kind of funny that the 12th place finalist in season 2 was better than every single singer on the last season including the winner. what have they done to this show?
Omg, I actually loved this. Why is everyone giving her such crap?? I think her voice was perfect for this song and I totally disagree with the judges!
I think its because in the auditions, they get to sing a song of their own choice.. In the actual live compotitions, they have to pick a certain song from a certain category.. that sucked. Thats why Matt Giraud got voted out in season 8. :(
Ok when Ryan is throwing the water on Simon, why is there no reaction out of Paula... she is just sitting there. like frozen.....wow that is weird. did they have a doll subsitute?
it sounded creepily low, even though thats her style it would have been much better in an octave higher, no personality in that performance, and it sounded like a creepy guy sang it.
i think the problem here is that her voice is deep and low, something unique when it comes to being a girl. However, she does sound and look really decent.
i like her but i think with this performance, she was pushing way too hard and she had almost no control over her voice. it wasn't bad, but it definitely wasn't good either.
hers was the only that captured the meaning. Josh Gracin's seemed rushed, Antonella's was well... Antonella haha, and David Cook's was too HAPPY. ugh. lol
I dont know why some people assume that she doesn't have much range. she may have limits on higher notes but she reached C5 on this one. And she went down to G3. For me that is enough range because she has a very beautiful deep tone already.
her version is better than antonella's but I kind of agree with Randy,it wasn't really the bomb. But I like her twist with it. Kind of unique version and I like her voice.
I just don't like the fact that she went down first in the top twelve. Too bad.
her version is better than antonella's but I kind of agree with Randy,it wasn't really the bomb. But I like her twist with it. Kind of unique version and I like her voice.
I just don't like the fact that she went down first in the top twelve. Too bad.
her version is better than antonella's but I kind of agree with Randy,it wasn't really unique. But I like her twist with it. Kind of unique version and I like her voice.
I just don't like the fact that she went down first in the top twelve. Too bad.
please remind me to do so ... i keep meaning to upload other videos of hers but it is difficult when i use this computer more than the one that has the lindsey videos on it ... i will upload the audition for you very soon if you cannot find it anywhere else
Antonella tried SO hard to copy how she performed, she did everything EXACTLY how she did it (except sing) lol, her voice will never compare to this, but she sure did do all her motions! lol
That couldn't be any more false... The end was different, Antonella sang it a little differently and she added a different verse. Everyone on the show is "copying" someone else, their not singing their own material. Antonella's was actually more original, Lindsay didn't really change anything about the song. She did sing it a lot better though.
She's got great vocals, very pretty, and amazing performance specially this song. I still wonder how amaricans vote.... she should've been in the finale
Why was she in the top 12 and not technically stronger singers like amanda avila? simple...the natural husky voice. she sounds the most different in the group.
When Anotella Barba sang this song tonight on AI6 I immediately thought of Lindsay's superior rendition. Thanks for YouTubing this so I could be sure I was right.
lol... try this video a local singer in the Philippines amazing voice... just write regine velasquez... and u can see how beautiful and amazing voice...
but very big voice for a pretty girl like her
nikaledesma 10 months ago
she has a boyish tone of voice
nikaledesma 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She was sooooo good!!!
Youssymeerkat 10 months ago
She would sound amazing in "Fireworks" By Katy Perry
jennydee2010 10 months ago
i love this song!!!!
soidoi10 11 months ago
Ryan is so cool
arashjan 1 year ago
kind of funny that the 12th place finalist in season 2 was better than every single singer on the last season including the winner. what have they done to this show?
Wadec 1 year ago
oh come on, that's stretching it a little far, if ound this girl boring, lauren and haley are better singers than her
spencerruefus 2 months ago
@Wadec Vanessa?
idoltyler06 1 month ago
Not that good :/
geheimpje 1 year ago
@geheimpje yeah you are right.
Hablachuga 1 year ago
I love the entry she does into the next lyrics at 1:33
JakobTennisMB 1 year ago
Comment removed
JakobTennisMB 1 year ago
Best season ever. Second best was last season. This season = by far the worst, can, barely watch it.
JakobTennisMB 1 year ago
how is she related to ryan? can anyone tell me?
t3ArL3Ss 2 years ago
Its funny that the best singer came from arguably the least talented season.
dman747707 2 years ago
Omg, I actually loved this. Why is everyone giving her such crap?? I think her voice was perfect for this song and I totally disagree with the judges!
SamanthaChurchill 2 years ago
BITCH WTF ARE YOU WEARING?
knagaroo 2 years ago
Does Randy drive anyone else crazy?... he's trying to be a teenager again and it annoys the heck out of me.
