As much as i loved Tarja in Nightwish, she let the band and the fans down. Too many Tarja fan boys/girls out there. Get over the fact shes gone and just listen to her solo stuff if you miss her so much!
the comments section is not meant for promoting yourself...get as far as Nettan, post your wonderful performances and prove that you can actually do better ;)
I'm sorry but my favorite song ruined this way, there is just no emotion, no lyrics interpretation, she can sing the song, but she can can't bring her the way tarja did! I love anette, but this just suck :(
Each to their own i guess, but i found from this performance, and hearing it live myself, she puts far more emotion and feeling into the song when compared to both studio and lie Tarja performances.
@DarkPasionWishmaster yes it does suck something wicked!! anette does NOT even try to sing the last part or chorus to this at all, which tarja did flawlessly!!
@jean15june I disagree here. Anette is not meant to finish the song, since it is performed as a medley. To people who don't like Anette's voice I strongly recommend to stop posting shit here and to focus on Tarja videos instead. If you don't like Anette, why bother? Tarja's dismissal was SIX YEARS AGO. She is now an awesome and successful solo artist. Can't we just accept that and stop quarrelling?
@OpheliaLestrange no ophelialestrange, you DO NOT know what you are even talking about because IF you did, you would have at least mentioned anette does not sing the last part to this song whatsoever nor has she ever since joining the band. i am pleading w/ you to make me understand exactly what it is you know what you're talking about. PLEASE REPLY back & explain. thank you. i will be waiting anxiously.
@jean15june Your comment is a bit confusing, so I am not sure what your actual question was, but as far as I know, the ending part of the song has never been performed live, neither in Tarja times...did you even notice that the melody changes to Walking in the Air? They played it as sort of a medley. Just in case that wasn't clear.
I have listened to this video a lot of times and I find it is one of the best memories of this awesome show and I feel that I know what I'm talking about
how come they didn't do this at the concert I ent to!!!!!??????? This is soo cool though and Annette did a great job. this is actually the first nightwish song I've heard.
BOTH?! *envy* I WAS going to get to go to two shows in May, buuuut... now I'll be lucky to go to one. Gah, if they were to play THIS and "Ever Dream", I'll need to bring a boat XD
They didn't play Ever Dream at the shows in Europe but maybe they'll change the setlist for the US. I'm crossing my fingers for you! Nettie's version is breathtaking^^
yes both im so excited! ahhh. i get to meet them as well! ahhh oh dear I GET TO MEET THEM! ahh if they play ever dream, dead boys poem, planet hell, slaying the dreamer o and if she knows over the hills and far away. i think im going to pass out!
It's probably because many (not sure if it's the majority or minority or if it varies by genre) love the music for what it represents, in addition to the music itself, and takes that very personally and close to heart. Thus, they perceive the people who present the music in the same manner. =P
Compared to the DPP tour in 07/08, for the DejaVu tour they changed the setlist: new intro, more older songs. First time I heard Ghost Love Score live....shivers down my spine...Thx for this evening NW
As much as i loved Tarja in Nightwish, she let the band and the fans down. Too many Tarja fan boys/girls out there. Get over the fact shes gone and just listen to her solo stuff if you miss her so much!
<3 Anette
kalem1988 8 months ago in playlist Nightwish Live München Munich 26.03.2009
beautiful song, beautiful voice, beautiful interpretation
I love you Anette!! keep on going, no matter what they say. you´ll always be in my heart
Mandrake213 8 months ago 2
nothing unique . . . .
y4t3z 1 year ago
What do you mean by part of Walking in the Air? Did I miss something??
Great Dead Boy's Poem though!
harrawrson 1 year ago
i love annette.
:D
MaisYeahSha 2 years ago 3
I wish they would play walking in the air with annete i think it would sound intersting
akaboo69 2 years ago 4
They already have now! =D
(That being said, it was an acoustic version of Walking in the Air, but whatever.)
1AzureSky 2 years ago
id like to know if the lonely soul-ocean soul - part is now not played live anymore?
it was the dramatic, the shaking part of this song..
i don't tell my opinion to annette
blackrose0812 2 years ago
It was never played live. Not even with Tarja.
