Prue vs. Paige (Charmed)

[torresdangerous]

Pagie (Y)

[cineticovenus]

Prue, siempre me encanto mas que Piper, Paige y Phoebe, siempre cuidando de sus hermanas y defendiendolas de todo, una autentica guerrera, Shannen la interpretaba perfectamente.

Paige tambien me agrada pero lo que no me gusto es que la rebajaran a el puesto que ocupaba Phoebe tratandola de opacar casualmente haciendola dependiente e irresponsable, cosa que era natural en Phoebe, que por cierto no me agrada su personaje.

[TheBelldandychan]

paige la mejor

[D77X]

prue would win

[TheZo4725lol]

shannen can act like a bitch sometimes,but Prue kicks ass!!

[CarolinaMtz11]

¡PRUE!

[ChaLuvRose]

Paige!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[hrochl7]

OBVIOUSLY PRUE!! The best Haliwell

[coolcat98802]

I think you should stop comparing them they're sisters not rivals. They both kick ass anyway OK people.

[AngemonRulez]

@coolcat98802 Amen.

[RedCrystalify]

PRUE IS THE BEST!

[itsmequeenbee235]

PRUE!!!

[ilovesingdancekiss]

PAIGE OWNS PRUE SUCKED AND WAS SOO WEAK SHE DIED PAIGE OWNS. BUT PHEOBE IS MY PERSONAL FAVE PIPER DOMONATES TOO

[TheZo4725lol]

@ilovesingdancekiss uh...she was the strongest out of the original three.the reason why she died is because once leo tried to heal her,he couldn't she was already dead because she was hit first.Piper was healed because she was hit second,meaning she still had spare time to come back alive.the doctor did die 3rd,but Leo was more focused on the girls so...yeah just because she died,doesn't mean she was weak :)

[ilovesingdancekiss]

@TheZo4725lol My friend wrote that a long time ago, I love ll of them every much, I agre with you and actually appriciate the timeyou put into writing all of that. =) but it wasnt me who wrote it.

[915anonymous]

Prue was better.

When paige first came onto Charmed, i hated her and thought that she was a really bad actress. But then after a while i thought she was actually quite good.

But i still like PRUEa million times better.

[0TheSeeker]

You know this is pretty easy PRUE without a doubt! It might have been a little harder if they would have cast the right person to play Paige but Rose was a complete miscast! Now if they would have cast Jennifer Love Hewitt as Paige than it would have been more difficult to chose!

[coolcat98802]

@0TheSeeker no Rose  waz a awesome actor so don't diss her

[witch26071]

PRUE!!!

[MissBethaniexoxo]

PRUE,

[ssseroki]

PAIGE !!!

[Doritocheeto319]

Prue was the best always she owned tht show... when Prue died the show died too. Yea they did bring a stupid girl to replace her. Shannen Doherty was Prue and know other actor or charecter could replace her.

[RadaBellaCullen]

what is this song?????????????

[witch26071]

PRUE!!!!!!

[arnaudblog]

Prue

[eMars96]

Prue!!! *-*'

[officiallytyshay]

Paige!!! But Piper is the best hands down

[philsearle123]

Paige is so much better. Her powers are way cooler

[takfreak11]

@philsearle123 Prue owns anyday!

[Charm4815]

Paige, course!

[seastarhorses]

prue has to win

i love prue

[CarolAnnePoltergeist]

It depends on season.When I see Prue I love Prue,but when I see Paige I love Paige

But Piper is the best (and the sexiest)

[Hollersnatch10]

LOVE the fact Paige can orbe objects, herself and her sisters! Prue never ran from a fight! Hello..But in all fairness, Piper rocks... why run, orbe away, fling away, when you can simply freeze, say a power of three rhyme in time of just blow the evil away.... RIGHT.....

[meandque]

@Hollersnatch10 what if they went up against an uper level demon, piper wouldn't be able to freeze him/ her in time to say a magic rhyme

[TheRobpattzlover]

Prue. The show lost a lot of heart when she died.

[hello1234567891094]

prue

[bookiecookie444]

Piper /Holly's sadness in the episodes immediately following Prue's death were so real & touching. Her crying, sadness, and mourning was like her best friend (Shannen) was leaving the show which enhanced her acting. But when Pheobe cried it was so incredibly forced! Milano was partly the reason for Shannen leaving and imo it showed in her acting. I wanted to smack the smugness off her face. I never felt the same about Pheobe after Prue died.. And I hated her stupid hairstyles too LOL!

