Der meiste quatsch der hier geschrieben wurde is sowas von no go es ging darum das man die Leute nochmal Live sieht ob die Youporn oder Tetris spielten aufm Laptop is absolut nebensächlich ganz ehrlich
kraftwerkmucke geht auch auf nem c64 oder, aber diese leute machen mucke schon seit 30 jahren! die haben denke einiges an equipment ausprobiert und kennen sich aus.
I wouldn't say Kraftwerk shows are 'rare' these days, as far as I can gather from bits and pieces, Rolf has no intention of stopping live shows yet though it might be two years before we have a new album - but that's Kraftwerk for you. Thank god i've seen them twice. I don't care if they stand there and do nothing, the shows were amazing.
Du brauchst dafür genau 4 Männer. Du kannst dich nicht auf die Videowand und gleichzeitig Melodien spielen und konzentrieren... und dann auch noch Sprechgesang Bass und die Effekte... es ist hald aufgeteilt. Kraftwerk ist Kult. Und die Technik lässt es einfach zu dass dafür 4 Leute gebraucht werden;-)
Ich arbeite selbst mit Steinberg Software und Propellerhead. Man kann alles aufeinmal machen aber um einen Perfekten Sound so zu produzieren sinds einfach 4 Leute
I think a lot of peeps may have got it wrong about Kraftwerk here. They are the original "robot band", so you want to see them standing there emotionless and playing very 8-bit vocoder tunes. It's like MJ and his glove, Madonna and her pointy tits, Prodigy and their energy. It's part of the act, the whole ambience. They've always been quite mellow - they're not a dance act necessarily. They're influential, seminal, and deserve some respect even if you don't like the sounds / visuals.
I totally agree with you mrvertigo73. KW being, how do you say, mellow, robot-like IS what makes KW so unique. I'll say it again and again they are my 4 handsome men from Germany as well as talented. It's good to see they, like a lot of the bands I use to listen to in the 80's are still performing. :)
ok... maybe the one standing left is playing tetris... the other one on the right is watching porn via wlan... the third is chattin' on icq ... and the last one is who has the song running on his notebook... while he plays online poker...? ;)
don't get me wrong... i'm just jokin. i respect kraftwerk since years... but nowadays u definetly don't need 4 guys with their notebooks playing such sound. ;)
it's ok that grandfathers of electronic music earn their money easy like that...
Hey KRAFTWERK FANS! The german musican Sabrina Setlur has stolen a sample of 'Metal On Metal' (without any authority from Kraftwerk). The german law has to entitle to do this. Search "Sabrina Setlur nur mir" on YouTube, watch this video and complain there! (Sorry for my bad english)
they just stand there looking into those laptops.. no crowd interaction what so ever.. very boring for me! so im glad above and beyond have a 3 hour set so i dont have to put up with it
I believe it's all digital, as their always talking about how they ported everything to the digital studio. But they still use their analog stuff, allthough not on gigs. Then again, I could be completely wrong as I'm only guessing :(
Can anyone tell me what their actuley seeing on their screen? or what their actuley doing as its mostly ready made sounds right? *hopes their playing solitare*
They're running a program called Cubase which controls MIDI in each individual station. What they do is add to whats already there where they see fit. In Ralf's words: "We sometimes think 'I'm going to intervene here'" Ralf controls melody, Henning and Fritz change the output, and Florian controls sound effects
Cubase is an entry-level music making program. While it is sufficient in many situations (especially when coupled with proper external patches), it simply hasn't got anything on, say, ProTools. (I don't count crap like ejay and magix, simply because those programs are mainly for copy-paste operations)
The program sets the limitations of what you can do. Kraftwerk wouldn't settle for second best - why should they? And since they are very unlikely to use Cubase in a studio recording session, why would they use it in a live performance? It just doesn't make sense.
