Britains got talent 2009 5th semi finals Episode 12 Part 4

[birthdayjin]

her crying was totally not fake, and she deserved that second chance!

[maomiandmyna]

WOW! I LOVE THIS LITTLE BOY

[nanazinhaamaral]

I don't think she was fake at all, I really think this is why people should be VERY careful when putting children in such big shows... She shouldn't be allowed a 2nd chance because she shouldn't be there at all... Not all 10 years old can sing on national TV and not get nervous... I really feel sorry for her, she shouldn't be put through this...

[thejakester79]

i have seen a four year old girl on americas got talent that sings more difficult songs, and remembers all the words.... nobody should have a second chance if they screw it up... i'm sorry she had problems, shes a great singer, but other acts that messed up, went home.. that simple.. you know the risks getting into it..

[killaz4life24]

she shouldnt get anotha chance no matter wat her age its a talent show n every1 get 1 chance n 1 chance only

[BetaArtemis]

Agreed!

[shishkababy24]

i totally agree!! plus her crying was fake, se's cute but she just did that make people feel sorry for her and get a lot of votes

[xoItsElizabethxo]

poor hollie!!!

[alharbimohammed]

aidan all the way :)

[15lovefan]

i really dont think they should give hollie another chance..... what if that had been an adult who cried due to stress? they shouldnt give her another chance just because shes a kid

[hanaru4111]

I agree with you! Even though I feel sorry for her, but she should not have preferential treatment just because she's young (and BGT has had even younger contestants!)

[Peace0MamaCas]

You know, I was about to disagree with you...until Aidan came on! Only a year older, he was awesome and brilliant! That kid can dance. So now I agree!

[AmieDanni]

I disagree!

[15lovefan]

Really? Why do you disagree? I'm not trying to be mean, I do want to know why you disagree :D

[AmieDanni]

Because she is only 10 and if they didn't give her another chance it would have made her live to regret that performance and destroyed any confidence that she did have

[15lovefan]

Okay, but what about Jamie Pugh?

[AmieDanni]

He's not 10... she is still young more of a future ahead of her..

[15lovefan]

But he has issues with his confidence as well! Which brings me back to my point that just because she's young she shouldn't be granted extra privileges. And just so you know, this is a friendly debate! I don't hate you because we have differing opinions! :D

[BetaArtemis]

Winning this competition is a combination of talent and showmanship, Hollie may have talent, but showmanship and self-control is what she lacks. She should not be given an extra chance just because she got nerves and cried, it only showed that she cannot take being a performer.

Kids YOUNGER than her have done better and controlled themselves better than her, look at Connie Talbot and the Cheeky Monkeys.

[inesgarciagao]

Not much mention of Martin´s wife, was there?? You´d think his mother-in-law was it...

[horror623]

she didnt have tears??? i dont get it. she is very talented, but it just shouldnt be her night, im sorry. she is great tho