NWphreek 2 years ago 4
I'm not sure, but I think that in from wishes to eternitiy tarja sings that part.
miikamy 2 years ago
@blackrose0812 I miss it too! But they cut that part out live years ago. :/
harrawrson 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anette she dont have a fucking voice for signing this song only Tarja can sing this song, I know what I talk Im a singer professional opera!!
Patrick Lelievre
Sur facebook: Aesma Asmodai
krotalle 2 years ago
the comments section is not meant for promoting yourself...get as far as Nettan, post your wonderful performances and prove that you can actually do better ;)
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
I'm sorry but my favorite song ruined this way, there is just no emotion, no lyrics interpretation, she can sing the song, but she can can't bring her the way tarja did! I love anette, but this just suck :(
DarkPasionWishmaster 2 years ago
for me the Anette version includes a lot more emotion, lyric interpretation and everything...but I also understand your point...
nevermind...we all love the song, we just prefer different versions, so let's not quarrel...whatever singer it is, it's always Nightwish, right? :)
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago 12
that's just what I'm always saying :)
The important thing (person) is Nightwish is Tuomas - without him there would be no Dead Boys Poem or any other :)
cheers =)
DarkPasionWishmaster 2 years ago 7
yeah, you're so right!
cheers :)
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
@DarkPasionWishmaster
Each to their own i guess, but i found from this performance, and hearing it live myself, she puts far more emotion and feeling into the song when compared to both studio and lie Tarja performances.
kalem1988 8 months ago in playlist Nightwish Live München Munich 26.03.2009
@DarkPasionWishmaster yes it does suck something wicked!! anette does NOT even try to sing the last part or chorus to this at all, which tarja did flawlessly!!
jean15june 2 months ago
@jean15june I disagree here. Anette is not meant to finish the song, since it is performed as a medley. To people who don't like Anette's voice I strongly recommend to stop posting shit here and to focus on Tarja videos instead. If you don't like Anette, why bother? Tarja's dismissal was SIX YEARS AGO. She is now an awesome and successful solo artist. Can't we just accept that and stop quarrelling?
OpheliaLestrange 1 month ago
This new singer she can't sing this song!!!!!!
krotalle 2 years ago
you don't know what you're talking about.
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
@OpheliaLestrange He know what he is talking about and I agree with him
moclis 11 months ago
@OpheliaLestrange no ophelialestrange, you DO NOT know what you are even talking about because IF you did, you would have at least mentioned anette does not sing the last part to this song whatsoever nor has she ever since joining the band. i am pleading w/ you to make me understand exactly what it is you know what you're talking about. PLEASE REPLY back & explain. thank you. i will be waiting anxiously.
jean15june 2 months ago
@jean15june Your comment is a bit confusing, so I am not sure what your actual question was, but as far as I know, the ending part of the song has never been performed live, neither in Tarja times...did you even notice that the melody changes to Walking in the Air? They played it as sort of a medley. Just in case that wasn't clear.
I have listened to this video a lot of times and I find it is one of the best memories of this awesome show and I feel that I know what I'm talking about
OpheliaLestrange 1 month ago
@krotalle TU no puedes cantarla, por que no sabes oirla :B
reveprofond 9 months ago
@krotalle agree...she ruined many songs, although I don't have nothing against her, that is just truth
Evenstar988 5 months ago
Awesome video!
I just love them. That's all I can say!
fairyxcorpse 2 years ago
I love Anette but out of all the old Nightwish songs i dident want her to sing this song =[
eggyburp 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you're right, she isnt good.
Evnightlerd 2 years ago
she is good.
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
wow! this amazing!
i love u nightwish!
GreenBrauZz 2 years ago
and walking in the air???
R2ROrancid 2 years ago
Part of the guitar solo.
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
I love it!
NightwishNewEra 2 years ago 2
Emppu's solo was soo great... very emotional.
senseilifesonsappren 2 years ago 3
how come they didn't do this at the concert I ent to!!!!!??????? This is soo cool though and Annette did a great job. this is actually the first nightwish song I've heard.
senseilifesonsappren 2 years ago
I was there
IT WAS FANTASTIC!!!
