I think that each of the actresses captures different aspect of Usagi's personality with different degrees of success. They all landed the part for a reason, and they're all doing a much better job than any of us probably would! ;) That said, Anza and Fumina are my *personal* favorites.
I like Fumina's best. After all, this was Fumina's song all along. Each Moon had her signature group songs, and "Everlasting Moonlight" and "LINK" were Fumina's.
Marina is cute though when she makes her intro speech.
I feel that everyones voices in Fumina's just blended better. I know a lot of people don't really like Fumina, but I think she had a really good voice and was pretty good as Sailor Moon.
People are evil the hate needs to stop, I mean its been over since 2005, and Miyuki's dead we should just be proud of all of their effort, and enjoy their legacies. Thank you for commenting.
Why do people hate Anza so much? I don't get it. She's a good Moon like the others. I feel Fumina sings very well. So she definitely wins this one. But, I don't think people should bash Anza, Fumina or any other Moon they don't like.
You´re right. Every moon has her good sides and bad sides, although I myself prefer Anza. But that doesn´t mean I don´t like Marina, Fumina and Miyuki. People should just enjoy their wonderful work!
#1 Fumina - not only is the song originally from her stage, but she is the one who performed it with the most emotion IMHO. I could never not like her voice so...yeah.
#2 Marina - I could stand to listen to her group sing this and I like the recording from Eternal Edition 3 a lot. Like Fumina her voice actually stands out for this.
#3 MIyuki - I like the performance, but Miyuki's voice in this really fades away.
Marina is my favorite, always. She's so damn cute. I think she's got the strongest voice of all four Moons, and she just seem to fit Sailor Moon perfectly. I just learned that Miyuki pass away... that's so terrible. Sudden heart failure! Insane. She was my second favorite Moon. Fumina is someone I have rarely seen; she seems to be the least talked about (or maybe it's just me!), and Anza creeps me out. She doesn't fit the part to me.
Fumina's always going to be my favorite not because the other three lack anything but because I've seen her musicals so many times I memorized half the stuff they say. She's just got something that keeps me stuck on her.
Marina: I seldom can say I enjoy her but this particular performance is good. I like the cast save for Manami and the dancing is softer so they don't sound tire like they usually do.
Miyuki: Excellent performance.
Fumina: Same as Miyuki. Gotta love the cast in this one. Mita Mao's a much better Saturn than Tomioka Mario but TnMK has a great cast too. Only two flaws in TnMK are Jupiter and Saturn. Chibiusa doesn't really do much but for the encore its nice to include her esp w/her senshi there.
Fumina, Miyuki, Marina: It got a little worse as the casts and moons changed. But their voices were all appropriate for the song. The three casts in this video are some of the best that the musicals had with the Fumina cast in this video being the best of them all.
Fumina: yeah she's not as exciting as Miyuki and Marina. she was indeed boring.
Miyuki: Miyukimoon always had the best cast, best choreography/dancing, and her musicals are the only ones that are original. Thats why Miyuki has always been my fave moon. May she rest in peace. =')
Marina: she's good. Marina didn't have to act cute because she's already is.
Fumina's Kaguya shima Densetsu musicals were original and Miyuki and Marina both did justice to her song that's how I see it. Fumina though is undoubtedly the better singer of the three. I also think she tops Anza in the vocal department and you say Fumina's boring like it's everyone's opinion of her but sadly that is not the case next time please don't comment on Fumina if you're not going to say something nice about her Fumina has become a very successful actress and much more since then.
Lol it's quite apparent that I have different Myu than you do. I think Anza has the better and the right vocals for Sailor Moon. Sailor Moon's voice is meant to be a soprano. Fumina and Miyuki are altos and Marina is a soprano but her voice was too Japanese bubblegum pop-ish for a musical such as this. When I said Fumina's boring I meant Fumina's musical dancing for ELM is boring.
And I'm a huge Miyuki fan and she died because for some oddball reason she needed to atleast Fumina's size and that led to her downfall...T-T Fumina my second favourite Moon and now's she my least favourite now. Because of what happen to Miyuki...
I still think Miyuki's ELM was the best! No doubt about it!!
Um you do know Miyuki did not become anorexic because of Fumina right? She became that way because she got self absorbed with her modeling career. Fumina even stated on her blog that she thought Miyuki had a lot of potential and was a very spirited girl and that she was disappointed that life had not rewarded her for her efforts.
*sighs* Yet another one never gets me. Forget what I said about Fumina. I'm a big Miyuki fan and I love Miyuki, and that's all that really matters right now. My honest opinion is I think Miyuki had the best performance of Everlasting Moonlight!!! So...GOOOO MIYUKI!!!
