With lots of Etudes, they really develop the right hand's technique, but the left hand is what shapes this as a piece in its own right. Without the delicate but present balance of the right hand slightly less projected than the left hand, it seems to loose a little bit of the line for me. Having said that however, technically brilliant!
Me gusta lo que hizo con los ultimos cuatro acordes. Aunque parezca algo sencillo eso se puede hacer de muchas maneras y creo que el ha hallado una muy buena.
Left hand never comes out. Looks and sounds like Kempf was too busy making sure he played all the notes on the right hand to care for the true melody. A disappointment.
Crazy comments. Left hand is melody and short accents not cantabile at all. right hand must be clear and smooth as Czerny but not leggierissimo. those who know say nothing so true at youtube. Most young pianists will play this etude. In many of the etudes melody is given to bass while right hand has a problem to figure out. Kempf 's solutions r so musical so right for Chopin style !
Ho ascoltato questo pianista dal vivo. Una delusione totale.Il suono di questo Kempf (che nenache lontanamente sogna di somigliare al suo ononimo predecessore) è corto e debole. Spesso con degli scatti inaspettati della sinistra che vuole farsi sentire in momenti poco opportuni. Questo video conferma la mia opinione. Pessima esecuzione, mancano morbidezza e fraseggio nella mano sinistra, manca la fluidità nella destra ma non mancano le botte improvvise (da 1'10" a 1'18").
I think its too tense and rudy...The left hand is not "cantabile" enough(only the last frase in Coda really got it,and its really nice),beides,I dont see the reason to lift up the fingers so much(right hand)...just an opinion...I like more Lisitsa version...
@heyyy19 Oh,no doubts -Horowitz is one the best,especially,early recording...There is a nice record of Backhaus,from the whole set,and I think,also,Bleschac (not sure how does it spell)ones,from the competition...
Bastard Chopin! , if some one be in this level there is no need to Etude!!, I don't know why he called it Etude!, Etude should be for poor people like me want to be able to play like this! not for someone this good to play better.,,...................daaaamn
This is an amazing performance. I am still learning this piece, it is one of my favorites of all of Fréderic's etudes... However, not to sound like a douchebag, but I think you could have brought out the left hand melody much more. When the focus is shifted to the left hand's melody, I feel that the song gains much more character and emotion.
C'mon man you're telling the living legend Freddy Kempf what to do? I think he knows what he's doing.. lol jk. I think it has to do with the sound quality of the recording. I'm pretty sure if they set up the mic's in the piano it would sound a lot clearer.
Kempf is one of Russia's favorite pianists for over a decade now.. (And he's married to a Russian woman :-)I've met him at several concerts in Moscow. The Russian audience is blown away each time. One time, he had to come out 4 times to play encore!
Your perfcermance is absolutely natural without efforts(!!!) THANK YOU lots and lots,,, and also I would like to listen to etudes by Liszt,,especially my favorate "Snow Storm" (Shasse Neige)
The harp one isn't so bad actually. I'm starting this one Op. 10 no. 6 now, it's madness! I noticed that you left this message 2 months ago. How's the piece going now?
I have Freddy's etude cd and the playing is much better. This etude in F was Chopin's first. This etude is not that tough if your right hand can "leap". Much easier for me at least than the "Winter Wind".
It's supposed to make you happy xD After all, it isn't nicknamed the "Sunshine" Etude for nothing xD
It was brilliant, (certainly better than my attempts :S) though the beginning trill (hang on... is it even called a trill? I've completely forgotten all my music theory :S) is supposed to be much longer, and he seems to skip notes in the right hand, i think-? Anyway some parts in the right hand sound as if they've been skipped. On the theme, the left hand is supposed to be heard more.
Well I can understand his mistakes, this song is played so quickly that the first page is done in 20 seconds. The right hand is meant to be play non stop, it plays continuously with no pausing and he often skips. But i am not going to penalize his score because I have tried playing this piece and i perform worse than this. This is abruptly a difficult song to play. This piece is truly a pinnacle misunderstanding, its only for the masters of the piano.
I think Freddy Kempf is the offspring of Wilhelm Kempff. Besides both having the musical gene, there's also a physical resemblance if you study their faces. I've not been able to document the connection; perhaps Freddy was not acknowledged. His bio says "German father and Japanese mother", with no reference to Kempff. Likewise Wilhelm's obit mentions five children not named. No reference to having ever been married to a Japanese woman. Perhaps Freddy took his name but changed the spelling?