XxXDeluXeBlinqXxX 2 years ago 3
God you're so lucky!!!! Love them!!!!! nice video thanks :PP
mishkyn910 2 years ago 3
Im so excited! i cant wait to see them! Im going to see them in may! ahhhhh thanks for the vid! i love it
Nightwishismysoul 2 years ago 2
You're seeing them in May? I might be!! I saw them on September 16th, 2008 - best day ever. =P
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
what no way! i dont know if im going bymyself or if my friend is coming but im coming from california! ahhh im so stoked! im seeing both shows!
Nightwishismysoul 2 years ago
BOTH?! *envy* I WAS going to get to go to two shows in May, buuuut... now I'll be lucky to go to one. Gah, if they were to play THIS and "Ever Dream", I'll need to bring a boat XD
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
They didn't play Ever Dream at the shows in Europe but maybe they'll change the setlist for the US. I'm crossing my fingers for you! Nettie's version is breathtaking^^
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
o man i agree she is getting so good! i cant wait to meet her yay!
Nightwishismysoul 2 years ago
yes both im so excited! ahhh. i get to meet them as well! ahhh oh dear I GET TO MEET THEM! ahh if they play ever dream, dead boys poem, planet hell, slaying the dreamer o and if she knows over the hills and far away. i think im going to pass out!
Nightwishismysoul 2 years ago
I got to meet 'em, too!! It was crazy >.> I cried. Lol
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
I met them, too and I also cried...one could think metalfans are crybabies xD
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
It's probably because many (not sure if it's the majority or minority or if it varies by genre) love the music for what it represents, in addition to the music itself, and takes that very personally and close to heart. Thus, they perceive the people who present the music in the same manner. =P
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
yeah, I guess your right^^
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
I saw them around the same time! XD hopefully if i can get a ride i'll see them in may!
HolmanAlexander 2 years ago
And not to forget, the part of Walking In The Air they put into the song... it's simply... so, so great..... I LOVE THEM SO MUCH!!!
TarjaHolopainen 2 years ago 3
Hey, that's amazing they have chosen older songs like these ones! Her voice sounds really great, thank you for upload, trully thanks! :)
Anette is awesome...
TarjaHolopainen 2 years ago 3
Compared to the DPP tour in 07/08, for the DejaVu tour they changed the setlist: new intro, more older songs. First time I heard Ghost Love Score live....shivers down my spine...Thx for this evening NW
rsmkegl 2 years ago
I've been watching this multiple times throughout the day... it's so beautiful...
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
hey u were there? That's awesome they sound fantastic as always
marandy55 2 years ago
I love Anette´s voice and Tuomas´s boat too :D
barunka0010 2 years ago
haha you were really close to they!! so lucky ¬¬ xD and nice vid!
r4xNW 2 years ago
Awesome =)
NettanFairy 2 years ago
hey hun, you were kind!
it's nice ^_^
do u have some pics too or audios?
anetteolzonc 2 years ago
Darn,you're lucky to hear this live!!! I hope I hear this and GLS live, even if it's with Anette xD
smrk3t4 2 years ago
In dont like the dead boys poem NEITHER Ghost Love score, with Anette.
I have absolutley nothing against her, but its such strong voices in those songs, and her is too soft.
Ebonybitch91 2 years ago
I love this song <3
Anette sings it perfectly.
=)
AmaranthxNightwish 2 years ago 9
Love this song. Anette sounds great.
rolsch474 2 years ago 3
Anette sounds great <3 I don´t like Tuomas´ boat, it looks so...Weird x´D Maybe I just have try to live with it :DD
ViimeinenTanssi 2 years ago
Thank you so much for uploading this!! I'm so excited that they're playing "Dead Boy's Poem" again!! (And Lol... Tuomas in a boat =3)
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
oh thank you^^
yeah, me too....the boat's name is "Ocean Soul" by the way xD
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago
Makes perfect sense. =O I love it =3 ... I wonder if they'll ever play that song, now that it's been meantioned...
Nightowljrm 2 years ago