Added: 4 years ago
From: agentorange20
Views: 119,735
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,006)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The 16-year old Muslim girl says she wants to wear the head scarf. But she doesn't say why. That would have been an interesting answer.

  • Comment removed

  • I hate that the person that directs the discussion always changes the subject when is "hot" and interesting, just to avoid conflict. I heard all 6 parts and only Dawkins is trying to make some points. The Islamic guy avoids questions, and the others are playing with words to kill the TV time. You are born Muslim, because of your parents (like all religions) and if you want to leave the religion you must die.. I can't believe that this faith survived until now..

  • *Muslim guy was asked a simple question*

    since he cant back up his answer he just : omg like leave me alone you guys are so ignorant and prejudiced against us ..shut up We are still better than all of you

  • Christians are white, Jews are... well jews... you know, that special look, muslims are middleeastern, hindus are well... redish looking? Im starting to see a pattern... maybe religion is not about truth, but of cultural pressure...

  • @RawSwedishMeatball are you sure most christians are white? South-america has a very high population of christians, as well as south-europe and other non- white countries.

  • @waksibra The point was that certain religions inhabit certain geographical areas, which most people label as "white" "black" or "whatever". I know a christian certainly doesnt need to be white, nor does a muslim to be middleeastern.

  • that woman sounds like she is on the edge of tears every time she talks, cowering before the Dawkins

  • 2:56 "They teat" hahaha, Freudian slip 

  • But, Mr Dawkins, is our sense of morality given to us by God, or is it just an evolutionary artifact? And if the latter, what does it matter in the end? Your version of morality is just your own opinion.

  • @franknhonest simple morality as a evolutionary artitifact will keep evolving and advance itself into a more moral form than previous (just like ape - modern human). and society will be a peaceful place. a better place

  • When islamic women defend their oppression, you know you're dealing with more vicious abuse.

  • the muslim guy isnt saying the whole truth..on 2:41 . check how his arms move when he is on the stand (on other video), and then check how he answer to the question in this video... plus he looked down many times.

  • Abortion is not only a sin, its common sense that it is the murder of a human.

  • 1.12 The cleaning woman has sneaked in!

  • Low v neck shirts are also often imposed on women 5:15. And this is coming from a devote Christian, that women is an idioto. So mindless and in her own world. 

  • Dawkins is soul dead. If he had faith he would find Gods truth. Christ.

  • @SunnyLovetts Which God? Yahweh? Allah? Apollo? Jupiter? Zeus? Horus?

  • Muslim girl is PISSED.

  • @ 0:51Oona Stannard: "... life is prescious..." Why does she, or anyone, think they need a god to tell them that?

  • 0:17 CATHOLIC GIRL IS NOT AMUSED.

  • You can tell that girl is brainwashed

  • To people who say "If god doesn't exist then who made the universe and god was already here.":

    That is unfortunately a very ridiculous assumption. If he who is so powerful to create such a diverse plane as this universe then shall he not be diverse himself? You cannot prove god did create this universe, nor can you prove god actually exists. If god was here in the first place, why can't you say that for the universe then? If not, then who made god?

  • My God (no pun intended)! That Muslim guy looks PISSED! You just could just see the fucking venom boiling beneath his face: "Bitch! You're lucky we're in a fucking studio! Fucking LUCKY! Otherwise, I'd cut your head off and put it on the internet! PRAISE ALLAH!!" Man. If looks could kill . . .

  • @billbenblue How the hell is that a pun?

  • @llumys The subject here is GOD and the fear thereof; Dawkins is obviously rallying against GOD and the people committing heinous acts in the name of GOD. Dawkins is asserting you don't need GOD. If I were in that studio and exclaimed "My God!" at what Dawkins was saying, it would no doubt elicit a chuckle or two, especially since he is saying GOD is irrelevant. Thus, it is a pun on the seriousness of the subject (GOD).

  • @billbenblue That's not a pun.

  • @llumys Yes it is.

  • @billbenblue

    SAY ISLAM IS RELIGION OF PEACE OR I KILL YOU!!!