ChelseAlice 2 years ago
Comment removed
thickinikki 2 years ago
Lmao, what does she have to snobbish about, she sucks!!!
curlingiron7658 2 years ago
Allison totally owned this song, this performance pales in comparison.
curlingiron7658 2 years ago
I loved her voice in the audition, but I hated her voice throughout the competition...weird.
mizzkitty20 2 years ago 3
I think its because in the auditions, they get to sing a song of their own choice.. In the actual live compotitions, they have to pick a certain song from a certain category.. that sucked. Thats why Matt Giraud got voted out in season 8. :(
Vicarageroad1 2 years ago
Ok when Ryan is throwing the water on Simon, why is there no reaction out of Paula... she is just sitting there. like frozen.....wow that is weird. did they have a doll subsitute?
qg6ff 2 years ago 4
Dude, that was weird. I just watched it again and you're right. It's like she's frozen. Or maybe has a migraine.
JWGames 2 years ago
No, the "water" throwing was scripted and Paula was bored with the shenanigans. Moreover, that was Stolichnaya in Pauler's cup!
cbotten106 2 years ago
but idk.. it's just like she's unphased by the entire thing. zero reaction lol.
qg6ff 2 years ago
it sounded creepily low, even though thats her style it would have been much better in an octave higher, no personality in that performance, and it sounded like a creepy guy sang it.
Ising4u93 2 years ago 2
her voice is amazing but it was the worst choice of song ever
albr0212 2 years ago 3
I really prefer this to David Cooks version. But, of course, I love Lindsey, too.
cbotten106 3 years ago 3
funny how i always have the opposing opinion. loved the performance.
annikam07 3 years ago 4
i know her and yall don't she is realy good friends with carrie underwood so burnn !!!!!
stanleysteamers1800 3 years ago 2
this isn't a friendship contest, it's a SINGING competition!
rjs5146 3 years ago
ok??? what eva !!!! :D ! sorry !!??
stanleysteamers1800 3 years ago
i think the problem here is that her voice is deep and low, something unique when it comes to being a girl. However, she does sound and look really decent.
janpaul100 3 years ago
she seems so shy
num1meekfan 3 years ago 2
Simon is such an ass hole.
gypsyasl 3 years ago
i like her but i think with this performance, she was pushing way too hard and she had almost no control over her voice. it wasn't bad, but it definitely wasn't good either.
dtotheavid87 3 years ago
please watch the version of Regine Velasquez... I think its the best version... for this video, it is os amature for filipinos
scian78 3 years ago
lindsay is really good.. carrie underwood still says they are good fiends, i thought that was sweet!
Maura2735 3 years ago
YEAH LINS!! you go hunn
Jesro8900 3 years ago
Loved Lindsey's look & voice.
cbotten106 3 years ago 3
Best Version Ever
McPhever224 3 years ago 3
hers was the only that captured the meaning. Josh Gracin's seemed rushed, Antonella's was well... Antonella haha, and David Cook's was too HAPPY. ugh. lol
LittleCloserBoi 3 years ago 2
Josh Gracin sang this better then her.!!!
DiinahmxD 3 years ago
1 david cook
1.5 josh gracin
oranger2525 3 years ago
Order of Who Performed This The Best.
1. David Cook.
2. Lindsey Cardinale.
3. Antonella Barba.
4. Josh Gracin.
[:
Pfilipino 3 years ago
Might one ask where Steven Tyler is on this list?
tyringekimmi 3 years ago
who? lol.
im sorry. i dont know that person.
xD
Pfilipino 3 years ago
Steven Tyler is the lead singer of Aerosmith..
Sukkerpige 3 years ago
DUH, he's the original singer of this song!!!!!!!!!
rjs5146 3 years ago
she is pretty and she has a nce voice. great.
i like this version, but i love david cook's better. hahaha.
but i also like this version, just to clear it out.
it's just a matter of opinion, anyway. =D
rinoaheartilly23 3 years ago
I dont know why some people assume that she doesn't have much range. she may have limits on higher notes but she reached C5 on this one. And she went down to G3. For me that is enough range because she has a very beautiful deep tone already.
TheXan 3 years ago
She has an amazing voice!!
and she's quite fine, if i do say so myself =P
primaip 3 years ago 7
why does she keep squatting?
madluv4tai 3 years ago 2
her version is better than antonella's but I kind of agree with Randy,it wasn't really the bomb. But I like her twist with it. Kind of unique version and I like her voice.
I just don't like the fact that she went down first in the top twelve. Too bad.
imlance 3 years ago
her version is better than antonella's but I kind of agree with Randy,it wasn't really the bomb. But I like her twist with it. Kind of unique version and I like her voice.
