Syeikh al-Qaradhawi: Sunnah & Syiah (subtitle BM)

[wardahali1]

Inti ajaran syiah 12 imam adalah MENGHUJAT KEPRIBADIAN ROSULULLAH!!!

[pesilatKELATE]

syiah shit!!

[sayyid14]

@pesilatKELATE Shit + E = Shite there are always SHIT=EEEE(mean or same with eerrr yaaksss) tahi eeeeiiikk(e) gilenya shia ni najis!

[mahariism]

Al Quran itu mukjizat Nabi Muhd saw Sila lawat sesawang Rashad Kahlifah tentang kod 19. Tak ada alasan utk mengatakan Quran itu x lengkap.

Umat Nasrani percaya Nabi Isa itu anak Allah.

Umat Islam percaya Hadis Nabi Muhd. itu perkataan Allah.

"Apabila nama Allah saja diseru hati mereka yg tidak percaya akan

hari akhirat berpaling keblakang

tetapi bila nama selaian nama Allah di seru berserta Nya

mereka hati mereka menjadi tenang". (Az Zumar 39:45)

[nsr2224]

Syiah...Pelampau Agama!

[NasserAlhak]

Thank God I have a mind

[NasserAlhak]

La ilaha illal-lah, wahdahu la shareeka lah, lahul-mulku walahul-hamd, wahuwa AAala kulli shayin qadeer. la hawla wala quwwata illa billah, la ilaha illal-lah, wala naAAbudu illa iyyah, lahun-niAAmatu walahul-fadl walahuth-thana-ol- hasan, la ilaha illal-lah mukhliseena lahud-deen walaw karihal-kafiroon.

[NasserAlhak]

‘None has the right to be worshipped except Allah, alone, without partner, to Him belongs all sovereignty and praise and He is over all things omnipotent. There is no might nor power except with Allah, none has the right to be worshipped except Allah and we worship none except Him. For Him is all favour, grace, and glorious praise. None has the right to be worshipped except Allah and we are sincere in faith and devotion to Him although the disbelievers detest it.’

[VBMalaya]

Alhamdulillah, the egyptian are still listening to their ulama'. May the black flag rise once again! Allahuakhbar!

[yusufbest]

Therefore, as we can see that shia beliefs are guided closely by Quran and sahih hadith and strong intellectual reasoning, therefore it can be said that shia Islam is the original Islam. Anyone who does serious research with guidance from Allah will definitely accept shia Islam unless he has syaitani arrogance.

salaams

[staringku]

@yusufbest why syiah people reject the other khalifah except ali, n why alot of syiah praise saidina Ali more than our prophet Muhammad pbuh

[yusufbest]

@staringku,

I have just one question for you. have you ever heard shias say the selawat? how do they say the selawat?

salaam

Allahuma salli ala Muhammad wa aali Muhammad

[akikazu87]

@yusufbest u are trying to say that ahlul sunnah followers is kafir?? fuck u shia laknatullah

[yusufbest]

@akikazu87,

no. I believe that even anyone who declare shahada are muslims even if they are as foul mouthed as you. salaam

[yusufbest]

another sunni hadith:

The Messenger of Allah (PBUH&HF) said: "The Shia of Ali are the real victorious in the day of resurrection/rising"

Sunni references:

al-Manaqib Ahmad, as mentioned in:

Yanabi al-Mawaddah, by al-Qundoozi al-Hanafi, p62

Tafsir al-Durr al-Manthoor, by al-Hafidh Jalaluddin al-Suyuti, who quotes the tradition as follows: "We were with the Holy Prophet when Ali came towards us. The Holy Prophet said: He and his Shia will aquire salvation on the day of judgment."

[yusufbest]

How can you say there is no word 'shia' in Quran and hadiths when I have already shown you the references to check out? I am no liar. You have to respect your own intellectuality.

Shias believe that after Rasulullah s.a.a.w's death, Allah appoint Imams as our guides to prevent Quran from being misinterpreted by people. Sunnis believe that we can choose our own leaders. Now I challenge you to prove from Quran where Allah says we can choose our own leader after Rasulullah s.a.a.w

[yusufbest]

I have answered your challenge and now I give you the chance to answer my challenge.

Where in Quran does Allah say we can choose our own khalifah?

What is the method to choose our own caliph according to Quran?

becos Islam is a complete religion. Of course it must have say something about successorship to Rasulullah s.a.a.w. Show us all. Syukran wa salaam

[spastic81]

@yusufbest where is your answer? i didnt see or read any about your answer! maybe you can`t answer my question. i write its once again. WHAT IS THE MAJOR DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SHIA AND SUNNI! by yourself opinion without asking or refer to the book of shias! ( because once you refer from the any books of shias you`ll twist the words! and i can`t accepted that! try be yourself and answer my question by yourSELF opinion! ) if you can give me the answer i`ll leave you without any debate! thats it...

[spastic81]

@yusufbest is it word followers pointing to Shia?come on mate! dont so greedy on that! i know that you already read too many books of shia thats why your mindset already burn and blur with all of this.dare to twist the Al-Quran words and meanings.i dont understand how can you accepted the disease on you. so, like this mate.i see you also cant help yourself either. we have to decide. you take your part. i take my part.what i know i never ever dare to twist or change the holy book Al-Quran Kareem.

[spastic81]

@yusufbest owh mate~ idoelogy based on your shia opinion is different! i`m so tired with you. just let it be like that! dont try to make the other story and do a copy / paste from shia`s ideology. because shia`s themself already said ` shia`s have their own Al-Quran that 3 times more than the Al-Quran nowadays`. Astagfirullah... thats means shia already ADDING and CHANGE the words of Al-Quran Kareem. remember, Allah S.W.T promised that HE will protect and keep the Al-Quran safely until Qiamat!