    ;D

  • @AceyBlade Exactly! Ha ha ha!

  • hahaha, yeah at once a heard they are debating about moral, i know the muslims will be deeply fucked up... they have fucked up morals. seriously.

  • The moderator in this debate did well keeping everyone on track. I am not sure how he did it. But He did a good job.

  • Its interesting that the debate was rather civil right until the issue of god and morals came up. Often, this is the point when people resort to, either evading the question, or using rather murky justifications that they wouldn't consider for any other issue in their lives. And yes, having a deity as the foundation of objective morals is deleterious to the advancement of humanity. Morality should be open to inquiry and public discourse because change in culture is ever-present, while god is not

  • Poor Richard, he's working with idiots here.

  • Ex-muslim rulez

  • Love the zooming in on the muslim guys facial expressions when the woman is talking.

  • That catolic high school girl creeped me out.

    She was all sitting there focusing and looking ugly and mad and it was as if she was trying to blow Richard.Dawkins head with the power of her mind

  • @wow1371 Lol me too, she was looking daggers at dawkins.

  • all life is precious? all life is god given? if destroying this life is a mortal sin, what about the life forms from which she derives her food? plants, cows, pigs, etc...that is life.

  • @Rorix9

    Every time I step on an ant I always know that no life is god given and it can be taken away at any time :)

  • @Rorix9 religion only makes room for 'justified' hypocrisies and blind contradictions. no accountability or even understanding of their own doctrines.

  • @allthingsancient greatly said

  • @Rorix9 there is reason called survivial necessity. she doesnt kill plants cows pigs for her blood thirst, vengence, righteous act, superiority complex, or show her might. just survivial necessity.

  • @Rorix9 More than likely cows and pigs, look at the size of her.

  • @xMatthewxOceanx lots of it...whatever it is

  • lmao..."i'm out of my home"...so that means you are not oppressed?

  • The pretty muslim next to the atheist in the back- (lol) She is so overcome and bewildered by this much open-mindedness at once. Look at her, poor girl...

  • I fucking hate his answer- such a sideways doge. Mullah's always play that card. WE LEARNED YOUR SHIT DUDE- Can't just lie about what is written in black and white.

    People that make it out of Iran are always awesome. Once the Islamic revolution was over, and they took control- the Gov gave great subsidies to families that had more than 4 children. They created a "Baby Boomerang" that created a pop of 82%+ ages 18-25 today. And they hate the religion. We have to help em destroy fascism~!

  • Faith Schools can be damaging because of the teachers. Here's a quote from an open catholic school in my city in Ontario, Canada. This was in response to a student in my grade 8 class asking the teacher what a person should do if they are gay. "IF YOU ARE GAY YOU HAVE TO MARRY A WOMAN AND HAVE CHILDREN LIKE EVERYONE ELSE OR YOU WILL GO TO HELL". Spit flying everywhere, raging eyes. We all shut up really fast... and I sat there silent (my mistake) hoping that everyone else knew he was wrong.

  • if religious parts are immoral then MORALIZE them but dont kill your identity COMPLETELY. If Islam has prejudice then go against that, dont completely Renounce it. Humans try to re create themselves in children, a better version of themselves, then HELP them dont throw the better out the door just because one of you heard a BAD news about ONE man killing his daughter. I can bring such ONE news anywhere in any religion even atheist ones.

  • They should deport all muslims back to their countries, in exchange for the ones that are dying for freedom in Islamic countries...lol, get it...dying...literally!

  • if it wasn't UK you would've been killed just by saying that in some of the Muslim extremists countries

  • That Muslim girl is generalizing all in her position. Just because 'she' wants to wear the hijab and doesn't see it as oppression doesn't mean that that's true for others. She's saying "because I don't mind it its being forced on others makes it OK."

  • Is she not comfortable enough in her own skin to see others as equal in her 'own' eyes rather than those of a deity?

