Added: 8 months ago
From: solacematt
Views: 119,951
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (212)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • words can´t describe how horrible this is

  • Hmmm...another pre-fabbed angst ridden band covering the greatest rock song ever made. Pathetic.

  • it's good, they just need to turn it down a little bit. the sound can easily be distorted by amps or speakers due to it's super high sound. i tried listening to this on a med-high vol in my car with $400 speakers and a lot of the parts just sounded like distorted sound. :/ and this doesn't happen with any other song other than this.

  • @mandy29231

    i disagree i think this is better than the origonal

  • @QuinctiliusVarus right on dude! I agree my generation needs to get some good taste in music, but i doesnt always mean they're going to go for the original version of the song unfortunatly (and yes i knew of this song before this band coverd it lol)

  • not as good as the original but hey, I bet they did this just for fun. Why hate on them

  • it sounds better than their original songs but they still sound like a bunch of angry assholes who practice a lot

  • I'm sorry, I love Mudd, but this cover sucks....

  • Damn good, of course not The Stones even they will tell you that but very professional indeed

  • I cant say what is better original or this remake.So i guess it must be at least equal good no ?

  • This is way better than the Original! Fuck ya'll haters.

  • COMPLETELY RUINED

    

  • @sebaale91 And you are gay too remember? I fuck YOU... I was trying to say in my 1st comment that we can't comparethis cover from the original version, and the singer don't know how to sing, capiche?

  • What a shitty cover ahn?... And the singer's voice is pretty annoying...

  • @mihawkezoro01 Just like you

  • @sebaale91 You never heard my voice, oh yeah, you heard when i fuck your ass, motherfucker...

  • @mihawkezoro01 So you're annoying and gay? I say you are annoying not your voice idiot

  • Rolling Stones blow

  • im sorry but the point in covering a song...is to make it in your own style so yeah...it wont be like the stones version -.-

  • THIS SONG IS SO FUCKING TASTY!

  • everybodies a big shot music critic nowadays i love music wish more bands were this bold.

  • Badd ass song

  • Whoever thinks this cover sucks is out of their minds. The guitar solo is awesome, at least it's better than Keith Richards lame ass one. The drums also give it a little more life than Charlie Watts did. The original version put me to sleep.

  • look, they are giving props to the Stones by doing this song. They did one of the BEST covers of all time in my opinion. Another great cover is Shinedown doing Simple man and Staind doing sober. Great song and great video!!!!

  • it sucks, there's nothing to do

  • lol a large cat being murdered thats rude but funny i love this rock on pom

  • I am a sixty year old Stones fanatic and I love this version. Well done cover versions are a plus for everyone; old songs are given new life and the old groups are honored by the young musicians. Younger listeners are exposed to some of the old classics and old folks are introduced to new, younger musicians. Everyone wins.

  • @QuinctiliusVarus unless it's hannah montanna covering kurt C. then everyone losses.

  • My favorite cover of the original. Unique.

  • I like it and I realize its not like the original by the Stones but a very nice remake IMO.

  • nope.... its the female that they found that makes it bad.

  • 2:53 you can hear a large cat being murdered

  • wow very weak shoulda left this 1 alone......

  • I can't believe I'm going to say this because I'm not even a fan of this band, but this is up there with original. Last two minutes kick hard.

  • here is what i will listen to the day i get shipped to boot camp marines heard this in the 60's now its my turn

  • this sucks

  • @johnreinhold97 your silly XD

  • @solace AT&T...it's fine if u like them but they sold out a long time ago, before this so I guess all I will say to u is enjoy.

  • it's better than the original

  • @Mandy29231 They're not trying to be better than the original. There are tons of people on youtube who do covers of bands songs, do you go and bash them and say why bother you'll never do as good as the original. Probably not, and if you do, that's pretty horrible.

  • @solacematt shes just voicing a her opinion and i agree this is so weak ive heard it covered much better......

  • @Mandy29231 I think a lot of bands cover songs they love because they enjoy playing songs they love listening to. so the stones possibly think its great someone else takes as much pleasure from their music as they do.

  • @Mandy29231 to tell you the truth, I think they did a really good job with the cover. Covers are really tricky to get right without messing up the original song. The away I see it, they changed the son enough that it wasn't the same as the original, but it also wasn't completely different. It could be much worse, just like when Kid Rock ruined Sweet Home Alabama by changing most of the melody and lyrics.

  • @Mandy29231 There are some covers that are better than the original and I happen to love this version. You're saying that no artist could ever cover someone else's song? Total BS as that's usually the biggest compliment to the singer/writers.

  • yes fucking please \m/

  • If i was worth about a hundred million dollars like Jagger and richards, I probably wouldn't give permission for a band to cover my songs, but i guess Keith is still worried he will snort all of his money and his next family relative to die

  • ..this is the best song, Mudd ever did.

  • This cover is just a shot away from the Stones

  • i love how sarcastic/immature you guys are being when you say that puddle of mudd sucks

  • I love Puddle of Mudd, and I love this version!

  • This is fucking horrible, Only came to show to a friend how shitty covers are, Get your own lyrics you shitty artist.

