Added: 4 years ago
From: tcnole
Views: 158,582
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (444)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She sings it effortlessly! Wow! Sebastian cannot sing it that good live, even back in the day. Studio enhancements made people think he could hold that huge note. Nope! The biggest thing he's famous for is getting hit in the head with a bottle.

  • I'd say she kills it. Nice to see a chick singing it. Let's not forget SB nailed in the studio but live he screamed it and now he can't even do 40% of it...lol

  • I like Carrie but instead of chasing Sebastian Bach's nuts, she should have done something original with the song.

  • fuck u bitch

  • She has a hard time singing it and she's a woman! Just imagine that it was sung by a man originally! Incredible!

  • @matzchase

    Whats incredible is your lack of hearing. She nails this song with ease, just cause she gives her all doesnt mean she is struggling. Bach doesnt come close to her flawless performance, his voice is raspy and ugly...

  • @matzchase

    What are you trying to say besides that you are a dick?

  • @tom9730 Awww....did I hurt your feelings? What I was really trying to say is Fuck You.

  • Not bad! I think she's out of breath.. Sebastian by all means has this hands down!

  • I have never been a fan of hers and now I never will be. agghhh

  • For your information Epica124, I'm quite well traveled. Thanks to the U.S. Marine Corps I have been fortunate to experience many cultures, many art forms and many artists in many countries, too many to list here. Spain in particular has several of my favorite artists. But I won't retract the fact that Sebastian Bach is not merely as you put it "good". In his prime he was phenominal. If you can't see that then I question your taste. Advice: don't bring a stick to a gun fight kid.

  • wow she does it all so cute

  • Sebastian Bach had the best rock voice.  Gotta say Freddy Mecury had the best all around voice. JMO1

  • Go carrie fav female country singer!!!!

  • THIS VIDEO JUST CHANGED MY LIFE!!!!!!

  • Still think Sebastian Bach is better. But if she lifts up her shirt, I might change my mind.

  • @gillettecrackers Plus she needs to be angrier.  I like angry sex.

  • @gillettecrackers Haha well said

  • Killer Job, Shes Awsome, Tough Song To Nail But She Did It!!

  • @bHuffy82 it's true, Sabastian can't hit the high notes that well anymore. Still one of the greatest voices in rock though.

  • God I love this woman!!

  • See That! Young Musicians Know What Real Music Is! Big Ups Carrie!

  • beautiful song.. beautiful woman

  • i agree. this song has to be done wit passion. her passion is prefabricated.

  • Sounds like karaoke. This song needs to have raw passion and desperation in the vocals and it's not here.

  • She hits all the right notes but she doesn't have the right tone in her voice to pull this off. This song is supposed to be screamed in a super raspy voice by a guy who smoked way too many cigarettes. Also, the guitar solo lacked feeling in this one. But this is an acceptable cover of this song. But that's about all it is- it's acceptable.

  • which gives me anger is that many idiots think that this song is from her and neither must know who is really skid row

  • It is not surprising to see other people covering Skid Row songs, or a ton of other songs, for that matter. Most singers all get their starts by singing cover songs that were originally done by others. Sebastian's and Skid Row's original version will always be the best, but I have to admit Carrie did a pretty good job on this song- and I am by no means a Carrie Underwood fan.

  • I wasn't at the concert but I could hear it, my friend and I would sit in her parents back yard and we could hear the concert pretty good.....would have been better to see it too, but hey if was free and we did see stars....they were in the sky, but start none the less LOL.

  • That was very good. Bach can't even sing this song that good now.

  • @tkojams.....Do you know how absurd your comment sounds? Any clue?

  • @bHuffy82 Do some searches on you tube and listen to him sing it. Try this one "Sebastian Bach at M3 Rock Festival 2011 - I Remember You "

  • Comment removed

  • fuck all of you!!!!!!!1 so what if she is covering all those bands.she is paying honor to those great artist. dont hate just because you dont have talent.

  • Great song and AMAZING singer...

  • Comment removed

  • It's a testament to Sebastian Bach that the only person that could come close to his vocals is one of the most talented FEMALE singers of our time. Carrie does a good job here but nobody, absolutely nobody, could do this song better than Sebastian did in his original.