I just don't like the fact that she went down first in the top twelve. Too bad.
imlance 3 years ago
her version is better than antonella's but I kind of agree with Randy,it wasn't really unique. But I like her twist with it. Kind of unique version and I like her voice.
I just don't like the fact that she went down first in the top twelve. Too bad.
imlance 3 years ago
wow
jantwennyeytty 4 years ago
WOW! amaaaaaazing voice! I love deep voices!
Cappucinia 4 years ago 3
alang kwenta!
raulito 4 years ago
What a voice! I still can`t believe she was eliminated! Me encanta y no se porque la eliminaron... mas chimbo... :(
victorarmandoyanes 4 years ago 2
melissa s n asia sang da best~
whateverlaa 4 years ago
It was Melissa Reyes not Melissa Smith.
MySilentCrisis 4 years ago
actually it was mellisa smith
divagirl1422 4 years ago
Fantastic!!!
loirinhobeautiful 4 years ago
she shoul've stayed longer in season 4..
wafumetz21 4 years ago 3
she sang great
damoochi82 4 years ago 2
so much better than antonella's rendition.
krepits 4 years ago 12
So true
NYChica23 4 years ago
so true I watched that to she is so horrible antonella
michy10animefan 4 years ago
Best season...
simmer126 4 years ago 7
HANDS DOWN.
o0bittersweet 4 years ago
where can i find her audition video.?
R1089 4 years ago
please remind me to do so ... i keep meaning to upload other videos of hers but it is difficult when i use this computer more than the one that has the lindsey videos on it ... i will upload the audition for you very soon if you cannot find it anywhere else
o0bittersweet 4 years ago
i live in ponchatoula where she from i m tryin out next year
nicksmi1234 4 years ago
lindsey...your the best....
lluvygomez143 4 years ago
her range is small.. very low for a girl too -_-
garyworld 4 years ago
i like her so much
hekaki 4 years ago
same ... check out her new singles on her myspace
o0bittersweet 4 years ago
she's great...how come she voted off too soon
hekaki 4 years ago
better than antonella
sxcamsy 4 years ago
Antonella tried SO hard to copy how she performed, she did everything EXACTLY how she did it (except sing) lol, her voice will never compare to this, but she sure did do all her motions! lol
RazeGeneration 4 years ago
How can antonella copy this performance? Antonella never saw American Idol before. Get your facts straight.
hpsimsoap92 4 years ago
That couldn't be any more false... The end was different, Antonella sang it a little differently and she added a different verse. Everyone on the show is "copying" someone else, their not singing their own material. Antonella's was actually more original, Lindsay didn't really change anything about the song. She did sing it a lot better though.
o0bers 4 years ago
i like it, (she looks pretty too)
strain121 4 years ago
lindsey was the best contestant of season 4
Abberrzz 4 years ago
She's got great vocals, very pretty, and amazing performance specially this song. I still wonder how amaricans vote.... she should've been in the finale
varzgani 4 years ago
defff!
o0bittersweet 4 years ago
Antonella's rendition was painful considering I love this song!!! At least Lindsey did the song some justice.
jerzygirlathrt 4 years ago
her voice is very sexy... her singing? not the greatest
dorood 5 years ago
Why was she in the top 12 and not technically stronger singers like amanda avila? simple...the natural husky voice. she sounds the most different in the group.
cyrusvail 5 years ago
i liked her but i knew from the start carrie was gonna win
hcostudd312 5 years ago
my fav american idol contestant eva
WhoCares1313 5 years ago
i love her!
millertwin4l 5 years ago
woo yayy Lindsey <333
wishbearxx 5 years ago
Gotta love Lindsey.
ashleycardinale 5 years ago
deff .. how could u not? ;]
o0bittersweet 5 years ago
When Anotella Barba sang this song tonight on AI6 I immediately thought of Lindsay's superior rendition. Thanks for YouTubing this so I could be sure I was right.
cbotten106 5 years ago
lins's was deff better lol
o0bittersweet 5 years ago
lol... try this video a local singer in the Philippines amazing voice... just write regine velasquez... and u can see how beautiful and amazing voice...
regjee 5 years ago
Lol Like I've said before.. I love Lindsey Cardinale forever, even my youtube name is LCFAN lol.. for Lindsey Cardinale Fan.. Chyeah she's amazing!
lcfan2 5 years ago
I loved Lindsey. She wasn't always rememrable, but she sounded really good on this one. This was her strongest vocal that season.
idoltyler06 5 years ago
i agree!
o0bittersweet 5 years ago
I think Ryan's reaction helped wake up people to vote. lol
BrianMcCallister 5 years ago
i know right lol
o0bittersweet 5 years ago