Post season 5 the show became too fairytale like and comedic. Then again, personally I preferred Shannen as an actress moreso than I did with Rose McGowan.
When Paige came into the picture and as her character developed, I feel as if though the sisterhood was incomplete. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe were not just sisters, they were friends. Paige never truly seemed like apart of the family. Though her powers provided a more “magical” theme to the show. However, I do agree that Shannen was a big baby and the Super-Witch Prue theme was very dried out. The seasons she partook in however were a lot darker and more serious (how it should’ve been).
why the heck would phoebe save Cole before Prue and piper if she was there when time was restarted and they said the spell to kill Shax once and for all Prue would still be alive she made the wrong decision of going down to the underworld to save Cole it was matter of life and death
@tentaculariano My theories are that "The Cleaners" were created after this fiasco, so that if something like this was to happen again in the future it could be avoided, or "The Cleaners" knew that it was part of their destiny. Therefore, perhaps they knew that the sisters would find a way to rewind time, one of them would be killed, and Paige would then come in as part of the destiny to reconstitute The Charmed Ones (series speaking).
@emeraldwarrior13 It should be simple to get rid of the news, all they have to do is use that "Mind Erase Dust" that they used in one of the episodes in season 4 or 5.
Personally, I would have played it as a hoax. Laugh in everyone's face, and act like you just want attention. People's skeptical behavior will take it from there.
There is suppose to be a part between the end of this episode and the beginning of the first episode of the 4th season where Pheobe turns evil and comes back to the good side and where Piper dies but somehow (don't know how) she comes back to life. At the end of the third season we see that Piper and Prue fly through the wall, but since Leo is still in the underworld with Pheobe, no one's there to heal them. Then the evil guy leaves. What happened after that? Can someone help find the next part?
if they made this episode as the pilot in season 1,but whitout anyone dying it would be the best episode ever to me you know why? because this was the first episode of charmed i watched
they should've just used a spell that took them in the past like they did in the 1st season when they had to kill tht demon that their mom made a deal with them or something if that makes sense they should've checked their book of shadowsor something.
@Liljoker14years They made the episode like that just because Prue or Shannen was kicked out of the show. They had to do something to kill her. That's the only reason.
@nicelydone31 actually prue did get fired she quit cause she had problems with alyssa milano she said that she has been trying to leave the show for six month
That stalker chick is so cute.. but embarrassing..
josefineforss 2 days ago
the old episodes were so much better written.
season 6 shit just started going down hill.........
CrisscrossOno 3 days ago
I wish they'd just let that doctor die. He was a bastard anyway.
Lynn15 3 days ago
Post season 5 the show became too fairytale like and comedic. Then again, personally I preferred Shannen as an actress moreso than I did with Rose McGowan.
kingphoenix92 1 week ago
When Paige came into the picture and as her character developed, I feel as if though the sisterhood was incomplete. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe were not just sisters, they were friends. Paige never truly seemed like apart of the family. Though her powers provided a more “magical” theme to the show. However, I do agree that Shannen was a big baby and the Super-Witch Prue theme was very dried out. The seasons she partook in however were a lot darker and more serious (how it should’ve been).
kingphoenix92 1 week ago
You know If I was in a similar situation I would use Prue's power to put that bitchy new lady in her place.
SageOfTheSixPaths21 2 weeks ago
This is why people don't like the media.
SageOfTheSixPaths21 2 weeks ago
why the heck would phoebe save Cole before Prue and piper if she was there when time was restarted and they said the spell to kill Shax once and for all Prue would still be alive she made the wrong decision of going down to the underworld to save Cole it was matter of life and death
TheCandylover456 2 weeks ago
I love charmed. Ive been watching since 98.
2147560654 3 weeks ago
@tentaculariano My theories are that "The Cleaners" were created after this fiasco, so that if something like this was to happen again in the future it could be avoided, or "The Cleaners" knew that it was part of their destiny. Therefore, perhaps they knew that the sisters would find a way to rewind time, one of them would be killed, and Paige would then come in as part of the destiny to reconstitute The Charmed Ones (series speaking).