  • @TheWiseBull Do you have any idea how many metal singer out there can do it better then Sebastian? Sure he is good but really get of the the USA is the only place singers horse. There are many singer out there female wise there would kick Carries ass and many male signers that put Sebastian to shame. Unless you are willing to listen to singer that are not just based in the USA you have no more to talk about great talent.

  • Ok just off the top of my head...Motley Crue Home Sweet Home,GnR Patience,Paradise City,Sweet Child O Mine,November Rain,Sid Row I Remember You,The Pretenders I'll Stand By You..Sure I missed a few but theres 7 not just 4,you get the point....stale and boring

  • She does too many covers,GnR,Heart and the list goes on.Lack of original ideas=Remakes, just ask Hollywood.

  • @144church The hell she does. She's done what, 4 covers in all different concerts? They're not on any of her albums which she has about 4 out now. She has a lot more original songs than covers.

  • @Danklin24 Just found 2 more that makes 9 Home Sweet Home and Kickstart my Heart by Motley Crue

  • @Danklin24 Gnr Patience,Sweet Child O Mine,Paradise City,November Rain,The Pretenders I'll Stand By You,Skid Row I Remember You...Sorry 8 I'm sure I'm missing several but why cover something if you can't touch the original?Lack of material.

  • Well....she tried. Not too bad, but not anywhere near the power needed to belt out this ballad, not even close.

  • WOW! I can't believe she did that great!

  • sebastain's real name is sebastain berk by the way

    over all not a bad performance should have done a duet with bass though

  • sebastain's real name is sebastain berk by the way

  • I'm sorry but Carrie trying to hit those notes shows she's not much of a singer..Any talent contest winner can blow her away,but its all about the image and feel so...

  • @SanEverett Just shows how stupid you really are! LMAO!

  • @SanEverett Just shows how stupid you really are! LMAO! BAZ should be proud! He and Axl were two of the greastest rock singers of all time. BOTH pissed it off! EGO I guess! Have you heard Baz try to sing country? LMFAO! He sucks! Atleast she can cover thier songs! And does a GREAT job doing it! And I LOVE Skid Row! GNR, You name it! Get off whatever shit you are on and appreicate this girl paying homage!

  • @sdlake Hey dumbass you might try understanding what I said before you show how retarded you are..

  • Country fans like skid rows version too they just won't admit it lol!

  • WHATTTA!!! Carrie sounds so perfect..she should record 80s rock kind of music..if she goes into rock pop,,she will be definitely the best on its genre

  • If it were not for a TV show she is singing "do you want fries with that" If she had talent she would have been discovered the way Sebastian was. Karaoke Queen at BEST.

  • nice 1 carrie..singing my favorite song!!!love it!!

  • she gets by with her looks. no complaints.

  • Bach does not sing this better LIVE. Carrie sings it dead on the the studio version, Bach can't do that. That's pretty impressive! Plus singing it here in the states keeps it current while Bach is an 80's has been, who's only popular now in Prague.

  • @VegasChaChing Are you fucking high?

  • all smoke no fire, sebastian or nuttin.....

  • Love you sweety

  • No just no

  • I guess I'm not sure why everything has to be a fight or a comparison. Sebastian is amazing, one of my all time favorites....... but Carrie did an incredible job of covering a very difficult song........ hats off to both.

  • Lol Bach sang it better.

  • MAKES ME NOT CHIKENS SKIN LIKE WHEN SEBASTIAN SINGS THIS SONG, CARRIE SORRY BUT YOU NEED SOMETHING, THE MUSIC IS NOT JUST A NICE VOICE, YOU NEED SOMETHING THAT IS CALLED "TALENT"

  • @marceconde5

    Wtf do you know about music or TALENT for that much? what are your accolades?

    Carrie has 13 str8 number 1's some of which she co-wrote. Her voice is not just "nice" its a 1 in a million voice, that doesnt go flat or EVER sound strained. She is the biggest selling AI winner, most popular. Won almost every award possible from grammies to industry picks, to PEOPLE choice awards.

    Finally Sebastian himself, loves her cover.... So Again who are you?

    Just a troll behind his computer.

  • @ChilenoPiscean22 I wont talk to ignorant people who like the lack of talent,I realize u dont know nothin bout music,I'll tell you what kid, the music isnt only a nice voice or one in a million voice as u said,anyone can bcome a singer with a voice not so good,carrie doesnt transmit me anything,I'm tired of always hearing the same voices, maybe i dont know about music but you dont know what the music is,then WHO ARE U?

    an ignorant who only like a nice voice, best of luck to u, keep going

  • @marceconde5

    I play 2 intruments, clarinet and trumpet. I write poetry which could be music.

