Pfft. Goth strikes me as the sort of sub-culture that would suffer if too many people joined it. I've heard it describe as being fond of the sort of things that the rest of society throws aside - what would that be if society joined the goths? I can almost understand those "Goths are evil!" thoughts, but I don't hate others for it.
im thirteen too and i know them. I cannot seem to find their cds anywhere. im not goth im more of a mix between tomboy and medieval goth but i prefer not to slap a label on me. And i guess it is true todays kids think evanescence or stuff like linkin park is goth(not saying i dnt listen to them) when stuff like this is goth. and are you kidding?? most of the music i listen to is ethreal bands like this or lorenna mckennitt!!!
I came here looking for "morose dirge" and found support for the new generation of Goth of which I am part of, in addition to this beautifully mournful song. Thank you fellow Goths, whatever type you are.
I am 44 and remember real GOTH. Goth, in general, died in the 90's and only a small handful of true goth bands survived. These dumb ass teenagers walking around all in black lipstick and all that crap couldn't tell real goth from the music played by an ice cream truck, and, essentially, have missed the whole point of true goth.
@whatwouldjudydo You should be supporting the babybats and teaching them. Not saying, "goth is dead", because everything changes, and change is an important thing. The best thing to do is support them through their teenage angst phase and showing them the real world and what little of the sub-culture is still left.
yes... the ingredients that go into every one of Taco Bell's mouthwatering menu items are indeed like the wealth of emotions that go into each and every Projekt release. The juicy ground beef is the honesty, the melting cheese is the longing, the tostadas and tortillas hold all the desires we feel within, and the fire sauce IS the burning of our inner-most yearning! Yes... a Projekt release truly represents The Crunchwrap Supreme that exists in us all!!!!!
I can play one note on the keyboard...drive 12 blocks to the Taco Bell, sit in the drive thru for 30 minutes, go back home and the same note will still be playing.
Lo and behold... another Projekt release from Steve Roacharito!
...Goths are neither bad nor evil... although a goth once stole my Beefy Crunch Box from Taco Bell that I had just bought to eat before going to a Vehemence Realized show... that @#$*ing goth made off with my speed stick too!!!
and about the goths being considered bad xD well, this is goth music, and goths are thought to be bad... then... rap songs should be considered... super hyper evil or what?
I'm 45 and like a wide variety of music....this is incredible....music,writings and film are not evil....actions that are a detriment to humanity are evil.....
I love all your positive comments on my song. You can purchase the album for $6.98 at projekt . com. That would really be nice of you. Support the music you enjoy. Sam
for some reason it reminds me of Gabriel Faure's Pavane. I think is the kind of harmony that has the same decadent quality. Does anybody know if Sam Rosenthal listen to Faure's music?
The sound of magick manifested, capturing your mind in its melody that leads down an enchanted forest... the belly of this forest is the spirit of gaia, and one returns to the scared home that we all belong to.
SHOEGAZERS & GOTHS!!! LETS START A RIVIVAL GO2 JOINMYBAND-point-CO(not point com) ITS ACTUALLY A DOT INSTEAD OF THE WORD point youtube WONT accept website comments SO DO THAT & POST AN ADD 2 START A BAND!!! IM ALREADY STARTING MINE SO GET YOURS. IF WE WANT2 BRING IT BACK IT JUST TAKES PEOPLE 2 COOPERATE SO ACT ON IT I DONT CARE HOW OLD U R JUST FUCKIN GO 4 IT 2 KEEP THE MUSIC WE LOVE ALIVE. THIS SITE ISNT HUGE SO ITS EASY 2 KEEP IN TOUCH. TELL OTHERS 2 DO THE SAME & COPY & PASTE THIS ON 5 VIDEOS
Da Vinci nailed it, when he painted "The Mona Lisa". Do we need another? Be satisfied that BTFABG is and who cares what anyone thinks about Britney Spears?
