Sick of comments telling Noel to "leave the singing to Liam". You think Noel really wanted to sing this? Wanna know why Noel didn't "leave the singing to Liam"? Maybe cos Liam had fucked his voice up,so much that he couldn't reach the parts that require him to raise his voice just a bit. Noel does a top job at this song too in my opinion too.
@TheGolin Hard to do when it doesn't exist seeing as you are correct that Liam has never sung this song "live". I love when people call others out and are wrong.
@catney11 Listen you scumbag, just because you can't find it on youtube, doesn't mean he hasn't sung it. You need to get out of youtube and go to concerts more frecuently you dumb piece of shit, ignorant cunt!!!
@alnpel It's funny how you had a private concert for you. just cause somebody calls you out on something doesn't mean you have to snap. Grow the fuck up, why don't you prove shit. Go on any Oasis fansite and everyone talks about how he never sung it live and refused to cause he hated the song. the only ignorant person here is you. So grow the fuck up and prove me wrong, cause until you do you look like a stupid fuck to anyone reading this. Prove it, or shut the fuck up. Simple.
@catney11 Listen Buddy I don't have to prove you anything, or anyone else. yes I snap, not because of the fact that you argue you have never seen liam sing this song live, it's the fact that you start insulting me. So what do i do? I reply back. Just FYI, I went to a concert in the year 96´ , and liam was arguing that he did not like the song, but noel dared him, and of course we all cheered, and finally did. Don't know how many times he sang that song thereafter, but i was lucky enough to seeit
@alnpel But see i don't have to believe shit from you when your the only one claiming to have seen it. I'm not insulting you, were on fucking youtube get a grip. i don't know your name or anything. How can I insult you. Sure you can reply back, you don't need to have a hernia. If your right why be so pissed off? Who gives a shit man.
@catney11 You're right, you don't have to believe me, nor knowing my name. So if you don't care, why r u responding? But anyway, good luck trying to find info on the net, like if everything on the net was true. But if you like bias info, goahead. As i said earlier, don't need to prove you shit.i 'm happy to know I saw him, you didn't, too bad for you. Consider going to concerts more frequently.
@alnpel Lol I'm replying cause your being a little redicoulous over a youtube comment. BTW the go to concerts more thing means shit all, for all you know I've gone to 600 concerts. It's not an argument. but this is pointless, peace and cheers.
Sick of comments telling Noel to "leave the singing to Liam". You think Noel really wanted to sing this? Wanna know why Noel didn't "leave the singing to Liam"? Maybe cos Liam had fucked his voice up,so much that he couldn't reach the parts that require him to raise his voice just a bit. Noel does a top job at this song too in my opinion too.
Feedersuper 1 day ago
undoubtedly,noel is a great singer .
However,Noel can't sing "She's Electric" as great as Liam .
he's not that type....
ilovehonglong 3 months ago
noel seems a bit bored
therunningtap 5 months ago
liking it :)
MrRyanSams 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stick to guitar Noel. Leave the singing to Liam. Seriously..
zackfromtheburgh 8 months ago
@zackfromtheburgh noel's better
NAFIANNA10 6 months ago
@zackfromtheburgh nah
MrRyanSams 6 months ago
i like it with noel, people say its shit but remember we have never heard liam sing this live (i)
TheGolin 2 years ago
@TheGolin You're wrong I have heard Liam sing this song. Know your shit first!!!
alnpel 1 year ago
@alnpel well why don't you fucking find me it then
TheGolin 1 year ago
@TheGolin Hard to do when it doesn't exist seeing as you are correct that Liam has never sung this song "live". I love when people call others out and are wrong.
catney11 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TheGolin And that goes to you too!!!
alnpel 1 year ago
@alnpel You should know your shit cause your wrong idiot.
catney11 1 year ago
@catney11 Listen you scumbag, just because you can't find it on youtube, doesn't mean he hasn't sung it. You need to get out of youtube and go to concerts more frecuently you dumb piece of shit, ignorant cunt!!!
alnpel 1 year ago
@alnpel It's funny how you had a private concert for you. just cause somebody calls you out on something doesn't mean you have to snap. Grow the fuck up, why don't you prove shit. Go on any Oasis fansite and everyone talks about how he never sung it live and refused to cause he hated the song. the only ignorant person here is you. So grow the fuck up and prove me wrong, cause until you do you look like a stupid fuck to anyone reading this. Prove it, or shut the fuck up. Simple.
catney11 1 year ago
@catney11 Listen Buddy I don't have to prove you anything, or anyone else. yes I snap, not because of the fact that you argue you have never seen liam sing this song live, it's the fact that you start insulting me. So what do i do? I reply back. Just FYI, I went to a concert in the year 96´ , and liam was arguing that he did not like the song, but noel dared him, and of course we all cheered, and finally did. Don't know how many times he sang that song thereafter, but i was lucky enough to seeit
alnpel 1 year ago
@alnpel But see i don't have to believe shit from you when your the only one claiming to have seen it. I'm not insulting you, were on fucking youtube get a grip. i don't know your name or anything. How can I insult you. Sure you can reply back, you don't need to have a hernia. If your right why be so pissed off? Who gives a shit man.
catney11 1 year ago
@catney11 You're right, you don't have to believe me, nor knowing my name. So if you don't care, why r u responding? But anyway, good luck trying to find info on the net, like if everything on the net was true. But if you like bias info, goahead. As i said earlier, don't need to prove you shit.i 'm happy to know I saw him, you didn't, too bad for you. Consider going to concerts more frequently.
alnpel 1 year ago
@alnpel Lol I'm replying cause your being a little redicoulous over a youtube comment. BTW the go to concerts more thing means shit all, for all you know I've gone to 600 concerts. It's not an argument. but this is pointless, peace and cheers.
catney11 1 year ago
@catney11 Finally till you said something smart!!!
alnpel 1 year ago