Okay I'm going to try understanding you but I really wonder why you suddenly dislike Fumina so much because Miyuki thought she needed to look like her to be something great. That's not Fumina's fault you shouldn't discredit her because of something she couldn't control. Miyuki happens to be my favorite moon as well but with her dead (which I'm still having a lot of trouble getting over) Fumina is alternately tied with Anza for 2nd. There's no denying Anza played the role well and...
...and if Fumina'd stayed longer I'm sure that she'd be my 2nd choice instead of tied for 2nd. I'm not telling you anything about your opinion just that I see it as wrong (just plain rotten really) that you would say Fumina was your 2nd favorite and all of a sudden Miyuki-san croaks and you suddenly drop Fumina to last. What's up with that? Are you not mature enough to understand it wasn't her fault Miyuki wanted to look like her?
I'm sure you're not crazy but blaming Fumina for Miyuki's death that's harsh. Miyuki's death has been rather hard on me she always had so much spirit that when I was down all I had to do was think of her energy and I would get back up and keep moving.
I don't believe I could ever blame Fumina for being someone Miyuki admired (and admire her she did) but Fumina admired Miyuki's personality and energy so if Miyuki really did take it as far as developing anorexia because she wanted to look like Fumina (and not because she was struggling to meet the demands of common models) then that's her own mistake you shouldn't suddenly have a hatred for Fumina. The fact you thought it her fault considering how Fumina and Miyuki were friends is just wrong.
There's no Anza in this video why should I say anything to those talking about Anza? Sorry but I neglect to see your point. Most showdowns have people commenting about how Anza was the first/longest and therefore the best because she was the first to do the song but in this one the first to do the song was Fumina. I'm not sure if Anza would do this song well or not but she never did and likely never will hence I have no reaon to bother with those arguing about how she would perform this song.
How can Fumina go from your 2nd to your least favorite over another person's death? A death with which she had nothing to do. That is extremely unfair.
I would get you if you made sense. But blaming Miyuki's death on Fumina and suddenly dropping her to the bottom of your moon list just makes me wonder about your mentality. Atleast try to comment when you can spare some time. Otherwise you make yourself look stupid.
I loved Miyukimoon's performance out of all of them. I'm a sucker when it comes to little kids dancing on stage. Their voices blended beautifully, and most of all, their choreography rocked!
When it comes down to it there is nothing wrong with this performance they all did it well but if I had to listen to it I'd listen to Fumina's and if I had to watch it I'd definitely go for Marina's. This video has one of Marina's best performances and one of her best casts too.
You know I just noticed something. It's not that Anza and Marina are bad actresses, singers or dancers that makes them unappealing compared to Fumina and Miyuki it's the fact that they could not be as free with creating an image for the character as Fumina and Miyuki were because they had no original stories. Fumina's Kaguya Shima Densetsu musicals and Miyuki's Dracul musicals had what overall I feel were the greatest musicals because you can't predict the outcome for those musicals.
In this song all of them did good. That surprises me in a way even now. Marina usually can't perform songs from other moons well but this one she did pretty good on. The Shin Densetsu Kourin original will always be my favorite though.
Fumina and her cast sung this song the best (of course!). Miyukis choreography was the best for me and it was the most energetic performance (although I think it's the extra senshis on stage lol.) I liked Marinas but it wasn't the best performance I've seen of her, nice chroeography though =). But really NO ONE can't argue with any of the three moons singing 'Everlasting Moonlight', they all did such a good job on it!!
Fumina wins this is one of her best songs and nobody could ever sing it quite like her and then there is the beautiful choreography. While Marina and Miyuki both had some spectacular changes to choreography its not nearly as fitting. Miyuki's was also too short.
Well all I can say is hurray for a showdown without Anza. All three of these moons are great and did a great job on this song. The original Shin Densetsu Kourin will always be the best one but they all performed it will a lot of energy and spunk. I'm glad I have their autographs!
Marina's - She does pretty good but this video just proves how far they took the role of moon. Her voice is so wrong for the part. It's not even too high it's too different in pitch from the others. She was extremely hard to get used to. I don't recall a time I went to a Marina musical and had a full audience other than Mugen Gakuen Mistress Labyrinth and Shin Kaguya Shima Densetsu Kaiteiban. Kaguya Shima Densetsu and Kaguya Shima Densetsu Kaiteiban was full audience the when I went to see them.