[superhero921]

I don't like Rose McGowan! She is so stupid...Paige is funny and good, but Prue is better...Shannen is great too! I watched some interwievs with Shannen....she is cool! Rose is so frustrated!!! Phoebe is my favorite one, Alyssa Milano is awesome, Piper is great like Holly!!!

[babbalouie23]

I say their both better then Phoebe and Piper is better then ANYONNE!!!!!!!!! Heres MY LISTT! Piper Prue Paige......Phoebe!! Sorry i just dont like her!!!!!!

[Nacha255]

@babbalouie23 I gotta agree with you there. Piper is the best by far. And Phoebs is by far my least favorite sister. She was cute at times but at other times incredibly annoying.

[babbalouie23]

@Nacha255 Hahah! Totally! yea! She can be cute sometimes! Like sometimes she can be funny! but at times she can be REALLY annoying!

[Griffanswing626]

Paige!



[witch26071]

Prue destroys paige. She was such a powerful witch!

[anberry]

I love Prue so much more.. The show wasn't just the same. I like the acting chops of Holy Marie Combs when Prue's character died though... Hell Hath No Fury was heartbreaking... o.O But still. I wish she hadn't died... Y.Y Her powers were the most powerful! Just check out Primrose Empath and u'll see... If she had had time to develop, they'd be unstoppable!^_^

Oh and btw, if ppl researched properly, Rose McGowan got into the show because Shannen Doherty RECOMMENDED her.

[AmeliaTalon]

I like Paige. Being able to transport and later able to heal really progressed and added to the show. Sure real telekinesis is badass compared to orbing objects, but you can't be too picky.

[digitalcyber2x]

I like Paige is so sweet!!! :D

[Bakosmos]

I have to say Prue. Prue is more offensive when it comes to the powers of paige and prue. I doubt paige can orb prues telekensis. Paige can orb but Prue can just use her power and stop her orbing and fling her into a wall while she is orbing.

[4EverABeyFan]

paige beacause she can orb.

[HorsezRock1000]

PRUE WINS FOR SURE!!!

[PyroDhenz]

i thi9nk they're both powerful.. it's better if it is the power of four.. Prue, Piper, Phoebe and Paige

[mileymontana95]

prue of course. She is a great actress and she kick ass. Sorry but Paige is in MY opinon, quite annoying. (just had to write that)

[waterspirit96]

i think paige would beat prue all she has to do is orb her into a volcano before she can use her powers

[alicesprrockstar]

me agrada mas paige

[rednaxela66]

I think Prue was better ! ! !

Besides her powers were better ! ! !

[PierreKEV]

Prue is much better

[DIVAORIGINALE4]

Prue is WAYYYYYYYYYY better!

[alabar7771]

prue and paige sister good ilove two power

[OTheSweetLifeO]

paige

[taraywill]

prue lovee !! 4ever !!

[cinpritchard]

can you tell me the name of the song?

thnxxx!

[GoodCharmedDevils]

i think its crash or danger zone by gwen steffani :) hope this helps mate :)

[cinpritchard]

thanks dudee! :D

have a nice day!

[GoodCharmedDevils]

anytime :) you have a nice day too :)

[bloekdasschaf]

i like them both. if you had asked me 2 years ago my answer would've been prue because i thought paige was flippant and her acting sucked, but now i couldnt choose. paige is different and none of them is better than the other. paige shows how deep she is in various episodes over time and i felt like from season 4 on, everyone got their fair share of attention, while watching seasons 1-3 i sometimes felt like the show was kinda prue focused. plus shannons a bitch in real life, rose is a sweetie.

[lisy93]

What the épisode at 0;07

[lisy93]

0:07 *

[kawaiioza]

prue n.n

[Choroll]

Prue

[neji0byakugan360]

maybe shannen's a bitch but i liked prue more

[superhero921]

@neji0byakugan360 Shannen is not a bitch!!! How do you know she is a bitch? Have you met her so you know that?

[Keytinka48]

I like both of them but better is Prue

[Kpz355]

Prue is rude in real life. Paige's fun and outgoing. Go check the video why did prue leave charmed. Thats what makes prue the worst, she left the show. She couldn't handle it, otherwise she would have stayed. So yea, Paige ROCKS.

[meandque]

@Kpz355 actually behind the camera allyssa and shannen didnt get along...long story short, allyssa threatened to quitresulting in the writters killing of shannen in 'all hell breaks loose"....

