Added: 3 years ago
From: Kyv3r
Views: 519,574
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,388)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Waw, just magnificent

  • I love it!!

  • is amazing

    

  • At first, I was like "Seems meh" later into the song, after forcibly opening my mind and just relaxing...this is a masterpiece. 5/5

  • i think very good song and i dont care if it plays matallica or sonata

  • why don't we all agree that both bands are amazing. And put all our anger at Bif Naked and that failed attempt of a Nothing Else Matters.

  • why no final solooooo :'( with jani skills that would have been amazingggggggggg

  • this is track 7 of seven on the album. they did a good job on their verion of it. ensiferum and sonata arctica as well as many others did covers for this son, including mastadon and kamelot.

  • Guys get so offensive over nothing... Metallica is my all time favourite band AND I think this version of the song is amazing! Why can't it be both ways? Relax..

  • I adore both versions :)

  • Metallica is big allright but this highlights that James Hetfield isn't much a singer.

  • amazing

    

  • Reprise intéressante, c'est rare de réussir à apporter un plus à une reprise et la c'est au top

  • their made it their own...and that is what covers are for...but if you play fade to black by metallica, you shouldnt fucking mess up the amazing guitar solo

  • solo ruined :S

  • Thank you, Tony :)

  • sonata and brother fucking Cock

  • Sound a lot better of Metallica ! ( i don't say i don't like Metallica ) :D

  • @MyBassCover Metallica's version was issued in 1984, Sonata Arctica was created in 1996, which means they at least recorded this version 12 years later than the original one. The sound is then "better" 'cuz the recording possibilities had increased in the mid 90's compared to the 80's. That's it. To my mind, the sound of the guitar arpeggio of Sonata's version is awful, and so are the synths. And so is the "No one but me can save myself" etc part. Anyway, Metallica and Sonata rule !

  • @victorblein you're right :)

  • I'd really rather the original version by MetallicA

  • they made it their own, just like covers are supposed to be done. it sounds like sonata arctica!

  • What the fuck happened to the solo???????????

  • excelllent cover

  • I really love sonata arctica, i love all his albums, but in this cover i miss the solo if they put in this would be as good as the original version of metallica still is amazing!!

    Tony kakko rulez the wolrd!!! |m|

  • Oh, hello. Where have you been all my life? My favorite Metallica song covered by the ever beautiful Sonata Arctica? Be still, my heart!

  • this is the best version.

  • i prefer this version, but do not forget metallica wrote it

  • i prefer the sonata version too, it does not have to have a solo to be a good song.

  • fail cover... metallica is metallica. Stay on your shit...

  • @blasbembi fail comment.... Sonata arctica is sonata arctica... Stay on YOUR shit!

  • @Rocker9522 yep but metallica is history, sonata arctica is nothing

  • @blasbembi You can't say that Sonata Arctica is nothing when it's very famous in Finland or in Japan for example..

    Of course Metallica is freakin' famous band but still it doesn't make Sonata Arctica bad.

  • @Rocker9522 I fell like a lot of fans of Zelda Abridged have been introduced to them because of Adamwestslapdog's Majora's Mask Abridged. I know thats how I got here

  • @blasbembi Sonata Arctica is beyond concepts of something and nothing. They surpass the confines of history.

  • @LuminOfMoonlight epic lol

  • that shit sux

  • @SuperRCBA fuck you, sonata arctica rules!

  • This is better than original! James Hetfield is BAD singer!!!

  • @TheMiodrag90 HAHAHAHHAAHAHHAHHHHAHAHA good one dude.. good one...

  • No solo because of no Kirk Hammett

  • It´s a great cover but, like Disturbed's one, there's no freaking guitar solo D: Why, God, Why????

  • METALLICA's original version is better BUT this cover is not bad , i agree YA ..

  • ależ to brzmi !!!!!!!!

  • magiiiiiic just missing the SOLO :(

  • Comment removed

  • What are the notes of the introduction? Can you tell me please? It is very important ..

  • @Stormix1992 search a tab for it on google

  • holy crap i just noticed how beautiful the solo is... the reason y i didnt earlier is cause i was commenting how good the song was

  • tremenda cancion

  • i love all sonata's cover songs

  • nice cover

  • i can definitely play this song while i'm playing skyrim along with Dragonheart's "gods of ice".

  • just imagine this solo but with sonata arctica... that the reason 4 the omit this part...

