How isnt Kurt Warner on here? he lead the cardinals to the super bowl and came damn near winning it, and Big Ben should be number 1, that super bowl performance was one of the best of all time. How the hell is Eli Manning number 3, Favre 2, and Brady 1 when none of them did shit, i mean brady did good but favre and manning did nothing.
first how is peyton manning number 6, and how is drew brees not on this list, i mean you have matt hasselbeck, derek anderson and david garrard one of the worst lists ive seen in my life, you have to do some research my friend
@melosher Brother, he is at number three probably for what he did in the playoffs. Many great plays, no interceptions, and one of the greatest plays in Superbowl history. Superbowl MVP too. He deserves to be there!
@lilArabz It was actually 18-1 my friend but its all good and you are right Eli helped beat the Patriots in an amazing game where they were the 13 point underdog.
@MrAranda86 Brady did know the defensive signals, and they won those playoff games against the colts because the Ty law was aloud to rape Marvin Harrison. Peyton Manning is better, he picks apart defenses without cheating. And he does not play in a west coast offense. Learn to say shit right before you talk.
@nyrangers1997 No he has everyone wrong why is Derek Anderson on there and Manning is better than Brady........ Brady was throwing to Moss... how come he was not recognized as the on that best receiver. Because before Moss came to New England, Brady never threw more than 28 touchdowns. He is elite but Manning made Marvin Harrison good and Reggie Wayne good. And he even made Garcon and Blaire white good. Tom Brady is a system QB now. All his passes are 5 yards and a 10 yard run after catch.
@Beatthemeat12 brady is way better than manning ...manning didnt make anyone good, the colts just draft good WRs, yea keep sayin tht wayne and harrison and garcon all sucked before they became colts, pats never had great recievers and brady still outplayed manning in tht span, even head to head games
Brady shouldn't be on the list as he is vastly over-rated and has benefitted from the era when Belichick was known to be cheating. At best he's 9th or 10th.
@TSM8088 yeah, he just broke a record for most td passes in a season that year, led his team to an undefeated regular season and led the league in yards, tds and passer rating. But you are totally right, he shouldn't be on this list at all. Fucking retard..
Kinda surprised you have Eli on this, especially # 3(not going to complain xD) But I must say(as much as I love Eli, and he's my favorite player) he doesn't deserve to be on this list for the 07-08 season....He had his worst statistical season lol...BUT who gives a fuck!!! Go Giants!!!
The best quarter back in NFL history, however is......wait for it...wait for it.......MY AUNT MARTHA! She was kick as during the 1913-1914 season. With 143 touchdowns and three tits. She made us proud.
@arwildcat24 tom brady is top 10 greatest players ever in general...manning has nothing on brady but stats and 1 ring? brady has 3 and hes played 2 years less then manning and brady was the 199 pick in the draft manning was number 1 it speaks for itself
hasslebeck hes only good for a western style offense, David garred has never really proven his status as an elite quarterback and i dont care what season it is Ben and Eli are trash they wouldn't have accomplished anything without probowl running backs
dis list iz lame derek anderson and david garrard plz not even supposedd 2 be on da list n tony romo and ben roithlesburger over peyton manning man u dont know football
@diannaransom i love how that was three years ago and probably beat ur dumbass giants who didnt even make it to the playoffs. just get it over with already. he even beat peyton's records. and probably every team cheated before and never got caught. hey u never know, maybe the giants even cheated in the superbowl... SO SHUT THE FUCK UP
@Cade9522 um actually any1 would argue that bc its not true...brady is a winner and manning lost 2 years in a row at home in the playoffs to the same team..brady is the only qb with out a bad season that is a fact..manning plays in a dome and had marvin harrison his whole career and one once imagine if brady had moss his whole career wow he would have 6 rings
@TMonsterthefat1 the pats never cheated its called studying tapes every team does it...just know that spy gate came out wen the pats went 16-0 only reason why they lost that super bowl bc tom brady's ankle was fucked up i agree with u man tom brady is better then peyton also just hadda say tht
@jjalves617 yes i agree,,, and i am a pats fan, but tom bradys ankle was not fucked up. it was just a little damaged. the only rason the dolphins went all the way b/c they only had to win 14 games to win it all. we had to do 19 games. we just got tired to win anymore. thats why we lost
@ultimatehineswardfan Kurt Warner threw for 27 TDs and over 3700 yards in just 10 games. He not only should be on the list, he should be in the top 5.
