Vanessa brings happiness, goodness & love to the world. Its impossible not to feel the love she is giving. I love her so much I can't imagine what life would be like without her. We should all appreciate & love Vanessa & I urge everyone to send her your love & prayers.
@izzatiBH lol my comment is old.. well yes..her mom is a native of Manila, Philippines..actually a Chinese-Filipino-Spanish descent. have you ever tried Google?
Okay, guys, let me set this straight :) She can't speak spanish AT ALL. She simply learned these words to sing them in the show. You can even see her glancing down to read them on stage while she's singing...
Yes, she does have some spanish blood in her, but she can only speak english, people. She's said so herself in an interview :)
She can sing, but her spanish she speaks like a white person not trying to sound mean. she is only part spanish/latina, her spanish not that great to be honest. girl can still sing though
@ilovecarlos89 ughh ive explained this to TOO many people so ima make it plain and simple. 98% of filipinos think they have spanish blood and are wrong.. in reality, only 2-3% fo filipinos really have spanish but 50% have chinese and taiwanese
Spanish(Spain) is a European language stupid americans...the US will turn into a brown indian shithole with ugly people like mexico in a few decades lmao fuck u....karma is a bitch
@mamoymomoy yeah she is! only the spanish part is live and the end! :) i think she can sing live, but maybe she's just scared to failll.... i don't know LOL :D
@dbestbud no she has roots in latin america too.. her mother is chinese, filipino and has roots in latin america and her dad is irish and has roots in native america.. okey? :) because of that she is soo beautiful..
@dbestbud vanessa consists of many backgrounds, shes filipino,chinese,spanish,irish and native american u can check on the net if u dont believe me haha
This is great but i know shes lip synching listen at 2:26- 2:33 when shes singing mind, u can hear that the backing is still having singing that ind sound when her mouth is already closed
@xazngiirlx She is not lip singing i can tell when a singer lipsingz but she is not...check other vids of her..when she was smaller she sings really good and she still does:)
quando comincia a cantare in spagnolo non c''è nessuna voce sotto...è lei proprio dal vivo!! sentite che voce??!!!! è bravissima! io l'adoro <3 come adoro lei! è stupenda! 4ever Baby V!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
when she changes from english to spanish.. it doesn't even sound like her anymore.. it sounds like someone else. she has a major white accent on some words.. i don't think she's singing live either..
it is defentily her voice if ur a little fan or you like the music then can u her it! even a little one from 5 years can here the differents! it is none! she`s good!!
well the bottom line is they ashley and vanessa have 2 Totaly different voices. they both sound great! im more of an ashley fan but yes vanessa sounds great! :D
@eleniJONAS U Freak lah u! anyhow comment! Can u even sing... Please okay... They have different ways of singing! Their problem uh.. U not famous right.. U not popular right! Then just shut up.. This shows u can't even sing compared to them! So just shut the freak up! U have no right to comment okay! Just be a good dog and shut up k ...
@jeanbloom12 woooow. what the hell is ur problem. i was just stating my opinion. what does it have to do with me being able to sing or not? just because i may not be able to sing doesnt mean i dont have my own opinion on what good music is. i think that vanessa is way better than ashley tisdale and that ashley tisdales voice is really high. if you didnt notice, im not the only one who feels that way. 55 ppl liked it. u gunna cuss em too? call em a dog? why dont u shut up before u look stupid.
ok, she's not filipina, she was born and raised in california. her father is amarican and her mother is spanish, filipina and chinees. she speak spanish cause that is a pretty coman language in california
but i think its a bit weird she sux in the other songs except this.
no offense, but i dont think she was any good at all on this concert, but thats my opinion. don't be harsh on me just cuz i don't like her voice live, but if this was live, then, she did great! :)) greetings from norway
me encant como canta yo la coonozi en persona y le dige q le queria pero en ingles jajaj oye es super guapa a y q VIVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA VANESAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
wow!!!!!!lore al oir esta cancion...su español es genial....I CRIED WHEN I HEARD THIS SONG..... HER SPANISH IS GREAT!!!....... ABSOLUTELY, SHE'S THE BEST.....GREETINGS FROM MEXICO CITY!!
