EVANESCENCE - HEART-SHAPED BOX (ACOUSTIC)

[MegaBadassmofo13]

..so that's what it sounds like when it's sung and not screamed... I must say I like Kurt's better, though...

[budakvoc]

good :)

[January20Covers]

not her best LoL Kurt rocks better

[DLais85]

damn i hate this version.

[austinskate141414]

This was to precise to be a good nirvana cover and in my opinion ruined the song

[StreamFake]

<3

[IgorUptheIrons]

DROP D ! SIDUHASIDUAHSDIUAHSDIHUAS !

[bobbyscountrygirl90]

i gree that amy lee is an amazing singer on HER SONGS!! but not on a classic kick ass nirvana song she just RUINED THIS SONG AND DISGRACED KURT!

[NTDmountain]

drroppp d fuck i was thinking that as soon as he started de tunbing it hahah majority of good songs are in drop d :D

[MrPooned]

@ pawsjangles r u serious? Her version was like a combination of shit and shit compared to kurt's and no she did not own it at all!

[TheEvanecencia]

es el mejor d todos >w<

[bs49184]

those string bends in the chorus are SICK :O

[Deamonwarp]

she has some balls to cover nirvana. its hard to compete with kurt on any level. bravo amy! nice try.

[femslashwritter]

she is the most amazing female singer I have ever heard. I fell in love with her voice the very first time I heard it. I love this version better than any other version. Maybe not this particular video, the audio quality is poor, but the Evanescence version is amazing.

[Hallomendi]

hey, don't forget to register!

[blackice1029]

@Hallomendi LOL :D

[trey187123]

it's not a horrible version but when you listen to this and then nirvana's this just seems terrible

[HerrNookenstien]

shame the audio quality is so compressed, muffles her voice sooooooooo much

[Avzzor]

horrible

she dosent sound honest and emotional like Kurt



[RagingBearVideos]

thumbs up if she butchered it

[pandacat17]

i wish nirvana had played this live once :x

[trey187123]

@pandacat17 they played it live many times

[FreyaH96]

was this on scrubs ? :L

[iliketheredchair]

her voice doesnt really suit it ... but even so still a good song :)

[pawsjangles]

Nirvana's version is good ,but I'm sorry this song just is owned totally by Amy Lee she did it awesome

[SuperTigoo]

bahh nirvana still the best version

[peacelovenukes]

Wow. This is amazing. The guitar part's pretty much the same (usually I prefer it when covers deviate from the originals more), but Amy Lee's voice is just mind-blowing! An absolute pleasure to listen to.

[drodga]

Awesome! My fave band doing one of another great band's best songs- has to be worth some major praise! :D

[emomeerkatflippinrox]

Evanescence covering Nirvana. amazing combination!

But i like the original better. Still though, Amy's an amazing vocalist <3

[monymony94]

Well, Tarja's cover of that song isn't good

[ConnieBunny69]

lmao! eww did he really make a cover? good God,what is the world coming to?!

[iac6969]

good cover,the first was better.dont get me wrong love amy

[ptcruzr]

this song puts me in a good mood

[Serileigh]

??????? Okay, so I've been on youtube long enough to know that this ALWAYS (and I mean always) happens, but it still baffles me how people visit the pages of songs/videos/wtfever that they apparently loathe and rip the artists to shreds. Please, get a life. Try listening to a song you like for a change, and maybe leaving a positive comment. And move out of your mother's basement while you're at it, trolls.

[iniquitous85]

Props.

T - up

[trinibird007]

wingsmulti probably has a very minute penis.

[florf09]

I love both bands, but Amy Lee isn't very good singing this song.

[fingerboardgod345]

i do like the nirvana version better BUT this is a great version...

[TheDeathToday]

@fingerboardgod345 Yes, the Nirvana version is so much better. I hate this song with female voice.

But I can understand that you like this.

[sherwood786]

i like how retards have to argue over the computer..........

[JohnsLazy]

@sherwood786 yup people all of a sudden have a lot of balls when behind the screen.