how does brady suck in 2007 he had 50 td,8 int,4,778 yards, and we all no wat happened with the 18 and 1 he set the record for alot of things in 2007 and he was mvp
@ZeroG28 this was in the 07 and 08 season. Derrick Anderson had one best seasons for qbs and the browns were 10-6 so it makes sense that he is on the list
im a giants fan but you really cant put eli over peyton cuz peyton is a better qb, and there is no way you can put tony romo in front of peyton either cuz he just plain sucks
Whoa! why is peyton number 6?! he is definately ranked #2 if not #1 cuz theres no doubt he is the best qb in a long time. And lei should be somewhere in the top 4
Tom Brady and Peyton Manning should always be number 1 and 2 when it comes to top quarterbacks of the season because one of them one day will be the greatest quaterback of all time
u got to be kidding me man wtf donovan mcnabb should have been up there in front of tony homo we creamed them last year dude do u even watch football to know stats
Now with that said: 1. Joe Montana 2. Tom Brady 3. John Elway 4. Brett Favre 5. Peyton Manning (numbers 4 and 5 are subject to change depending on this year and how the rest of mannings career plays out) 6. Dan Marino 7. Steve Young (ok how is Marino better than Young? I dont know,just how I see it) 8. Johnny Unitas 9. Fran Tarkenton 10. Kurt Warner I'm only 23 yrs old, Never seen the old guys play so I cant discuss that. None of them have GREAT numbers or lots of rings so...
u guys r idiots, u have to take it case by case, Just bcuz Trent Dilfer has more rings than Dan Marino doesnt make him better. But the fact that Brady has more rings than Manning does. Montana is the unquestioned best QB in history by far, but Aikman has 3 doesnt make him better than Elway. Favre has less rings than Phil Simms but Favre is clearly better. If you're unbiased u can make a top 10 QB list despite sum1 may have better stats but less rings or sum 1 with more rings but less stats
@1xxmikexx21 You can't count out a superbowl win, EVER. Especially with that 2minute drill he gave us. He didnt throw a single int in the playoffs btw.
were the fuck derek anderson come from in dis shit and hassel back these guess suck!and peyton manning #6 wtf u thinkin dude but tom brady number 1 though right and philip rivers #8 wat da hell u thinking u is ego trippin
this is my top 10 1 peyton manning 2 eli manning 3 brett farve 4 tony romo 5 tom brady 6 drew brees 7 phillip rivers 8 ben rothlisberger 9 donovan mcnabb 10 chad pennington
this is fucking redicules tom brady had the best singgle season proformences ever and ur saying whos better no he only ther 50 td passes and was mvp dont let hatred for the pats get in the way ill admit we were out played in the super bowl
Hahahaha that was really funny.
chillaman35 1 month ago
brady most beast season 2007
cpza64 3 months ago
How isnt Kurt Warner on here? he lead the cardinals to the super bowl and came damn near winning it, and Big Ben should be number 1, that super bowl performance was one of the best of all time. How the hell is Eli Manning number 3, Favre 2, and Brady 1 when none of them did shit, i mean brady did good but favre and manning did nothing.
DwightWhite78 4 months ago
eli shouldn't be #3 all he had was a good playoff run but during the regular season he sucked like he usually does
portugalrocks9 5 months ago
first how is peyton manning number 6, and how is drew brees not on this list, i mean you have matt hasselbeck, derek anderson and david garrard one of the worst lists ive seen in my life, you have to do some research my friend
vancouvercanucks99 5 months ago
@vancouvercanucks99 well hasselbeck, gerrard, and anderson actually had good stats in 07-08 brees didnt
portugalrocks9 5 months ago
@portugalrocks9 no he only threw for 5,000 yards around 30 tds you can do much better
vancouvercanucks99 4 months ago
top 10 Qbs of one season.. cuz theres only like 40 of em
19Gui86 7 months ago
ur crazy about the 6) penton naa broo buh the only reason i like this video is TOM BRADY IS A BEAST U ANT STOP HIM JUST STOP BEING HATERS
planb9100 8 months ago
you had no idea what your talking about
MichaelPompa 9 months ago
plz commet on mine its in my channel
slyfoxpro 10 months ago
Comment removed
GaryProducoes 10 months ago
how does this fool have eli manning at number 3... that team was carried by the legs of brandon jacobs and that defense
melosher 10 months ago
@melosher Brother, he is at number three probably for what he did in the playoffs. Many great plays, no interceptions, and one of the greatest plays in Superbowl history. Superbowl MVP too. He deserves to be there!