Kiickzfeen 1 month ago
where were the cleaners here? ....
tentaculariano 2 months ago
piper always saying its not ment to be gosh have some faith tht is y she ganna get shoot in her belly
ackeal 2 months ago
Dear reporter: If I were Piper I would blow you up even if you ARE a human
butterscotch1997 3 months ago 3
oohhhh news at 11.....oh thass badd
GhostGardens 3 months ago
Why didn't they just say it from the safety of their car?
alwdreamer 3 months ago
Why didn´t Piper freeze everybody at the hospital and then steal the tape from the camera?
biigu94 4 months ago
This is when they have to come up with the idea of "the cleaners"!!! Why they didn't show up?
toskis 4 months ago
Alice is... annoying >.< and so is the news crew - the should just tell them it they were testing special effects for a magician act or something...
Applebutter799 6 months ago
Phoebe was so stupid, who chooses to stay with a Guy who only gets with them in the first place just to kill them and their family, retard!
donisetaylor 6 months ago 3
lol Piper Haha I Love her!
piper372 6 months ago in playlist Charmed Season 3
that doctor should be castrated
emeraldwarrior13 7 months ago 3
@emeraldwarrior13 It should be simple to get rid of the news, all they have to do is use that "Mind Erase Dust" that they used in one of the episodes in season 4 or 5.
MillionDollarSonHQ 7 months ago
@MillionDollarSonHQ and in season 3 p3 h20 the guy used it on them that wl who clipped his wings step dad
windowsvista786 6 months ago
Oh news at 11, oh that's bad. :)))
marijasquirrel 7 months ago 3
uggggh stupid a** news crew
cpcccollegechick88 8 months ago 38
haha prue failled the test XD
RusselXJoyce 8 months ago
does anyone else find it worrying that phoebe wants to be with cole even though he clearly isn't the best for her?
moonlightkisu 9 months ago
does anyone wish the reporter lady in this should be kicked in the face?
moonlightkisu 9 months ago 67
Personally, I would have played it as a hoax. Laugh in everyone's face, and act like you just want attention. People's skeptical behavior will take it from there.
ussmwm 9 months ago
There is suppose to be a part between the end of this episode and the beginning of the first episode of the 4th season where Pheobe turns evil and comes back to the good side and where Piper dies but somehow (don't know how) she comes back to life. At the end of the third season we see that Piper and Prue fly through the wall, but since Leo is still in the underworld with Pheobe, no one's there to heal them. Then the evil guy leaves. What happened after that? Can someone help find the next part?
SailorMoonAnimeToys 10 months ago
I don't like to watch this episode because of the death of Prue. I also don't like it because the whole thing is tragic :(
yacoubjayoghli 10 months ago
i thought there was a mutual agreement between the forces of good and evil never to fight in public, exposure and all....
MarieAntoinettexx 10 months ago
LMAO
Phoebe hits Cole
Cole : you're not an easy girl to dump
douuth 10 months ago
they should call the cleaners , i know that they didn't know them yet , but still :)
douuth 10 months ago
Couldn't they use some powerful spell to make the whole city forget?.. Another illogical thing
Patchofme 1 year ago
ur not an easy girl to dump - lol
jonanice 1 year ago
You know what would really be coooool?
if they made this episode as the pilot in season 1,but whitout anyone dying it would be the best episode ever to me you know why? because this was the first episode of charmed i watched
MrVenio 1 year ago
what is the idea with the crazy blond
jenniferJaneParker1 1 year ago
they should've just used a spell that took them in the past like they did in the 1st season when they had to kill tht demon that their mom made a deal with them or something if that makes sense they should've checked their book of shadowsor something.
Liljoker14years 1 year ago
@Liljoker14years They made the episode like that just because Prue or Shannen was kicked out of the show. They had to do something to kill her. That's the only reason.
BobiRules 1 year ago
@BobiRules actually at the time shannen didnt know she wouldnt be coming back in season 4. she got fired after.
nicelydone31 1 year ago
@nicelydone31 actually prue did get fired she quit cause she had problems with alyssa milano she said that she has been trying to leave the show for six month
THELESLIEJ 11 months ago
okay I don't get something either.....If they both vanquished SHAX, why did prue die? I thought that it was Shax who killed her...Wasn't it????????
MrsRainingRoses 1 year ago
@MrsRainingRoses the thing is when cole phoebe and leo go to the underworld
to help return time bcuz magic was exposed shax atacked piper and prue
prue was hurt the most and leo that is in love with piper save her first and when he turn to prue it was too late
diandri11 1 year ago
how did Prue die ?, when she lived in this episode ??
tomprentice88 1 year ago