[SLIPKNOTATTACK]

wat a great song and wat a nice cover great job(:

[hopecheyanne]

I like it...actually a voice...most singers now sound like shit without all of their digitalized stuff...cough miley cyrus.

[WithinNightsCoil]

Ahaha i agree

if ou wanna hear the most amazing live voice ever

SHARON DEN ADEL

x

[metallicarules56]

they did okay but you guys judge them on that one song. they are a really good band. amy has a good voice.

[wingsmulti]

Incorrect, I judge them on not only one song, but how she is, and how vindictive she is even though she "acts" like she's always the victim, further more, she sings through her nose to say the least.

[koRnFREAK82]

she's famous, you lot aint, like it or not if she died tomorrow the world would know, if you lot died, well WHO THE FUCK ARE YOU???

[wingsmulti]

The world would know, many would party, and the few idiots that actually "like" her would jump off a bridge, Not really a big loss.

[ricochetfuzzy]

god i hate amy lee

evansescence just murder this song

[wingsmulti]

well said1

[missbrijimenez94]

Wingsmulti should fuck off. You commented on this way too much. 'Kay? Everyone knows your opinion, and I doubt anyone really gives a fuck anymore.

[wingsmulti]

LOL Fail, you're way too inexperienced to ever dream of phasing me.

[fooktard007]

is tha jack black at the beginning?

[MMunoz711]

what are you guys talking about? This sounds great! You all need to grow up and get in with the century, AMY IS SIMPLY AMAZING, sorry if you can't handle it!

[wingsmulti]

She's a talentless whore, and you're a fool.

Enough said.

GTFO Grown ups are talking.

[TwistedSynthetics]

Wingsmulti, You've posted on this thing like 30 times, Obsessed-much? :D

[MMunoz711]

You're the fool, you have no ears for talent and if you can't see that than I feel sorry for you. Have fun with this video, you seem to like it so much you keep posting on it.

[wingsmulti]

Were you dropped on the head as a child? or perhaps thrown at a wall?

[MMunoz711]

hmm you know i'm not sure but if I was that's saying something since I have more brains than you. anyways i'm done playing this pathetic childish game, she's great you suck have a nice day.

[blakem375]

she's a good singer, just not the right person to sing it

[blakem375]

kurt cobain is better

no offense any lee

[TheTwitchkid]

well no duh =p

you can never beat the original, but this is pretty damn good, amy lee is perfect for nirvana song covers ^_^

[wingsmulti]

Wrong, she fails, and disgraces them, Kurt would turn in his grave if he knew about this garbage.

[avakiss]

wingsmulti - you need to get your head examined, this cover is amazing. she has an incredible voice.

i'm so sick of whiny brats complaining about people covering bands.

unless you could do it better and prove it, stfu!

[wingsmulti]

How old are you? 14? This cover isn't worthy of being called a cover, let alone that joke you said "amazing"

You're overstepping your authority telling people to STFU when in reality unless you can make them you should really learn to shut your mouth yourself.

She fails at everything and her VOICE? Incredible?! Maybe incredibly irritating, incredibly boring, exceedingly untalented and I could go on, but I won't sit here and hold your stupidity against you, afterall, you can't help it :)

[wingsmulti]

ROFL,

You have NO idea how old I actually am. Although, judging by the way you replied, I wouldn't imagine you being out of your teens as of yet.

Here's some advice:

Give up, you have ZERO chance of stopping me from ridiculing/belittling people's stupidity.

In reality, you'd be better off talking to a wall then ever hoping to stop me, or phase me, little one.

[avakiss]

so what you're saying is you're actually some old guy pretending to be be 22 online? creepy, get help!

[wingsmulti]

Fail, you must've been beaten as a child.

[XXuNiQuEfReAkXX1]

Your such a pathetic asshole, wingsmulti. Get a life, you ten year old.

[wingsmulti]

Blah blah blah, that was a waste of reading, try again, fool.

[cutiepiemorlan]

besides kurt, whose voice other than Amy's could pull off this song?