  • That 16 year old Muslim girl says that she wears the Hijab by choice and that her religion does not stop her from 'being' and 'expressing' herself.That's because she lives in the UK,a secular country. If she was living in an Islamic country like Saudi Arabia,she would not have any choice.She would be probably married to an old Arab(as his 4th wife)

  • @jefin94 exactly. lets send her to a sharia country and see how she feels...

  • @nsekh085 Her current choice would be her only option

  • I love how he starts blinking and stuttering as soon as he has to pretend Islam treats women as equals.

  • @ChortortleC look of GUILT...he wishes he could taqiyaa on that one. lol

  • 1:13 : Meh!

  • she has a huge ass

  • Slightly immature but that has got to be the best cliffhanger of a video about religion EVER!

  • 0:421:19 I heard somewhere that “In the eyes of god everyone is equal” this came from a Christians mouth; she obviously has not read her own bible, what about the book of the law? In the book of the law god specifically says that it is fine to own a slave if you follow his set rules on how to treat them, (which I feel I should point out are absolutely barbaric thus it is questionable whether any loving god would allow such things) That said how can everyone be equal in the eyes of her god?

  • the Islamic guy is such a dick! He should be castrated, then shot !!....

  • Richard Dawkins is not given ANYWHERE NEAR enough time in this POXY "debate" - he's been allowed to say roughly 3 words throughout the whole thing. FUCK ISLAM and FUCK CHRISTIANITY. "There is probably no God - stop worrying and enjoy your life" - Richard Dawkins. Utter LEGEND :D

  • 1:12 whoa, don't scare me like that bro

  • Catholics doesnt allow abortion but fat chicks`?

  • That muslim teacher has all the makings of a terrorist...

  • I feel for the Iranian born lady, who speaks against Islam. The difference between a 16 year old in UK wearing the Hijab on her own and women in Iran, is that she's doing it because she feels like it, but women in Iran are forced to wear it. Just google "hijab police beating women iranian" and you see what I mean!

  • Richard dawkins is spot on

  • 0:17 HURR I'M A DUMB BITCH AND I GET NO DICK

  • @ScrewGlennBeck Its not that religion is evil. People are evil. Humans are all corrupt and selfish. The religion I believe (Christianity) teaches people to love one another. However we all know that Christianity has without a doubt caused evil to occur . ex. the crusades So I know that religion can cause evil but we cannot forget that fact that even though humans are evil we all have the capacity for good also.

  • hes moral all because of religion 9/11 was planed by a muslim religious dickhead

  • One thousand years from now, and the human race will still be debating this

    issue... 

  • @controllerism

    If it's still around...

  • Religion is damaging, and its not a race, im sick and tired of ppl claiming its racist to criticize ridiculous beliefs.

  • I think the situation is clear... the state should not under any circumstances get involved in religious practices except to teach about religious beliefs and non-beliefs as a subject... if you like the bible as literature.

    If people want to setup private schools which are faith based they should be allowed to do so, but they should also be monitored to make sure that all the same education in public schools is afforded to them.

    And the UK IS A SECULAR SOCIETY.

  • It is interesting that the outspoken atheist is also the person who seems to know the ten commandments the best.

  • The Muslim girl says she wears the hijab because she wants to and that it's not forced on her. So if wearing a hijab is so great how come none else does it so ritually outside of Islam? Speaking of free choice, what would happen if she still wanted to be Muslim, but she decided that she didn't want to wear a hijab?

    She'd ultimately have to confirm that there are other Muslims who'd look down on her and try to impose it on her or that she herself can't reconcile with that choice.

  • @bb1televator I'll like to add that whether she likes it or not, she has no choice but to wear the hijab. Honestly, I reckon that the girl is forced to say that she "chose" to wear the hijab just so that it doesn't tarnish Islam

  • @Epsio0 Sorry, meant headscarf, but I'm pretty sure that the same ruling applies to the hijab as well

  • @Epsio0 Gah, I'm thinking burkha >.<

  • That Iman is a fucking douche , europe wake up !

  • After the muslim tells us it is due to ignorance and the discussion moves back to mariane, did you see at 3:05 everyone looked towards her, but him?

