@naddiels Daughtry as a pure alternative rocker is great. But it's a bit like comparing Neil Diamond and Elvis. Elvis could sing any genre of music well, and while Neil's great, how do you top the King?
well daughtry won i guess...dang.. i meant cook won i guess...thats why american idol is rigged...the whole crying for sympathy thing..give me a break..the guy cant sing...oh well when both of there cd's come out i would be money on it archuleta makes more hits and makes more money....
ncpa2011--what's your problem???... ALL 3 songs of DAVID COOK during the FINALE beat all of Archie's songs for the finale as top downloads in iTunes. So who was the REAL winner that FINALE evening?????? And who made more hits that FINALE evening????
David Cook is sooo real. He is the most talented idol ever and this time america got it sooo right.He can change a song and make it his own.goo go go David Cook I'll be waiting for your first cd. great job!
OMG..original?!?! there are so many rocker voices out there like that its crazy....if he wins its just retarded cause he is clearly not the best singer straight out...he might be able to deliever a better performance...as far as vocals..archuleta has got cook beat bad!
A very original talented singer. If David Cook does not win tonight it's because the show is totally fixed. David A has a nice voice, but he doesn't come close to David Cook's ability to perform, and most importantly entertain. I can watch is videos over and over and still get goose bumps.
Simon was way to hard on David C and totally contradicted himself about wanting originality when he said David C should have sung Billy Jean???
For me, David Cook won this competition weeks ago!
I'm pretty sure David Cook is going places whether he wins this competition or not. This was my favorite performance of the night by far. "Imagine," was beautiful, but we've heard it before so it was kind of boring.
Guys, look. Simon just tell such poor things to Cook to oblige Cook's fans to vote for him. He needs to give him some extra pushes though he knows that Cook deserves to win more. Do you see my point?
if they are really looking for the original why they praised David A & left David C with just ok...are they out of their mind?..though what they say is just opinion it still have an impact..when all the performance of David A be combined in a single recording you'll end up bored but for David C you'll gonna end up smiling for in 1 recording almost all genres are covered.Americans prove the world you're not boring!...
Archie may have won the night for the judges, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! COOK OUTPERFORMED Archie many times during the tournament. I can listen to an Archie song halfway. But I can listen to COOK songs again and again! VOTE VOTE VOTE
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
why the hell did he have to do this?
i love collective soul (the band who actually does this song) and where im from, Blue Springs MO, aka where he is from. Most people have never heard of CS, and after this everyone will think its a bad song, because he did it very badly.
THIS IS MY OPINION! I DO NOT GIVE A TINY RATS ASS WHAT THE REST OF YOU THINK ABOUT WHAT I HAD TO SAY. so save you self some time and dont try to get in an argument with me about this.
hey, edgehead...if you don't care what anybody else has to say, don't post your opinion in a public forum...second, if you think most people have never heard of collective soul, or this song in particular, you're on glue...david cook's version was, for me, better though...the original always seemed like cheap pink floyd...cook's version, especially the first verse, and the lines about new york city, were really touching...
I was so mad last week when he didn't sing this, and now that he has I must say he did way better than i thought he would, and trust me, I thought he was going to do great!
Oh come on! - David Cook is so much more talented than David A. ! David A. is so incredably boring and predictable!!! Who is really going to be listening to him sing "heart felt" ballads over and over again? David Cook is original and ABSOLUTELY ADDICTIVE to listen to and watch perform! For Gods sake please vote for David Cook and spare us the altenative !
thank you!!! the judges made me so mad, because they are obviously just saying what the producers want. Cook puts his emotion into every song, unlike robotic Archuleta.
I loved this, personally. It was very authentic feeling. and for some reason it made me cry a little. I must be tired...it was nice after a long, hard day (or long, hard few years). I liked it better than the original version.
i think he is different from daughtry. david cook is waaay better than daughtry (for me) ;D
naddiels 3 years ago
@naddiels Daughtry as a pure alternative rocker is great. But it's a bit like comparing Neil Diamond and Elvis. Elvis could sing any genre of music well, and while Neil's great, how do you top the King?
surfer53 1 year ago
I like this one better than the original. Yet another great performance by David Cook.
tomrudd25 3 years ago 2
This is a wonderful performance!
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Read this.
There are 20 angels in this world.
10 are sleeping.
9 are playing.
1 is reading this post.
Put this on 4 other video comments within the next 15 minutes.
If you do, someone you love will suprise you somehow.
If you don't, you shall lose your dear beloved. =(
MYYEM 3 years ago
I can't stop listening to this song! David Cook does a fantastic job with it!
lynnprice7 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
well daughtry won i guess...dang.. i meant cook won i guess...thats why american idol is rigged...the whole crying for sympathy thing..give me a break..the guy cant sing...oh well when both of there cd's come out i would be money on it archuleta makes more hits and makes more money....
ncpa2011 3 years ago
did you not see idol gives back? when they sing shout to the lord? the boy can sing.
empboy142 3 years ago 3
ncpa2011--what's your problem???... ALL 3 songs of DAVID COOK during the FINALE beat all of Archie's songs for the finale as top downloads in iTunes. So who was the REAL winner that FINALE evening?????? And who made more hits that FINALE evening????
