer everr. that david archulets kid...yea. hes a big fag. dont forger it :)

  • do u have taste?? r u deaf???shut up.

  • u shut up he sucks

  • i really like his voice but doesnt really fit with that song..

  • not so good

  • love this song soooo much he's a great singer....

  • OMG! my heart totally melted right now...amazing performance...and i agree cook and archuleta are amazing singers! probably the best ive seen in american idol seasons...but the rite guy did win...i see him more in concerts while archuleta is love and inspiration lol but they are both amazing!.... and i agree with simon one of the best songs made of all time and he took the cake... [=

  • 1:13 was exciting xP

  • this is my favorite love song ever!

  • archuleta and cook are amazing singers, they were the best top 2 in the entire idol season.

    but i prefer david cook.

  • No affence allison iraheta should of won this year (2009) and david archuleta should have won last year

  • yeahh i know. i totally agree with the david archuleta part..but im glad kris won;;but allison is a totally amazing singer tho!

  • I agree with the allison comment, but not the other. They are both amazing though, but the right guy won. I just seen Cook in concert..he was amazing.

  • dude... matt giraud, kris, adam, danny were all better than alison... but dont get me wrong... she was amazing... although the competition was just too much for her

  • Those guys... better? You effing kidding?! Matt was maddeningly inconsistent, Kris and Adam were at par with her, and Danny had subpar performances covered up with lavish praise.

    And FYI, the competition got too much for her because the judges/producers, especially Simon, were being tools. She always got backhanded compliments, while Adam and Danny had full-on praises, one of the being often undeserving.

  • Sorry I do not agree with you. I realize the truth. Here it is. Matt Giraud was consistent the whole way through. The judges just put him down because they wanted Adam or Danny to win. That is why they praise them a lot. Allison was also consistent all way but she needed to dressmore properly and had no sex appeal. That is why some of the people did not like her. I am happy Kris won. It was something to put the judges in their place.

  • I agree that Kris winning put the judges and the producers in their place, and it better stay that way!

    And Allison is something of a "You either get it or you don't" type of thing. She's cute to boot. And you don't talk of sex appeal with regards to underage girls.

  • 0:35 omg!! what a smile, david cook!!!! ur awesome!!!

  • eric, i am attracted to you because of the quailty that you have. i would like tell you now . i just want a chance to be your girlfriend. emotion attraction does not have to be a factor in being girlfriend and boyfriend. attraction can be a factor to be a couple.

  • amazing!

  • i like david cook than archuleta...but their both amazing!

  • yea. david cook and david archuleta are both from last season. david cook won and archuleta was runner up

  • Wow.

  • Awesome Singer!!

  • im from europe .. and am not able to watch american idol .. so .. david archuleta and david cook were in the same edition ?

  • no i think this version is absolutely amazing i love david cook he sings this song perfectly

  • I hate this Version, it is way too fast!!!

  • Allison Iraheta did this song better this season then Cook did.

  • my question is, why doesn't anyone comment on the fact that half the notes david cook sings are quite out of tune? his intonation is horrible.

  • i agree

  • David Cook is nowhere near as good with this song as Aerosmith. I don't know why anyone things Cook is good. I've heard much better.

  • Heard better where??? Go to a Karaoke bar 8 years from now when you finally turn 21 and you'll appreciate these guys much more.

  • I'm 40. Karoaoke bars are for losers who can't sing. & I've heard better on the radio. Aerosmith, for example, sings this much better than Cook.

  • yeano wonder, you're 40.

    that explains everything.

  • Explains what? That I have better taste in music than you? Or that I appreciate substance over style? Cook is way out of tune here & I'm not the only one who noticed.

  • That your time is almost up.

    That you're so fixated onto liking one style or version of a song and apparently the public likes his personal interpretation and performance of a song in his own style instead of imitating the original.

    No one is suggesting him to be competing with Aerosmith so there is no need for comparison. He is his own case.

  • My time is almost up? You do realize people in this day & age are living to 90, right? It's not "fixating". Cook doesn't sing this very well. Has nothing to do with the song itself or the style or version.

  • "Your time is almost up"?

    You're kidding, right?

  • then why the fuck r u watching it

  • Because I wanted to see if he's any good.

  • his best song.. though im 14 so i obviously like david better :P

  • he was gud=>

  • david cook is so humble nd has a great voice =]

  • Comment removed

  • I totally agree ., David cook is so much better...great vocal, gerat singer......the right David won...

    DAVID Cook really GREAT

  • yes his d right one

  • Wow, awesome, his voive matches with the song pretty good, i lovee this performance :)

  • I always thought Paula's kindness and shit was exaggerated, but wtf? Has she EVER said something with even SLIGHT criticism to a performance other than in the auditions?

  • yeah i agree

  • true 'nugh, it started good... though..

  • omg this song is awesome and he killed it :(

  • in my opinion, those notes the band were playing should be long, but nonetheless he did a great job

  • He was so awesome!

  • His voice matches the song really well!

  • Randy is an ass. His Archuleta pimping didn't work----THANK heavens for that!

  • Frankly I think David Cook's performance was really awesome.. although the band didn't manage to cover this song so well. lol the guitarman solo in the middle of the chorus that was ridiculous and not professional at all.

    Almost like if they wanted to kick him out :))

  • I think if David Archuleta sang this song, it would have been much better... David Cook is better at a faster paced songs... Overall though both David's deserved to be in the finals. They are both pretty good.

  • i like david archuleta better. [;

  • David Cook's voice is AMAZING! pfft Way better than David Archuleta. DC's sounds so manly! =)

  • ha!of course david cook voice is so much stronger n btr n nicer den DA.gosh.

  • that was awesome. haha.

  • Nowhere near as good as Archuleta. Good, but Archuleta can sing incredibly well, and Cook does not have that power in his voice.

  • david cook is hot./

  • What a great song!! A great song...and a great performance!! A great guy!!

  • Nice solo by the guitarist. Preformance was a bit dull for the song, I missed the soul, the pain, the fact that he meant it.