In Colombia there a man very virtuos. He too play that 24 etudes... HE IS WIHT ZIMERMAN O KEMPF SURE.... SOBRADÍSISMO IS THE BEST PIANIST OF COLOMBIA JUAN DOMINGO CORDOBA AGUDELO. Lo tenemos tan cerca como podemos y no lo vemos. !
I think Freddy Kempf is the offspring of Wilhelm Kempff. Besides both having the musical gene, there's also a physical resemblance if you study their faces. I've not been able to document the connection; perhaps Freddy was not acknowledged. His bio says "German father and Japanese mother", with no reference to Kempff. Likewise Wilhelm's obit mentions five children not named. No reference to having ever been married to a Japanese woman. Perhaps Freddy took his name but changed the spelling?
Yeah, I know...but no one ever plays it like that. I think Chopin meant that those notes needed to be heard and stressed for the purpose of rhythm, not really accents though.
With lots of Etudes, they really develop the right hand's technique, but the left hand is what shapes this as a piece in its own right. Without the delicate but present balance of the right hand slightly less projected than the left hand, it seems to loose a little bit of the line for me. Having said that however, technically brilliant!
monobrow638 7 months ago
Me gusta lo que hizo con los ultimos cuatro acordes. Aunque parezca algo sencillo eso se puede hacer de muchas maneras y creo que el ha hallado una muy buena.
I like the final chords, a fine ending
unydosytresycua 11 months ago
Left hand never comes out. Looks and sounds like Kempf was too busy making sure he played all the notes on the right hand to care for the true melody. A disappointment.
bontempo01 1 year ago
@bontempo01
Very true. Neither I don't hear the left hand's melody and I don't consider myself deaf.
NewRachmaninoff 1 month ago
Crazy comments. Left hand is melody and short accents not cantabile at all. right hand must be clear and smooth as Czerny but not leggierissimo. those who know say nothing so true at youtube. Most young pianists will play this etude. In many of the etudes melody is given to bass while right hand has a problem to figure out. Kempf 's solutions r so musical so right for Chopin style !
lovesGenet 1 year ago
I notice Chopin uses this technique in a lot of his pieces, such as black keys.
Nocturne2000 1 year ago
Ho ascoltato questo pianista dal vivo. Una delusione totale.Il suono di questo Kempf (che nenache lontanamente sogna di somigliare al suo ononimo predecessore) è corto e debole. Spesso con degli scatti inaspettati della sinistra che vuole farsi sentire in momenti poco opportuni. Questo video conferma la mia opinione. Pessima esecuzione, mancano morbidezza e fraseggio nella mano sinistra, manca la fluidità nella destra ma non mancano le botte improvvise (da 1'10" a 1'18").
keenanrol 1 year ago
Really good performance of this difficult etude. Thank you for your upload!
AntipovSvyatoslav 1 year ago
I think its too tense and rudy...The left hand is not "cantabile" enough(only the last frase in Coda really got it,and its really nice),beides,I dont see the reason to lift up the fingers so much(right hand)...just an opinion...I like more Lisitsa version...
pincheruso 1 year ago
@pincheruso What do you think of the Horowitz version? I've listened to Lisitsa and the Horowitz version and I like the Horowitz one the best.
heyyy19 1 year ago
@heyyy19 Oh,no doubts -Horowitz is one the best,especially,early recording...There is a nice record of Backhaus,from the whole set,and I think,also,Bleschac (not sure how does it spell)ones,from the competition...
pincheruso 1 year ago
this is like, wtf hard
llethaface1 1 year ago
Bastard Chopin! , if some one be in this level there is no need to Etude!!, I don't know why he called it Etude!, Etude should be for poor people like me want to be able to play like this! not for someone this good to play better.,,...................daaaamn
Amiramid 1 year ago 6
This is an amazing performance. I am still learning this piece, it is one of my favorites of all of Fréderic's etudes... However, not to sound like a douchebag, but I think you could have brought out the left hand melody much more. When the focus is shifted to the left hand's melody, I feel that the song gains much more character and emotion.
LordFrankencock 1 year ago
C'mon man you're telling the living legend Freddy Kempf what to do? I think he knows what he's doing.. lol jk. I think it has to do with the sound quality of the recording. I'm pretty sure if they set up the mic's in the piano it would sound a lot clearer.
JayIvory87 1 year ago
horowitz sad that this etude is for left hand... not right !