Hi, Buga. I hope you're well. Tell your father I said, "hello". Now for my verdict:
Marina- Very nice choreography. All of the scouts voices synced together perfectly.
Miyuki- Her version was too short. The scouts didn't even have time to introduce themselves, but all in all their voice were fine, and Miyuki held a note...for once. YAY!
Fumina- Wonderful. Beautiful voices. Great choreography. I love how they end the song with poses.
I think that each of the actresses captures different aspect of Usagi's personality with different degrees of success. They all landed the part for a reason, and they're all doing a much better job than any of us probably would! ;) That said, Anza and Fumina are my *personal* favorites.
LadyRissa211 7 months ago
Fumina Miyuki marina
Larkawolfsgirl 1 year ago
how could i have not known about this when i was a child ????
O_O
this is entirely random i have to favorite it!
i was looking at the article of sailor moon in wikipedia and i saw SERA MYU so i looked it up... and here.... it... is...
sharosudo 2 years ago
i like them all
lonnerridder 2 years ago
I like Fumina's best. After all, this was Fumina's song all along. Each Moon had her signature group songs, and "Everlasting Moonlight" and "LINK" were Fumina's.
Marina is cute though when she makes her intro speech.
BibliophileGirl 2 years ago
I feel that everyones voices in Fumina's just blended better. I know a lot of people don't really like Fumina, but I think she had a really good voice and was pretty good as Sailor Moon.
DrOlogy 2 years ago
People are evil the hate needs to stop, I mean its been over since 2005, and Miyuki's dead we should just be proud of all of their effort, and enjoy their legacies. Thank you for commenting.
emiru411 2 years ago
Dear DrOIlogy,
Thank you for your support for Fumina. I do share the same oppinion with you regarding her. <3<3<3<3.
TheJoJoBeBe 2 years ago
Why do people hate Anza so much? I don't get it. She's a good Moon like the others. I feel Fumina sings very well. So she definitely wins this one. But, I don't think people should bash Anza, Fumina or any other Moon they don't like.
destinyluck 2 years ago
I can't believe the hate still goes around with one of them dead.
emiru411 2 years ago
You´re right. Every moon has her good sides and bad sides, although I myself prefer Anza. But that doesn´t mean I don´t like Marina, Fumina and Miyuki. People should just enjoy their wonderful work!
Katjeschatje 2 years ago
#1 Fumina - not only is the song originally from her stage, but she is the one who performed it with the most emotion IMHO. I could never not like her voice so...yeah.
#2 Marina - I could stand to listen to her group sing this and I like the recording from Eternal Edition 3 a lot. Like Fumina her voice actually stands out for this.
#3 MIyuki - I like the performance, but Miyuki's voice in this really fades away.
RenamonEspeonWolborg 2 years ago
1º Fumina
2º Miyuki
3º Marina
TheBlueKeeper 2 years ago
That's what I said!
emiru411 2 years ago
Miyuki is my favorite; everlasting Miyuki Moon
thewill0306 3 years ago
Marina is my favorite, always. She's so damn cute. I think she's got the strongest voice of all four Moons, and she just seem to fit Sailor Moon perfectly. I just learned that Miyuki pass away... that's so terrible. Sudden heart failure! Insane. She was my second favorite Moon. Fumina is someone I have rarely seen; she seems to be the least talked about (or maybe it's just me!), and Anza creeps me out. She doesn't fit the part to me.
oohmyjonas 3 years ago
Fumina's always going to be my favorite not because the other three lack anything but because I've seen her musicals so many times I memorized half the stuff they say. She's just got something that keeps me stuck on her.
Momoirokagami 3 years ago
I think Miyuki wins this one, Fumina a close second and Marina in third for this one. ^^
Hyattiee 3 years ago
Fumina and Miyuki tie. Marina's is good but the song just isn't made for her.
IidaAiRisaYossieMabe 3 years ago
Hmm they were all good. Fumina does win though. I don't think that the other two's choreography fit the song.
KaorinYossieSayumin 3 years ago
That's exactly what I think.
1st2nd3rd4th5th6thGO 3 years ago
Marina: I seldom can say I enjoy her but this particular performance is good. I like the cast save for Manami and the dancing is softer so they don't sound tire like they usually do.
Miyuki: Excellent performance.
Fumina: Same as Miyuki. Gotta love the cast in this one. Mita Mao's a much better Saturn than Tomioka Mario but TnMK has a great cast too. Only two flaws in TnMK are Jupiter and Saturn. Chibiusa doesn't really do much but for the encore its nice to include her esp w/her senshi there.