[yusufbest]

@spastic81,

hmm... to be honest, I am confused. Allah promise too protect His Quran. Shia have their own Quran 3 times more than Quran.

Are u saying shias are more powerful than Allah? Nauzubillah.

What a fitna. May the curse of Allah be on those who spread fitna knowingly.

Truth is brother, shias have the same Quran as you. This is what happen if you wants to learn about shia from sunni books. By any standards, thats unjust.

Anone who says there is another Quran is a liar

[yusufbest]

anyway, its apparent to all here that you do not know how to read the Arabic Quran. Thats ok and fine with me. But I dont understand how come when one does not know Arabic, one can confidently say that there is no word 'shia' in Quran. You have to be honest. This is the first time I meet someone who confidently make a claim while not having the knowledge on it.

The word shia is in the Arabic Quran. Its not tafseer. Its not translation. Its in the original Arabic Quran. Theres only one Quran

[yusufbest]

there is no reason why any muslim must be a sunni. But if there is, please explain to me why. why stop this conversation? If you dont know why and you just have blind faith, then admit it. I will understand since I had blind faith before too, until Allah guided me to the true Islam.

Anyway, I have shown enough that shia follow Quran and authentic sunnah. If you wish to believe in illogical fitna and wish to stay in ignorance, thats your choice.

salaams

peace be upon Muhammad and his progeny

[yusufbest]

"They desire to put out the light of Allah with their mouths, but Allah is intent on perfecting His light though the faithless should be averse"

(Holy Quran 9:32)

[spastic81]

@yusufbest Nice.. you pointed this verse to yourself. Alhamdulillah...

[yusufbest]

@spastic81,

Holy Quran 37:83

Verily among those who followed his Way was Abraham.

Wa-inna min sheeAAatihi la-ibraheema

Can you see the word 'sheeaatihi'. I got this from a sunni website. The problem is one can be an intelligent being in almost everything but when one talks about religion, one can suddenly become dumber than a five year old child.

My conscience is clear as I have seen the proofs and my yakin has increased especially after seeing that many people are just blind followers.

[yusufbest]

let me show the original Arabic again so that everyone here knows who is lying

(Holy Quran 37:83)] وَاِنَّ مِنْ شِيْعَتِهٖ لَاِبْرٰهِيْمَ‌ۘ

The word shia is there. There is no doubt about it. You sure you can speak Arabic. Now, be a man and admit your mistake. Even if you do not want to admit, the truth is the truth. Seek the truth, you will find it. Run away, truth will still come to you.

[yusufbest]

brother, since you have been brainwashed by fitna spread in sunni books and refuse to open up your horizon, you think we shias are like you.

Brother, hadith books are not perfect. The collector of hadiths are not perfect. We shias do not take all hadith as sahih. There is no such thing as a sahih shia hadith book unlike sahih bukhari etc. Our ulama investigate each hadith on its own merit. Hadith that is against Quran is definitely false and can be thrown out of window

[yusufbest]

We shias believe that Quran is perfect and Allah protects it. That is what we all believe.

I have shown you earlier that your sunni hadith book say that a goat eat a verse of Quran. Now, although some sunni ulama say the hadith is sahih, we shias respect our sunni brothers and say that sunnis like shias believe there is only one Quran.

Just because you are afraid of truth does not make truth a fantasy. Shias are man enough not to run away even if people insult them.

salaams

[yusufbest]

"There is no compulsion in religion; truth is clear from falsehood"

Holy Quran 2::256

If it is not clear than it is not truth. Islam is clear, perfect and complete. Not just because we said or thought it is but because it is.

peace

[martini926]

@yusufbest Hey man. stop your bullshit. is this part of your TAQIYAH a.k.a lie first, truth second?

[spastic81]

@yusufbest i want to stop this conversation because you still refer from the shia`s IDEOLOGY that doesnt make sense to us. you keep saying that words `shia` is there in the Al-Quran. you just dream and fantasize after Shia brainstorming your heart! ok, you keep living in your fantasy and dreaming about your word shias!. it`s doesnt change my life.

[spastic81]

@yusufbest i`m work in Qatar and arabic is my third language since 7 years ago. i`m practically used arabic daily in my life for now. i also want to say this is my 1st time have a conversation with hard-header! and i want to show you the words coming from shia`s about Al-Quran ;

Shia`s says : original Al-Quran will not come into view until the manifestation of Iman Mahdi ( shia`s 12th imam ) by Anwaar ul-Na`umania, Vol#12, Page#360 Published Iran. and many2 more statement circle on it.

[spastic81]

@yusufbest another words you try to twist! shia`s is only know how to twist the words. even you also didnt know what is the propaganda was happen inside the shia`s union,how can you describe yourself being a shia`s member/supporters? and you said, anyone who says there is another Al-Quran is a liar means Shias is liar! because shia said that! and everyone knows. ok, if you denied it and saying the issue coming from the traitor inside the shia`s union, means Shia`s khilaf and blunder! FRAGILE!

[spastic81]

@yusufbest keep adding words didnt means anything for the peoples who have brain and know the truth! keep it up~keep it going~keep it your own~ whatever you write here it doesnt change anything on me. because i know my AKIDAH is the truth.i do BELIEVE only ONE god Allah S.W.T and His Prophet is Muhammad S.W.T.the Al-Quran is the best reference without CHANGING any words with the ideology who will make Muslim destroy.and the sunnah Rasulullah is the best guide of life according to the SAHIH ones!

[yusufbest]

"And he (Moses) went into the city at a time when people (of the city) were not watching, so he found therein two men fighting, one being of his Shia and the other being his enemy, and the one who was of his Shia cried out to him for help against the one who was of his enemy" (Quran 28:15

again you have to know Arabic. English translation of course will translate the word shia. The word shia is in the Quran brother. Sometimes you have to admit truth even if you dont like it.That is call justice

[spastic81]

@yusufbest that`s shia`s ideology! how many times i want to tell you. the meaning from your shia`s translation is totally kachara! according to shia`s idealogy they will keep saying that their are the chosen ones in Al-Quran. same like you! i`m not ulama3 and you either. i dont know where you studied me either. so, just like this. i give you the verse from Al-Quran below ;

[yusufbest]

@spastic81,

salaams to you.