Check their credits in the minimum-maximum album booklet... they mention just about any manufacturer of music software. Given the fact they probably get to test drive most of them... I'm sure they take the right tool for the right job, and I'd be surprised if cubase isn't one of those tools in some cases.
especially the sound was very very very good at that gig. normally on festivals, the organizers find a compromise that fits on all bands of a festival. but this one was something other. it was VERY loud, but also it didn't hurt and it was very clear. no idea how they did that. i think that is the reason why it worked quite well for the camera. but u weren't allowed to film there...securities all around...no idea how he did that.
from someone who is in the states, i appreciate you taking the time to post this! i have NEVER EVER seen kraftwerk live or any of their videos.. but i have just about every track they have ever released. these cats and the art of noise rock! thanks again!!! this video was clean and clear which makes it thata much better...
Der meiste quatsch der hier geschrieben wurde is sowas von no go es ging darum das man die Leute nochmal Live sieht ob die Youporn oder Tetris spielten aufm Laptop is absolut nebensächlich ganz ehrlich
TheFlitzeflo 6 months ago
kraftwerkmucke geht auch auf nem c64 oder, aber diese leute machen mucke schon seit 30 jahren! die haben denke einiges an equipment ausprobiert und kennen sich aus.
Bl4sch3k 8 months ago
Das is der ursprung....nur zuhöhren und geniessen.....ich war auch da.....
TheCarstamc 1 year ago
Division of Labour
Tonsenle 1 year ago
I wouldn't say Kraftwerk shows are 'rare' these days, as far as I can gather from bits and pieces, Rolf has no intention of stopping live shows yet though it might be two years before we have a new album - but that's Kraftwerk for you. Thank god i've seen them twice. I don't care if they stand there and do nothing, the shows were amazing.
brismike65 1 year ago
@ gehirnfrisur
Du brauchst dafür genau 4 Männer. Du kannst dich nicht auf die Videowand und gleichzeitig Melodien spielen und konzentrieren... und dann auch noch Sprechgesang Bass und die Effekte... es ist hald aufgeteilt. Kraftwerk ist Kult. Und die Technik lässt es einfach zu dass dafür 4 Leute gebraucht werden;-)
Ich arbeite selbst mit Steinberg Software und Propellerhead. Man kann alles aufeinmal machen aber um einen Perfekten Sound so zu produzieren sinds einfach 4 Leute
LeshKimoto 1 year ago
Ich war da - es war so geil - aber ziemlich "schattig" - hat sich aber alles gelohnt. KNALLER KRAFTWERK - Grüße aus und nach Düsseldorf
maxwellundercover 2 years ago
how did you get this video?
digidsg 2 years ago
I think a lot of peeps may have got it wrong about Kraftwerk here. They are the original "robot band", so you want to see them standing there emotionless and playing very 8-bit vocoder tunes. It's like MJ and his glove, Madonna and her pointy tits, Prodigy and their energy. It's part of the act, the whole ambience. They've always been quite mellow - they're not a dance act necessarily. They're influential, seminal, and deserve some respect even if you don't like the sounds / visuals.
mrvertigo73 2 years ago 4
I totally agree with you mrvertigo73. KW being, how do you say, mellow, robot-like IS what makes KW so unique. I'll say it again and again they are my 4 handsome men from Germany as well as talented. It's good to see they, like a lot of the bands I use to listen to in the 80's are still performing. :)
werkinwoman83 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
just to confirm how shit they are
jakewilliams2026 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thats just fucking boring
jakewilliams2026 2 years ago
Why the fuck did you watch it then?
ratanakul 2 years ago
Tonight at EXIT FESTIVAL 2009!!!
Ralexcar 2 years ago
12 june 2009 Bucharest,Romania..Palace Hall...can`t wait!!!
kkklaus 2 years ago
ok... maybe the one standing left is playing tetris... the other one on the right is watching porn via wlan... the third is chattin' on icq ... and the last one is who has the song running on his notebook... while he plays online poker...? ;)
don't get me wrong... i'm just jokin. i respect kraftwerk since years... but nowadays u definetly don't need 4 guys with their notebooks playing such sound. ;)
it's ok that grandfathers of electronic music earn their money easy like that...
gehirnfrisur 2 years ago 9
Na ja, scheinbar haben die Elektro-Opis nichts von ihrem Charme verloren, sonst würden die Leutz die Konzerte nicht besuchen...