[takfreak11]

@meandque No Shannen Left, she directed All Hell Breaks Loose, and they wrote a cliffhanger just in case Shannen wanted to return..she obviously didn't :( I blame it on Brad Kern.

[heysiegfried]

prue prue prue.

[alysssaaoxo]

PRUE!!!! the show was waaaay better when she was on it. i love her and piper<3

and i love this song and gwen stefani btw<33

[tony13498012]

paige is the best

[lizzyvance]

They both are so different but awesome in their own way. I would have to like to see Prue and Paige together on the show to. I like them all. I wish they would have had Prue back instead of Billie. Billie made the show very boring. I stopped liking it when she came on. Anyway they both have great powers. I like both of their characters. I see Prue and Paige as sisters who never had a chance to meet.

[lizzyvance]

They both rock. Are very different. Which is why I cant pick.

[shakiira24]

prue

[Springirl1988]

they are too different!!!

[vmprVenom]

between the two....... Paige.

[lfgeoghegan]

no one is better, theyre both great characters. Prue was great and powerful but paige brought more humor to it which made it better. phoebe and piper grew more funnier too. there wasnt much humor with prue tbh..who cares if we lost a powerful character. Pipers the more powerful. her power kicks ass!

[locosalvi4life]

paige stop hatin

[dudeitsjorrelios]

like i think paiges is cuz she gets two fer one..

and while prue maybe able to go and throw people away

paige can go

"that guys nuts!"

and orb the nuts to lake titicaca or something ahhaah

[usetheluck]

i prefer both of them They did a great job,the pity that Paige didn't now her older sister prue.

[amyleegtk5]

buen video

[LovisaLupin]

Prue own the show then we have chris and then paige

[charmedn1]

paige is more fun, but prue fit the show better, she really seemed like one of the original three. then again, she was a bit self-obsessed

[JewelsShield23]

Prues the best. ive got nothin against paige but prue was the best and always will be.

GO PRUE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

[jorgealmeidax]

my favorit is page but prue is realy cool...

[bibigaytan123]

No Paige is the best stop being such haters

[Dahelmaeth]

Prue is way better than Paige

[bibigaytan123]

No paige is stop such hater and get over it paige won the show. Prue left because of ther attitude.

[johncena6672]

I think Paige

[doyouknowx23x]

Prue was the best but paige is better

[Kenwantanabe]

Prue was the best

[Charminggirl13]

Paige's better<33333

[maybemaybenot160]

i agree!

[2959958393]

Prueeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

[mysteriuosangel]

Prue and Paige are both awesome and powerful witches and would be inappropriate to say that one is better than the other.They are sisters not rivals and have cool powers and I do not think that Paige replaced Prue in any way.If Prue was ever insulted in any way was when her powers were given to that toad Billie,who additionally was considered the ultimate power.Instead of bringing Prue back for the final,the producers brought that stuid girl to replace her.

[twilightlover03]

Paige is better

[doyouknowx23x]

i say both are great in their own way but i like paige

[ueripities]

what song is this. I've gotta know

[laquenoseavecina]

Prue!! Me encanta Prue! Por para siempre!! Aunque Paige lo hace tambien genial ^^

[ilovelovestory01]

i love prue. i never really warmed up to paige. to me she was just another version of the "early days" phoebe take two. it was like all the sisters were acting like the other sister. prue was deas. piper was acting like prue and paige was acting like phoebe

[smck2009]

My sentiments exactly

[Muhkuhx3]

i think paige was better <3

i love her :D

[vaggos013]

i think it would be a great idea if they make a movie or a special episode with all the sisters (Prue, Piper, Phoebe, Paige).

[XxXgOtHgIrLxXx]

Who sings this song and whats the song called?

please write back soon

im my opinion i loved prue and thought she was an amazing character she was the leader and very strong willed and i think that was good .

many people say that they dont likke prue because of shannen doherty she was just the actress playing her .

but i prefer paige shes quirky funny and i think she suits the third sister betterx.

x x

[tiffcharmed1277]

i like prue more than paige but paige is good 2 but the thing that piss me off when ppl call phoebe a weak link cuz she is not a weak link there is soooo many times when she had 2 save her sisters ass n it not her felt that the stupid write couldn't find her a better power from all the powers in the world they gave her the stupid power but my fav sister is phoebe, prue, piper, and paige.