  • @Redstorm3265 ...said the bum sitting on his computer with more money in his wallet than his wallet is worth. Suck on their success dude. They're big time for a reason.

  • It sounds a lot like the original

  • @TheBreakdown2010  Thats what isaid.. untill he dose the little talking/singing in the middle i couldnt tell the difference....

  • Nowhere near the Stones' version, but still a great shot.

  • i think this is terrible... i heard this on the radio the other day when i was getting ready to pump my diesel. and i thought "this has got to be a joke"... and sure enough a p.o.s. band thinks they are good enough to cover rolling stones and think they are good enough to do it good enough.

  • damm good job boys.. You nailed this song..

  • damm good job boys...,.

  • you guys are fighting over it like the Walk cover by A7X(originally Pantera).you know what they did?they listened to their music and didnt complain.you know what that is called?BEING FIKKEN MATURE

  • Fuck me they made a hash of it! (FAIL)

  • if you dont like this,fikk off

  • i wish all these fucking shitty radio bands will keep their hands off of classic songs and stop butchering them fuck these faggots they ruined this song just like waht 5 finger fistfucked did with bad company and what shitdown did to lynard skynards simple man fuck these faggots this is absolute garbage

  • @joelakastud123 Haters gonna hate...

  • @joelakastud123 Seems to me your issue is with the fact that it's a cover. What if I said Cash ruined Hurt, God's Gonna Cut You Down, Desperado...etc because they're covers? Shut it.

  • @joelakastud123 Don't be a douche, they're paying tribute to a band that influenced them, grow up faggot.

  • @CoReYcRaCkDoWn the paying tribute by taking a good song and turning it into another generic radio rock shit version no other way around that

  • They did not do the stones justices... butchered it

  • This just sounds like Wesley Scanton doing a bad karaoke of "Gimme Shelter." Instrumentation's not awful. Whatever happened to the days when Puddle of Mudd was good? I still love "Come Clean." It's a great record. It's all kind of gone downhill from there, though...

  • @TheExie27 Actually this cover is pretty awesome, but the quality doesn't do it justice. I know as I've heard it on the radio and it sounds ten times better.

  • 28 people need shelter

  • to all the haters: it's just good to put a great song out to a whole new generation. I think they were very respectful. To the noobs...definitely check out the original.

  • its a rolling stones song u ass

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • heard this on the radio earlier, really blown away. im generally not a big fan of these guys, but this is an amazing cover

  • Amazing...love this song!

  • Take one of the greatest recordings in rock and roll history. Extract all the nuance. Carefully peel away the subtlety, and let the remaining vestige of talent evaporate. Add 4 cups of Nickleback, and bake until stupid. Play on local commercial radio as the "Black Ops" song.

  • @ambroseaz Did you come here just to bitch?

  • @WolfofShades you bet I did. What Puddle of Mudd did to this song is nothing short of outright blasphemy.

  • @ambroseaz In all honesty, you can't really blame them too much. No one will perform this song anywhere near as good as the Rolling Stones.

  • @WolfofShades yeah but no 1 will perform it as bad as a generic radio band

    just like at what shinedown did to the great skynard or what five finger fistfuck did to the classic bad company!

  • @joelakastud123 you might say this now.. but if you go back and see what the original band says.. they like the way these newer bands did the song.. so in all honesty stfu before u say anything thanks.

  • @joelakastud123 actually there are much worse covers of this song if you would believe it. This is probably one of the better covers.

  • This is an abomination.

  • I like Puddle of Mudd...now more than ever. It's like a dream for them to play songs they love. Wish I had that ability.

  • Comment removed

  • Yeah, like we want a whole generation of kids thinking Gimme Shelter is a Puddle of Mudd song. The cover is OK. I don't really like the vocals though.

  • Good cover but I wonder if they realize they left out a verse.

  • I dislike Puddle of Mudd, but I have to say this does sound good. I could not believe it was them when I heard it on the radio.

  • damn good....fo sho

    

  • 2:53-3:03 sounds just like kurt cobain

  • Damn, I'm a Stones FANATIC and I must admit that this version of the song is great! Puddle of Mudd kept a lot of the originality to this song, from the female backup singers, to the rhythm, and finally to the lead guitar. They've duplicated Keith Richards to the "T" and added their own personal touch. Very good!

  • I dislike PoM and stones covers but this is admittedly the single best cover Ive ever heard . It took over an hour to find out who it was after i heard it.

  • nice

  • I just like "Come Clean" album I think maybe this is very good :)

  • Don't get me wrong I like puddle of mud but this, this is just horrible compared to the original by rolling stones

  • rollings stones is still better. but this is good. but not stones goood

  • love it i heard it on the radio the other day and fell in love with it

  • saw it live! remarkable!!!

  • they were bad ass last night in oklahoma with buckcherry and papa roach an p o d

  • @cheyenne22goodwin i was there too! that was a badass show!

  • @Toxic7Shadow mee too! impressive!

    

  • this is shit

  • you guys are bickering like the people on Pantera's "Walk".youre just being complete idiots over a COVER.who cares if you dont like it?go complain to someone else

  • I love the Stones version so much, but I must say that this comes so close to it. They did a great job.