    Secondly you DO not read, you cherry picked what i wrote and read it, you OBVIOUSLY lack the abilty to grasp something in it's entirety. Another reason why you dont know NOTHING about music, because every musician KNOWS to read EVERY line of music, they dont cherry pick what to read like you.

    SEONDLY your messages make NO sense, learn to write proper sentences that make sense.

  • @ChilenoPiscean22 first you are a stupid and you dont play any instrument, but if you do, im sure that YOU SUCK because you listen a nice voice n u think that is music, stupid ignorant you dont know nothing about music, you want to, but you cant because you are stupid n you like carrie underwood n every stupid of AI

    Secondly, SUCK MY DICK

  • @marceconde5

    I listen to a nice voice and think its good music? I like this song, thats why i listen to it. Cause carrie is a WAY better singer then sebastian. I know you idiots like hearing a CRACKING voice due to smoking and hard drugs and liquor BUT FOR ME i do NOT enjoy that type of voice. Carrie sings better then sebastian PERIOD. You one of those idiots who will NEVER accept another singer, because you so in love with his cock you ALREADY thought she sucked BEFORE even hearing her sing.

  • @ChilenoPiscean22 AND PLEASE SHUT THE FUCK UP BECAUSE I WONT HEAR NO MORE THIS FUCKIN VERSION OF THIS MASTERPIECE BY SKID ROW

  • @marceconde5

    BTW idiot, she plays intruments as well as write music and SINGS. Yea she has no talent...even thou she won the BIGGEST talent show possible, with MILLIONS AND MILLIONS of people voting her NUMBER1.

    You can talk all the shit you want about her, at the end of the day she is the LEADING artist in her field.

    She is popular, rich and famous NOT too mention GORGEOUS.

    You? your nothing. You have nothing. and WILL never be nothing in music. Just a loser calling talented people names.

  • @ChilenoPiscean22 i wont be no one in music stupid fuck, thats way im nothing, but you are less than nothing because you study music but u r so stupid n ignorant that u never be no one, keep listening this shit, you n all of her fans ignorants

    keep going ignorant, you will be no one, keep studying but you never be anyone in life, best of luck

    and u will never change my thinkin of her, HER COVERS, "MUSIC" IS SHIT ! ! ! !

    PLEASE STOP COVER CARRIE "NO TALENT" UNDERWOOD winner of shit between shit

  • Comment removed

  • Awesome! LOVE her! I like when she covers rock songs! :D

    

  • not her best...but damn she looks good in those jeans!

  • average singer

  • @emrah309

    Yeah, average......even though she has sold untol millions and millions of albums, won dozens and dozens of awards, she's still just "average." Get a clue. 

  • why did she hold the guitar in the beginning? to show off? unnecessary moment

  • The guitar player sucks. He should be ashamed of himself. You can watch any bar band playing this song and they would kick his ass.

  • I take my hat off to her!! One of my favourite songs ever...and she nailed it. She didn't try and stuff around with it, didn't try and do it her way.....just sung the damn song like it's always been sung. Well done Carrie....very impressed.

  • Sebastian should do a duet with her......only problem is, he'd have her in his hotel room that night! lol

  • Bruce Dickinson is the only one who could top both versions (original plus this cover), I believe. He has the range, we'd just have to see the softness.

  • @Sycopre ever heard sebastians cover of children of the damned? killsss itttt, as much as i love bruce and maiden, bach is the best forever.. and ever

  • @KramerW5150 When I found his cover, I was all "holy shit that's so awesome!"

    But it's not the same. It didn't have the same appeal, Bach was made to sing Glam Rock and not Heavy Metal.

  • Hey Carrie... quit reading the words, and look to your left... you have fans over there too!

  • oh wow i was watching skid row didnt expect to see this. i had no idea she covers this song..damn awesome cover she did great job

  • I knew you had a little metal in you Carrie

  • skid row :P

    love that band

  • great cover, still I'd rather hear the skid row version, just sayin..

  • Rock on girl. I love it.

  • Man, She did a great job on this song! Is there anything she can't do?

  • She does a really good job with the song, but it's funny to see that girls are supposed to have a better vocal range in the higher notes and she still can't top sebastian bach lol.