BoristheONEandonly 1 year ago
The left hand is certainly what makes this piece hard D:
Haeronthegreat 1 year ago
so effortless O_O
TayuyaCS2 2 years ago
Just love his interpretation so much. A lot of things can be learned from this video when I practice daily.
etudestableaux39 2 years ago
Kempf is one of Russia's favorite pianists for over a decade now.. (And he's married to a Russian woman :-)I've met him at several concerts in Moscow. The Russian audience is blown away each time. One time, he had to come out 4 times to play encore!
jazzovayamachia 2 years ago 13
he has beautiful hands
eugatm 2 years ago 10
wtf
Avada10 2 years ago 4
lol.. he does
eugatm 2 years ago
My 2. experience with the comments that just made my day XD "he has beatiful hands" -> "wtf" xD xD xD
horekar 2 years ago
The piano seems to trap him.
perhapsforever 2 years ago
this is infinite level.
whoopsforgotmypiano 2 years ago
I like those arpeggios at the end. Nevermind - I love the whole piece, and the whole performance!
IrenkaKaspar 2 years ago
what level is this piece?
pierolivier111 2 years ago
bsd level
dudusmoreira 2 years ago
I think this is the hardest etude personally, more difficult than Op. 10 no. 1 and 2 even. Great job!
scottturner1994 2 years ago
nooo..... it was quite easy for me to learn this etude....op.10; no.1; C major is much more difficult
BoristheONEandonly 2 years ago
@BoristheONEandonly
Agreed.
LordFrankencock 1 year ago
sunshine
stradavarius 2 years ago 3
i think they deliberately filmed this from the left side of the piano to emphasize the left hand.
sauternety36 2 years ago
i love the sound !!
gcaee 2 years ago
This is a lovely version, but i think that Lisitsa's is better.
Alejandro270193 2 years ago
I LOVE KEMPF!!!!!
gracegirl09 2 years ago 2
If I had that piano and that haircut I could do that! Haha nah he's amazing, I couldn't play like him
UnwrittenPaul 2 years ago 6
y'a rien à faire je ne peux pas le voir en peinture ce pianiste !
tchebinai71 2 years ago
Your perfcermance is absolutely natural without efforts(!!!) THANK YOU lots and lots,,, and also I would like to listen to etudes by Liszt,,especially my favorate "Snow Storm" (Shasse Neige)
natasha0610 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i HATE the cinematography. it's overstated and obscene. the audio is pretty shitty to.
mdoub 3 years ago
I was going to leave a comment saying he needs to hire an audio engineer...
I couldn't imagine spending 10,000 hours of my life on the piano and not even care about my work being displayed with this audio quality.
itsanthonyhere 2 years ago
why do you talk of your mother?
pian000 2 years ago
fantastic piece. I'm working on it now, but i'm not anywhere close 2 playing it this well.
i gave up on working on the harp one, it was too hard
Ly1212 3 years ago
Op25 No.1 is easier than this though...good luck with this one.
trigalg693 3 years ago
The harp one isn't so bad actually. I'm starting this one Op. 10 no. 6 now, it's madness! I noticed that you left this message 2 months ago. How's the piece going now?
ds280608 2 years ago
Bravo!!
Simmijenn 3 years ago 2
I have Freddy's etude cd and the playing is much better. This etude in F was Chopin's first. This etude is not that tough if your right hand can "leap". Much easier for me at least than the "Winter Wind".
PianoClassMan 3 years ago
cool?
pian000 3 years ago
cool?
47834783 3 years ago
It's supposed to make you happy xD After all, it isn't nicknamed the "Sunshine" Etude for nothing xD
It was brilliant, (certainly better than my attempts :S) though the beginning trill (hang on... is it even called a trill? I've completely forgotten all my music theory :S) is supposed to be much longer, and he seems to skip notes in the right hand, i think-? Anyway some parts in the right hand sound as if they've been skipped. On the theme, the left hand is supposed to be heard more.
LianiVine 3 years ago
i <3 you
pian000 3 years ago
Huh? Why?
LianiVine 3 years ago
i<3you
47834783 3 years ago
Love this etude! It's definately my favourite!!
r19rsi 3 years ago
my favorite of chopin's etudes
hammer29106 3 years ago
this song makes me so happy
pian000 3 years ago 3
Well I can understand his mistakes, this song is played so quickly that the first page is done in 20 seconds. The right hand is meant to be play non stop, it plays continuously with no pausing and he often skips. But i am not going to penalize his score because I have tried playing this piece and i perform worse than this. This is abruptly a difficult song to play. This piece is truly a pinnacle misunderstanding, its only for the masters of the piano.