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago 2
archie?? i really don't think so!
katypucp 3 years ago
Wow
jentn0308 3 years ago 2
That was supposed to be a reply to someone's really negative comment..I love Cookie!
jentn0308 3 years ago
LOVE...just love...
dmo1616 3 years ago
David Cook is sooo real. He is the most talented idol ever and this time america got it sooo right.He can change a song and make it his own.goo go go David Cook I'll be waiting for your first cd. great job!
curmikey 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jenniferedwards5....c'mon now..David Cook is a Chris Daughtry wanna be...haha and you know it
ncpa2011 3 years ago
has david archuleta EVER changed around a somg arrangement? nope.
he is so predictable, no where near as good as cook.
you are crazy.
jenniferedwards5 3 years ago 5
right on, Jenny
nyc3299 3 years ago
OMG..original?!?! there are so many rocker voices out there like that its crazy....if he wins its just retarded cause he is clearly not the best singer straight out...he might be able to deliever a better performance...as far as vocals..archuleta has got cook beat bad!
ncpa2011 3 years ago
archie is too boring btw, he didn't deserve to be top2.. maybe saysha
katypucp 3 years ago
DAVID COOK IS SIMPLY AMAZIN!!!
Shereeda2202 3 years ago
A very original talented singer. If David Cook does not win tonight it's because the show is totally fixed. David A has a nice voice, but he doesn't come close to David Cook's ability to perform, and most importantly entertain. I can watch is videos over and over and still get goose bumps.
Simon was way to hard on David C and totally contradicted himself about wanting originality when he said David C should have sung Billy Jean???
For me, David Cook won this competition weeks ago!
Figgy1966 3 years ago 3
I'm pretty sure David Cook is going places whether he wins this competition or not. This was my favorite performance of the night by far. "Imagine," was beautiful, but we've heard it before so it was kind of boring.
cookerlb 3 years ago 4
How the hell?!
Is that David Cook?!
How The World wouldn't know him?
Your the best no matter what!
redwin123 3 years ago
can't wait till david cook wins and proves simon rong and sells more albems then eny one could.
jerms927 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Guys, look. Simon just tell such poor things to Cook to oblige Cook's fans to vote for him. He needs to give him some extra pushes though he knows that Cook deserves to win more. Do you see my point?
ikill03 3 years ago
I don't know what had gone to Simon's mind..
if they are really looking for the original why they praised David A & left David C with just ok...are they out of their mind?..though what they say is just opinion it still have an impact..when all the performance of David A be combined in a single recording you'll end up bored but for David C you'll gonna end up smiling for in 1 recording almost all genres are covered.Americans prove the world you're not boring!...
vote only the ORIGINAL!!!
blessedniqi 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Archie may have won the night for the judges, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! COOK OUTPERFORMED Archie many times during the tournament. I can listen to an Archie song halfway. But I can listen to COOK songs again and again! VOTE VOTE VOTE
866-436-5701
866-436-5703
866-436-5705
TEXT "VOTE" - AT&T ONLY - to 5701
XsupermanFBI 3 years ago 2
Cook was brilliant on this song.
OwnerofSeb 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why the hell did he have to do this?
i love collective soul (the band who actually does this song) and where im from, Blue Springs MO, aka where he is from. Most people have never heard of CS, and after this everyone will think its a bad song, because he did it very badly.
THIS IS MY OPINION! I DO NOT GIVE A TINY RATS ASS WHAT THE REST OF YOU THINK ABOUT WHAT I HAD TO SAY. so save you self some time and dont try to get in an argument with me about this.
later.
edgehead2377 3 years ago
hey, edgehead...if you don't care what anybody else has to say, don't post your opinion in a public forum...second, if you think most people have never heard of collective soul, or this song in particular, you're on glue...david cook's version was, for me, better though...the original always seemed like cheap pink floyd...cook's version, especially the first verse, and the lines about new york city, were really touching...
tarheel8494 3 years ago
Wow I love the way he sang this song.
Vxy55 3 years ago
I was so mad last week when he didn't sing this, and now that he has I must say he did way better than i thought he would, and trust me, I thought he was going to do great!
Greenwave247 3 years ago
Oh come on! - David Cook is so much more talented than David A. ! David A. is so incredably boring and predictable!!! Who is really going to be listening to him sing "heart felt" ballads over and over again? David Cook is original and ABSOLUTELY ADDICTIVE to listen to and watch perform! For Gods sake please vote for David Cook and spare us the altenative !
Vxy55 3 years ago 2
thank you!!! the judges made me so mad, because they are obviously just saying what the producers want. Cook puts his emotion into every song, unlike robotic Archuleta.
He did an amazing job with this song. Beautiful!
martymilkshake 3 years ago 2
you are absolutely right. Because now, I am into him so badly... Certified DAVID COOK ADDICT!!!
aaadddzzzz 3 years ago 4
I absolutely adore him.
He has such a connection with me.
I love the emotion.
Amazing.
sugarRUSH07 3 years ago
hope he wins
tazland1 3 years ago
I loved when he cried at the end:)
bcpooky 3 years ago 2
I loved this, personally. It was very authentic feeling. and for some reason it made me cry a little. I must be tired...it was nice after a long, hard day (or long, hard few years). I liked it better than the original version.
tarheel8494 3 years ago 2
I cried a little too. I also agree; I like it better than the original.
kairiluvsora 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This was Cook's best song of the day. But it still didn't cut it for me
uchoob00 3 years ago