  • Great cover, Carrie :) You do have a great voice for rock.

  • who is on the guitar? (solo)

  • Carrie, I know you have many country fans but I'm a metal fan and I would love if you started singing metal....but you'd have to change your clothes lol

    Awesome, Awesome job Carrie. This coming from a huge Sebastian Bach fan...notice how I didn't say Skid Row fan rofl

  • Sebastian Bach already said that he thought Carrie did an awesome job with the song.

  • Not rsapy enough but nice..

  • Sorry she just dont have the same magic as Sebastian Bach has. no can Rock that

    Like Sebastian Bach

  • Wow....That was really awesome. I saw Skid Row in Sacramento in 90'. I tell ya, Carrie nailed it. Is one of my favorite songs and am honored to have her respecfully pour her heart in a song that I though ONLY Sebastian Bach could achieve. Fu#k, I sound old, lol!!

  • I would only enjoy this if she was sitting on top of me!!!!

  • nothing beats Sebastian Bach!!! NOTHING!

  • @metalDCM8 i agree the best fucking singer or hardrock

  • wow this album was so good too bad scottie and snake couldnt follow it up far as sebastion goes ddint you see that power group show sheesh even had uncle ted going

  • I can't hear someone else singing this song we all know that it belongs to sebastien bash besides she didn't sing it well

  • @SuperLola1993

    Pfft stfu you hater, She sounded amaizng, iMO beter then the guy live, HE SUCKS LIVE!

  • @SuperLola1993 His name is Sebastian Bach not Sebastien Bash, and if you can't hear someone else singing it, why did you watch the video? Not trying to be rude here, just curious. As for me, this song will never have the same meaning or, obviously, sound the same without Sebastian's vocals, however, I think Carrie did an amazing job.

  • @H65Laura  yah she did

  • @H65Laura I agree. No-one can get the same amount of emotion into the song as Bach, but she does an amazing damn job!

  • @H65Laura

    I totally agree with you. I however think it is awesome to see someone like Carrie Underwood covering this song. Sebastian Bach even said he liked her version better...he might just be trying to score though.

  • @ 2:37 Lemmy leaves, looking distinctly unimpressed.

  • Bitch fuckin ruined this song for me

  • Geez, can't anybody do the pinch harmonics in the guitar solo?

  • It only lacks two things, long hair, and a bit more hard rock..

  • what the hell the video cuts off at the best part of the song

  • wish she would cut loose and let herself rock out. sound like that might be something good

  • wow. i am actually impressed.

  • @brian445 JAJAJAJAJAJAJAJA

  • @ponshi Is that all spicks can say??

    What? you monkey's can't speak???

  • It sucks that no guys can sing song except Sebastian!!!

  • @MrGangstaman96 if ur talkin about this song check out Aaron Lewis of Staind do this

  • Carrie Underwood sucks!  Corporate media sheep!

  • @RussX5Z BHAHHAHA. yea right bud. Farm girl is now a corporate sheep.... She is just doiing what she loves AND she doesnt sing about sex drug violence... Idiot

  • @ChilenoPiscean22 But she's all glam up like most country acts of today. All about beauty, sex appeal, money, fame, popularity, same shit. And her voice isn't even all that great. Have you heard the song "Casanova Cowboy? The lyrics to that song is ridiculous. Loretta Lynn, Hank Williams, Charlie Daniels Band, Buck Owens, now that's real country and honky tonk from the heart!

  • @RussX5Z

    wow, she grow up on a farm with LITTLE to no glam, so what now that she is big, she is not allowed to wear a little make-up,jewerelly, nice dress.... She is a woman formost, so you CANT tell a woman not to try and look beautiful, second she is part of a bussiness that puts alot of importance on physcial beauty.

    That doesnt mean in her mind, she thinks she is hot shit, or she walks around thinking she is better then anyone else.

  • @ChilenoPiscean22 Okay fine then.  Today's music industry and media is SHIT!! Goddamn it! And its getting shit on day by day. Which is a good thing. Lindsay Lohan is a good example. The cooperate assholes need to DIE!! I'm done ranting. :)

  • @RussX5Z shut uip

  • Wow everytime I see her sing cover tunes of Rock and Metal, I am just blown away by her singing. Now I wish I could go and see her in concert. She is just amazing. Very talented young woman. I am going to have to listen to her country stuff now. :)

  • I'm not really a fan of Carrie Underwood coz i don't like country music. not until now that she has her own cover of I Remember You.. she's great, she can hit the high notes and pitch. sounds like a female version of Sebastian... she even did a great rendition compared to Salinger. .. hahah!

