Noel Gallagher - If I Had A Gun - Live on Later... With Jools Holland (HD)

[matigues]

Noel is brilliant

[LedilsonD]

anthony chewed gum does not sing or anything else in music

[MrBriaman]

1 dislike was from liam

[leonoiz]

@MrBriaman and Two dislikes was from liam on another account.

[dave790]

Good tune, good performance. Stood out by a country mile on this episode of Jools.

[continuouscurve]

I'm not willing to listen to the opinion of anyone who can't string a sentence together using words. This performance is piss poor. If I had a gun...

[trampusjones]

I think it's shit too.

Just saying.

[NeutralRain]

I love you, Noel Gallagher! I really admire you! You're the highest british artist!

[victoreun]

1:21

anthony kiedis: "ok, have to admit it. this guy makes way better music than me."

[juankevinable]

@victoreun hahaha i dont think so n__n

[arturtregozi]

PERFECT.

[chizeys]

I swear Anthony Kiedis looks like a beefed up Hitler... >.>

[stevierotten22]

looks like anthony kiedis is weighing up noel for a fight with his arms crossed lol but he is probably loving the music:)

[BlackWhisper28]

Red Hot Chili Peppers standing somewhere in the back... interesting

[rhcpemma1990]

flea

[alejosan74]

great videos!!! thks

[fondoogle]

Makes ya go cold.

Legend.

[livlavluv23]

see it goes to show that real talent doesnt need crazy tattoos and big hair like the other characters oggling him lol...he was smashing it with real talent..and thats why his career has lasted this long. keep it real Noel!!

[DallasChilders]

Paul McCartney 2.0

[bonkatron]

boring mediocre !! trundles along like a boring train on its way to boring city via boredom central, seriously Noel, if you did have a gun, do us all a favour and stick it in your gob ! it might help stent your awful attempt at singing

[iliatilev]

@bonkatron ahahhhahaha go fuck yourself bitch you dont have the intelligence to comment Noel's videos! Go watch Sponge Bob! ..

[bonkatron]

@iliatilev thanks for your kind words, music is obviously a matter of opinion and in my opinion this is shit ! for some reason this has provoked a strange aggressive outburst from yourself, where you feel you have to abuse me from behind the safety of your computer.. please explain to me (genuine plea) what is so special about this performance, personally I can't understand why anyone would think this sounds good !!

am i missing something ?

[JoanCWood]

@bonkatron yes, probably you forgot to connect your ears to your brain. bitch please, you were the first one who came here defecating your clear not taste on music, saying what you don't know and don't understand. noel does not sing as an angel, but he does has technical skills. go comment on bieber's videos and let real music fans appreciate real music videos.

[bonkatron]

@JoanCWood sorry didn't realise that having a negative opinion on Noel would label me a beiber fan ??? jesus christ i would rather poor bleach directly into my eyes than listen to the likes of bieber !! I love real music, I just don't think that Noel's as good as he thinks he is and this live performance is dia.. his a great song writer who is capable of a lot more... and no, he's not technical, he plays the guitar like an amateur

[chizeys]

@bonkatron See I never understood why people like you for example come to watch vids when you don't appreciate them and like them. Noel has never said he was good or great live, look up your shit before blurting out and second he may not be as technical with his guitar as some other artists but ill bet you he's made more hits than them and can pull out a #1 song than most. Anyways it doesn't matter how technical you are as long as the song is good to listen to.

[bonkatron]

@chizeys I felt an urge to criticise his performance after seeing him on Jools ! basically what your saying is: if I had known he doesn't state to be good live then I wouldn't be within my rights to have an opinion ? maybe he should put a disclaimer on his live show tickets to avoid disappointment.. but i totally agree on the fact you don't have to be a great musician to make great music and Noel has written some classics, I personally find his new stuff weak, hence the bad comment..

[chizeys]

@bonkatron To say his songs are weak is funny because his album went #1 and not only that people have said this is the best he's done since Definitely Maybe and Morning Glory. And I'm just stating that your criticism is just like all the cliche ones. If you actually came up with some decent criticism then fine but talking about his guitar playing and shit that's old news and if you clarified why his music was weak then that'd be a different story.

[bonkatron]

@chizeys his album went to No. 1 because his die hard fans lapped it up the moment it came out, its been dropping ever since ! personally I wouldn't compare his new album to anything off Definitely Maybe, only a mad man / someone who stands to make money would state that. Personally i would have liked Noel to come out with something edgy and exciting, riff based rock with killer hooks, I find his new stuff trundles along a well trodden boring path, crap melody's and boring chord progressions !