Why can't more bands be like this one? This style is like nothing I have ever heard before. Why is it that singers like Britney Spears get such mainstream success, yet only a handful of people even know of this band? The masses are blind, but this music lets me know there are likeminded individuals out there...
10 facts 1.Your reading my comment 2. Now your saying/thinking thats a stupid fact. 4. You didnt notice that i skipped 3. 5. Your checking it now. 6. Your smiling. 7. Your still reading my comment. 8. You know all you have read is true. 10. You didnt notice that i skipped 9. 11. Your checking it now. 12. You didnt notice there are only 10 facts Copy and paste to 1 video, tomorrow will be your best day ever! no matter what
may I suggest some underground hip-hop..ie non radio played, non cliched hip-hop. There's some good stuff out there as long as you make a conscious decision to find it. Keep in mind, they don't sound like radio artists in the least which is why they can't get played on the radio
Ethereal gothic music at its best. Maybe if more people of my generation (I'm 42) realized that this is what gothic music is, they wouldn't be so scared of their kids...I'm proud to call myself an "eldergoth", and delighted that the genre I love continues to grow and evolve into haunting beauty like this...
@befuddledman well put i myself am partcial to many forms of goth but i seem to find myself as never getting enough and i think ethereal goth is only one part of a larger most beautiful expression some one asked me the other day if goth was dead and had died in the 90's to which my response was no and even though it at times seems like such a small population it still continues on with pos goth white goth 3erd generation goth and acustic i bow humbly before an elder goth though i am only 27
@462jinks yep you are an elder goth. since you are over the age of 18. i like your comment. goth will never die, but the thing is these kids today have no guidance on what goth really is so they are partly the reason why goth is considered crazy (i don't mean to mock those kids). elder goths should try to help more of these kids. but i guess it is hard getting through to them. :)
@befuddledman i totally agree. since i am a Romantigoth this is the type of music that is listened to, but even though i still love it even if it wasn't. i love hearing about eldergoths (it brightens my day knowing another goth over 20 exists). exactly, this is what gothic music is. none of that manson crap (excuse my language.) but still there are many different types of goth music, but this is goth at its best. love this. and i agree with your comment. :)
Icewald, i belive you are oneof the younger generations of posuer-goths, as theyre called. Listeners of Cradle of Filth and such? You dont have a clue what goth is, its not screaming into a mic or guttoral vocals, its bittersweet and mistifying, gloomy but with hope. So next time you put on ur black polish, think:, Is this who i am? For me, it is.
Dear i suggest you to change your music attitude from metal to techno-rave. Pathetic, You dont have a glue about the beauty of silence. Nice sad song, thanx Jasmine for adding
oh my... what the hell... amy lee sings like shit, maybe she has a good technique and stuff, but her voice is unbearable!!! how can you prefer EVANESCENCE instead of black tape? go to watch mtv
me gusta,,preciosa cancion...wonderfull song like sooo much...mi piace molto questa canzone
oseznopolar 1 week ago
Pfft. Goth strikes me as the sort of sub-culture that would suffer if too many people joined it. I've heard it describe as being fond of the sort of things that the rest of society throws aside - what would that be if society joined the goths? I can almost understand those "Goths are evil!" thoughts, but I don't hate others for it.
This song is beautiful.. <3
moxmortuusdiabolus 6 months ago
im thirteen too and i know them. I cannot seem to find their cds anywhere. im not goth im more of a mix between tomboy and medieval goth but i prefer not to slap a label on me. And i guess it is true todays kids think evanescence or stuff like linkin park is goth(not saying i dnt listen to them) when stuff like this is goth. and are you kidding?? most of the music i listen to is ethreal bands like this or lorenna mckennitt!!!
torrentXofXdarkness 7 months ago
I listened to this cd 4 times in a row yesterday.