  • In my opinion, if it is something you cannot chose, such as race, sex or orientation then it can't be mocked or questioned. But any, such as religion, culture, etc can be mocked and if need (to protect lives or society) can be destroyed.

  • Its amazing. I can imagen puting your averge rabbi in the middil all this will end

  • That atheist chick with glasses is getting the hots for Dawkins @ the start of the video :>

  • The ex muslim woman is awesome!

  • @Fenrirsdoom Yup. And hot.

  • @Fenrirsdoom Funny that she was the first victim of Rudeness from the Islamic School chap, in this incredibly polite forum. Is he trying to be a stereotype???

  • @HENJAM48 haha yeah well religion messes with people's mind turns good people into bad people etc etc

  • @Fenrirsdoom She was lost and now is found. Ironic really...

  • Anyone whose prophet raped a 9 year old girl... raise your quran.

  • I've always wanted an ex-Muslim girlfriend from the Islamic world. "Yo Allah fanboys, Imma stealin ur womenz!"

  • The muslim faith does not seem friendly 

  • Dawkins like a boss!

    

  • When confronted with the ex-muslim woman's story about a 16 yr old girl being killed, in what I assume was most likely performed as what is called an honor killing, the muslim gentleman there COULD have said "wow, that's an awful thing to hear". Was this his response? No. His immediate, and somewhat aggressive response (reaction) was to demand to know if the ex-muslim went to muslim school, and then to ask again if the father went to muslim school. A kneejerk reaction to excuse the act. Asshole!

  • @MrDBarch yup! They have no humanity, she only want to forward Islam down our throats. Asshole!

  • To question and discover with our minds is one of the greatest things that has ever happened to humans. It's sad that people don't look outside at the nightsky and realize that we are a part of a vast universe that entails many answers to questions beyond our ability to comprehend. To know that we are essentially born to die and that our matter will be reused and that we do not simply live in the universe but are APART of the universe...our universe...that to me is satisfaction enough.

  • everyone saying the same thing " I agree with richard dawkins ". if only people in high places would..

  • @branahawk Why would they? One of the best things about relligion is that they keep the drones from revolting about their own situation. "you're poor? Nevermind, because that means you'll get in heaven!!"

  • the religious crowd dont make many appologies do they

  • @seroeth forget apologies, they don't make ANY good arguments :)))

  • The muslim dude asked if the father went to a muslim school... If he did... Did his grandfather went... yes... what about his greatgreatgrandfather? No? See, what did i tell you?...

  • @costa200 LOL! Somebody sometime made a similar argument: "Are your parents jewish? No. How about your grandparents? NO! Greatgrandparents? Well...one of'em was. OK, off to Auschwitz with you." And they say religion is not divisive.....

  • 1:01 She claims that she believes "everyone is equal in the eyes of god". Tell me then why so against the gays and the lesbians?

  • Everyone Spam this page 10 times to get it to 100,000, Thumbs up to pass the word.

  • I personally am against religious schools i also believe that it is a shame that what the Islamic schools tend to teacher is mainly Pakistani culture and not the actual religion, for example don't listen to music where the headscarf from a young age, is not an actual part of the religion but is taught as if it was which is wrong.

  • When the muslim man was about to speak I thought he was going to say: "Silence! I kill you!"

  • @baihbalm ah man that made me laugh hard XD

  • @baihbalm Dawkins would have kicked his ass :-P

  • That muslim guy is literally full of shit.

  • The five most beautiful words "I agree with richard dawkins"

  • 3:35 is so revealing! The Mussah wishes that the woman talking was dead.

  • Wow.....atheists chicks are hot!!

  • Iranian ex-muslim very hot to the eyes of Indonesian ex-muslim......

  • I don't know what's worse. Wearing a headscarf or speaking a Geordie chav accent. lol

  • 8:29 KAAAAAAAAATE!!!!!!!!