pvt1stclassbmk 9 months ago
Ok worst list ever mine is better
mikethesteelerfan 10 months ago
U suck start watching football if u do not no anything bout football try to make a video
mikethesteelerfan 10 months ago
You can tell this list sucks if David garrard is on it
Gikanks556 11 months ago
@spongebob397 i think thats the year he won the superbowl and beat tom brady 17-0 which became 17-1
lilArabz 11 months ago
@lilArabz It was actually 18-1 my friend but its all good and you are right Eli helped beat the Patriots in an amazing game where they were the 13 point underdog.
pvt1stclassbmk 9 months ago
@pvt1stclassbmk eli almost blew the game for the giants if asante samuels hadnt dropped a pick thrown right to him, learn what ur talking about
kevdoyleman 8 months ago
@pvt1stclassbmk 18-1 is a better record then the giants will ever have
portugalrocks9 5 months ago
Favre isnt with the jets!
slyfoxpro 11 months ago
@slyfoxpro bro this was made 2 years ago at the time he was.
Donkeykong21425 11 months ago
Comment removed
Mikaykay009 1 year ago
@MrAranda86 Brady did know the defensive signals, and they won those playoff games against the colts because the Ty law was aloud to rape Marvin Harrison. Peyton Manning is better, he picks apart defenses without cheating. And he does not play in a west coast offense. Learn to say shit right before you talk.
Beatthemeat12 1 year ago
@Beatthemeat12 you know the pats didn't spygate that year right u shouldn't open your mouth when you don't know shit.
Donkeykong21425 1 year ago
thats bad ass worng brett favre lost to eli so yah
johnathanzavala 1 year ago
Peyton #6? This list is fucked up so bad haha
Richterz94 1 year ago
@nyrangers1997 No he has everyone wrong why is Derek Anderson on there and Manning is better than Brady........ Brady was throwing to Moss... how come he was not recognized as the on that best receiver. Because before Moss came to New England, Brady never threw more than 28 touchdowns. He is elite but Manning made Marvin Harrison good and Reggie Wayne good. And he even made Garcon and Blaire white good. Tom Brady is a system QB now. All his passes are 5 yards and a 10 yard run after catch.
Beatthemeat12 1 year ago
@Beatthemeat12 brady is way better than manning ...manning didnt make anyone good, the colts just draft good WRs, yea keep sayin tht wayne and harrison and garcon all sucked before they became colts, pats never had great recievers and brady still outplayed manning in tht span, even head to head games
MrAranda86 1 year ago
Where is brees? Your an idiot
Frymaster318 1 year ago
Wheres Drew Brees they didn't make the playoffs that season but he had a better season then david garrad 4 sure.
sanjayis1 1 year ago
s.o.b. Brady aint cheat
keimark22 1 year ago
Ur smoking something Brett farce sucks Peyton is better then Eli romo is better then Eli the only one u have rite is Tom brady
nyrangers1997 1 year ago
@nyrangers1997 Maybe you just can't read, this 2007-2008. Remember Favre vs. Eli in the NFC championship? Eli won and went to the superbowl and won,
airventschinatown 1 year ago
matt sucks
ALLDAWAYLIVE8663 1 year ago
tom brady cheated
MrSam603 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ok im a giants fan but why the hell would you put eli over peyton?
BIGxWILLxXx638 1 year ago
Comment removed
BIGxWILLxXx638 1 year ago
NO DONOVAN?
JMadriz69 1 year ago
DUDE! YOUR KIDDING ME! PEYTON MANNING IS NUMBER SIX!!!!!!!!!!!
TheSmexyBeast87 1 year ago
Peyton mannig y tONY rOMO NO deberian estar ahi
lacrimosathebestdoc 1 year ago
Drew brees???