Norahja 2 years ago
@gehirnfrisur best comment!
ketatech 1 year ago
@gehirnfrisur every guy got 1 lane, ;) thats Division of Labour
Tonsenle 1 year ago
@gehirnfrisur
Tonsenle 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ich glaube, etwas was schlechter, langweiliger, beschissniger & blöder ist als das gibt es nicht!!!!!
was hat diese scheisse mit musik zu tun?
funkyoutoo 2 years ago
Kraftwerk sind die Väter und Erfinder der elektronischen Musik.
Ohne sie hätte es Bands wie Depeche Mode, Scooter oder (ganz allgemein gesehen) viele Musikrichtungen nicht gegeben!!!
Norahja 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
du hast ja keine ahnung...
elektrofalter 2 years ago
Is THIS that you open Radiohead's concert? D'oh!
Chinescombarbalonga 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey KRAFTWERK FANS! The german musican Sabrina Setlur has stolen a sample of 'Metal On Metal' (without any authority from Kraftwerk). The german law has to entitle to do this. Search "Sabrina Setlur nur mir" on YouTube, watch this video and complain there! (Sorry for my bad english)
1986abc 3 years ago
simply we love you
hamidrbendez 3 years ago 2
i love kraftwerk
hamidrbendez 3 years ago 5
25.04.09 - Wolfsburg 23:59
YESSSSS!!!!!!
dibx101 3 years ago
thats a very narrow sighted comment to make. kraftwerk are legendary.. nuff said
panface88 3 years ago 3
1980:A revolotion Music
Today:Shit!
FreakofJ 3 years ago
Shit Hot!!!!
Coxynuma.66.
lisaemberton 3 years ago
was an awesome festival, right next to a huge artificial lake and dam.
liamjones, this is kraftwerk, not your average joe who is djing for 3 days.
this is what they do.
MaxtronZero 3 years ago
they just stand there looking into those laptops.. no crowd interaction what so ever.. very boring for me! so im glad above and beyond have a 3 hour set so i dont have to put up with it
liamjones1 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is fuckin awesome
dehofmann 4 years ago
what keyboards are they using? are they analog?
ofmontreal88 4 years ago
I believe it's all digital, as their always talking about how they ported everything to the digital studio. But they still use their analog stuff, allthough not on gigs. Then again, I could be completely wrong as I'm only guessing :(
VoiceOfEnergy 4 years ago
ahhh, ok thanks. it does look like they ahve soem keyboards behind their laptops, but i could be wrong too!
ofmontreal88 4 years ago
Yourie right if it was all analog ger the entire stage would be full of stacks of equipment, and they'd never be able to play this set list
theorytest5 3 years ago
They definitely do not use analogs. All analog stuff is in the magazine, ready to use but they know that it will not happen ;).
kraftwerkmann 3 years ago
I think the keyboards are custom built by Doepfer amd they also use;
- 4 Sony VAIO laptops
- Cubase SX sofware
DieMenschMaschine85 3 years ago
i wish they went old school. i love their old stuff. tour de france didnt float my boat :(
ofmontreal88 3 years ago
yes is good ya
TCONA360 4 years ago
"WE LOVE YOU!"
UncleSamEagle 4 years ago
i was there and it was sooooooo awesome!!!!
tobotron 4 years ago
Is minimum-maximum album is good?
jednostka15 4 years ago
Ja!Das ist das!Kraftwerk ist super!
jednostka15 4 years ago
Ich hatte das Vergnügen es live zu erleben. Es war traumhaft. Und es war arschkalt!
Keloidbildung 4 years ago
what the fuck!!!!!!
4thevol 4 years ago
what do you make of this?