  • one of my favourite power metal bands + my favourite song of all time = life is good right now

  • this version sounds cleaner at the start than metallica's version

  • They left out the best half of the song :O

  • Like if u think sonata should do a cover for either November rain or sweet child o mine by guns n roses!

  • @starfireninja Sonata is way good for guns n' shit.

  • @scarletthunder100 lol i like guns n roses its just ur probably right sonata arctica, dragonforce, power quest... FTW!!!

  • @scarletthunder100 dude, Sonata and Old Guns rules, you're acting like a moron!!!!!

  • didnt the singer of sonata arctica have a solo project where he did a bunch of cover songs? if anyone knows what im talking about i would appreciate finding that artist again. it was really good.

  • @HaggardKing You might be thinking of the Northern Kings.....they do covers of lots of songs. Granted its not just Tony singing, but that is the only thing i can think of now that fits that description.

  • @sunfisharegreat *searches northern kings*

    *plays take on me*

    yessir, this is it. thanks

  • @HaggardKing *thumbs up*....:D you are quite welcome!

  • I like it but the intro guitar had (i don't know if this is the right way of putting it but) to much whine to it and they sped it up to much as the original version was almost 7 mins.

  • @ps3tna its called WAH , and yes it does, but Kirk is well known because of using wah, they probably tried to impersonate him, using it on a solo he didn't. I agree though, it's too short and missing the awesome solo at the end :/

  • @intii93 Yeah that's it wah but it seemed like there was way to much like to the point where all the notes and chords just kinda string together into one constant sound.If you understand what i mean by that.

  • @ps3tna yeah I do understand you. As a guitarist I know that too much wah muffles up notes and makes an overall covered sound where you can't tell which note is which. I personally think this wasn't too much, but I must admit that I don't like how it sounds compared to the original. And I'm not flaming, I love both Metallica and Sonata Arctica, I just like Metallica's Fade to Black more.

  • @intii93 I totally agree and its still a good cover.And i'm glad it's one of those cover where they have a guy who sings in a weird way and it ruins it.

  • is that gandalf?

  • @LnGuitarist then fuck off

  • all it needed was a big solo finish, if they cldnt come up with one they shldve used the original. wldve went well

  • the best cover there is..

  • soooo good though

  • y el pinche solo?

  • who this tempo is exactly ride zeeee liyytee ninin's i'm fukn diggn it. i went into taco bell like and hour a go and fade 2 black was on the lobby music weird eh in taco smeell?

  • absolutely wonderful!!! It's my own opionion, but I prefer the version of sonata <3

  • @4eSaintSeiya

    Hahahahhahahahahhahaahaha!

  • @tns2 ????? my comment is so funny???? -.- I said that this is my opinion!!! and I love also the original version!

  • @4eSaintSeiya

    Oh yeah, it's very funny hahaha!

  • @tns2 I haven't words, only bad words -.-"

  • @4eSaintSeiya  Not only your opionion :)

  • i cry...

  • Excelente cover!! 

  • me gusta mas que la original N_N

  • superrrrrrrrrrrrr

  • whao ! it's even more depressing  than that metallica

  • Very beautiful. Very interesting changes. Always refreshing.

  • Great cover besides the missing solo.

  • Worst cover ever....

  • @ottocardonarosado You're the only one that thinks that, gtfo fucking troll.

  • @fred123212 youre the only one who cares about my opinion....thank you sir :)

  • Comment removed

  • @ottocardonarosado I agree with Fred though?......so uhh...yh....

  • they put out the best part!!!!!!

  • NAH! MISSING THE SOLO :(

  • @PumpkingSmasher beacause you call solo that of metallica?

  • @PumpkingSmasher INDEED.

    In my modest opinion, Fade to Black IS THAT SOLO

  • @PumpkingSmasher It would be like copy - paste. From the original song

  • i wonder why the top comment is one with 10 likes,while @Ninjastyle124 comment has 164 likes...

  • Bien mais je préfère celle de Metallica!

  • Best Metallica Cover I´ve EVER HEARD!!!!! $&M = SONATA & METALLICA lml lml

  • q merda.....

  • i am not comparing or anything but at 0:55 to 1:01 it sounds like replica

    Great cover!

  • i really love the outro

  • FROM ARGENTINA..... AGUANTEEEEEEEE  SONATAAAA AAARRCCTIICAAA!!!!!! CARAJOOO!!!!! :D

  • What's the meaning of 'covers' If you guys believe they can only sound like the original? Totally agree with @Ninjastyle124 .

  • PROSTE NADHERA..................