GLORY3456 1 year ago
Brady shouldn't be on the list as he is vastly over-rated and has benefitted from the era when Belichick was known to be cheating. At best he's 9th or 10th.
TSM8088 1 year ago
@TSM8088 i agree
metallicafan1297 1 year ago
@TSM8088 yeah, he just broke a record for most td passes in a season that year, led his team to an undefeated regular season and led the league in yards, tds and passer rating. But you are totally right, he shouldn't be on this list at all. Fucking retard..
mitchellmacc94 1 year ago
how can u say eli's better than peyton manning, i agree with u on brady,but eli over peyton,c'mon!
kevdoyleman 1 year ago
@kevdoyleman lmaoo u dont remember that play he had in the superbowl?
how about being the superbowl mvp
how about winning a superbowl?
this is 07 when they won
BXFYNEZT95 1 year ago
@BXFYNEZT95 yea he also almost blew the Superbowl if asante samuels didnt drop an interception tht was rite to him
kevdoyleman 1 year ago
Kinda surprised you have Eli on this, especially # 3(not going to complain xD) But I must say(as much as I love Eli, and he's my favorite player) he doesn't deserve to be on this list for the 07-08 season....He had his worst statistical season lol...BUT who gives a fuck!!! Go Giants!!!
LAKNYGLAA213 1 year ago
This fucking song sucks dick....and so do your picks...
Gaffhart77 1 year ago
tony romo #1
dommy9861 1 year ago
Wow 10.Kurt warner 9.Brett Farve 8. Tom Brady 7.Big Ben 6.Eli manning 5.Phillip Rivers 4.Tony romo 3.Derek Anderson 2.David garrad 1. Peyton manning
AznDynamite1 1 year ago
REALLY? Peyton manning at 6? I stopped watching the list after I seen that.
YoungMatt94 1 year ago
patriots are the best team so far i the 2010 season and they will finish 15-1 how much do guys want to beat
RNE586 1 year ago
Peyton is better than Eli Manning
MegaSteelersfan9 1 year ago
@MegaSteelersfan9 nnot in 07 retard eli was superbowl mvp
BXFYNEZT95 1 year ago
matt hassleback sucks
B1ackAce15 1 year ago
manning?
cambeever 1 year ago
Go Philip Rivers
chargerboy0423 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
bradys is much better than manning
TheJdog982 1 year ago
bradys is much better than manning'
TheJdog982 1 year ago
Matt Hasselback....ha ha ha .he is like No. 32..
evilzpowers 1 year ago
Brady is smoking white hot!!!
shellygreen 1 year ago
Brady's the 2nd greatest of all time, just behind Montana.
WR12MSH 1 year ago
@WR12MSH no brett farve is best
dougashby3 1 year ago
@dougashby3 Favre MAY make the top 10 all time...maybe. He's become more of a pain than anything else. He's ruining his own legacy by still playing.
WR12MSH 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Brady's the greatest of all time!
WR12MSH 1 year ago
you guys are all stupid....this list is from 2007-2008!
all of the other QB yall naming sucked during the 07-08 season!
this list is perfect!
chalmer2wade 1 year ago
Worst ratings! wheres MCNABB!!!!?????? ELI BEFORE PEYTON????? CMON MAN! DEREK ANDERSON SUCKS!!!/ hes mediocre
arbitorseal 1 year ago
tom brady and manning are the 2 greatest let alone best in the leage haha manning and brady will both go down as the greatest qb's to ever play
jjalves617 1 year ago
Pretty accurate list, though I can't stand Derek Anderson on there!
Vs2nice 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
check out my lists
smvgamer2395 1 year ago
The best quarter back in NFL history, however is......wait for it...wait for it.......MY AUNT MARTHA! She was kick as during the 1913-1914 season. With 143 touchdowns and three tits. She made us proud.