I think once you read the Quranic verse I quoted in Arabic, then case is solved.

I will explain once again. Shia is an Arabic word. It is NOT a translation. Allah use the word 'shia' in the Quran in its ORIGINAL form which is in Arabic.

I quoted many sunni hadiths too. It is up to you to research. And yes, I agree. Only Allah can change hearts.

[yusufbest]

if you want to study about Islam, do you read a book written by christians?

If you want to learn science, do you read a book written by a mechanic? Of course not.

So, why is it when you want to learn about shia, you have to read sunni books? Is that logical? Brother, respect your own intellectuality. Be a just muslim.

[yusufbest]

the major difference between shia and sunni is that shia believe that after prophet Muhammad s.a.a.w's death, Allah has appointed Imams to safeguard the religion from misinterpretation. The shias believe that the Imams know best the correct interpretation of Quran and are direct inheritors of the true sunnah

Sunnis believe that Allah did not appoint any Imam or successor and we can interpret Islam by ourselves using Quran and hadiths narrated by any companions of prophet s.a.a.w.

[yusufbest]

my question to you my dear brother in Islam, why must we be sunni muslims? whats the reason?

google 'Amaan message' which is signed by many sunni ulama including sheikh Qardawi himself. Read that please.

salaams

[yusufbest]

And remember that Abraham was tried by his Lord with certain commands, which he fulfilled: He said: "I will make thee an Imam to the Nations." He pleaded: "And also (Imams) from my offspring!" He answered: "But My Promise is not within the reach of evil-doers."

Quran 2:124

[spastic81]

@yusufbest yes! that`s right! so, what i`m here wanna to say... i`m totally didnt accepted what is the shia`s opinions~ ok mate. stop the conversation here. because seems you already know which part muslim have to stand for! that`s your choice between 2 of it... if you still wanna shia on you right its up to you. because both of us have a MAJOR different here. take care yourself and have a nice day~

[spastic81]

@yusufbest you are so naive here mate. try to give an example with the stupid and poor argument. who said i want to learn about shia while i know the shias is not true? why i want to put myself in NARR while i know i already live in the true part? and 1 thing, since you said Be a just muslim is not for me. be a just muslim only by a name on your i.d or birth certificate? i`ll give you my statement... Be a REAL muslim. tired on you mate!

[spastic81]

@yusufbest i`m learned arabic when i`m in school. and for us who trust with our AKIDAH.. words of SHIAS just created by philosopher Arabic who`s the shias theirself! how many times i wanna to tell and told you! thats shia`s word coming and exist from shia`s ideology to add inside the Al-Quran! i never saw a single word in Al-Quran wrote SHIA`s ( in arabic writting! ) you try to twist the meaning so i want to say here... IT`S NOT ACCEPTABLE! forever and ever until Qiamat...

[spastic81]

@yusufbest Therefore do thou give admonition,for thou art one to admonish. Thou art not one to manage (men's) affairs,But if any turn away and reject Allah, Allah will punish him with a mighty Punishment,For to Us will be their return, Then it will be for Us to call them to account.(Surah Al-Ghaasyiyah:21-26) ~you have to read it clearly with your mind and heart.even Prophet Muhammad S.W.T dont have a power to change the peoples heart,who is me?only a small slave for Allah S.W.T. take care mate!

[weeezeee111]

Thank you brother for uploading this video. We should work together whether Shiah, Sunnis ,Wahhabi etc. against our real enemies, the Zionist. We must work out our similarities instead of barking on each other on the differences. This is what our enemies want, to split the Muslim unity.

[spastic81]

@weeezeee111 1st thing you should have to do is stop ALL the shias activity for cursing sahabah, rejecting hadith sahih (mostly from Abu Hurairah), praise highly Ali A.S more than Prophet Muhammad, thinking the twelve imam is the chosen ones, drawing a picture of sahabah, reading a shia`s kitabs more than Al-Quran, disturbing jemaah at Masjidil Haram who in solah with their sing-a-long songs,doing asyurah who just hit the body and bleeding and many2 more. while the muslim is nothing like that!

[yusufbest]

not ALL shias curse the sahabas and some sunnis curse Yazid and Muawiya too.

Sunni not shia historians record that caliph Umar got Abu huraira beaten up for narrating hadiths. So, you have got issues with sunni historians not shia. We dont practise double standards.

The point is that many of the sunnis are discarding the sunnah of Rasulullah s.a.a.w. but we dont say ALL sunnis. Thats extremist way and Islam is middle way.

salaams

[spastic81]

@yusufbest for me ALL shia is bad! thats it! Mat Allah S.W.T will lead all shia members the true way of life!

[yusufbest]

@spastic81,

you say all shia are bad. I say there are always bad sheep in all community. Unfortunately, you are not honest to yourself. Being a muslim means you must be a person of reason. You must follow the conduct of Rasulullah s.a.a.w who is the best example for man. He is a reasonable man.

Where is this kitab of shia that shia wrote themselves? where are they? You have a wild imagination

[spastic81]

@yusufbest i just follow with Al-Quran and Hadith. no others will change it! i want to ask you. what is the MAJOR different between SUNNI and SHIA? why must have sunni and shia in ISLAM?if you answer that without any doubt on me. i`ll let shia go with thier shadow! and wanna tell you the `reason` is INSIDE the AL-QURAN and HADITH!