[wingsmulti]

Almost anyone could do it better, she's just a fucking stupid cuntfaced little bitch that needs to quit "singing" and give everyone's ears a rest so they can appreciate REAL music.

[Lueyek]

she did very well lol

[SeekInDarkness2]

yes amy is amazing and got an amazing voice! <3

5*

[NatashaLeeCobainXWP]

The best cover!!

Amy Lee is the best <3

[2691983]

although Nirvana's version may have been better, that doesn't mean she has no talen or isn't good at singing, in fact she's great at singing.

[SwtSacrfc3]

She has an amazing voice but it didnt fit well with this song.

[iwakami6666]

i prefer the evanescence version because of the perfect voice of Amy Lee

[doodlin17]

thats cuz she used to be in opera.

[markbecker333]

Fick dich du hure!!!!

Ich wuerde dir hoechstens mal in die fresse spritzen!!!!

Zu mehr taugst du nicht!!!

Nutte!!!

[spazabarri]

I agree!

she's a good singer though

[anijanka]

nirvana has a better verson true :) but this is also a great though, this is the song that introdesed me to the original song.

[TrueMusicGuy]

*yawn*

[romanticdarkness09]

how dare you this is great

[Triconomicon]

Really now, Evanescence wish they were 1/100 as good as Nirvana was. :)

[Ilovekirby]

He says its the last time anyone could see them for only $5. He must have known how privileged he was to hear them live in his studio XD

[elarddee]

shes an amazing singer :) great acoustic cover

[johnmcnamara]

dis is pretty gud :)

[beneaththesky18]

lol@pointless arguments

[njg94]

like yours?

[beneaththesky18]

lol, that's not a pointless argument.

that was just laughing at the pointless arguments..

[njg94]

jk when i read the comment i thought argument read comment

sorry it was to earl in the morning for me to write comments

[beneaththesky18]

lol! ahah i know what you mean.

no problem home slice.

[saraballerbby]

Amy has a great vocie&Evanescence is awesome...But I perfer Nirvana's version.

[LittleApocalypse]

Heart Shaped Box is my fav n i lik it with Amy singin it, but u can NOT deny that Kurt did it bettr.

[xxLAURSIExx]

It is clear that she has an awesome voice.. I prefer the Nirvana version though.. I think it's cos it's the original.. though she does sing this well :)

[GCluver3]

I personally like this version better. However, my sister likes the Nirvana version better. I think that Kurt had more soul singing it though.

[wingsmulti]

Of course, she just did it because she's an idiot. Not because she actually aspired from anything kurt has done. lol

[shariganz]

love her voice very .Angel like.

[wingsmulti]

LOL, more like a person singing through their nose :\

[DeathSlayerKid]

... Or a bad quality playback maybe douche bag. Shes fucking amazing, if you don't like it, don't watch it genius.

[wingsmulti]

From something recorded in a studio? LMAO

Bad quality? ROTFLMFAO Everything I watch on youtube automatically gets converted to HQ via &fmt=18.

Amazing? Yes, I suppose you're right,

She's an amazing! ' Whore, bitch, and amazingly! Stupid, Narcissistic, Arrogant.

So yep, amazing!!!!

So all in all, EPIC FAIL

I was expecting better, and especially because, HSB was a great song, and still is, Kurt Cobain would fucking turn over in his grave if he knew she redid this song so fucking badly.

[DeathSlayerKid]

youtube refuses to post long comments atm so all i'll say is.

What the fuck made you think that posting a hateful comment towards a band people are going to watch BECAUSE THEY LIKE THEM wouldn't get you into a load of shit with the fans?

[wingsmulti]

Hateful?

LMFAO

Hardly

More like a comment of how much disgust they provide :)

It hasn't got me in any shit, simply because in order for it to do such, it'd have to bother me, fact is, what a stupid reject fan has to say doesn't bother me or make me lose sleep in the least, I find it utterly amusing.

So Please ramble on with more useless comments so I can laugh more :D

[DeathSlayerKid]

Waitt, i have a better idea than continuing to spam the video.