DominiqueDiablo777 7 months ago
Please, can some of you give URL of picture in this video???
neon5774 8 months ago
@neon5774 printscreen button, paste it into a paint application and save it as a jpeg, then host it at something like photobucket
MsCandi1369 7 months ago
I love this song, it's my favorite on the album :)
DominiqueDiablo777 8 months ago
I came here looking for "morose dirge" and found support for the new generation of Goth of which I am part of, in addition to this beautifully mournful song. Thank you fellow Goths, whatever type you are.
MutleeIsTheAntiGod 9 months ago
I am 44 and remember real GOTH. Goth, in general, died in the 90's and only a small handful of true goth bands survived. These dumb ass teenagers walking around all in black lipstick and all that crap couldn't tell real goth from the music played by an ice cream truck, and, essentially, have missed the whole point of true goth.
whatwouldjudydo 10 months ago
@whatwouldjudydo You should be supporting the babybats and teaching them. Not saying, "goth is dead", because everything changes, and change is an important thing. The best thing to do is support them through their teenage angst phase and showing them the real world and what little of the sub-culture is still left.
KamiGekido 9 months ago
She must be on break from working the night shift drive though at Taco Bell
KabbalahBelGrande 10 months ago
yes... the ingredients that go into every one of Taco Bell's mouthwatering menu items are indeed like the wealth of emotions that go into each and every Projekt release. The juicy ground beef is the honesty, the melting cheese is the longing, the tostadas and tortillas hold all the desires we feel within, and the fire sauce IS the burning of our inner-most yearning! Yes... a Projekt release truly represents The Crunchwrap Supreme that exists in us all!!!!!
salsawaftingsomewear 10 months ago
I can play one note on the keyboard...drive 12 blocks to the Taco Bell, sit in the drive thru for 30 minutes, go back home and the same note will still be playing.
Lo and behold... another Projekt release from Steve Roacharito!
SteveRoacharito 10 months ago
Havah Gordita
Havah Gordita
Havahhhhhhhhhhhhhh
VidnaObmanacho 10 months ago
...Goths are neither bad nor evil... although a goth once stole my Beefy Crunch Box from Taco Bell that I had just bought to eat before going to a Vehemence Realized show... that @#$*ing goth made off with my speed stick too!!!
salsawaftingsomewear 10 months ago
@salsawaftingsomewear should have hurled a CrunchWrap at him ninja style
KosherCrunchwrap 10 months ago
God... this is almost as dreadful as finding a pubic hair in your enchirito
BlackBeanBlueCorn 10 months ago
reminds me on Faith and the muse without the male voice..Love it!
Reykjaviking 11 months ago
I LOVE THIS!! :)
and about the goths being considered bad xD well, this is goth music, and goths are thought to be bad... then... rap songs should be considered... super hyper evil or what?
Nandanyx 1 year ago
song is about Manchester Citys goalie...
MythicShot 1 year ago
this is not trying to be Goth ~~~ it is Goth ~~~ very damn haunting music ~~~ like to know about the band and singer ~~~ Sam
thankGodforDavidG 1 year ago
I'm 45 and like a wide variety of music....this is incredible....music,writings and film are not evil....actions that are a detriment to humanity are evil.....
smcgillis248 1 year ago 2
The 4 Dislikes on this song need to obviously get their ears cleaned out. This song is so beautiful.
dreamsofelegance 1 year ago 2
wow! just... wow ! this is so soulful, i love it
WalkingDead6six6 1 year ago
Relaxing and for lack of a better word 'angelic'.
Soothing...
ThePoisonDoor 1 year ago
I love all your positive comments on my song. You can purchase the album for $6.98 at projekt . com. That would really be nice of you. Support the music you enjoy. Sam
samrosenthal 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow
beautiful song
I like this, I'm 19.
Where did you get the picture? I'd love to have it it, its so beautiful
xXAlonIntheDarkXx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow
beautiful song
I like this, I'm 19.
Where did you get the picture? I'd love to have it it, its so beautiful
xXAlonIntheDarkXx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow
beautiful song
I like this, I'm 19.
Where did you get the picture? I'd love to have it it, its so beautiful
xXAlonIntheDarkXx 1 year ago
Wow
beautiful song
I like this, I'm 19.