[yusufbest]

@spastic81,

ok brother, thanks for your challenge. All the muslims here are still waiting for your views on the Sunni Hadith that I quote earlier. By the way, are you sunni? I have to ask this because there are many zionists pretending to be muslims in youtube who like to see shia and sunni fighting.

[yusufbest]

sunni hadith:

The Messenger of Allah said to Ali: "Glad tiding O Ali! Verily you and your companions and your Shia (followers) will be in Paradise."

references:

Fadha'il al-Sahaba, by Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, v2, p655

Hilyatul Awliyaa, by Abu Nu'aym, v4, p329

Tarikh, by al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi, v12, p289

al-Awsat, by al-Tabarani

Majma' al-Zawa'id, by al-Haythami, v10, pp 21-22

al-Darqunti, who said this tradition has been transmitted via numerous authorities.

[yusufbest]

Quran:

And most surely Abraham was among the Shia of him (i.e., Noah)" (Quran 37:83) 

[yusufbest]

ok, now show me the word 'sunni' or 'ahlus sunnah' or 'wahhabi' in Quran.

You can also share with us where in Quran Allah says that after prophet s.a.a.w died, we can choose our own leaders.

thanks.

salaams

[yusufbest]

No two person in the world have the same opinions.That doesnot mean we have to fight everyone. The more civilised and Islamic way is to discuss and learn from one another. This can only happen when our intention is to get close to Allah.

Arrogance, pride, hatred are characteristics of satan and the reason why it is now accursed. Iblis used to worship Allah for thousands of years with pure tauhid. One act of pride and disobedience caused its downfall. We muslims have to beware.

salaams

[spastic81]

@yusufbest i can see you a good person who had a politeness inside. who is reallly need the truth. who is still dig which part is better. but please.1 thng i want you to do leave the books of shias.leave it far away! its just make you in a fix! i know that you a malaysian. malaysia only hv syariat sunnah wal-jamaah.that what we learn and study from our child.why you still need to put yourself in difficult way? i never see sunnah wal-jamaah incomplete. because al-quran already perfect. MasyaAllah

[spastic81]

@yusufbest no show in Al-Quran word Sunni, Wahabi, Shia, Ahli Sunnah or else! dont you get that! you only tafsiring Al-Quran and Hadith with your shia`s ideology! thats why you HOPE the word shia is inside the Al-Quran nor Hadith. shame on you. better you leave all the shia`s book before it`s to late. before their eat you alive! sorry mate, poor of you~! May Allah S.W.T will open your heart to taubat. insyaAllah...

[spastic81]

@yusufbest Verily among those who followed his Way was Abraham. (Surah As-Saaffaat : 83 ) didnt mention a name of SHIA! dont you dare to add the name of shia inside! Astagfirullah... be careful with what you wrote here according to Al-Quran. dont ever change the tafsir! because your tafsir is according to shia`s ideology! and it`s not acceptable! READ THIS! IT`S NOT ACCEPTABLE if your tafsir it based on shia`s ideology! shame on you!

[yusufbest]

@spastic81,

salaams brother,

you have to check out the verse yourself. The word 'shia' is used by Allah and not by me. Maybe you lack arabic knowledge. Then you have to ask your ustaz to read out the verse to you in Arabic. Shia is an arabic word that means supporter or follower. It is in the Quran whether you like it or not.

[spastic81]

@yusufbest Verily among those who followed his Way was Abraham. (Surah As-Saaffaat : 83 ) twice i give a the phrase. followers in arabic is Atba3an! not shia! "Shia" is the short form of the historic phrase Shiatu Ali, meaning "the followers of Ali" or "the faction of Ali". you guys too much of `praise highly` to Ali than Prophet Muhammad S.A.W. and try to twist the word and HOPPING that you guys are the chosen ones! so sad i continuously heard that. thats all is shia`s ideology. Astagfirullah..

[spastic81]

@yusufbest where`s your answer for my questionare? one more time i asking you if you really want to hold my challenge. what is the MAJOR different between Sunni and Shia? why must have 2 kind/part of muslim sunni and shia? how it`s happen?

[AhmaDNiSFu1]

salam..

aq sunni nk org2 syiah yg bebal thp cipan jwb soaln aq..

1)klau syiah 2 btol yg mne 1 aq nk plih,,sbb syiah imamiyah kafirkn syiah zaisiyah,ismailiyah dan lain2 la..klau dh btol,wtpe nk kapirkn syiah ngan syiah???

dh xde akal..stupid.....

2)pe beze mazhab korg ngan kristian???

bley lukis rasulullah dgn sahabat2..aq nmpk sme sm kristian la........

[martini926]

Syiah is all about politic. syiah people please, come back to the original islam. don't fight over politics. deep inside, syiah is all about politics.

[yusufbest]

@martini926,

so Rasulullah s.a.a.w just praying in his house ignoring politics?

His companions were also just praying and doing no politics?

[spastic81]

@yusufbest please open your mind. what martini926 want to said here is Shiah is totally politics agenda! not a religion! Islam is religion including politics, economics and way of life. how dare you saying that Rasulullah just praying ignoring the politics. Astagfirullah. dont twist peoples words like shias like to do! May Allah S.W.T open your heart, mind and aqidah. Amin...

[yusufbest]

@spastic81.

so, we have many things in common after all. Not all shias are political and since you said that, I assume you are like those christians who read the news and think all muslims are wahhabi terrorists.

We are common because I too based on my personal research believe that the prophet Muhammad s.a.a.w had political and spiritual leadership over the people. even if no human accept him, he will still be the prophet of Allah s.w.t.

[spastic81]

@yusufbest if you saying your research based on your personal, i`ll say that i`m research about shia based on my personal research also. for me shia is a political issue from the beginning indeed! shia like to wrote their own kitab and never eccept this Al-Quran Kareem is perfect! and they said their Al-Quran is the true ones? is it make sense to you? for me shia is totally jerk! and so many propaganda their make for their union. and i dont ever understand they still called themselves is muslim!