ayyy ke lindos recuerdos, estuve ahí esa noche, recuerdo que el único que hablaba español era lucas y que cuando decia bailarines sono un poco como tallarines xdd
(L) es hermosa y canta mas q bien.. pero lo q no me gusta de los recitales q televizaron es q editaron el sonido... y solo dejaron unas partes en vivo....... el resto lo mezclaron con el audio del disco..... :S
basta con mirar videos no oficiales grabados x fans en los recitales (en los q sí esta el audio en vivo) xa ver la diferencia de una voz en vivo y una voz grabada en estudio......
y cuando a alguien le gusta un artista, una de las mejores cosas es escucharlo cantar en vivo ! =)
wwhy has she 2 mics
jbandsg4ever 2 months ago
hermosa vannesa soy su fan
elviscristian1 3 months ago
holaaaaa en espeñol quiero el tema me gustaria encontrarlo alguien sabe en donde lo puedo conseguir gracias saludos!!!desde argentina
adrylamjr 3 months ago
Comment removed
xmamiiciitax 4 months ago
She is so beautiful i love her sooo much!!:)
essanessa73 5 months ago
I love you vanessa hudgens :)
2LWMAGIATV 5 months ago
Y cuando vinieron yo no era tan mega fanatica, y ahora me arrepiento tanto...hubiese conocido a mi idola :'C !!!!!
Zefroncrazy 5 months ago
@Zefroncrazy Quien vino?Solo Vanessa? =)
Thelmina1996 5 months ago
IDOLA!!
ShinjixxMizui 5 months ago
Wwoo! q hermoso Cantha Ella es mi Modelo a Seguir Osea!! D :)
AnneRose98 6 months ago
porque dobló? O:
EmiVickyFan 6 months ago
es la mejor! (L
sofiamaria09 7 months ago
y los subtitulos?
Eniimeju 8 months ago 6
i miss my bf i should of never breaken up with him i still love him a lot i miss him so much i hope he will come back to me
iluvupam 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Vanessa brings happiness, goodness & love to the world. Its impossible not to feel the love she is giving. I love her so much I can't imagine what life would be like without her. We should all appreciate & love Vanessa & I urge everyone to send her your love & prayers.
Ramubay 8 months ago
vc canta de+++
a melhorrr
biatavares100 9 months ago
Nessa has a fantastic voice.......she should sing all the song, but she sings the spanish part only!
scikkitignak 9 months ago
SHE'S THE BEST GIRL AROUND THE WHOLE WORLD
niqotap 10 months ago
guys is her spanish accurate?
xazngiirlx 10 months ago
mmmm me encanta jejejejejejeje lo hiso demaciado bn jejejejej besos vane muakkk
cristopher629 11 months ago
50% American
25%Spanish
25%Filipino
= The Pretty Vanessa Hudgens:)
jenjenCERENO 1 year ago 12
@jenjenCERENO shes a bit of chinese aswell
babyExEdge 9 months ago
@jenjenCERENO she's a filipino?
izzatiBH 1 month ago
@izzatiBH lol my comment is old.. well yes..her mom is a native of Manila, Philippines..actually a Chinese-Filipino-Spanish descent. have you ever tried Google?
jenjenCERENO 1 month ago
Okay, guys, let me set this straight :) She can't speak spanish AT ALL. She simply learned these words to sing them in the show. You can even see her glancing down to read them on stage while she's singing...
Yes, she does have some spanish blood in her, but she can only speak english, people. She's said so herself in an interview :)
I love her!!!
matildacolorful 1 year ago
LOVE IT. she has an amazing voive and i love spanish <3
XoXoNewYorkGirlOxOx 1 year ago
que lindo video como extraño hsm
kariinaaxjb 1 year ago
Anyone else notice the change in sound when it switches from english to spanish and back? ..lipsyncing? xO and you can hear the lag..LOL
tOtAlLyInLoVeWiThEd 1 year ago
@tOtAlLyInLoVeWiThEd wtf??? its laggy because its the video on effin youtube. & no there was no change in the sound ;D
lauruxinjs 1 year ago
She can sing, but her spanish she speaks like a white person not trying to sound mean. she is only part spanish/latina, her spanish not that great to be honest. girl can still sing though
gumboy8 1 year ago
@gumboy8 shes not spanish...
carissa4655 1 year ago
@carissa4655 she's Filipina, Chinese,and Spanish (from her mother); Irish and American Indian (from her father). :)
ilovecarlos89 1 year ago
@ilovecarlos89 ughh ive explained this to TOO many people so ima make it plain and simple. 98% of filipinos think they have spanish blood and are wrong.. in reality, only 2-3% fo filipinos really have spanish but 50% have chinese and taiwanese
carissa4655 1 year ago
she sing really good in spanish...