Drbolla345 3 years ago
like me ?
pian000 3 years ago
like me?
47834783 3 years ago
shutup you annoying person, and enjoy the music
mvs1312 3 years ago
I just got done taking a shower!
i love this video Y0
Changmin51191 3 years ago
Average performance. Nothing special or memorable about it.
badfan3 3 years ago
great feeling. Right hand seems to be unclear/skips notes occasionally, though i'd be happy myself to work up to his level of technique
ezpiman 3 years ago
I love this piece, and he plays it beautifully, thanks for posting this!
scottturner1994 3 years ago
heyy is this wil. kempf's descendent?
henrypurcell111 3 years ago
I think Freddy Kempf is the offspring of Wilhelm Kempff. Besides both having the musical gene, there's also a physical resemblance if you study their faces. I've not been able to document the connection; perhaps Freddy was not acknowledged. His bio says "German father and Japanese mother", with no reference to Kempff. Likewise Wilhelm's obit mentions five children not named. No reference to having ever been married to a Japanese woman. Perhaps Freddy took his name but changed the spelling?
NicoleKatri 3 years ago
I like it a lot! He takes the time he needs to make some music! He breaths, i like the phrasing, he es clear, all the notes are clear. I like it
CarlaUY 3 years ago
In Colombia there a man very virtuos. He too play that 24 etudes... HE IS WIHT ZIMERMAN O KEMPF SURE.... SOBRADÍSISMO IS THE BEST PIANIST OF COLOMBIA JUAN DOMINGO CORDOBA AGUDELO. Lo tenemos tan cerca como podemos y no lo vemos. !
zetangie 3 years ago
Zimerman>Kempf (obviously)
rankfrankrank 3 years ago
you're right,but he plays well,too.
piano0989 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
A 15 y.o. student of mine plays it wayyy better.
giuliacap 4 years ago
This piece sounded really lively and fun!
PJmusicFan 4 years ago
is he the son of wilhelm kempff?
heroicpolonaise 4 years ago
wilhelm Kempff has 2 f's and Freddy Kempf has 1 f
huatut123 4 years ago
I think Freddy Kempf is the offspring of Wilhelm Kempff. Besides both having the musical gene, there's also a physical resemblance if you study their faces. I've not been able to document the connection; perhaps Freddy was not acknowledged. His bio says "German father and Japanese mother", with no reference to Kempff. Likewise Wilhelm's obit mentions five children not named. No reference to having ever been married to a Japanese woman. Perhaps Freddy took his name but changed the spelling?
NicoleKatri 3 years ago
i think in the beginning you started out really well--but you started slowing down after the first three measures
have you heard of Elena Kuschnerova's rendition of this piece? it's fantastic--clear and rapid
but still you played amazingly
simplypianissimo 4 years ago
the first three measures ends after about 8 seconds
boratanice 3 years ago
he's slow
amelialw 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It doesn't flow...more dynamics would be better
aldebussy 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nothing special. Sounds like a final year student. too many accents and not clear enough.
nostromissimo 4 years ago
you are a moron!
bcggx2 4 years ago 2
Accents? Chopin marked the first semiquaver of every group of four with an accent. It's in the score. It's not meant to be an even tone all the way.
prismsmiles 3 years ago
Yeah, I know...but no one ever plays it like that. I think Chopin meant that those notes needed to be heard and stressed for the purpose of rhythm, not really accents though.
BachFong11 3 years ago 2
Keep these videos coming! I want the complete Chopin Etudes
kenplaysviola 4 years ago
Excellent - with passion
HobokenXVI 4 years ago 4
I love the etudes. They're so impressive. I have to play them soon.
Musicman180 4 years ago
Not so great on this piece as Dmitry Poperno, but it was good nonetheless. (though he was rather slow)
Havenscope 4 years ago
ya i agree he's a bit slow on this piece.
ThunderJacky 4 years ago
great ! so clear
pianocesar 5 years ago
Wow! What a pianist! Those fingers...! Wonderful!
TolBy 5 years ago 3
Thanks for all the videos you uploaded of Freddy Kempf!
I liked them all!
MoonTribe 5 years ago 3
Keep em coming please!Thanks!
LVB1770 5 years ago