MrRonLafleur 1 year ago
Tom Brady is the best and garrard sucks he should even b in the nfls top 100 QBs
arwildcat24 1 year ago
@arwildcat24 tom brady is top 10 greatest players ever in general...manning has nothing on brady but stats and 1 ring? brady has 3 and hes played 2 years less then manning and brady was the 199 pick in the draft manning was number 1 it speaks for itself
jjalves617 1 year ago
MY MAIN MAN tom
MrJfresh98 1 year ago
hasslebeck hes only good for a western style offense, David garred has never really proven his status as an elite quarterback and i dont care what season it is Ben and Eli are trash they wouldn't have accomplished anything without probowl running backs
unn4md 1 year ago
Peyton Manning is the best qb in the nfl at the moment lmao
ThePkmadness 1 year ago
dis list iz lame derek anderson and david garrard plz not even supposedd 2 be on da list n tony romo and ben roithlesburger over peyton manning man u dont know football
javon745 1 year ago
This list sucks
multisoldier88 1 year ago
NO DREW BREES!!!!!
menumber81 1 year ago
THIS LIST SUCKS!!!!!
jdp81085 1 year ago
tom bradys a faggot nd sucks balls.......but i guess there arent very many qbs that can stand 2 play 4 a coach that cheats......FUKK THE PATS
diannaransom 1 year ago
@diannaransom i love how that was three years ago and probably beat ur dumbass giants who didnt even make it to the playoffs. just get it over with already. he even beat peyton's records. and probably every team cheated before and never got caught. hey u never know, maybe the giants even cheated in the superbowl... SO SHUT THE FUCK UP
TMonsterthefat1 1 year ago
@TMonsterthefat1 Peyton Manning has the edge by a lot on Tom Brady, and no one should argue that
Cade9522 1 year ago
@Cade9522 actually a lot of ppl do...
TMonsterthefat1 1 year ago
@Cade9522 um actually any1 would argue that bc its not true...brady is a winner and manning lost 2 years in a row at home in the playoffs to the same team..brady is the only qb with out a bad season that is a fact..manning plays in a dome and had marvin harrison his whole career and one once imagine if brady had moss his whole career wow he would have 6 rings
jjalves617 1 year ago
@TMonsterthefat1 the pats never cheated its called studying tapes every team does it...just know that spy gate came out wen the pats went 16-0 only reason why they lost that super bowl bc tom brady's ankle was fucked up i agree with u man tom brady is better then peyton also just hadda say tht
jjalves617 1 year ago
@jjalves617 yes i agree,,, and i am a pats fan, but tom bradys ankle was not fucked up. it was just a little damaged. the only rason the dolphins went all the way b/c they only had to win 14 games to win it all. we had to do 19 games. we just got tired to win anymore. thats why we lost
TMonsterthefat1 1 year ago
@TMonsterthefat1 yeah i guess i just dont like to admit it cuz it makes me sad i wanted them to make history
jjalves617 1 year ago
@diannaransom your a retard im a colts fan and the pats did not cheat...they studied tapes like every team
jjalves617 1 year ago
wow, ben over peyton huh? let me know what fantasy league your in.
noble3131 1 year ago
Comment removed
FrIcTiOn623 1 year ago
maybe you guys should go back school and learn how to fucking SPELL!!!!
Mateaki45 1 year ago
you under rated peytom way to much hes first or secont best in the leag
ThePassword105 1 year ago
I live in wisonsin so i hate brett farve for switching
pumakil 1 year ago
@pumakil
Why the fuck do you hate Brett Favre,
You guys traded him to the Jets, he didnt fucking switch on you guys!!
OpressionOffical 1 year ago
@OpressionOffical Brett Favre retired and then came back and signed on as a free agent.
spyman178 1 year ago
Yeaaa my boi Eli manning at numba 3 haha
he doesn't get paid 100mil for no reason baby!
Giants Baby! NYC4l1f3
H0lyPh3n0m 1 year ago
Fuck Eli Manning
05Eagles1 1 year ago
no kurt warner
do you even watch football?
lonewolf537 1 year ago
2007-2008 buddy........warner sucked
ultimatehineswardfan 1 year ago 4
he thew 27 touchdowns without even playing the whole season. thats pretty good in my book
lonewolf537 1 year ago
threw*
lonewolf537 1 year ago
@ultimatehineswardfan you are stupid,
azrulz1993 1 year ago
@ultimatehineswardfan Brady number 1 these were some good picks...you should makes some picks for this year too bro..Im interested in what you think
Gaffhart77 1 year ago
Comment removed
WaltScott4 1 year ago
@ultimatehineswardfan Kurt Warner threw for 27 TDs and over 3700 yards in just 10 games. He not only should be on the list, he should be in the top 5.