TheIlovehim99 1 year ago
From wikipedia "her father is of Irish and Native American descent, and her mother, a native of Manila, is of Chinese-Filipino-Spanish descent"
carolburns4 1 year ago 2
@carolburns4
wow XD
darkworrior885 1 year ago
this is awesome
LDisney21dvm 1 year ago
al menos canto en vivo la parte en español jeje. Y lo hizo muy bien...
Oswalvideos 1 year ago 3
Vanessa Hudgens is half Filipina not spanish for you guys who are confused.
m3mane30 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Spanish(Spain) is a European language stupid americans...the US will turn into a brown indian shithole with ugly people like mexico in a few decades lmao fuck u....karma is a bitch
XJorgeLorenzoSpainX 1 year ago
she is lip singing, but she is so beautifull, she has a nice smile! i love here
TheNaydeen 1 year ago
la cancion en español con su voz seria espectacular the song in Spanish with her voice would be spectacular
luis92955 1 year ago
she's lip singing in this video! :D
mamoymomoy 1 year ago
@mamoymomoy yeah she is! only the spanish part is live and the end! :) i think she can sing live, but maybe she's just scared to failll.... i don't know LOL :D
melissamougin 1 year ago
@melissamougin She doesn't lip sing.
brittanylsmoore 1 year ago
im from chile!!
laukowm 1 year ago
she sounds like shes singing in Japanese
saravelasquez101 1 year ago
I like the spanish part
waldemarrrrr 1 year ago 2
from 0:12 to 0:14 she doesn't sound like herself???????? what???
tacosruletheskool 1 year ago
great
Bashiud 1 year ago
Canta genial en español.
She sings really great in spanish :)
Paulaonlylovesyou 1 year ago
shes a powerhouse :-)
yixuan0404 1 year ago
@yixuan0404 lol quentin terentino
timar03 1 year ago
its so cool when she sings spanish :D She is pretty good at it.. :D
maru369 1 year ago
Why does she lip synch here? I think she's not that bad singing live, but here she's really is lip synching. Check out 0:06-0:17
abigailkristina 1 year ago
Playback, she is just singing the spanish part live !
Sunnychack 1 year ago
@Sunnychack i sthink the all is playback.
Kugahh 1 year ago
@Kugahh That is possible !
Sunnychack 1 year ago
trop bien
raihere987 1 year ago
@Sunnychack trop bien
raihere987 1 year ago
exelenteeee..!!!!
YURIDIAZ96 1 year ago
she was great and wasnt dressed like miley
briannedeezy 1 year ago
she has good stage presence, and she sang the Spanish part really well
pokadotguitar92x 1 year ago
wow! this was great!!! nice job Vanessa. ☺
chulita2029 1 year ago
i love her from the first hsm
tacomodolasideas10 1 year ago
You REcorded At Your Stupid TV...
MrRichHabbo 1 year ago
there are some who know about you can get this full version in Spanish of this song
Chanel8273 1 year ago
lindOOOOO
emilio608 1 year ago
Whats her lastes CD??
CamilleLive 1 year ago
she shouldve been a spanish singer even though shes filipino but spanish or english she still sounds great...i love you vanessa!!!!
shyxcrazy31 1 year ago
i think that she does sing live but that the music is way to loud to hear her true voice.. so that it seems that she's the best singer
CARRYB92 1 year ago
she has got the most amazing voice of all the hsm stars!!
and vanessa is ALWAYS singing LIVE♥♥
i love her so freakin much<3
ChocolateVanessaFan 1 year ago 2
she is awesome like always
TamannaMussamad 1 year ago 2
was she realy singing in spanish
02Kassy 1 year ago 8
yes she was
babe231000 1 year ago
yes.. she can speak spanish.. she has family in latin america too..