Where did you get the picture? I'd love to have it it, its so beautiful
xXAlonIntheDarkXx 1 year ago
for some reason it reminds me of Gabriel Faure's Pavane. I think is the kind of harmony that has the same decadent quality. Does anybody know if Sam Rosenthal listen to Faure's music?
ptose 1 year ago
dont froget evanescence!!!!
cyclonescythejutsu13 1 year ago
watch my dark videos....peter coukis
toddplum 1 year ago
beautiful music.
Lollipop708 1 year ago
The sound of magick manifested, capturing your mind in its melody that leads down an enchanted forest... the belly of this forest is the spirit of gaia, and one returns to the scared home that we all belong to.
TheBardOfBaphomet 1 year ago
This is what gothic is all about
lazord1991 1 year ago
parcially...
you cant forget deathrock, batcave, goth rock.
Socialantithesis 1 year ago
Just enjoy it... O...o
WOLFNEZIRU 1 year ago
If you like this song, then you might also like "Masked Ball (Eyes Wide Shut) Played Backward". It's in Romanian, but it is very beautiful.
danni13371 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SHOEGAZERS & GOTHS!!! LETS START A RIVIVAL GO2 JOINMYBAND-point-CO(not point com) ITS ACTUALLY A DOT INSTEAD OF THE WORD point youtube WONT accept website comments SO DO THAT & POST AN ADD 2 START A BAND!!! IM ALREADY STARTING MINE SO GET YOURS. IF WE WANT2 BRING IT BACK IT JUST TAKES PEOPLE 2 COOPERATE SO ACT ON IT I DONT CARE HOW OLD U R JUST FUCKIN GO 4 IT 2 KEEP THE MUSIC WE LOVE ALIVE. THIS SITE ISNT HUGE SO ITS EASY 2 KEEP IN TOUCH. TELL OTHERS 2 DO THE SAME & COPY & PASTE THIS ON 5 VIDEOS
birinbirinbirin 1 year ago
this reminds me of my dying bride for some reason
wolfdemon99 1 year ago 2
More more more..this is it..lovely
TheLolitaLune 1 year ago
this is so haunting! reminds me of a cold winters day, with the sunset peaking over the snow---
Quinton111100 2 years ago
peaceful, lovely voice, emotional, and that violin is perfect...i must listen in again
kobazchetina 2 years ago
Comment removed
fadedblu3 2 years ago
i luv them so much i even bought their shirt haha
birinbirinbirin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BORINGGGGG
tyler73074 2 years ago
THIS is real gothic music. Forget screechy heavy metal. :D
thePlagueCat 2 years ago 12
Fucking-a, thank you!
realityfiend12 2 years ago 3
heavy metal with goth is fucking sucks lol
sanguebr 2 years ago
What about Specimen? *Blank stare*
mobscene9305 1 year ago
@mobscene9305 Not my kind of thing, but of course I can't speak for everyone. :)
thePlagueCat 1 year ago
this is real art
^_^
XxKewlxKatxX 2 years ago 10
no words to descripte the quality of this art !
mobyboy 2 years ago 4
I could listen to this song all day long!!
sbrute66 2 years ago 3
one of the best songs ever. I used to dream of love.....
asinyacesar 2 years ago 4
Reminds me of my home.
Lamantzebekk 2 years ago 3
Da Vinci nailed it, when he painted "The Mona Lisa". Do we need another? Be satisfied that BTFABG is and who cares what anyone thinks about Britney Spears?
NickCave13 2 years ago 4
Why can't more bands be like this one? This style is like nothing I have ever heard before. Why is it that singers like Britney Spears get such mainstream success, yet only a handful of people even know of this band? The masses are blind, but this music lets me know there are likeminded individuals out there...