  • What did they play this on...a ham sandwich?

  • the rolling stones one is WWWWAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY better

  • Whenever someone asks why rock music is dying, I'll just point them to this. Thanks.

  • Good job!

  • Love the song, the only problem I have is where he starts grunting instead of singing which doesnt fit this song, other then that, amazing cover

  • awesome, been hearing it on radio, crank it UP, love the stones man but this f'ing rocks!!!! great job puddle of mudd

  • the fucked up the lyrics 

  • I was driving and flipping between radio stations when I herd the guitar and knew it was gimme shelter but when I herd the vocals I had to refrain from throwing up the worst cover and if they are going to do covers at least sing the lyrics right!

  • =/ I tike them but I think this sounds like ass...

  • I  like POM but this cover ??? bof !!!!! frankly ...the cover of STEREOPHONICS is so much better....

  • not a PoM fan but they did a good job. Heard this on the radio last night and had to find out who did it

  • Original is so much better, but this is fun to listen to.

  • Best remake of a song ever!

  • Comment removed

  • Driving my Shelby stang down i80 and this comes on. Ducking great

  • this is awesome,

    anyone know the other puddle of mudd cover songs?

  • @RIPtheREV800 I posted alot of their covers here from the rediscovered tour. Off the top of my head rocketman, stop draggin my heart around, The Joker, Old man, D'yer M'ker, TNT and a few more. I think I have 13 videos from that concert posted here.

  • i heard this on the radio yesterday.effing awesome

  • am i the only one who doesn't like this cover?

  • @MrPants432 I hate it, haha.

  • @MrPants432 i dont that much either but it aint that bad i dont think

  • F-ing great. Can't wait for the CD to come out. Almost said album,lol...why do we still call them albums? hmmmmmmmmmm

  • This is a damn good cover. I don't care what any of the PoM haters say. Even those people can't deny that. And, jeez, ya gotta admire the bands who rarely play serious shit to tackle a classic like this.

    Rock on, PoM!

  • I totally facepalmed when I heard about this but im glad i was wrong, great cover!

  • great cover

  • This gargles old man balls.

  • Never cover The Rolling Stones. End of.

  • Nailed it

  • I just saw this live in rochester, puddle of mudd fucking rocked it. I like some of their music, some not so much. I will say it was phenomenal. Quite a treat

  • Not too shabby...Puddle of Mudd is one of the few modern rock bands I can semi-enjoy. And the Rolling Stones are, of course, already badass.

  • Modern mainstream rock has turned into Hollywood. These newer bands keep remaking classics and fucking them up. The best part was the backup singer. The guitars were horrible and the singer has always been shite. I give it 0/10.

  • @CleansingtheDamned I give them a 10 for passing the torch onto the next generation

  • It's not as good as the original, no sir, but this is still a pretty good cover. And for PoM, it's a lot better than much of their more recent releases.

  • As if my hate for Puddle of Mudd needed anymore fuel. This is an auditory abortion.

  • This is god damned terrible.

  • This is the worst cover of Gimme Shelter that Ive ever heard.

  • Horrible version of an awesome Stones song...stop covering and ruining great classic rock

  • @kornrocks00cr125 says the guy who likes korn and this is a very good cover they didnt do anything wrong

  • wow good man !!

  • thanks for the upload! :)x

  • not bad at all... ide like to hear them play it live though....

  • @slak96u Watch the Rehearse video at the top of ur page. Then fast forward to the last minute or so. Sounds good to me.

  • I heard this on XM Octane on the way in to work today. Holy shit, that's good. There was a rumor that Keith Richards was going to play on this. Anyone know?

  • Comment removed

  • I like this rocked up version. PoM you guys flat F'n jam!  The chick nails it too. What happened to the "just a kiss away" line of the song?

  • I like this rocked up version. PoM you guys flat F'n jam! The chick nails it too.

  • This is actually pretty good, I expected this to be about as good as Avril Lavigne's cover of Chop Suey.

  • i have this song

  • Awesome

  • sounds like shit

  • Love PoM...This song kicks ass, might get them some of the resepect they deserve.

  • hello apology chance you will not have the original song I'd appreciate it if you had your answer I hope

  • @miguelangelbeta its the stones the did it originally

  • sweet cover...nice job puddle!!!!

  • Best Sounding copy I have found! I can't wait for the album release!

  • my life is complete. i can die now =)

  • I can't wait to see what other covers they did !! This one they NAILED it !! Congrats Puddle !

  • it doesn't even sound like p.o.m. but god damn it's amazing!

  • this is freaking awesome

  • Just heard it on the radio. It won KISW 99.9 The Rock of Seattle's 9:00 song battle against a song by Red. This is awesome.

  • @kingbuggie hahahaha same

  • This is probably the best cover I've ever heard. They did an awesome job. Especially considering that the Rolling Stones are one of the pioneering rock and roll bands and couldn't have been better in their time

  • Yep, gotta say I've never liked PoM and the thought of them covering this song makes me sick to my stomach, but they pulled this off and it sounds great.

  • @axlrosegnr You took the words from my mouth. (and fingers. sticky fingers.  LOL)