WaltScott4 1 year ago
@ultimatehineswardfan 2008 season warner got to the 2009 SB
rickygdep18 1 year ago
how does brady suck in 2007 he had 50 td,8 int,4,778 yards, and we all no wat happened with the 18 and 1 he set the record for alot of things in 2007 and he was mvp
c9crowley 1 year ago
@c9crowley Peyton Manning robbed Drew Brees of the 2009-2010 NFL MVP. Your point is?
Chipfan1111111111111 1 year ago
this by far is the worst list i have ever seen u must not know much about football
flyguy8171 1 year ago
DERRICK ANDERSON!!!!!!!! u cant b serious
ZeroG28 1 year ago
@ZeroG28 I know.he blows, and thats comin from a damn browns fan
skerbilly 1 year ago
@ZeroG28 this was in the 07 and 08 season. Derrick Anderson had one best seasons for qbs and the browns were 10-6 so it makes sense that he is on the list
freshlikeunh 1 year ago
tony romo ahead of peyton!
do you know how much tony fumbles?
facebut52 1 year ago
philip should be higher!
facebut52 1 year ago
derek anderson? are you kidding?
this is a very bad list
facebut52 1 year ago
brady he fuckin sucks dude favre should of bin number 1... stupid ass
55irock 1 year ago
@55irock brady sucks? favre has the most int then any qb in history and has 1 ring over the 18 seasons hes played theres no comparison
jjalves617 1 year ago
and then the vikings for favre kid whats wrong with you kid watch the games
55irock 1 year ago
Tony Romo ahead of Peyton Manning? Are you on crack????
eaglesphilsphan 1 year ago
im a giants fan but you really cant put eli over peyton cuz peyton is a better qb, and there is no way you can put tony romo in front of peyton either cuz he just plain sucks
davidb1d 1 year ago
ELi*
captainjs7 1 year ago
Whoa! why is peyton number 6?! he is definately ranked #2 if not #1 cuz theres no doubt he is the best qb in a long time. And lei should be somewhere in the top 4
captainjs7 1 year ago
brett farve is on the vikings
Duncan9876543210 1 year ago
he spent 16 years with the packers dipshit
ultimatehineswardfan 1 year ago 12
@ultimatehineswardfan 16? i thought it was 17.... o well.
grylam 1 year ago
@ultimatehineswardfan 17 dip shit
dougashby3 1 year ago
@ultimatehineswardfan lmao what retards!
Yamaha52g 1 year ago
We are the Champions ... Roll Tide Roll ...
JKM070 1 year ago
Tom Brady and Peyton Manning should always be number 1 and 2 when it comes to top quarterbacks of the season because one of them one day will be the greatest quaterback of all time
TheCeltics1734 1 year ago
@TheCeltics1734 agreed. brady will be better but its always gonna be
brady 1a
manning 1b
jjalves617 1 year ago
u suck man peyton manning 6th stupid
amun18dc 1 year ago
well ur retarded cuz Payton got injured tht year n didnt play a full season............. next time get ur facts straight BICTH
shozab703 1 year ago
u got to be kidding me man wtf donovan mcnabb should have been up there in front of tony homo we creamed them last year dude do u even watch football to know stats
MrJbreezy05 1 year ago
wat happened this year douche cowboys beat the eagles three times
anonymoustities 1 year ago
You really have Eli over Peyton?(even tho eli did win sb that year he still had a mediocre year.
Gildwing 2 years ago
umm yes he is the best what team do you like?
kelsi848 2 years ago
ew eli manning ew thats gross hes filth
AmazingProductions69 2 years ago
duuude r u kidding derek anderson blows a fat wadd
AmazingProductions69 2 years ago
This is a joke, right?
Cinderdan 2 years ago
Hasselbeck should have been higher than 10.
