this song (both melody & lyrics) is created by Paul & recorded in "秘密警察" CD, sad moody song & Paul sing very well in 2005 live, excellent!!!! I love it very much since it is good feeling!!! High Digitial (in full screen) is very appreciated, thanks Pepper23.
Beyond Show in Beijing, the singers added Tibet independance substances. Of course, the organizer was warned. I am surprised why the people used to add anti-China substance no matter it is 2008 Olympic or in Show. If you sing Alaska independence in USA, and Ryukyu Island independence in Japan, that is funny. You will be arrested.
Bet most of you didn't realised that this is a very old song by paul. Fact is even some of those who claim to be beyond's fans have always overlooked the rest of the band's work.
yea well, too bad the original singer aint here. Beyong could've been one of the few gods that still remain in HK. Singers nowadays can never replaces beyond and the other old classic singers.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
well...paul wong could do that. Dam too bad he aint here anymore. no one can replace him man. Beyond should've fallen long ago. But pplz still have sympathy with beyond becasue of its fame, and not becasue of the songs anymore. R.I.P paul wong. All my Condolences to his work and delicates.
this was the first time he totoally understood the real meaning of the lyrics! listen to the sadness in his voice! what an awesome song!what a talent musician!
PAUL唱慢歌好好好聽呀!!不過吾可以邊彈邊唱,o尼首歌多太高音位,要好專心甘唱
kayeechoy 4 months ago in playlist kayeechoy's Favorited Videos
confius lah! ka keong ni paul ke? bkn paul main drum ke? adui ai
ctkmdsr 6 months ago
這幾天已經快聽了百多次
iw1avw 8 months ago
再聽88年的CD Version和91年的和聲版本
我個人比較喜歡2005Live的版本, 可以從阿Paul的心中聽出滄桑/唏噓以及心境的轉變, 更是令人覺得感動...
iw1avw 8 months ago 4
好 !!!
sidneywongable 8 months ago
好有共嗚既一首歌..
alexi0826 1 year ago
把聲好靚
JASON1995824 1 year ago 4
啊paul keep得到佢把聲
eason163 2 years ago 3
好感動.................
fire2046 2 years ago 6
人群内似未能够找到我...
aphroboy 2 years ago
Comment removed
ken67549 2 years ago 5
what meaning?
xfzhang7 2 years ago
That's what i preceived
As people are being more realistic and materialistic, they become further apart and forget about their dream
simontse1992 2 years ago
totally fantastic.. i never get tired of listening to this song...
RaeleneLo 2 years ago 6
MEANINGFUL
Hope Hong Kong people can understand and think about the lyrics!
simontse1992 3 years ago 18
what do the lyrics say??? sounds very good...but the vocabulary is beyond my level haha
tehmofo 3 years ago
Everyone becomes realistic and only cares about money
No one fights for their dreams (music) anymore
simontse1992 2 years ago 6
this song (both melody & lyrics) is created by Paul & recorded in "秘密警察" CD, sad moody song & Paul sing very well in 2005 live, excellent!!!! I love it very much since it is good feeling!!! High Digitial (in full screen) is very appreciated, thanks Pepper23.
thrillerinmate 3 years ago 5
好好听!!!
justsher 3 years ago 10
阿Paul~正
beyondsignal 3 years ago 22
This has been flagged as spam show
where is ka keung?
VALDICAMO 3 years ago
He appears near the end man.
lwc888 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Beyond Show in Beijing, the singers added Tibet independance substances. Of course, the organizer was warned. I am surprised why the people used to add anti-China substance no matter it is 2008 Olympic or in Show. If you sing Alaska independence in USA, and Ryukyu Island independence in Japan, that is funny. You will be arrested.
Macaugiraffee 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
沒有了家駒那天,Beyond已經不是Beyond了.
剩下了3個掛了Beyond之名,狗咬狗骨的人,
violaviolin1 4 years ago
this song is by paul, i have videos of old concert which he sing this very same song, i also have the original cd with Paul singing this song
Pepper23 4 years ago 2
Ah Yin is good.
ImpulseGT 4 years ago 3
Bet most of you didn't realised that this is a very old song by paul. Fact is even some of those who claim to be beyond's fans have always overlooked the rest of the band's work.
aphroboy 4 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song was written by wong ka kui. I saw the 1991 one. It sounded better.
turbobenx 4 years ago
Correction. This song is written by paul. It's even stated at the beginning of the video.
aphroboy 4 years ago 4
BEYOND IS FOREVER!
bravehelen 4 years ago
such a nice song... sang so well
Bbcat1789 4 years ago
yea well, too bad the original singer aint here. Beyong could've been one of the few gods that still remain in HK. Singers nowadays can never replaces beyond and the other old classic singers.
turbobenx 4 years ago
the song was originally by paul, but yeah i noe, beyond's most glorious time was when bukai was there
Bbcat1789 4 years ago
good lyrics, love BEYOND, thx for uploading
kmysss 4 years ago
re chickenboy2006 : different style , difficult to compare..
hkaying 4 years ago
paul wong or eason chan?
chickenboy2006 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
eason suk balls.
turbobenx 4 years ago
明顯地 , 阿paul唱功對比過往進步左
hkaying 4 years ago 4
to: hkaying
of course. He wasn't playing guitar while singing. It is so hard to do both at the same time.
lightbulb369 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well...paul wong could do that. Dam too bad he aint here anymore. no one can replace him man. Beyond should've fallen long ago. But pplz still have sympathy with beyond becasue of its fame, and not becasue of the songs anymore. R.I.P paul wong. All my Condolences to his work and delicates.
turbobenx 4 years ago
lol, u scared me.
chickenboy2006 4 years ago
wat i meant was ka kui.
turbobenx 4 years ago
oh dear, 佢未死, 唔好咁講話
benoityip 4 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
wat the fuk did u just say, lol.
turbobenx 4 years ago
i meant wong ka kui
turbobenx 4 years ago
this was the first time he totoally understood the real meaning of the lyrics! listen to the sadness in his voice! what an awesome song!what a talent musician!
leon711 4 years ago 2
umm no i think that pauls just getting old and going out of breath
keithrocks123 4 years ago
that or the smoker's voice now.
ahlinjadeen 4 years ago
願我能
收錄係 - "秘密警察"大碟
pykillua 4 years ago
sorry.. i miss out the title at the start..
etky85 4 years ago
wat's the title of this song?
etky85 4 years ago
Paul sang this song with saddness. His ending solo is real good!!
dabingrou 4 years ago
rock`n paul wong
GordonXm 5 years ago
ho ho teng....really good vocals
hunniebird 5 years ago
Always the best band of course :).
ale03000 5 years ago
Beyond is always d best...anyway...do u hav other videos of tis 2005 concert?
DeS99 5 years ago
the best ever.
blcujerry 5 years ago 2
the best chinese band
BandMania 5 years ago
superb u cant beet Beyond nothin cn comper wit em!!!!
StreetFootie123 5 years ago
love this song, very emotional
tinijim 5 years ago 3
You could hear the saddness in his voice in this concert compare to the 1992 performance.
LadyButterfly83x 5 years ago
Pul u're the best...
keep it up!!
antaaw 6 years ago