Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (103)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Freedom!

  • personally i dont know if its real or fake... i cant tell. However, there is A LOT of controversy on the news about this video

  • my chest feels heavy after watching this

  • Indeed. Has to be one of the most chilling thing's I've ever, ever seen.

  • wow you little dick don't know anything whats going on right now, or?

    It's reald, n00b

  • jason23296....ur such a fucking wasteman++++++

  • you have obviously never experienced war, gunshot victims, or death yourself. This is definitely real. Watch it again...and read the article on exactly what happened.

  • I've been deployed to Iraq twice and have seen people die but the reason why I think it's fake is because there are 2 versions of the video that have the same sound track but vary slightly.This video shows her falling to the ground and the camera man comes behind the man in stripes and shows her starting to bleed. The 2nd version the same thing happens but it's different because in the other one she already has blood on her face. The video is fake.

  • It's real. In the other version it's shot a little after. She was shot in the heart from what I know, which explains the blood coming from the mouth.

  • yes but the angle is the same but the footage varys slightly which is indictive or a repeat attempt to film the scene. Being shot in the heart doesn't cause people to bleed from the ears eyes and nose

  • The blood starts coming out of her mouth at 0:11, then from her nose at 0:14 and runs into her eye. I don't see any blood coming from her ear. The man has his hands placed a little high for her to have been hit in the heart. From where his hands are I am guessing she was hit in the trachea. There are several major blood vessels in that area that could have been hit too. The blood from one of those vessels probably filled her trachea then came out from her mouth & nose.

  • Call this video A and the other one video B. Video B starts 9 seconds after video A. At 0:17 on video A, cameraman B steps in front of cameraman A and you can briefly see most of cameraman B below the shoulders. Cameraman A then moves to the other side of Neda.

    The videos sound a little different because the mics pick up the sounds closest to them more clearly. The 2 loudest vocalizations, a woman screaming at 0:19 then a man roaring at 0:21, sound the same on the 2 videos.

  • I have a feeling this will not be the last video we see like this. It's becoming impossible for people to ignore what is happening

  • It is so unbelievable how human kind has been killing each other for thousands of years in great masses...Do you think we will ever get used to it?

  • stronzi bastardi, perchè nn si sparano fra di loro? bastardi

  • i never see  that horrible , i just looking while i'am thinkin doctors see the blood often, but this is no humanity

  • R.I.P

  • Who are these idiots giving these videos ratings? I saw this once, and hope to never see it again.. It's a fucked up world period.

  • i also believe that the election was not rigged because i think ahmadinjead has far more supporters. the rural population outnumbers middle class students by far.

    those ppl protesting are upset at the result and at 30 years of bein treaten like children but i honestly do not think the votes were rigged.

    i was slightly leaning towards mousavi but wasnt disapointed or surprised at all when ahmadinjead was re elected.

    i think alot of iranians living abroad are jumping on the bandwagon too.

  • My deepest sympathy for her family.May they find peace from this terrible,sad day.

  • You're an idiot.

  • at 0:12 it starts coming out of her mouth. She probably had damage to her lung allowing large quantities of blood to enter her airway. The chest compressions probably propelled this blood out of her mouth.

  • You are an idiot! At first, before she lays back the blood is pouring out of her chest. When she lays back on the ground blood then pools in the chest cavity and airway and is forced out of her mouth and nose rather quickly. It is obvious that she was shot in the chest.

  • yeah you have believing whatever dumb ass things you want.

  • THis has been reported on Yahoo news, and other major television news networks like CNN. Her name was Neda Agha Soltan. Search it!  Get your facts straight before you look like an ignorant fool.

  • Hey Ted,

    You need to get beaten with a large clue bat. STFU.

  • CIA poured 400 million into Iran to stir up Violence and they got their money worth.

  • i'm sad...ahmadinejad you are a beast the world watching you but here we are watching also the italian government.

  • this is the human face of Iran itself!!... such a beautiful country, a whole nation with an enormous history behind, being murdered every day by this regime!!!!!

    IT' STHE START OF THE END!!!!

  • Where is the Basij?

  • exaclty

  • que fuerte...

  • fuck all dictators!!!!!!!!!

  • Speechless!!!!!!

    If you have kids or you ever thought of having them ... you can imagine the pain of her own father holding her had and crying to "Stay here" while she is dying in his hands!!!!

  • This is one of the saddest things I've ever seen. I don't know if I can sleep tonight. Please stop this, somebody!

  • Every night, while we sleep, our western govts are startinf trouble like this, all over the world. Maybe we are in the right, who knows ? All i know is they dont tell us anything, except "shut up".

    And then we see foreiogn (normally muslim) countries being attacked, all over the place.

    We live a lie, and im not so sure any more, that we are on the "right" side.

    Its sick !

  • Jesus Christ. :| That is fucked.

  • so painful to watchso painful.

    Khamenei, ahmadi nejad, you're done, you're really screwed now. the whole world is watching you.

    Khamenei, indafe dige ridee. tof be ghabre madare harjaeet, arb zadeye bi sharm.

  • wow thats nuts

  • A martyr for freedom.

  • Iranians should rise up against ahmadinejad!! That guy is a psychopath.

  • give it a rest dude. The Iranian nation voted for him, twice. This whole killing and shit is another problem. Blame it on the Hashemi mafia clan.

  • f#@% you 16607880, you'r not better then these dictators

  • there is one thing you might like to know, in iran, ordinary people are not armed, just the police and basijies who have the license can carry weapons.

  • Deep regret on the loss of those who died and those who are about to die for freedom and human rights.