KaoriTakagiChico 3 years ago
Thanks for commenting.
emiru411 3 years ago
1. Miyuki- She nailed this song perfectly!
2. Fumina- I just don't see enough energy for this song, but she does have a pretty voice.
3. Marina- I felt like the choreography and the vocals were both a little slacking. But it wasn't bad. Just not as good as the other two.
oneshortkat 3 years ago
Fumina, Miyuki, Marina: It got a little worse as the casts and moons changed. But their voices were all appropriate for the song. The three casts in this video are some of the best that the musicals had with the Fumina cast in this video being the best of them all.
Oitsumerarete 3 years ago
Fumina: yeah she's not as exciting as Miyuki and Marina. she was indeed boring.
Miyuki: Miyukimoon always had the best cast, best choreography/dancing, and her musicals are the only ones that are original. Thats why Miyuki has always been my fave moon. May she rest in peace. =')
Marina: she's good. Marina didn't have to act cute because she's already is.
First to last: Miyuki, Marina, Fumina.
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
Fumina's Kaguya shima Densetsu musicals were original and Miyuki and Marina both did justice to her song that's how I see it. Fumina though is undoubtedly the better singer of the three. I also think she tops Anza in the vocal department and you say Fumina's boring like it's everyone's opinion of her but sadly that is not the case next time please don't comment on Fumina if you're not going to say something nice about her Fumina has become a very successful actress and much more since then.
emiru411 3 years ago
Lol it's quite apparent that I have different Myu than you do. I think Anza has the better and the right vocals for Sailor Moon. Sailor Moon's voice is meant to be a soprano. Fumina and Miyuki are altos and Marina is a soprano but her voice was too Japanese bubblegum pop-ish for a musical such as this. When I said Fumina's boring I meant Fumina's musical dancing for ELM is boring.
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
And I'm a huge Miyuki fan and she died because for some oddball reason she needed to atleast Fumina's size and that led to her downfall...T-T Fumina my second favourite Moon and now's she my least favourite now. Because of what happen to Miyuki...
I still think Miyuki's ELM was the best! No doubt about it!!
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
Um you do know Miyuki did not become anorexic because of Fumina right? She became that way because she got self absorbed with her modeling career. Fumina even stated on her blog that she thought Miyuki had a lot of potential and was a very spirited girl and that she was disappointed that life had not rewarded her for her efforts.
emiru411 3 years ago
*sighs* Yet another one never gets me. Forget what I said about Fumina. I'm a big Miyuki fan and I love Miyuki, and that's all that really matters right now. My honest opinion is I think Miyuki had the best performance of Everlasting Moonlight!!! So...GOOOO MIYUKI!!!
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
Okay I'm going to try understanding you but I really wonder why you suddenly dislike Fumina so much because Miyuki thought she needed to look like her to be something great. That's not Fumina's fault you shouldn't discredit her because of something she couldn't control. Miyuki happens to be my favorite moon as well but with her dead (which I'm still having a lot of trouble getting over) Fumina is alternately tied with Anza for 2nd. There's no denying Anza played the role well and...
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago
...and if Fumina'd stayed longer I'm sure that she'd be my 2nd choice instead of tied for 2nd. I'm not telling you anything about your opinion just that I see it as wrong (just plain rotten really) that you would say Fumina was your 2nd favorite and all of a sudden Miyuki-san croaks and you suddenly drop Fumina to last. What's up with that? Are you not mature enough to understand it wasn't her fault Miyuki wanted to look like her?
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago
I'm just not a Fumina fan. Sorry but I just like Marina's and Miyuki's Everlasting Moonlight better.
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
It wasn't even about the performance just why you blame miyuki's death on fumina.
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago
Oh that. That kinda got out of control. I was going through some things at the time. -__-
I'm crazy.
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
I'm sure you're not crazy but blaming Fumina for Miyuki's death that's harsh. Miyuki's death has been rather hard on me she always had so much spirit that when I was down all I had to do was think of her energy and I would get back up and keep moving.
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago
I don't believe I could ever blame Fumina for being someone Miyuki admired (and admire her she did) but Fumina admired Miyuki's personality and energy so if Miyuki really did take it as far as developing anorexia because she wanted to look like Fumina (and not because she was struggling to meet the demands of common models) then that's her own mistake you shouldn't suddenly have a hatred for Fumina. The fact you thought it her fault considering how Fumina and Miyuki were friends is just wrong.
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago
Why do you allow Anza-haters to comment and you won't allow me, who has something negative to say about Fumina, comment?