[ejajufri]

Kalau gitu, sepakat kah Anda, Syekh Qaradawi, untuk berhenti menuduh apa yg Anda ucapkan?

[dex2813]

Assalamualaikum..

saya percaya ada diantara kita disini yang membela syiah sememangnya syiah..saya juga percaya yang syiah adalah sesat..sesat sesatnya...kita tgk sendri la ibadah mreka..ucapan mereka yang tidak menhormati para 4 sahabat yang utama kecuali saidina Ali...bagi sunni kita menghormati dan selawat dan salam keatas mereka termasuk saidatina Fatimatul Azzahra iaitu anak rasullulah dan juga isteri kepada saidina Ali karammallah huwajhah semuanya...tp tidak mereka..

[Man2873]

@dex2813

Bolehkah saudara buktikan semua tuduhan yang saudara buat ini samada melalui buku-buku karangan ulama' syiah ataupun dokumentari-dokumentari yang datangnya dari syiah sendiri.

Sesuatu itu bukanlah suatu bukti kukuh jika saudara menggunakan kitab karangan sunni itu tak sepatutnya dijadikan bukti

Saya berusaha mencari bukti, tetapi masih belum menemuinya

[rezaichi]

@Man2873 kalau saudara nak tgk bukti syiah hina para sahabat saudara boleh cari dalam youtube... " syiah melaknat sahabat "

[yusufbest]

@dex2813,

waalaikum salaam.

saya dari sunni masuk syiah tetapi setahu saya rukun iman sunni ada enam sahaja. Kenapa awak punya rukun macam lebih je?

[kur4s4ku4s4]

kalau betul pun anak yusuf qaradawi ni syiah,,apa masalahnya? yang nabi nuh tu,,isteri dan anak dia ingkar perintah allah? kita nak salahkan nabi nuh?

[yusufbest]

@kur4s4ku4s4,

betul, isteri rasulullah s.a.a.w pun buat jahat, kita tak terkejut. :)

[0177231064]

...

Muslims shouldn't curse other Muslims or harm or hurt Muslims..

if theres any arguments we could shows GOOD EXAMPLE.

Do not curse, We can talk peacefully.

ISLAM Is About Peace, right?

use Hikmah..

=)

As-salaamu'alaykum..

[Taroreh]

wahabi takkan berputus asa utk melaga-lagakan sunni dgn syiah..

[miemusha4]

panau06 cakap macam bagus..bukti?

[nagasulung]

syiah pendusta paling besar!!!

[ibnurathi]

gjghj

[kambingterbaek]

perbincangan puak2 tak berilmu..

[panau06]

hehehe..anak yusuf qardhawi pun Syiah ape cerita..

sbb tu sekarng yusuf qhardawi dah slow dlm gerakan menentang syiah..sbb dah kena tarbiah oleh anaknye lah tu..

[pef7649]

jgn kata cmtu...

nabi nuh a.s pon anak dia kafir...

tu nabi nuh a.s.

kita bukan nabi...

kita lg lemah..

jgn dok tau kutuk org...

[TheBro090]

jgn sedap2 tuduh anak yusuf al-qardhawi syiah. tunjuk bukti jika kamu berada di pihak yang benar. Yusuf Al-qardhawi adalah ulama' ilmu dia dengan ilmu kamu tidak sama, ilmu dia dengan ilmu orang yang kamu dengar fitnah tentang nya juga tidak sama... dalam berdakwah die ada cara2 nya atau kaedah2 nya.. bukan main semberona saja.. ulama2 dimalaysia juga tidak setanding dengan yusuf al-qardhawi..

[cikguyati81]

org kafir tepuk tgn ja tgk Muslim Bercakaran

[matnoq71]

syiah tu bukan muslim, belajar lah sejarah...jangan bagi komen bodo je

[kazeem88]

last2 anak qardawi nih beraqidah syiah ahlul bayt . menangis tak berlagu la ...

[Azonedaa]

kalau boleh tu,,,,,, sementara hidup dlam dunia ni.. saya berharap syiah dan sunnah,,, bersatu,,,, tentang JEWISHHHHHH,,, TENTERA DAJJAL

[matnoq71]

syiah tu agama lain la...nak bersatu mcmana...cuma mirip je dgn Islam...syiah dicipta oleh Yahudi. Seorang yahudi pura2 peluk islam, namanya Abdullah bin Saba' yang cipta agama ni...

[triodamn]

oo..ye ke..hehe..cube bagi name penuh Abdullah bis Saba' ni..dengar citer..sejarawan arab x pernah gagal beri name penuh (maksud aku..susur galur name..A bin B bin C bin D bla..bla..) org dari kbilah yang terkenal..n dgr citer jgak..ibn Saba ni berasal dari kabilah popular..amacam bro..

[Taroreh]

ko munglin terpengaruh dgn propaganda wahabi..rajin2 la serach kat internet ttg wahabi..majoriti org sunnah tak mengkafirkan syiah..

[d33l00n]

Orang Syi'ah bernama Syekh Ali al Kaurani dari QOM-lah yang berdusta bahwa anak Syekh al Qardhawi masuk Syi'ah...

Dustanya itu sudah dibantah oleh anaknya Syekh al Qardhawi sendiri.. juga orang-orang lain yang mengenalnya. Termasuk oleh orang Syi'ah sendiri.