UGLYSTIKCOLIN 2 years ago
and what team do u like?nicksterandjdog?
kelsi848 2 years ago
im a huge cowboys fan and don't think romo should be ahead of manning, who should be number 1!
lanalu12 2 years ago
why is derek anderson there
cookievill 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
shall2347 2 years ago
u guys r idiots, u have to take it case by case, Just bcuz Trent Dilfer has more rings than Dan Marino doesnt make him better. But the fact that Brady has more rings than Manning does. Montana is the unquestioned best QB in history by far, but Aikman has 3 doesnt make him better than Elway. Favre has less rings than Phil Simms but Favre is clearly better. If you're unbiased u can make a top 10 QB list despite sum1 may have better stats but less rings or sum 1 with more rings but less stats
shall2347 2 years ago
big ben shouldve been #1
kelsi848 2 years ago
bis ben? you mean that ugly peice of sh-t that is freak
nicksterandjdog 2 years ago
Fuck no!
guysdave1 2 years ago
are you kidding me donavan mcnabb should have been number 5.
haydopotatos 2 years ago
WTF Eli so wat if he won a superbowl that year he sucked that year he had the worst QB Rating and the most interceptions he sucks overall
1xxmikexx21 2 years ago 7
@1xxmikexx21 You can't count out a superbowl win, EVER. Especially with that 2minute drill he gave us. He didnt throw a single int in the playoffs btw.
MrBlazay 1 year ago
@MrBlazay but he had the worst QB RATING EVER. he wouldve never made the SB w/o brandon jacobs and all those RBs
TMonsterthefat1 1 year ago
@1xxmikexx21 He still one a superbowl........
LeeCeeThree 1 year ago
@1xxmikexx21 screw u..he still won the superbowl
DerekRaux11 1 year ago
@1xxmikexx21 sowhat????? he was good enough to lead his team to a SB, not like chokeartist Peyton Manning
11BartSimpson 1 year ago
u know wat ur doing 1=brady!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
cpresuttis 2 years ago
@cpresuttis i now i hate tom brady to every one thinks he is so good but he cheted so fuck tom brady
mrfootballman101 2 years ago
manning best qb ever. so go suk a sak u fukin loser
blakesangelbaby09 2 years ago
@blakesangelbaby09 What the hell is suck, sak, and fukin?
Also, if Peyton Manning sucks then Tracy Porter must kick ass.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Chipfan1111111111111 1 year ago
@blakesangelbaby09 But, then again, Peyton is a choke artist.
Chipfan1111111111111 1 year ago
I hate Tony Romo so much
Nirvanaholicxxx 2 years ago 2
duh
remulade100 2 years ago
were the fuck derek anderson come from in dis shit and hassel back these guess suck!and peyton manning #6 wtf u thinkin dude but tom brady number 1 though right and philip rivers #8 wat da hell u thinking u is ego trippin
madden20637 2 years ago
derek anderson?????????
matomchak 2 years ago
.........hines ward fan my ass =( thats our QB thats #4 you jerriacttrcal fuck
brandonxwalter 2 years ago
tom brady is the best QB ever no on e can touch brady when he is on fire you can not put out the flames he makes
MrSycoman90 2 years ago 2
now i dont like eli manning but i think he should be number #1 because he won the bowl
klmb318 2 years ago
@klmb318 just bcuz he won the bowl doesnt mean hes should b #1 brady won 3
jjkinskie 2 years ago
Derek Anderson??? HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA!!!!
gmatsue84 2 years ago
he was pretty good in 07-08 now he is shit.
Allistar123 2 years ago
yeah you are right, with when braylon edward was there he had a chance to do something
gmatsue84 2 years ago
K3dNfl1 2 years ago
@K3dNfl1 u think in 07-08 brady was 5?? r u like an idiot?
outtacontrol333 2 years ago 2
This sucks your missing Donovan McNabb and plus Payton Manning is better than Eli
DariusS158 2 years ago
Wheres vince young??????
DieHardTitansFan10 2 years ago
Well, my top 5:
1 - Tom Brady (obviously, no one else)
2 - Brett Favre
3 - Phillip Rivers
4 - Ben Roethlisberger
5 - Eli Manning
Samhainwicca 2 years ago 2
my list
1:peyton manning
;
winexburgkid 2 years ago
this is fucking redicules tom brady had the best singgle season proformences ever and ur saying whos better no he only ther 50 td passes and was mvp dont let hatred for the pats get in the way ill admit we were out played in the super bowl
MAxx00123 2 years ago