  • To not wear the hijab invokes ostracism or verbal abuse (no matter how mild) from the girls family so influences them to wear it from "choice". This is in addition to the religious brainwashing that they have endured from birth, and litlle girls are hard-wired by general human nature to want to emulate their mothers so if the mother wears it, the daughter will see it as compulsary too.

  • oh for fucks sakes Dona, why do you have to eat so much. I can't concentrate at the sight of you 5 chins.

  • this woman completely destroyed all of them. and that burka wearing young whore is saying "i wear it cause i want to"vof course you want to! because you have been taught to wear it idiot! and you WANT to wear it cause you think if you dont you will somehow become a whore! Well, NEWS FLASH BITCH! you are a whore, for that fucking arrogant bastard at 3:02

  • @R2rGangstaFC Yes.

  • Whats with Wednesday Adams in the audience at 0:16 lol .. It looks like she is about to bend over backwards, crawl up the ceiling and start speaking in tongues.

  • Islam is about submiting to a big Asshole, who would send anyone to HELL. If they dont give him the plesure, of laughing at us.

    Allso to hit your wife and force Sharia Law on the World.

  • Is it just me or does the Catholic woman always sound like she's about to cry? Has the bombshell that she's been wrong all these years suddenly hit her like a Muslim husband angry at his wife?

  • @ragerancher lulz

  • Is it me, or does the head of muslim schools face twitched into a weird expression from 3:25-3:23

  • lÒl_I_feËl_sÒ_lÖñÊlY_tOdÂÿ

  • 0:18 the girl...she's pure evil. i mean, just look at her!!!!

  • that muslim chick is so ugly she should cover her whole head... sorry had to say that

  • @MrDVicius No it's not her being ugly... it's the fact that she's a muslim, that make you wanna puke at her... just like me ;D

  • Richard Dawkins makes the bishop and catholicschoolwathshername look retarded.

  • arghh people who eat meat and allow the torture of animals for human gain but then say that they are against abortion.. Animals have a right to life

  • Typical religious types ' the catholic avoids answering the mortal sin/ teenage abortion question . the muslim avoids the apostate question and the c of e bishop is a political hack for a church who's values are based on the morals of henry tudor and of course the real political hack the' mp' is so busy trying not to offend anyone so as to not lose any vote's that the only one with any morals or standards is 'prof' Dawkins .. lolooolll you could not make this up .......

  • @MrStewart149 That's a funny summary... but the supernanny Catholic sheila did answer the question. The chick has committed a mortal sin, she makes no apology for that, and you love the misbegotten sinner regardless. Which renders the sin and therefore the doctrine gratifyingly toothless... the Islamic bastard is much worse with his mangled response to apostasy. You can tell his hairy bearded person would greedily hold the knife to the apostate. The good Bishop is admiringly tepid, the mp too

  • @drifting789 i take it one is a catholic or at least christian judging by your own bias but the point stands she says things like love the sinner etc etc but will not admit that the catholic church condems abortion as a mortal sin at no time will she use those words. so the point stands hypocrites one and all ...

  • Everyone keeps saying how they as parents have the right to teach their children what they want and what religion they want their child to be a part of. Its like saying "we as parents have the right to ruin a child's life". But, when it comes to abortion, no parent has that right.

    Ain't that funny?

  • Religion is inherently evil. In all forms. Any religion pushing an agenda in schools or though politics needs stamped out. My morality as an atheist is far superior and quite frankly I'll not apologize for it. I'll not sit on my hands and have my children subjected to the horse shit. I'll not vote for idiotic republican Christians. You can't bigot that which doesn't exist. God doesn't exist blasphemy is a victimless crime. Fuck off if you don't like it. :)