LazarusDrealamant 2 years ago 5
Because they like bands (or singers) that get the most gossip or do the bad stuff.
but a band (or singer) who doesn't do anything bad or get that much gossip is just...well forgotten
(horrible!)
roxzy980 2 years ago
my friends, the top 10 is shit, mainstream yes, but this is what the people(--->mainstream) loves, this wonderful music is for people who loves music
proplayerinc 2 years ago 2
awesome..
dereqferreal 2 years ago 6
more than...
proplayerinc 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
wattaame 2 years ago
Bellissima
8432Sx 2 years ago
It sounds a little like Lacrimosa
curunir11 2 years ago 6
in fact it does, just without her singing with an accent :P
it's so beautiful (Lacrimosa too)
SchwarzesPCSchaf 2 years ago
yeah, a LITTLE bit ;D
proplayerinc 2 years ago
This is beautiful, to say the least.
Whenever someone asks what goth is, I like to share this with them. It immediately washes away all of the "Goths are evil!" thoughts.
IsabellaIrony 2 years ago 39
@IsabellaIrony Also the "Goths only listen to Marylin Manson and Slipknot" mentallity
CybeRogue23 1 year ago
@IsabellaIrony
Goth is mixin with metal now, and u listen all these growling singers...
tikzero 1 year ago
Comment removed
YvesIsaki 2 years ago
tru gothic musik
3li0n 2 years ago 3
This is not depressing, it's more like very quiet and slow, it just calms me down
shadow33abram 2 years ago 8
Thank God real goth exists.
tentwo70 3 years ago 6
yes! im getting tired of the electronic shit nowadays
NYCPulpHero 2 years ago
The Cruxshadows rely heavily on electronics, and they're good.
jpmgmpj 2 years ago 5
I'm getting tired of hip-hop
roxzy980 2 years ago 5
may I suggest some underground hip-hop..ie non radio played, non cliched hip-hop. There's some good stuff out there as long as you make a conscious decision to find it. Keep in mind, they don't sound like radio artists in the least which is why they can't get played on the radio
MrRadaikon 2 years ago
Damn this just wrecked my good mood. I'm off to find me some Kool and the Gang!
GerryDisthename 3 years ago
this is good goth music fuck all of you who say its not
dirpinduty0100 3 years ago
Ethereal gothic music at its best. Maybe if more people of my generation (I'm 42) realized that this is what gothic music is, they wouldn't be so scared of their kids...I'm proud to call myself an "eldergoth", and delighted that the genre I love continues to grow and evolve into haunting beauty like this...
befuddledman 3 years ago 92
Oh, I'm 39 and i think the same. I loved and agree completely with your words.
spetronilho 2 years ago 3
@befuddledman That was such a perfect sumarry Im gonig to subscribe to you. just cause.
MyLordPariah 1 year ago
@befuddledman You rock!!!(:
Most people think goth (not posers) is bad! This is an amazing song(=
2898paula 1 year ago
@befuddledman great comment and i would be proud too if i was an elder goth
Evarose777 1 year ago
@befuddledman I didn't know Alzheimer's set in that early. :o)
SteveRoacharito 10 months ago
@befuddledman well put i myself am partcial to many forms of goth but i seem to find myself as never getting enough and i think ethereal goth is only one part of a larger most beautiful expression some one asked me the other day if goth was dead and had died in the 90's to which my response was no and even though it at times seems like such a small population it still continues on with pos goth white goth 3erd generation goth and acustic i bow humbly before an elder goth though i am only 27
462jinks 9 months ago
@462jinks yep you are an elder goth. since you are over the age of 18. i like your comment. goth will never die, but the thing is these kids today have no guidance on what goth really is so they are partly the reason why goth is considered crazy (i don't mean to mock those kids). elder goths should try to help more of these kids. but i guess it is hard getting through to them. :)
azulrey23 3 months ago
@azulrey23 since when does being +18 have anything to do with being an elder goth...? just curious where you caught this myth^^
IzzieIceRomancer 2 months ago
@befuddledman
I doubt the goth kids of this generation don't even know what Ethereal Gothic music is.