mia131mia 1 year ago 4
@mia131mia shes filipino, not spanish
dbestbud 1 year ago
@dbestbud no she has roots in latin america too.. her mother is chinese, filipino and has roots in latin america and her dad is irish and has roots in native america.. okey? :) because of that she is soo beautiful..
mia131mia 1 year ago
@dbestbud vanessa consists of many backgrounds, shes filipino,chinese,spanish,irish and native american u can check on the net if u dont believe me haha
xazngiirlx 1 year ago
@mia131mia she cant speak spanish.
therealoneperson 1 year ago
she is awesome like always
beautifulgirl09000 1 year ago
This is great but i know shes lip synching listen at 2:26- 2:33 when shes singing mind, u can hear that the backing is still having singing that ind sound when her mouth is already closed
xazngiirlx 2 years ago
its the ekko in the last but it is vanessa singing
minimonberg34 1 year ago
@xazngiirlx She is not lip singing i can tell when a singer lipsingz but she is not...check other vids of her..when she was smaller she sings really good and she still does:)
juventuddechrist 1 year ago 3
canta bien en español!! =D
thaxaa 2 years ago
i love you vanessa (gabriella)
LeRagazzeDiHolliwood 2 years ago 3
Vany can good sing spanish! I like the language, then I learn it at school. It's cool!
juliabecker98 2 years ago 3
I love her she's so fabulous
Fan1692 2 years ago 3
i was born the same place as she was Salinas,Ca
barcakid86 2 years ago
quando comincia a cantare in spagnolo non c''è nessuna voce sotto...è lei proprio dal vivo!! sentite che voce??!!!! è bravissima! io l'adoro <3 come adoro lei! è stupenda! 4ever Baby V!!
TheGirlLunatic 2 years ago
she actually speaks it extremely well.
zacefronlovee 2 years ago
Ok...so for some reason she needs 2 microphones even though she's singing along to a recorded track....
bouldercrotch 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
when she changes from english to spanish.. it doesn't even sound like her anymore.. it sounds like someone else. she has a major white accent on some words.. i don't think she's singing live either..
ElleCastle1993 2 years ago
it is defentily her voice if ur a little fan or you like the music then can u her it! even a little one from 5 years can here the differents! it is none! she`s good!!
lyricsjeltje2 2 years ago
i love vanessa!
missale98 2 years ago 5
Her spanish is good
BlueDiva95 2 years ago 9
omg!!! your hair so so nice.
i love you:)
fifimomo717 2 years ago 7
man i just love her hair :D
BTW: i love her voice its s strong
fisheatsnoodles 2 years ago 7
ashley tisdale is not better than vanessa hudgens. ashley tisdale sounds like a little girl when she sings. its tooo high .
eleniJONAS 2 years ago 62
well the bottom line is they ashley and vanessa have 2 Totaly different voices. they both sound great! im more of an ashley fan but yes vanessa sounds great! :D
landonmorrisonblane 2 years ago 4
@eleniJONAS Yes!!!Ashley is great,but Vanessa is better!! ♥
TheAnette159 1 year ago
Comment removed
jeanbloom12 7 months ago
Comment removed
jeanbloom12 7 months ago
@eleniJONAS U Freak lah u! anyhow comment! Can u even sing... Please okay... They have different ways of singing! Their problem uh.. U not famous right.. U not popular right! Then just shut up.. This shows u can't even sing compared to them! So just shut the freak up! U have no right to comment okay! Just be a good dog and shut up k ...
jeanbloom12 7 months ago
@jeanbloom12 woooow. what the hell is ur problem. i was just stating my opinion. what does it have to do with me being able to sing or not? just because i may not be able to sing doesnt mean i dont have my own opinion on what good music is. i think that vanessa is way better than ashley tisdale and that ashley tisdales voice is really high. if you didnt notice, im not the only one who feels that way. 55 ppl liked it. u gunna cuss em too? call em a dog? why dont u shut up before u look stupid.
eleniJONAS 7 months ago
she's pretty good ! better than other celeberties
cbescuderoj 2 years ago 57
@cbescuderoj Yes...Vanessa is cool ♥ I love her .. but i think,than Miley Cyrus is better .. :D
TheAnette159 1 year ago
i like it wen she sang in spanish she did well
pascuales94 2 years ago 6
is this her real voice? or totally computerized?
jeongwon1 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
no real
marshymelody 2 years ago
IM LOVE VANESSA HUDGENS!!!