  • i love Sebastian Bach, i love skid row not until Johnny Salinger came.. I'm not against him but Seb does better. good job Carrie!

  • i wish she sang rock. it would make it that much better. i don't like country but hell at least you need a voice unlike these shitty disney bands

  • lol she does skid row great !!!!!!!!!!!

  • when was this ?

  • look she is very very cute and she has a really good voice and i commend her for singing this great skid row song but why doesn't she just sing rock music i mean i see she is singing so many rock songs why don't you release a rock album i hate when people try to cross over into different genre's she sings this good but man i am a rock singer and you need a certain voice for this not every one can sing rock and not every one can sing country

  • Comment removed

  • Tava com a porra do violão só pra fazer pose no começo? POSER Ridícula, mas canta muito bem...

  • \m/

  • This just made her 10x HOTTER! One of the hardest friggin songs to sing...sorry but no one can nail it like Sebastian.

  • She sings this perfectly. Her stage presence has improved so much since then, though. I'd love to see her perform this at one of her Play On shows.

  • okay, NOW i love her....

  • carrie underwood & sebastian bach should do this in studio as a duet

  • She can't support the notes like Sebastian does but she did a good job .

  • @sunnfun agreed. Normally i am not a fan of covers...but this wasn't so bad. Skid row's version will always be superior.

  • WOW good job Carrie, one of my fav ballads, and she just rocked it!!!

  • became a carrie underwood fan after watching this cover along with her gnr covers

  • @hcallahan44 lol same here best covers i heard of ANY of those songs

  • awesome!

  • country girl singing rock is such a turn on !!!!!!!!!

  • @djacksonc Thanks for agreeing with me man, and since you brought me back to this vid it reminded me that this is really fucking hot seeing Carrie sing Bach's song.

  • i miss the real sebastian bach voice

  • EXCELLENT !!!!!

  • I really don't understand why all the pop singers today have guitars. You can't even hear them, the guy behind her to the right was playing that intro not her. Is this some kind of ploy to make them look cooler? Just makes them look stupid.

  • @AnimosityGMC Yeah, it's a slap in the face to the fans... either play it or don't...  and don't play for 20 seconds and get rid of the guitar.

  • she does a pretty good job considering no one has pipes like sabastian did back in the day

  • actually, she did her best...but it's not enough to sing this song....i miss sabastian bach....

  • I love this chick. I love that she does rock songs in her shows.. It lets me know how cool she is and how she needs to be my girl,lol

  • Wow, what a beautiful ass she has! :o)

  • good job.,.,.so hot......

  • Nice job on this classic Bach tune

  • I love watching chicks struggle singing notes originally sung by a guy. Bas struggles live big time, but no ones going to top his voice, why try?

  • I just acquired wood..and that's not underwood

  • HEY SABASTIAN! Eat your heart out man...ha ha ha

  • WOW!!! I hate country music, but carrie did an excellent job of this, I am very surprised. Carrie really is a lot better than that fake bitch Taylor Swift. And judging by this video I think Sebatian Bach would agree with me, and probably so would Kanye lol

  • I don't tend to listen to any female singers, call me a sexist but I've read that Taylor Swift at the age of 14 is the youngest staff songwriter ever hired by the Sony/ATV Tree publishing house. So the kid probably deserves it.

  • @hangar187 this isnt't country music LOL... this is glam metal

  • @hangar187 How rude, Taylor Swift is living her dream and she's one of the nicest people you would ever meet, I have met her I would know! Yes Carrie did a great job (Not nearly as good as Bach) but it's beside the point. Did you have to include that terrible comment! Why don't you try to sing, your the fake bitch, hiding behind your computer screen enjoying your pringles judging others because your a terrible personalized and looking person, you have an ugly soul!

  • @hangar187 i agree country blows but she does this decent...not bad at all.

  • what the point of holding a guitar for 30sec and stop playing?

  • @3itachi3 so you dont look like a boring asshole during the acoustic parts, duh

  • man carrie loves all the old sleeze metal,makes her that much hotter