[gghpkasa]

macaman org syiah sggup mendera diri sendiri pada hari asyura. sedangkan meratap orang di kuburan pun Rasulullah s.a.w. larang, inikan pula guna pedang, rantai, tampar muka diri sendiri. sebab syiah la org barat mengatakan Islam agama yang tidak bertamadun. Ye la, nak bertamadun apa duk mencederakan diri sendiri. Allah tak pernah bagitau pun adanya benda-benda camtu dalam Islam. Wahai sahabat2 ku dari Syiah, kembalilah kepada Islam. Kamu kafirkan sahabat2 Rasulullah, hina isteri Rasulullah,

[exuaf]

Aku tak boleh selamanya terima SYIAH

[exuaf]

Buat apa la nak bergaduh pasal Ali R.A. Kadang aku pelik jugak orang shiah ni. Ali dah lama meninggal dunia. Masa Abu Bakar jadi khalifah tak der sapa pun tolak atau bantah dia jadi khalifah, Ali pun tak bantah. Kalau Ali yang wajib jadi khalifah masa tu dah ramai sahabat nabi bising dan bantah pasal perlantikan Abu Bakar jadi Khalifah.

[triodamn]

bro..kaji sejarah balik..ali x tentang? cube cakap ape peristiwa yg menyebabkan fatimah sampai keguguran bayinya ketika tempoh pem'baih'an abu bakar?..kalau dapat jwb..bagusssss..cheers..;>

[exuaf]

Bagi tahu aku macam mana dan cara apa Ali menentang semasa orang madinah membaiah Saidina Abu bakar

[exuaf]

Aku tak tahu macam mana fatimah meninggal dunia dan pasal apa. Kalau ko tahu cuba la bagi tahu

[chipmie]

Kalu Saidina Ali KW telah dilantik Allah secara Nas mengapa beliau RA tidak terus menentang sehingga berjaya@syahid? Sedangkan ia perintah Allah?? dan Ali KW maksum menurut syiah?? Saidina Ali KW bukanlah org yg pengecut seperti syiah gambarkan... Beliau org yg sangat tinggi darjatnya... Tanpa sedar syiah telah merendahkan Saidina Ali yg mulia.. Ya Allah sedarkanlah org2 syiah...

[panau06]

pengikut syiah..video nih dah lama...Yusuf qardawi dah tahu kesilapannya memhentam syiah..sbb tu dia kurang glamour sejak kebelakangan ni..

mungkin dah kena tarbiah oleh anaknya yang bermazhab syiah kot..

[triodamn]

hahaha..qardawi lupe sejarah..

syiah cuba memasuki mesir? apasal tak tanye soalan tu dekat salahudin al-ayubi yang membawa fahaman sunnah memasuki mesir taktala mesir dikuasai oleh syiah fatimiah? lawak betul la..

nak sekat mane2 mazhab masuk kedalam mane2 negara merupakan satu kesalahan dari segi kebebasan individu. tidak boleh menyekat seseorang muslim untuk mencari kebenran..

[exuaf]

banyak la ko punya kebebasan. Kebebasan untuk apa memaki sahabat nabi. satu benda yang aku tak boleh terima sama ada aku sunni atau shiah

[zlystonefly]

anda jangan berfikir pengertian pintu Ilmu disitu

sekedar dalam arti berwhudu,berjamaah dan taharoh lain-lainya

Ilmu disitu adalah Ilmu Langit dan bumi.

langit yang bergeserpun ia mengetahuinya

sebagaimana Rasulullah mengetahuinya

ilmu hikmah ilmu fisika ilmu alam

biologi astrologi dan lain lain.

ingatlah kotanya Ilmu maka laluilah pintunya

kalau tidak yaa ......?

[zlystonefly]

satu lagi adakan pintu Ilmu

dibuang lalu mengangkat yang tidak memiliki

ilmu ?

padahal hadis sunni selalu mengatakan mendahului orang yang berilmu ?

mengapa kita tolak kenyataan

kalaulah anda tau kota ilmu (Rasulullah)mengetahui jalan jalan dilangit dan dibumi bagaimana caranya maka anda harus melewati pintunya sekali lagi Pintunya.

[zlystonefly]

nah ketemu ni

Rasul mengatakan kalaulah mau memasuki kota ilmu maka laluilah pintunya ,siapakah pintunya ?

satu lagi coba buka kitab sejarah tentang

haji wada semasa Rasulullah dihari akhirnya

ghdir khum dimn pada saat itu Rasulullah

telah memberi mandat kepada Ali Bin Abi Thalib....

coba buka kitab sejarah dari semua pihak

lalu cari mata rantai yang hilang

atau yang ditambah....ayo mulai

[abadia70]

tertarik dengan ulasan al qardawi tadi.. mengapa umat islam masih bertelagah siapa yang patut manjadi khalifah.. ali r.a atau abu bakar r.a dsb... sedangkan ketika ini mereka semua sudah menjadi sejarah.. yang penting umat islam semuanya mempercayai Allah tuhan yang maha esa, mempercayai Al-Quran, dan mengaku Nabi Muhammad s.a.w adalah rasulullah... kita sepatutnya bermula dari situ untuk mencari titik pertemuan menguatkan semua umat islam.

[SyawalBawal]

Sejarah pjg Sunni & syiah b'larutan hingga kini lepas nabi nabi wafat sehinggakn t'jadinya perang saudara. Darah ummat Islam bertaburan ke bumi angakara ummat islam sendiri. Kalau perbezaan pendpt dr sudut ilmu feqah tak m'jadi maslh besar tp perbezaan ada kalanya hingga ke bab akidah. Islam utk semua bukan kpd sahabat2, ahlulbait, atau khalifah2 semata2. Islam itu Universal utk semua. Kalau tauhid nya 1 tak perlu sangsi atau dgn mudah m'kafirkn sesama muslim walaupun segunung langit dosanya.

[zlystonefly]

sepertinya sulit yaa mencari

tokoh sunni yang baik

yang tidak berbohong yang ,sopan didalam dialog,kira kira dimanayah ?

[kalepensel]

Thank God he still alive!! I hope someday I`ll be like him!!

[saRRaLee91]

All Syiah great Ulama say that the Quran is complete, for example, Sheikh Mufid, the greatest Syiah historian to live.