Reypz100 2 years ago 5
i have meet her yay love you nessa xx
vanessahudgendsfan1 2 years ago 4
I wish she can come to SIngapore!
MusicRocksLikeHell 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ashley Tisdale is better
MsSandy1969 2 years ago
i hope she can come to taiwan:))
ch03182000 2 years ago 3
she's filipino,spanish,chinese,native american and irish
darjahomie12 2 years ago
she isn't that bad..
leztiVHfan4eva 2 years ago 4
dam sh3 n33ds 2 practic3 h3r spanish mayb cuz I can sp3k iit it sounds w3ard...lol but sh3 gud though so r3al gud..sh3 pr3tty 2 n0 h0m0
bubblez18fm 2 years ago
ok, she's not filipina, she was born and raised in california. her father is amarican and her mother is spanish, filipina and chinees. she speak spanish cause that is a pretty coman language in california
peutje007 2 years ago
@peutje007 Vanessa has some Filipina in her
23emohottie 2 years ago 5
she's filipina or however it's spelled
chickenbutt101 2 years ago
Demi Lovata?¿
LOL
I LOVE YOU VANESSA!!
I LOVE YOUR VOICE WHEN YOU SING IN CASTILLIAN/SPANISH
:D
cinderellaisa 2 years ago 4
she is soo pretty with straigh hair,
love yopu VAnessa:)
eve4cool 2 years ago 6
she is spanish. well like one quarter.
xjustpromise 2 years ago
is she spanish as in puerto rican or sumthing
myhijaelizabetha 2 years ago 2
she is Spanish as in her mom is from Spain
juicieloo 2 years ago
no she's half filipino
liveyourlife1128 2 years ago 2
asuuuu
canta lenndo ahi i lov you vanessa
ahahah si me fasina sus canciones y mas zac efron ahahaha
pzz bueno no la cristiquen es perfecta tiene el novio perfecto is exactly the that a man need ahaha biie
nnalok1 2 years ago
k pasada!!! podria gravar un disco y meter una cancion en español seria todo un exito,por lo menos en España
irisabina 2 years ago 2
me encanta!!! se entiende bn!!!
irisabina 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
La amo demasiado*-* ES LA MEEEJJJOOR
Demi lovaatoo sucks 8-)
vaneyzachsm234 2 years ago
mira esta le gusta la gringa que se tiro photos nuda y no le gusta demi lovata la latina que canta presioso
TheSheryl35 2 years ago
la AMO (L)
0000000pacheco 2 years ago
LINDA!!!
ValeriiaJ 2 years ago
wow, se siente como ayer cuando estuve en ese concierto... las cosas cambian rapido
marih1993 2 years ago
she sings very good in spanish !!
canta muy bien y se le entiende perfecto el espanol no se que tanto critican !!
lucefy94 2 years ago
she speak a good spanish, i speak spanish and english and i understand her spanish. asi ke los dicen ke ella habla mal español es mentira.
95salome 2 years ago 2
Yo sí le entendí clarito cuando la escuché cantar... no sé que tanto critican... y no se necesitaron subtítulos en el concierto
nandanieves 2 years ago
I love her voice.
:]
JayloveXTebear 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
she needs to learn spanish better she sux, demi even did better u couold atleast understand her
wuzupandy 2 years ago
demi sigs so bad in spanish !!
lucefy94 2 years ago 2
no she dosnt, not as bad as this girl!!
wuzupandy 2 years ago
but i think its a bit weird she sux in the other songs except this.
no offense, but i dont think she was any good at all on this concert, but thats my opinion. don't be harsh on me just cuz i don't like her voice live, but if this was live, then, she did great! :)) greetings from norway
tiptapstair 2 years ago
if she WAS lip singing.
then why would she have 2 microphones ?
flow3rfair33 2 years ago 5
me encant como canta yo la coonozi en persona y le dige q le queria pero en ingles jajaj oye es super guapa a y q VIVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA VANESAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
TheRaquelfernandez 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lip singing ?
allyfilostyle 2 years ago
liar there are no Spanish subtitles ugh you tube
SuperGreatSinger 2 years ago 2
wow her voice is great
4everjblover99 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
she cant sing...
cheapsexslave101 2 years ago
Vanessa is very great! I love her so much! I'm her biggest and number 1 fan ever!
princessvanessahsm 2 years ago
Muy bueno su español
me encanta mucho mas..
muy linda voz
amazing song!!