  • @ScrewGlennBeck Clearly, that kind of argument gets you nowhere. Elitism and arroagance are intelligence' greatest obstacles.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck Buddhism mate.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck I think that there are only a few peaceful religions: Buddhism and Hinduism are two of them. BTW Just like you I`m an atheist myself.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck hold on now, your morals and values have nothing to do with your atheism, and you can't really think that said morals are "superior." that's the kind of attitude that needs to be expunged. you seem to be displaying the same type of self righteous and pious tendencies that our religious enemies exhibit. focus on the fact that their values are worthless and their morality perverse, and not that yours is better. Some murderers call themselves atheists, and their morals are fucked.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck I agree with you, but there is a fundamental flaw to your argument: Religions are institutions, god is a theological and philosophical concept. The evil religion does in the name of whatever god they believe in doesnt change what is fundamental and common to all religions in the concept of god - a first, intelligent cause of existence.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck My point is: if all religions fell apart once for all, the concept of god would ncessarily still stand, for it´s negation is as much as dogmatic as its affirmation.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck

    I agree completely with you. My future children will be Atheists and clear logical, rational thinkers. Free to choose their way in life with no indoctrination whatsoever! And of course Scientifically literate!

  • @ScrewGlennBeck

    My morality as an atheist is far superior and quite frankly I'll not apologize for it.

    You sound religious about your atheism...

  • @ScrewGlennBeck

    Religion is not inherently evil, that statement is bigoted itself. Regardless of what it is today, you should recognize that the original purpose was for the cohesion of society. I agree with @jacobhamselv.

  • @ScrewGlennBeck I'm an atheist/humanist. But no all religion is evil, Buddhism for one Definitely isn't. I agree that Islam and Christianity (in all forms) are both awful, but not all religions are. :)

  • Have you noticed that every muslim always tries to attack a critic by telling them they are not Muslims, or they dont understand the Quran, but look what happened when a Muslim woman gives criticisms Islam. The Imam tried to blast her talking about "oh did you go to a Muslim school" and blah blah blah and she was like yes... fucker remained silent after that....

  • @puertoritalian1

    Sorry but he asked if the girl's father went to an Islamic school, to emphasise his point that there was no connection in that example she gave of the girl being killed by her father and the teachings of Islam....so I think you got it wrong as well as the 18 thumbs up you have! lol

  • @trueguynolies and now you have a thumbs down so you can feel special too. Good day.

  • @Sirver

    It's ok if you got it wrong..everyone makes mistakes...Have a good day too!!

  • @puertoritalian1

    actually the guy said "did **HE** go to a Muslim school" . . . try listening to what's actually said before trying to quote it

  • @puertoritalian1 lol @ fucker remained silent :P...but agree with you lol

  • @puertoritalian1 Muslim are very arrogant they believe we are all infidels and should leave this world and they own this country and they are saving it from the infidels when the ex muslim woman says her opinion he so wants to kill her you can tell in his eyes hes thinks less of her for been a woman and hates her for leavin the bullshit that is islam and religion

  • muslime = primitive animal behaviors!

  • Wow, the ex-muslim woman is so fuckin right!!!!!!

  • The fatty-boomboom girl looks brainwashed.

  • The religious leaders all know very well that if they weren’t able to indoctrinate people as children their religions would soon wither away. It was very noticeable that the Muslim leader was the least educated, the least able to make intelligent observations but presented his opinion as fact, and when challenged relied on words such as ‘you are ignorant’ ‘prejudiced’ and other hypocritical accusations.

  • I get the feeling that most of the members of the Council of Ex-Muslims are women

  • @twombonu religion is only "less restrictive" in the same way as a Lit class, where you can have many interpretations and find supporting quotes. And science is only "more restrictive" in the sense that 2+2 will always equal 4 (as it should be). THAT'S IT!

  • @HeXiBokkos If you understood yourself better, you would realize how off the mark you are!

  • Believe me, science, at least as an educational system, is much more restrcitive and intolerant than any religion. Any system designed and administered by people like Richard Dawkins is nothing more than intellectual police brutality.

  • @twombonu Oh hardly. the point of science is to ask questions. If this were not so, we would still think that the earth was the center of the solar system and that bleeding people is the best way to cure insanity. If you have a question in a science class, you ask them. Any proper scientist or professor of science would answer question and has an open mind to being wrong. Now if I ask my religious roommate why is there a hell if god loves us, he freaks out and tells me not to question his god.