[kokenP3]

Both are good in their own way. Both are very powerful witches (not like the useless Phoebe who had the worst powers besides she lost them) and have very different but cool personalities. Maybe Prue was mature but arrogant and Paige was very pleasant but irresponsible at first. Prue's powers were very strong but Paige's one are still more due to her whitelighter influence. Paige is my fav followed by Prue and please, stop comparing them coz they are just sisters who didn't know each other

[13javichu13]

PRUDENCE!

[damagecontrol808]

continued from last one...

happy because everything fell into place. and rose didnt have to work for it well she did but not as hard. but anyways she didnt have it easy u noe she still had to get hollys apporaval. so i dont c a problem.

[damagecontrol808]

for me its hard 2 chose cause they wer all so gr8 im mad but happy pure is off. mad cause they should have done 1 with her meetin page

[lilg3mini]

I Think that Paige Is Better Because Off-Set Prue Was a Bitch And Paige Was Jus A Replacement...Paige Is spunky and prue is a uptight BITCH

O I Choose Paige!! Rose McGowan ROCKS!!

[anberry]

@lilg3mini Lol urm... did u know Shannen Doherty recommended Rose McGowan to Holly Marie Combs to replace her?

[LoveDancingMusic]

I like both Prue and Paige... I admit I didn't like Paige at first because I loved Prue and because I loved Cole but Paige ruined Phoebe/Cole relationships... But in season 7 and 8 I LOVE her... She was perfect with Kyle and Henry...:)

[smck2009]

Prue is better in every possible way, to me Charmed begins with Season 1 episode 1 and ends with Season 3 episode 22

[msflauntit]

i think paige is more fun since she was new and all

but prue is the big sister, so she's always the one to look up to

gah! they're both wonderful

it's a shame charmed never had an epie where thay met. i would love to see how they would get along.

[dancekingshon66]

I think Paige was the weakest in the beginning, but Phoebe became the weakest link when she lost her powers.

[simflip]

It would have been better if it was Phoebe who was killed, then Prue, Piper and Paige would have been a more formidable power of three!

[damagecontrol808]

how can u say that? u wouldnt noe?

[simflip]

How can you say it wouldn't? You woudn't know that either!Hint..look at Phoebe's powers. Can she premonition the demons to death? I don't think so.

[crazykit7]

I agree. Phoebe isn't as powerful that's why she had to take martial arts classes. If it had to be one I would have gotten rid of her. Still it would have been nice to have all four of them.

[LovisaLupin]

simflip

You have so right! They could have been awesome together! But no, everybody love phoebe, sorry i dont, the first season yeah she was fine but, noo...

[TCVideoz]

ooooh my god me too paige and prue are sooooo much betta than smelly phoebe shes a bitch to everyone then walks around likes shes tought shit i hate her i miss prue sooooooooooooooo much

[nancydrewgirl911]

how could Paige have been the weakest even in the beginning no offense but Phoebe's powers couldnt harm a fly i think the only thing that kept her alive were her awesome martial arts skills

[nicegirl1000]

prue, piper and paige!! would be a very powerful power of 3!!! but i think prue was the best!

[PrueDoherty]

I'm supporting that one.

[shai4ever79]

i think phoebe was the weakest link on the show prue, piper, & paige would have made a great power of three. if i had to choose between prue & paige though i'd choose prue her powers were great for just being a witch paige was already a whitelighter so she didn't really earn any like prue did.

[Noogie93]

Nice video :D

I don't know who I would vote for, because I think Paige is the coolest caracter, but I think that Shannon Dorethy is a much better actress..

[diegop4bs]

i vote for two the best charmed ones prue and paige!!!

[sex76]

I vote for prue hands down. she was my idol. i loved prue :'( i miss prue.

[paigematthews92]

I like Paige better yet I don't know why.

[paigematthews92]

I like Paige better yet I don't know why.

[gorzkazemsta]

fantastic video :) i think prue and paige are special for they own way so you can't ask who's better i love Shannen And Rose :))) (sorry for my mistake i'm not from england)

[cubhicbu]

What would happen if Prue astral projected and that astral projection was hit with a fireball...

[LovisaLupin]

No that much i think, it is not like that part of Prue is really "real"

[anberry]

@cubhicbu She'd just shoot right back to her body... ^_^

[cubhicbu]

@anberry Wow. You replied to a comment I forgot I made 2 years ago. Lol.

[anberry]

@cubhicbu Lol nice. I didn't exactly look at the date. But I have now.. XD

[LittleCharmedy]

Great video! Good job!

[Petraaaaaaa]

Thank you very much! :-)