PaolaGR17 2 years ago 2
she sing this real
and it isn't playback.
i'm sorry but i know it better(A)
jajagirl19 2 years ago
this is one of my favorite songs she is so talented shes my favorite hsm 1 2 and 3 chracter
beebeegigi 2 years ago 2
1. she is wearing the same clothes as the other concerts
2 i don't like her with bangs
3.this is 100% playback
she didn't sing ;like this when she was at mexico
MaiRI235 2 years ago
is this live?
iluvuA1 2 years ago
amazzzzing! :D
13ellimac 2 years ago
wow!!!!!!lore al oir esta cancion...su español es genial....I CRIED WHEN I HEARD THIS SONG..... HER SPANISH IS GREAT!!!....... ABSOLUTELY, SHE'S THE BEST.....GREETINGS FROM MEXICO CITY!!
edrian0991 2 years ago
jeje
vaneessa no habla españOl
dicee quee su españOl es muii malO
ii prometio regresar a mexico con un español mejor
aunque la canzion me guzto mucho
vaneessa es la mejor
me encanta!
ZacNeZza 2 years ago
i love you vanessa (L)
beautiful (L)
jonathanlussier200 2 years ago 2
bueno no es mala yo si le entiendo auqe algunas noo
ami me ancanta la cancion en el concierto sii se oye biien bueno a los k fuimamos soi mas fan de ashley qe de vanessa pero kanta biien
dayanalove1 2 years ago
vanessa canta muy bien pero debo decir que la adapatación de la canción al español es demasiado mala
angelikitty7 2 years ago 2
she is so beautiful =]
moquito702 2 years ago 3
ayyy ke lindos recuerdos, estuve ahí esa noche, recuerdo que el único que hablaba español era lucas y que cuando decia bailarines sono un poco como tallarines xdd
marih1993 2 years ago 2
i love her so much,she is my life,my favorite singer <3
xortans 2 years ago 4
i like her voice
and her spanish is awsome!!!
porsiempre1994 2 years ago 3
amo como canta en español
luvaanper 2 years ago 2
her spanish is awsome!!!
1vanessahudgenslover 2 years ago 5
I love her voice so much.
JayloveXTebear 2 years ago 5
amazing vanessa!♥
reshatin4lyf 2 years ago 5
luv it is r 1 hole spanish version of her?
lyricsjeltje2 2 years ago
she's amazinnnng
missdestiny15 2 years ago 9
at 0:15 she sounds really good
but she was okay in other parts
Shelbanna3 2 years ago 4
keren banget !
tapi, Ashley Tisdale sama Lucas Grabeel lebih keren lagi !
keren banget dah pokoknyaa !
chatrine24 2 years ago
(L) es hermosa y canta mas q bien.. pero lo q no me gusta de los recitales q televizaron es q editaron el sonido... y solo dejaron unas partes en vivo....... el resto lo mezclaron con el audio del disco..... :S
basta con mirar videos no oficiales grabados x fans en los recitales (en los q sí esta el audio en vivo) xa ver la diferencia de una voz en vivo y una voz grabada en estudio......
y cuando a alguien le gusta un artista, una de las mejores cosas es escucharlo cantar en vivo ! =)
FaaaCuuu 2 years ago 3
she sings really amazing on spanish . she's so beautiful :)
i'm learning spanish since 1 jear :)
kLainez9 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Is she lip singing?
scholarface 2 years ago
very good
Lifecrews 2 years ago 6
sin duda suena y canta muy bien la lengua castella o española
sinsenti1234 2 years ago 2
ja!! me enkanto!! nunk la había oido kntar en spañol!! ^^
29vAnNiA29 2 years ago 2