Anyone who falsely claims that the Syiah do not believe in the Quran, I reply:

"Glory to (Allah), this is a big slander! (Quran 24:16)."

so, stop this nonsense....

who is Qaradhawi??

is he a syiah???

[ammumisr]

fahaman syiah ni mesti dilenyapkan,klu tdk akan mmpengaruhi umat islam lain,jelas sekali syiah adalah sesat dan menyesatkan,akidah mrk terpesong..dan bg org yg membela atau menyokong syiah termasuk jg dlm golongan sesat,wlupun syiah menyembah Allah n sembahyang spt kita tp itu belum cukup jika sanggup menghina al Quran dan menolak hadis nabi serta mengangkat saidina Ali dgn begitu tggi..asas kepada pegangan agama islam adlh akidah,tanpa kekuatan akidah manusia pasti sesat..

[babehugeng]

asalammualaikum ya akhi semua orang juga tau terutama ahlu ilmi kalo syiah tu kafir bukan islam sdh keluar dari dr kelarga kaum muslim.syiah itu munafik tulen pencaci shabat2 rasul mencela rasul  bicaranya takhiyah menuhankan sahabat ali bin abitholib ghuluw penyembah 12 iman mereka.hisbulloh itu hizbu syeton pengecut pecundang orang kafir syiah lempar batu sembuni tangan tai orang syiah

[bersih86]

Syiah terkeluar dari SUNNAH WAL_JAMAAH..

SUNNAH WAL-JAMAAH satu-satunya jalan yg diterima Allah..Nabi Muhammad itu pesuruh Allah bukan Saidina Ali. Syiah menganggap Saidina Ali yg sepatutnya m'jadi Rasulullah..Adakah ini menolak sunnah namanya??Kamu(yg m'nyokong syiah) b'pegang pd al-quran? Habis, mengapa kamu msh berdegil. Sedangkan kita wajib b'pegang pd Al-Quran!!

[048289684]

adakah syiah sesat ?

[azriefaris]

memandai ja cicak ni kta org yahudi reka syiah.tau la cicak mksudkan tu abdullah saba' kan?tahniah abdullah saba' coz cipta agama atau mazhab yg cukup lengkap dan paling tinggi falsafah.slama saya dlm sunni,saya rasa cukup jumud.

[drc4rd1n]

Ni apsl ko ni..jumud2 ni..

ko syiah ke???tp mmg Qardawi ckp x btul pn..

ko jgn mcm2....

[sairussalikin]

masyaallah... angkuhnya al qardawi. cuba teliti ayatnya diatas.. ada orang syiah mempunyai keberaniaan untuk menjawab yusuf al qardawi?? adakah yusuf qardawi itu maksum sehingga tidak membuat kesilapan? inilah punca keangkuhan ahlussunnah yg menyebabkan kebenaran tidak dapat sampai kepada masyarakat. bidang muzakarah ditutup lantaran sentiasa merasa benar dan sempurna dan tidak mahu menerima pendapat orang lain..

[acap66six]

Syeikh al-Qaradhawi memberikan pandangan beliau..terpulang untuk terima atau tidak.

[sairussalikin]

memang lucu bilamana sunnah mengatakan bahawa kita dperintah oleh orang asing dan lupakan persengketaan. cuba lah ikuti perkembangan dunia masa ke semasa, dlm dunia ini semua negara sunnah diperkudakan amerika, sebutkan satu negara sunnah yg menentang israel atau amerika? jawapannya TIADA. hanya hizbullah dan iran yg menentang amerika dan israel tanpa takut. dan hanya mereka yg berani menolong palestin secara terang terangan. mana sunni? hanya cakap je pandai tmasuk qardawi. FIKIRKANLAH

[zil1111]

apabila berpecah belah, kembalilah pd quran, x sangka plak aku yg dikatakan ulama yg terkenal mcm ni seorang pemfitnah,aku da 20thn belajar ttg syiah,yg dia cakap semenya bohong,kalo ajak debat seme x berani,bacalah buku dialog sunah-syiah diantaraulama besar sunnah-syiah, lg ada makna utk kedua2nya......

[islan]

sy sokong zil111 moga...saudara blh mengajar sy ttg isu ini...sy sedia mendengr..

[komandoasia]

wahabbi is still wahabbi!

and dr asri is the wahabbi's puppet!

[hameerulfaisal]

Shiah dan sunnah tak mungkin bersatu syeikh,akidahnya sesat,tabal ali jadi tuhan tak sesat?kata quran tak lengkap tak sesat lagi??kapirkn sahabat tak sesat,kata aishah jalang tak sesat,mengatakn orng sunnah najis tak sesat????piki la baik2

[islan]

sape kata tabal ali jd tuhan?sunnah..kenape kapir sahabat..kamu kaji balik sejarah Islam..baru tau...mengatakan sunnah najis?orang sunnah jugak....sape yang wat finah ni?orang yahudi yang telah menyerap dalam pemikiran org2 islam..spy kita berpecah...JGN SEKADAR DGR CERAMAH AJE..PIKIR,ANALISIS,KAJI BLK

[mnasb]

ni nak bg komen pun janganlah melampau sangat...memang la mereka dah terpesong jauh tapi kalau kita nak kata tu faktanya kenalah correspond to the reality hameerufaisal oi

[drc4rd1n]

Bengong ke ape ko ni...xbca buku..

kalo da xbaca buku jgn r ckp mcm2...

bila msa ali jd tuhan org syiah..

ko sesat ke ape ni...mazhab ape ko ni??