SeaDevilLagoon 2 years ago
Can anyone tell me what their actuley seeing on their screen? or what their actuley doing as its mostly ready made sounds right? *hopes their playing solitare*
kahn200697 4 years ago
They're running a program called Cubase which controls MIDI in each individual station. What they do is add to whats already there where they see fit. In Ralf's words: "We sometimes think 'I'm going to intervene here'" Ralf controls melody, Henning and Fritz change the output, and Florian controls sound effects
Richiepookinshoo 4 years ago
Cubase, really? Why not a program for professionals, like Protools or even Logic?
uibajs 4 years ago
You ever tried recording something on Cubase? Trying to make something even resembling a song is an effort, lol
Richiepookinshoo 4 years ago
... What's your point?
uibajs 4 years ago
Well you said "Why not a program for professionals", and Cubase doesnt exactly accomodate beginners.
Richiepookinshoo 4 years ago
Cubase is an entry-level music making program. While it is sufficient in many situations (especially when coupled with proper external patches), it simply hasn't got anything on, say, ProTools. (I don't count crap like ejay and magix, simply because those programs are mainly for copy-paste operations)
uibajs 4 years ago
Whats important is that the music is good, not how advanced the program you use is.
myrtorp 4 years ago
The program sets the limitations of what you can do. Kraftwerk wouldn't settle for second best - why should they? And since they are very unlikely to use Cubase in a studio recording session, why would they use it in a live performance? It just doesn't make sense.
uibajs 4 years ago
Check their credits in the minimum-maximum album booklet... they mention just about any manufacturer of music software. Given the fact they probably get to test drive most of them... I'm sure they take the right tool for the right job, and I'd be surprised if cubase isn't one of those tools in some cases.
VoiceOfEnergy 3 years ago 2
only boring to a simple brain devoid of any musical knowledge.
eb0nics 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
B O R I N G !
Unabomber2 4 years ago
Kling Klang indeed!
ekimshield 4 years ago
Kling Klang
struantheruin 4 years ago
kraftwerk has to be about the most repetitive band ever
installcd 4 years ago
was this indoor or outdoor?
directorspassion 4 years ago
outdoor
wilke5 4 years ago
Wow. Love the graphics for this show.
nostyleja 4 years ago 2
is this a soundboard recording? this is fucking awesome sound!
directorspassion 4 years ago
especially the sound was very very very good at that gig. normally on festivals, the organizers find a compromise that fits on all bands of a festival. but this one was something other. it was VERY loud, but also it didn't hurt and it was very clear. no idea how they did that. i think that is the reason why it worked quite well for the camera. but u weren't allowed to film there...securities all around...no idea how he did that.
tobotron 4 years ago
do you have this on DVD?
directorspassion 4 years ago
Verursacht bei mir immer noch eine Gänsehaut...Danke fürs hochladen!!
reh47 4 years ago
es war sowas von beeindruckend !!! wahnsinn !!!
totmacherin1 4 years ago
War das das Lied, wo Elmar Gunsch ursprünglich (auf der LP) mitgesungen hat?
Hewson60 4 years ago
i like that guy screaming. i'd probably do so myself if i would go to a kraftwerk concert. unfortunately, we never had one in romania :((
djmixsound 4 years ago
pioneers in there field,after gettin the man machine album 20 years ago i love em,still goin strong today awesome!!
scousersmate 4 years ago
I bought Die mensch maschine album for this song.That's greatest song of Kraftwerk.
jednostka15 4 years ago
kraftwerk having a 2007 - 2008 tour??
psen2001 4 years ago
I fucking hope so!
directorspassion 4 years ago
best one yet
brisbrio 4 years ago
Awesome.
desh79 4 years ago
Great video, thanks for sharing!
Nenne1988 4 years ago
from someone who is in the states, i appreciate you taking the time to post this! i have NEVER EVER seen kraftwerk live or any of their videos.. but i have just about every track they have ever released. these cats and the art of noise rock! thanks again!!! this video was clean and clear which makes it thata much better...
marctronixx 5 years ago
GEIL!!!
lookcloser1976 5 years ago
Kraftwerk has the best live special effects of any band, and a refreshing break from the now all to often unoriginal recycled music videos of today.
beartube1 5 years ago
these guys invented modern electronic music and have inspired countless bands in many geners, good to see them still performing live.
Defconfx 5 years ago
I saw them too this past saturday at M2 Indoor Festival in Zaragoza (Spain). Check out my videos ;)
Cheers!
Guilen 5 years ago