[chizeys]

@bonkatron I'm only stating facts. And no his album didn't go just #1 because of die hard fans idiot. What an ignorant statement. His album went #1 because people actually fucking enjoyed it. And the album can be compared to Definitely Maybe. It's been done. If you don't like his new shit then why are you still here?

[bonkatron]

@chizeys so his die hard fans didn't rush out and snap it up then ? and they all enjoyed it? everyone I know who bought it was disappointed !! definitely maybe is an exciting album, full of youthful tension and angst, this album in my opinion isn't anywhere near as good and yes i did buy it .. if you or anyone else didn't retort with abuse or a question? I wouldn't still be on here boring on !!

[RawjerLee]

@bonkatron Not to add to this, but you're saying that the Foo Fighters have the third best rock album of the year (behind Noel Gallagher) and Coldplay has the first because of their loyal fan-base? There's a reason these three have loyal fan bases and that's because they produce great music. You've stated an ignorant comment in which you can't back up because Bieber and Gaga have great fan bases as well. I don't like their stuff, but you can't deny that they have a loyal fan base.

[bonkatron]

@RawjerLee I've stated an ignorant comment because I didn't enjoy / like this performance and said album !! gaga and bieber have a loyal fan base, is that because they make great music ? or would you only state that if the artist was more credible ?

I actually haven't got a clue what point your trying to make other than stating that: because music fans stay loyal to an artist must mean that they can't make any bad music ? the crux of my point being, performance = bad ( in my opinion )

[fondoogle]

@bonkatron

You know who Justin Bieber is and could list 10 of his songs.

I'm still listening to Be Here Now.

1-0.

You're shit, ahhhhhh.

[bonkatron]

@fondoogle justin bieber is a fucking parasite / oxygen thief, get your facts right !! ... try reading and digesting the full content of the rant before you butt in ... " if i had a brain " etc etc 

[ClyderSkyner]

@fondoogle Justin Bieber comments on youtube, that's shit. Bieber may be a musical crap, but that thing of posting anti-Bieber commets to show how you skilled in music are, and what a good taste you have... smells.

[chizeys]

@bonkatron You're obviously not getting the point since your so single minded. His album went #1 because people enjoy his music, it's not just the die hards who bought the album. You can always ignore if you ever heard of it.

[bonkatron]

@chizeys I understand people enjoy his music, I could say Noel Gallagher is crap till the cows come home, his wallet tells me otherwise.. my whole point, that has been twisted and turned, people mentioning other artists etc etc is that this performance in my humble opinion is bad, I also don't think his new album is very good ! .. except the fact that I have an opinion and stop taking it personally !! jesus christ do you love him or something, I could quite easily criticise somebody I admire ...

[chizeys]

@bonkatron Wow you are so blunt. I am just defending my position in saying that his numbers prove why he's is so great. I don't see many other artist who can sing their songs today. A lot of them use technology to help them sing and when you see them live it blows your mind. And I'm not taking it personally I just find it funny that you think this performance is bad.

[bonkatron]

@chizeys jesus christ give me strength, there's thousands of artists that can sing live, what a ridiculous statement ! get your head out the charts and you might discover something called music, not spoon fed money making pop pap.... for the last time, I'm not disputing Noels popularity... His greatness doesn't change the fact that I think this performance is shit !! did you see the show this was on ? it was like watching a child amongst adults ...

[chizeys]

@bonkatron Wow idk wtf you watch. There are hardly any bands out there in the "music" industry that can sing their owns songs. True statement. Oh I thought the charts had music... I guess the music industry made it up for looks then... how odd. I wasn't disputing his popularity just backing my shit up idiot. Look you have your opinions and I got mine. Idc about you, idk why you are even on this. Your the only kid here that thinks its shit. Bye.

[RawjerLee]

@bonkatron Don't listen to everyone else, you're just entitled to your own opinion. However, if you think that he's not a great musician, why are you here? Plus, he's already stated that his singing and guitar skills are above average at best - his lyrics make his songs.

[bonkatron]

@RawjerLee I'm on here because I felt compelled to state my views !! isn't that what a comments forum is for ? I haven't commented on any other Noel videos apart from the ones I personally saw on Jools ! as I thought that he was awful, especially compared to the other bands / musicians who were on there ! ..

[McChickenjoy1]

@bonkatron HAHAHA. Now get the fuck off.

[bonkatron]

@McChickenjoy1 thanks for that McChicken, its great to be abused by someone who shares a username with a tasteless greasy McShit burger !! obviously your taste in food reflects your taste in music ......

[ains085]

best live performance ever!!!! Noel is the best cant wait to see live at Sheffield in feb!!!!1

[STGuilherme]

@Melwen2626 you have the best of internet on you channel.