    

  • Their solos are a bit too high pitched IMO.

  • nice cover...

  • Sonata Arctica, simply rock. Very nice adaptation.

  • This is fantastic!

  • CHE BELLA...QUASI QUANTO L'ORIGINALE!

  • @blackgirl217 :D italiana? ciau piacere xD comunque concordo ;)

  • @LUXXXable si italiana...amo fade to black e questa versione le rende giustizia! :)

  • @LUXXXable xD ^^

  • Όχι άσχημα.

  • I love metallica and this is not a bad cover. There ' s a lot of cover of metallica songs on youtube but i like to find the ones best =D this is really cute

  • i love wolves

  • @xBlackxMaggotx I love Sonata Arctica! I love them to death!

  • that's fuki,ng awesome holy shit

  • I think SA is the better, but i heard their version first, which probably had an impact on my opinion

  • Beautiful.

  • Pretty good cover :)

  • More ballad-y. I like it :)

  • non dico che debba essere uguale ma questa mi sembra la versione pop dei tokio hotel.............che cagata!!!!

  • eeeeeeppppppppppppiiiiiiiccccc­ccccc!!!!!!!

  •  It's a totally different style guys....I could never listen to a better POWER METAL BALLAD version of this song....!!! It's wonderful from both bands!!!

  • divine.

  • Oh my fucking god, this song is divine

  • i like cover band, cuz sumtimez it has that little difference which makes it sounds great

  • Epic song by an Epic band!!!

  • que buen

    cover

  • 3:22 Here should be an agressive interlude :C

  • i love sonata arctica, but this is the worst cover that i've ever listen, what about the solo? what about the heavy part? WTF!

  • @Caayaaa Implying Metallica is Heavy.

  • @Caayaaa You don't know what a cover is?

  • @Tibiademon555 obviously i know, but come on man, the main solo is the entire song, you cannot kick it away, even if youre a doing a cover

  • @Caayaaa

    Yes you can. It's been done.

  • fucking awesome!!!!!!!!

  • when the music got to the first verse i thought it was pantera i was like, uhh...what the fuck

  • Don't you like this version, just go and listen to original!!!

  • @DsScorpion0 Not sure if warding off haters

    Or being a hater.

  • @Tibiademon555 I don't hate them.. I can understand them, but I asked them not to post such comments here ^^

  • ALL SHUT THE FUCK UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC!

  • My only complaint is that they didn't do their own version of the outro solo. Otherwise, beautiful work Sonata, as always ^.^

  • why coudlnt they made this longer?:<

  • Not bad, but I prefer Metallica's version...

  • 6 stars! Sonata Artica has a more cleaner powerful sound than Metallica on this one.  And I have been a fan of Metallica since I was 14!!! Sorry Metallica...This song goes to them...

  • Only major differece is the better recording quality but that's time's fault

  • Interesting, I have not listened to it yet right now, but wonder what it will be like :D

  • Perfect. awesome. Fantastic.

  • Metallica is overrated, this is proof of it

  • @Ikesmashbros Why? Because many many many bands cover their songs and consider them to be massive influences? ^_^

  • @Evilrex500 Not really, they are way good, but some people just blindly call them gods and hate other bands like SA

  • Comment removed

  • You know what, to all you fucking idiots that say this is too fast, songs Metallica has covered also had their tempo upped up a bit, sometimes when they play live the up the tempo in their own songs, so just STFU.

  • Is it odd that I always picture the guy singing as the bearded dude in this picture? xD

  • @Ygdrasel Absolutely not. In fact, we encourage that sort of thing.

  • the band itself is what you call music!!

  • great song man!!

  • Esa Canción Es De Metallica Maldito Cabrón...

  • @annafso @Ninjastyle124 Both agreed

  • Sonata does this music epic style haters!

  • Wow completely astonished with this version.... so fuckin' good.....

  • this is eargasmic

  • very very nice job!!!different style!!!

  • both versions are totally different and I like both equally

  • @twistsanny Agree.

  • @twistsanny Agree.

  • Sonata Arctallica

  • This band has managed more renown than metallica in the overall scheme of things. Music has come along way since the 70s/80s in the sense that we insist on finding it and not just accepting the popcorn/junkfood music that the money machine keeps throwing at us. Internet has gone a long way in that cause. So is my TOTALLY MUSIC ARTIST CHANNEL. Its a multigenerational rock/metal band support effort. Over 200 bands are official friends in just 6 months! You will not believe the playlists.