  • May God STOP THIS....I love the Iranians! PLEASE YAHWEH STOP this evil....Tears all day cannot express my sorrow for this....i am so angry....where is the International community? Where is the American elite gov......plz help!

  • Way to show how racist Persian nationalists can get. You think it's going to help your cause by referring to Arabs as savages? Grow up you imbecile.

  • stupid comparison. This isn't the first time foreign powers have meddled in iranian issues. Even killing people from both sides to divide and conquer. You guys are dumb for falling into this trick.

  • Maybe you are right, it wasn't a basiji to shoot...

    there is no reason why iranian forces should fire to someone calm in a corner, probably some infiltrated terrorist payed by the western countries did it... it was SOOOO readily taken in film and spread around so well... by 2 different cameras too.

    Still your comment "i don't see a basiji in the clip" is dumb man.

  • Well my point by saying "i dont see a basiji" in the clip was to make a point about it could have been anyone. How come noone mentiones the young man you got kicked and stoned to death by the "protestors" because he "looked" like a basiji. He was walking with his wife, and on their way home he got stopped and killed. Again, even that i am willing to give the protestors the benefit of the doubt. The MKO and Jundullah and other scum have done so much, you cant count them out.

  • The Police , RGC and Basjij should stop fucking around with batons and rifles , and start BOMBING North Tehran from the air , that cesspool from where all these cockroaches emerge.

  • God bless her and the people of Iran

  • Thank you and bless the one who got this one out...i was not able....i pray to GOD this evil will STOP!

  • God won't stop this. This is the work of humanity. And unfortunately the work of humanity is the only hope we have.

    How many tears must be shed before it fucking ends?

  • to those who died and those about to die, I salute you. RIP

  • Her name is NEDA

    WE CANNOT FORGET

    LONG LIVE IRAN

  • God bless Neda's beautiful soul.

  • this woman wasnt doing anything but watching, she wasnt protesting she wasnt against the protestors, she was just watching. she's just neutral.

  • The US and other countries do care. But you must know that many think these protests were fomented by the West, and if they were, the Iranian people are being used as a means to someone else's ends. There is no easy solution to this. Do Iranians want to change from a theocracy to a secular democracy?

  • Maybe you are right,

    maybe there is some western help behind, but what's wrong then, when SO MUCH people is on the streets, they WANT IT

    If anything ever changes, there's to pay attention not to be betrayed by the same hidden hands

  • The atrocities of this regime shows that there are many people in that part of the world who want change

  • obviously SOME DO

  • I was referring to politcal or military intervention,

    sure all the people on earth is with them in their hearts

  • LEave  OUT Obama and all the fuckin Wester countries

    this is Iranian's people revolution, and nobody has the right to put a single word in it

  • i disagree. this revolution does not belong exclusively to iranians. it belongs to all of us. it belongs to all Earthlings who aspire to freedom. she was my sister.

  • the whole world must see this. there is dignity and grace in her beautiful, calm face. i will never forget her. i love her. her death will not be in vain. it will inspire freedom seekers for generations to come.

  • "Our liberty depends on the freedom of the press, and that cannot be limited without being lost."

    Thomas Jefferson

    This woman died trying to achieve liberty, at the very least her story should be made available to the world.

  • This is a horrifying image but it is important that the world see what is happening. It took a great deal of bravery to bring this image to the world; the bravery of the cameraman, the bravery of whoever got the image out, and the bravery of the young woman who sacrificed her life to make make her voice heard by her government. I hope that You tube does not nullify all that bravery by removing this video because it makes people feel squeamish.

  • If only Obama cared as much about the Iranians as he does about the Palestinians.

  • hell no. Let it be seen.

  • Horrifying.

  • To all the people of Iran wanting change...the people of U.S. are with you! We want you to have freedom and democracy so you can begin to live "your' lives!

  • This is so heartbreaking...

    My prayers are with this young woman and her family.

    May there be a special place in hell reserved for the person who pulled the trigger.

  • the average people of Iran the USA are praying for a peaceful ending of this.

  • im speechless(or in this case, text less). i usually would type something sarcastic or combative, but what i just watched wont allow that.

    politics has nothing to do with this, its murder. plain and simple.

  • This poor woman!.......Peace to the people of Iran! The whole world is behind you!!!

  • مهما حدث من تقدم فى إيران مازالوا وسيظلوا مجوس

  • oh god, where are you?

  • With the protesters. What else but that and the desire fro freedom would motivate so many to such a cause? The Iranian government will be held accountable for all their strikes against the common person's right to be themselves.

  • The people of America are with you!

    Our prayers are with you! Our thoughts are with you!

  • When this is all over, and it WILL be over soon, and the leaders of this evil regime that kills its own beautiful children have all been brought down and brought to justice for their crimes. . .a 30-foot-high, gleaming bronze statue needs to be raised in this young woman's honor.

    She gave all she had to give for her God, her Country and the Freedom of her people.

    May she never be forgotten.

  • MONSTERS!!

  • God help them!

  • Your tears are our tears.

  • the blood of innocent victims will wash the eyes of the iranian people, so they can see the real face of this political regime like the rest of the world has been seen it since decades.

  • I wish Americans cared about liberty like these people do.

  • Death to the terrorist government of Islamic republic of Iran. Death to the Arab supreme leader Khamenei. Death to the Basijies. May the lord protect these brave innocent people since the super powers have decided to sit back and just express their sympathy.

    Please help our people.

  • Your loss is felt all over the world! The people of USA are with you. Don't give up!

  • May God help the brave people of Iran, and give them the strength to continue their noble resistance....THE WORLD IS WITH YOU IRAN

  • ... what was this over?.. :(

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more