xXAlonIntheDarkXx 7 months ago
@xXAlonIntheDarkXx Iäm 13 and I do =)
obviously lol)
Nutarei 7 months ago
@befuddledman i totally agree. since i am a Romantigoth this is the type of music that is listened to, but even though i still love it even if it wasn't. i love hearing about eldergoths (it brightens my day knowing another goth over 20 exists). exactly, this is what gothic music is. none of that manson crap (excuse my language.) but still there are many different types of goth music, but this is goth at its best. love this. and i agree with your comment. :)
azulrey23 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
im sad. some1 msg me on msn. L
bbista 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my boobslook WAY better. goto my profile and msg me on MSN! p
alexwood005 3 years ago
Wow. This girl and the music KILL me.
7111nailuj 3 years ago
Beautiful.
dinaklarisse 3 years ago
very very good love the voice sorta haunting very nice
HoustonGaston 3 years ago
IDK why I never youtubed this ensemble...this is amazing...now I have to order it...
SdotWriter 3 years ago
it is so haunting and beautiful....i can hear it and escape in my fragile gothic world.....
thydeadbeloved 3 years ago
cocteau twins is better...
moneyllica 3 years ago
Dead Can Dance too, but this is amazig
ULTRAMIND7227 3 years ago
I love both of them, but this group, especially this song, is incredible, you have to admit.
7111nailuj 3 years ago
Makes me feel poetic and dreamy...~sighs~
ailovesu204 3 years ago
Not the best I've heard but still beautiful and depressing song...
BannedLol4l 3 years ago
not depressing to me
ScorpioMalkavian 3 years ago 6
I love beautuful haunting ethereal songs like this. Anyone ever heard of autumn's grey solace. Just wondering !
TaintedCandy21 3 years ago 4
autumn's grey solace... one of my favorite... eirin's voice is so expressive...
i could not love anything as much as i love black tape's beautiful and haunting music... and the photos, especially the one in "the rope"
TheMouthOfTheBeast 3 years ago
Absolutely beautiful! The world needs more good music, like this... **sigh**
CorsetMonster 3 years ago 3
i really like this song. I'm going to look more in this group.
shojogrl 3 years ago
Icewald, i belive you are oneof the younger generations of posuer-goths, as theyre called. Listeners of Cradle of Filth and such? You dont have a clue what goth is, its not screaming into a mic or guttoral vocals, its bittersweet and mistifying, gloomy but with hope. So next time you put on ur black polish, think:, Is this who i am? For me, it is.
RomanticShade 3 years ago 13
i love it
it has such a strange way of sadness
pinkexminka 3 years ago 3
Beautiful, haunting song.
ElberethGilthoniel3 3 years ago 3
:D...<3!!
rakelpunto 3 years ago
ke cancion mas hermosa!!! es simplemente preciosa
sinetiketa94mar 3 years ago
i love this band <3
seegrub62 3 years ago 3
i love this band <3
seegrub62 3 years ago
One more time please
Kossxbe 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
uniquely boring,,but not bad,,i have a gothic band i use to sing like her but not that boring,i have a high pitch voice like amy lee,
icewald 3 years ago
Dear i suggest you to change your music attitude from metal to techno-rave. Pathetic, You dont have a glue about the beauty of silence. Nice sad song, thanx Jasmine for adding
Kossxbe 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
oh come on! yuck! do you have a hear? i mean, can you hear the ugliness and how boring this is?.. WTF! lol
icewald 3 years ago
A voice like Amy Lee you say...I'd like to check that out.
namelsess93 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh my... what the hell... amy lee sings like shit, maybe she has a good technique and stuff, but her voice is unbearable!!! how can you prefer EVANESCENCE instead of black tape? go to watch mtv
TheMouthOfTheBeast 3 years ago
dont be such a jerk, the both have amazing voices
hauntedspirit6 3 years ago 9
This is my favorite.
SinNanna 3 years ago
beautiful!
mothgirl27 3 years ago 3