[wingsmulti]

ROTFL,

FAIL

[DeathSlayerKid]

Woah, really.. Your rather pathetic.. Please do stop waisting both of our lives by continuing to write shit about a fucking video.. Seriously.. I have exams, and yeah.. DON'T HAVE TIME FOR YOU TO BE PATHETIC FROM THE OTHER SIDE OF A COMPUTER.

[wingsmulti]

If it's such a waste, why bother replying?

FAIL.

I CAN TYPE IN CAPS TOO, IT DOESN'T MAKE YOU LOOK BIG :P

[DeathSlayerKid]

Yeah.. I can hide behind a computer and talk pointless shit too, it doesn't make you look big.

And stop saying fail, your life is the embodiment of fail.

[wingsmulti]

lol. hahahahaha, Fail again,

Everything you've just said has zero relevance.

I never once Implied it did make me look big, unless you can't read lol.

[lmyhoosier]

your just mad because you cant sing like her.

[wingsmulti]

Am i? Really now? Weird, I don't feel mad or the least bit frustrated, I wouldn't want to sing through my nose like the cuntfaced whore she is..

[lmyhoosier]

yes, as a matter of fact you are. she is one of the best singers out right now

[ShabalMahdi4life]

Let me ask you something wingsmulti, if you were discovered to have a good voice, nd you started a band, would you for once sing a cover of nirnava? evanescence was new, Amy was obviously a fan of nirnava, and she thought she'd sing it cuz she can, and she did a good job.

[wingsmulti]

No I wouldn't. and she did horribly, saying she did a good job is a disgrace to human-kind, you need your head examined.

[TwistedSynthetics]

Just because your tone deaf doesn't mean she didn't sing good, She sung wonderfully. :D

[wingsmulti]

Unfortunately for you I major in Music arts, and can play several instruments, if anyone here is tone deaf, it is you, little one.

[TwistedSynthetics]

Good thing she's singing and not playing an instrument. :)

[madamen13]

I agree with ShabalMahdi4life.

Just admit it people, she did a great job. Ofcourse, the original is better, but come one, Amy sung this song beautifully.

[ShabalMahdi4life]

ShabalMahdi4life agrees with you too ;) lol

[wingsmulti]

She did horrible, regardless of what you think, she fails epically. Enough said.

[madamen13]

I'd like to see YOU sing it then :)

Then we'll see who fails miserably ..

[wingsmulti]

I'd prefer not to drag Kurt's name through the dirt by singing his own original song. The song was great anyone else that does it simply sullies it's clarity. I would do it, don't get me wrong, and maybe if I'm confident enough that I can somehow Improve it with my own general music style I will. But cover's of bands long since gone Very often fail, especially when a stupid cunt like Amy Lee sings it.

[madamen13]

Regardless of who is singing this or not, you have no right to drag anybody's name through the dirt just because someone decides to take a risk and sing this fantastic song. Amy is a great singer, even though this wasn't at her best.

The only cunt here though, is you.

[wingsmulti]

I know I'm a cunt, and proud. And I don't have the right? LMAO

I have every right you fool, and I will continue to do so, regardless of what you or anyone else foolish enough to conflict me says. I'm not picking fault just because this whore took a risk to sing this song. I'm picking fault because she is a disgrace to the entirety of music. So do yourself a favor, and give up, you have no chance of making me back down or ""see the light"" because you think I'm in the wrong.

[madamen13]

I have no intention to make you give up or "see the light."

This sounds great, even though you believe this is shit. You're obviously only here to create a fight and a discussion.

Disgrace to the entirety of music?

She creates marvellous music that helps other people. People either like it or they don't.

And whore? Then I'd like to see what you think of Lady Gaga, Lindsay Lohan, Britney Spears, Miley Cyrus and all that crap. Amy doesn't act like a whore to sell records.

[x3x2x1xKAPOW]

It's not even worth arguing with you, since everything you typed made absolutely no sense.

[wingsmulti]

Then why bother replying, fool?

[x3x2x1xKAPOW]

To make a point. Not too complicated of a concept, is it?