[kleftreble]

tabal ali jadi tuhan tak sesat? - bila plak syiah kata macam ni?

kata quran tak lengkap tak sesat lagi? - yang ni pun bila plak org syiah kata?

kapirkn sahabat - bila masanya dioarang kafirkan sahabat plak?

kata aishah jalang - korang ni biar betul2 nak tuduh orang. jangan main hentam je. better tahu betul2 apa yang korang cakap..kalau orang syiah lain dengar, diaorang gelakkan je sebab nampak sangat la ceteknya ilmu korang.

[poyo57]

bnyk jenis syiah...

lagi pon sape je ko nk bandingkn dgn al qardawi...

sure al qardawi tahu apa yang dia katakan..

ko penah ke pergi iran ?

atau dgr ceramah ustaz2 syiah je ?

[thekatyusha]

To me, As per statement by Yusof Al Qardhawi said, stop talking about the DIFFERENCES between Sunnah and Syiah. The important things is we must find the point of that we understand each other. Fiqh Awlawiyaat = prioritization on certain matter on other matter during critical situation.

[ibnshamsuddeen]

Imam alBukhari:

"I don't see any difference between praying Salah behind a Jahmi or a (Shia) Rafidhi and a Christian or a Jew. They (Jahmis/Rafidhis) are not to be greeted, nor are they to be visited, nor are they to be married, nor is their testimony to be accepted, nor are their sacrifices to be eaten."

(Khalq Af'aalul-'Ibaad, p.14)

[cicakman69]

Jangan Terlalu Taksub Terhadap Ulama2 Lebih2 lagi Selepas wafatnya RASULLULLAH,Kerana Kita Dituntut MEnyembah Hanya Kpd ALLAH. Bukan pd Sesama Makhluk.

[eddycombat]

salah satu tanda tanda besar kiamat adalah apabila kata2 ulama tidak dipercayai dan ulama dan pinggirkan.

[combi1107]

yup dorg ni bukan sesat..lagipun syiah ni byk pecahannya..ade yg taksub n yg xtaksub sgt..ape2 pn same2la kita meyokong ke arah penyatuan mereka..

[Edaladiva]

Hmmmmm Syiah ka Sunni ka..apa nak susah payah fikir...rasa nak ikut sapa ikut saja lah....kalau dah yakin ISLAM....Lain la Tak yakin.....

[akunih]

apapun bagi sayalah syiah ni na da terpesong tol x?klu betol la terpesong na mungkin syeikh Makkah yang jaga pintu masuk masjidil haram bagi orang2 syiah ni masuk wat tawaf dalam tu....saya pun tahu dari sumber yang boleh dipercayai....

[abduh2012]

1)elakkan pengaruh syiah..itu adalah terbaik..

2)oleh kerana mereka menghina para sahabat,dan byk mencipta hadis2 palsu,maka,siapa mereka,anda fikir2kan..

3)ya,kita boleh taqreeb syiah dan sunni di negara seperti iraq..akan tetapi,seOLAH-OLAH mustahil utk mencapainya kerana terlalu byk perkara yang berbeza dengan kita hatta perkara paling asas yakni kaifiyyah /cara solat mereka tersangatlah berbeza dengan mereka..

[kambingbetula]

sapela cipta syiah ni, nyusahkn umat betul..

[cicakman69]

syiah ni adalah ciptaan seorang muslim dari bangsa yahudi.

[BabaRizwan]

Orang Islam perlulah menyokong taqrib baina syiah wa sunnah..jgnlah kita merugikan diri kita lagi.. spt kata syaikh yusuf al qardhawi.. "umar, abu bakr, usman dan ali radiaallahuanhum.. semuanya telah tiada, negeri kita pula diperintah musuh".. kita masih mahu bergaduh? mahu jadi bodoh? fikir2kan

[areevekent]

ape yang aku paham,,maksud 'mendekati' 2 adalah untuk membetulkan kesalahan org syiah nie,,aku pon bukan dalam agamenye tp aku rse syiah nie still terpesong cam dorg anggap imam dorg pon maksum,,sme2la doa Allah jge iman kite,,

[zezzty99]

kesalahan orang shi'a?? emangnya mengikuti keluarga Prophet Muhammad(s.w.h.) itu termasuk salah? Jangan megambil kepatuhan tanpa menyelidiki sejarahnya shi'a? Coba selidiki sendiri Hadith Al Ki'sa dimana Prophet Muhammad mengatakan " Ahl al-Bayt "(artinya Keluarganya Prophet or, in english literally means people of the house) from the second part of verse 33:33 of the Qur'an, the verse called "Ayat al-Tathir" or "the verse of purification"

[akunih]

apa y sya perhatikan Dr. Yusuf al- Qardhawi tidak pula mengatakan Syiah ini sesat.secara zahirlah apa yang y d katakan o Dr. Yusuf al- Qardhawi ini. satu perkara lagi npk Dr. Yusuf Qardhawi pun ingin melihat perpaduan antara dua mazhab ini. oleh itu kita perlulah menyokong usaha ke arah tersebut....apa pendapat saudara2 ku sekalian?

[akudhaif]

Non-muslim memandang sunni dan syiah sebagai muslim. Mengapa harus kita keruhkan pandangan mereka terhadap muslim... Tidak seharusnya kita saling bertentangan... Kita sama-sama berpegang pada kalimah agung La Ilaha Ilallah.

[munsyi]

Maksudnya syiah sesatlah, sebab tu Qaradhawi tak bagi sebar. Kalau mazhab 4 yang lain, tidak pernah dihalang oleh Qaradhawi untuk sebar jika anda megatakan kerana ingin menyatukan mazhab.

Lagipun syiah secara terang sudah sesat malah dihukum kafir oleh ulama2 salaf seperti Imam Bukhari dll.

Mereka sudah terkeluar dari akidah islam kerana tisak menerima para sahabat dan isteri2 Rasulullah. Meraka juga menolak al-Quran kerana bagi mereka Al-quran sudah diubah oleh para sahabat

[Feerhan]

Hmmm....