Added: 4 months ago
From: LoudOne28
Views: 8,939
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (36)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Beautiful cover, so much emotion.....just beautiful! Man, I wish Kelly had recorded this song:(

  • What makes Kelly Clarkson so talented and unique is the way she sings. She sings directly from the heart and feels each one of the words she says. That's real music, the one that makes u forget where u are at that moment. That's the difference between singers, not the voice only, the way that they sing, the magic!! Kelly's the best!!!

  • When Carrie sings this , it sounds like she's singing the words reading them out of a script. Kelly "performs" this song.

  • Kelly changed the music to not be the same version of Carrie, too loved the way she sang, brought the song to her and destroyed.

  • this is so good! reminds me somehow of Whitney in her prime days.

  • She is amazing and she gives me chills when she sings! <3 Her!!

  • Is she real? 0o

  • omg, this is simply an amazing cover. Love both version the original from Carrie and Kellys

  • I love both Carrie and Kelly. I think Carrie has amazing clarity and range, but quite frankly - her singing ability is rather one-dimensional. Kelly can do all that but also consistently demonstrates unbelievable versatility, soul, and control. She can sing anything on the planet and make it sound great.

  • To SpeakNowand PlayOn, this is what is called a cover. No disrespect to Carrie fans but I prefer Kelly's more soulful version.

  • Okay okay. No doubt about it, Kelly does have a more soulful voice than Carrie, and both Carrie and Kelly are VERY talented. I love both. However, I do not like how Kelly changed up the tempo, melody, and the words. If you're going to sing someone elses song, have the decency to leave it the way it was made. There was NOTHING wrong with Carrie's version. Why change what doesn't need to be fixed, ya know? I'm glad Kelly likes Carrie's music though, wish they would duet =/

  • @SpeakNowandPlayOn I understand what you are Saying but a cover i Suppose to be different, its person views the song. both versions show the same concept just different emotion.

  • Ladies & Gentlemen the one and only Miss Kelly Clarkson OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE

  • All the "children" like to get into a pissing contest. My artist is better than yours, my artist has more octave range than yours, my artist sells more records than yours! Give me a break. I'm a CU fan but love Kelly too and they both do great jobs on this song and if either is "better" is just your opinion as there is no "fact" when it comes to personal taste.

  • @classicmicro THANK. YOU. I love both artists... and though I'm defs biased towards Carrie's original version... you can't deny that Kelly is incredibly talented.

  • Wish all Carrie and Kelly fans would just look at each of these artists for their own amazingness. Kelly was tweeted by a fan awhile back and they said that she was better than Carrie. Kelly's answer " NO ONE IS BETTER, WE'RE JUST DIFFERENT". And there you are guys!!!!

  • ALL WHO DISLIKED THIS VIDEO IS CARRIE FANS, let's face it.. both are talented.. and has nice range and personality.. but kelly's voice is just way soulful and it demands attention.. stop being idiot repeating who had bigger range and who sold more.. Kelly got 3.2 octave range, carrie got 2.3.. kelly sold 23million albums and 36 million singles.. kelly belts 6 notes higher than carrie.. and an octave higher.. KELLY IS BETTER.. DEAL WITH IT! A FACT! not saying carrie sucks coz she is very talented

  • @carshe209 i totally agree with you, the carrie fans who come on a kelly video to spew their crap ruin it for me, because of them i can't stand carrie and will not buy her records. it's the voice people not how much they weigh or how many records they sold. to me kelly is better but carrie does have a good voice, but i don't go on carrie's videos to say that. ( i come on kelly's videos instead LOL) :)

  • @carshe209 FYI Carrie has > 3 octave range, but Kelly's version is great too.

  • @carshe209 Likely not the Carrie fans that badmouth Kelly. Most Carrie fans are also Kelly fans. I suspect it's Taylor Swift fans posing as Carrie fans that make the bad comments about Kelly. They are always trying to stir up crap about Carrie to take away from the fact that their girl sings like shit.

  • She must be from another world. Nothing on earth could sound this heavenly!!!!

  • uhm HI... how amazing does she want to actually be?!

    WHOA. <3

  • ...woah.

  • Wowwww!!!! Just Wow.

  • ...and that is why we all love her!

  • Ashley brought me here!Thanks Ash for making our Kelly so beautiful & always support her even when she pissed you off sometimes :)

  • her voice is unbelievable!

  • What a voice! Am always always always gonna be a huge KC fan

  • I've always loved that song, and Kelly has always been one of my favorite singers of all time, so to hear the two come together is just amazing. This version was perfection

  • Bitch whyd ya cut your hair!!!!

  • My first thought: It's impossible to sing like this, just unreal...This woman is a God gift

  • OMG what was that? I'm speechless, AMAZING <3

  • Now that's how you do it! :'))) My favorite Carrie song covered by my favorite singer of all time. She can do anything.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more