Stop stalking this video and calling everyone fools, since you're the one who seems completely foolish.

[wingsmulti]

Or what? You're going to cry to your mommy?

[sofsofsoof]

i prefer the original......but evanescenes cover is nice too.....i still find it boring...

[EmbraceMe711]

i didnt know this was a Nirvana song

i thought she made it

[drl453]

hope you are joking

[EmbraceMe711]

ive never listened to Nirvana so I thought she made it when I heard her sing it.

sorry.

[wingsmulti]

that talentless whore could never make a great song like this.

She did horrbile.

[EmbraceMe711]

no she didnt.

f off

[wingsmulti]

Yup, she did, because she's a stupid whore,

Kurt's version > This one, actually as a matter of fact, ALL versions over this one, even the bad ones.

So you little child, why don't you make me 'fuck' off ?

Just because your emo doesn't mean people have to like what you say, expect people to disagree, idiot.

[EmbraceMe711]

ok one I'm not emo or goth or punk or anything dark, I'm 16 not a little child and i dont want people to agree to me im just saying my opinion

[DeepRiverBradSG]

I agree with your opinion

[EmbraceMe711]

thanks so much.

[DeepRiverBradSG]

well you do have a point.

[AmySnowQueen]

amy <3

[swedishxoperaxdiva]

Amy is one of my biggest inspirations. No way I would be where I am without her.

:)

[swedishxoperaxdiva]

Well that TALENTED ANGEL got me pretty damn far. KTHANKS.

[swedishxoperaxdiva]

Wow. You think I'M the pathetic one?Hahaha that's embarrassing.

Ha. We shall see.

She inspired me and got me through my darkest days. That's much more powerful than anything you could say to me. It doesn't matter. ;) I'm already succeeding.

My career in opera has taken off because of people like Amy, Tarja Turunen, and Sarah Brightman. You don't like it? Well talk to the directors who are putting me in the operas, giving me major solos, and recording studios begging me to sing for them. Deal.

[daringuy20]

wow her voice sounds haunting. i love it

[ilovemidna22]

I bet that Kurt is cheering for them in his grave. :)

[scottish1337]

here voice is fuckin from the badass side of hevean :|

[electrolito74]

me gusta mas esta version

[poserkidsrus]

i think this is the version from Y100 before the station got turned to 100.3 the beat. Which is, in fact, beat.

[afcwandsworth]

kurt cobain has too much pain in his voice that nobody no matter how good a singer can match it. amy is the better singer kurt has the better voice

[crimsonmoon92]

That is so true.

[Cheyannewhore]

gahhhh i luv her

[Newwaver2007]

i wonder if she covers more Nirvana songs :)

or something

kurt was a good singer and artist

if he only were alive

Amy's voice is great <3

[GameOverXbox]

Wow I just got chills. I bet Kurt would love this.

[Mikli7]

I think so too. It was really good. :)

[FallenDemon649]

Wow she's amazing!!!!

[ilovemidna22]

i LUV this song! Evanesence plays it so good. but to be honest, i like the Nirvana version a little bit better....BUT THIS IS STILL KICKASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!YAY FOR EVANESENCE!

[Bdear1]

Love this one!!

[ATFrez]

Not gonna lie, Amy Lee has a hell of a voice, but I don't think covering Nirvana is right for her style of singing. The pronunciation of the lyrics is too different. Kurt Cobain had more of an angst fueled voice, whereas Amy Lee has a more operatic voice. She gave it a great shot though!

[Audtodd90]

Haha, I wish I could've seen them when it cost 5 bucks.

[insertafeckingname]

damn, she sings this very well! i had my doubts about hearing a female singing a nirvana song (well i've only heard the nirvana version)\but im very impressed with amy...<3

[Cockatiellover453]

she sings this much better than the original artist.

[HeavenluvzVamps]

dude i love this fuckin song....she does it good but its nothin compaired to the origanal

[jamjlove]

I love this song!!!

I think nirvana was better at this but this is still good :)

R.I.P Kurt Cobain