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
There's no Anza in this video why should I say anything to those talking about Anza? Sorry but I neglect to see your point. Most showdowns have people commenting about how Anza was the first/longest and therefore the best because she was the first to do the song but in this one the first to do the song was Fumina. I'm not sure if Anza would do this song well or not but she never did and likely never will hence I have no reaon to bother with those arguing about how she would perform this song.
emiru411 3 years ago
How can Fumina go from your 2nd to your least favorite over another person's death? A death with which she had nothing to do. That is extremely unfair.
emiru411 3 years ago
Because you're Japanese! lol xD
Plus, you made some boo-boos in your comments.
AuntieNoriko 3 years ago
Lol I knows. I had to get ready for work!!! I was rushing!!!
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
It's okay. God forgives you. =P
AuntieNoriko 3 years ago
I would get you if you made sense. But blaming Miyuki's death on Fumina and suddenly dropping her to the bottom of your moon list just makes me wonder about your mentality. Atleast try to comment when you can spare some time. Otherwise you make yourself look stupid.
emiru411 3 years ago
you're a true seramyu fan/friend. Good luck on your seramyu projects! =D
LuffytheNinja 3 years ago
I loved Miyukimoon's performance out of all of them. I'm a sucker when it comes to little kids dancing on stage. Their voices blended beautifully, and most of all, their choreography rocked!
AuntieNoriko 3 years ago
Oh, I forgot to add: Everlasting Moonlight has got to be one of my favourite Seramyu songs EVER!
AuntieNoriko 3 years ago
Anza would suck just like she sucks singing in general.
sailorsenshi003 3 years ago
Anza would kill this song. And Fumina's is the best maggot!
sailorsenshi009 3 years ago
When it comes down to it there is nothing wrong with this performance they all did it well but if I had to listen to it I'd listen to Fumina's and if I had to watch it I'd definitely go for Marina's. This video has one of Marina's best performances and one of her best casts too.
Anzapwnsall 3 years ago
You know I just noticed something. It's not that Anza and Marina are bad actresses, singers or dancers that makes them unappealing compared to Fumina and Miyuki it's the fact that they could not be as free with creating an image for the character as Fumina and Miyuki were because they had no original stories. Fumina's Kaguya Shima Densetsu musicals and Miyuki's Dracul musicals had what overall I feel were the greatest musicals because you can't predict the outcome for those musicals.
Truesailorsenshi 3 years ago
Marina had Ai no Sanctuary, But I would have liked to see her do something else besides Kaguya Shima Densetsu.
reindeercrossing 3 years ago
I forgot Ai no Sanctuary was also an original.
Truesailorsenshi 3 years ago
Love it. I think Marina considering what she usually does to previous moons songs did pretty good. Miyuki's was well done just a little too short.
narehodone 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fumina's is and always will be the best.
narehodone 3 years ago
In this song all of them did good. That surprises me in a way even now. Marina usually can't perform songs from other moons well but this one she did pretty good on. The Shin Densetsu Kourin original will always be my favorite though.
Myumoon4eva 3 years ago
Fumina and her cast sung this song the best (of course!). Miyukis choreography was the best for me and it was the most energetic performance (although I think it's the extra senshis on stage lol.) I liked Marinas but it wasn't the best performance I've seen of her, nice chroeography though =). But really NO ONE can't argue with any of the three moons singing 'Everlasting Moonlight', they all did such a good job on it!!
Cookai11 3 years ago
Fumina wins this is one of her best songs and nobody could ever sing it quite like her and then there is the beautiful choreography. While Marina and Miyuki both had some spectacular changes to choreography its not nearly as fitting. Miyuki's was also too short.
Fuminaisbest 3 years ago
You read my mind.
DarkAngelSatsuki 3 years ago
Well all I can say is hurray for a showdown without Anza. All three of these moons are great and did a great job on this song. The original Shin Densetsu Kourin will always be the best one but they all performed it will a lot of energy and spunk. I'm glad I have their autographs!
FuminaMiyukiMarina 3 years ago 7
My favorite will always be Fumina-hime's too. But Miyuki and Marina both did very well with this song. And yes no Anza finally.
Fuminahime 3 years ago 5
Thanks for commenting.
emiru411 3 years ago
I agree with you both.
Anzamustdie 3 years ago 3
Thanks for commenting.
emiru411 3 years ago
You stole my thoughts.
Anzadacrackhead 3 years ago
I've decided I don't care who sings this song, I can't get enough of it xD
reindeercrossing 3 years ago 6
I'm not sure about Miyuki's Transylvania no Mori Kaiteiban. I'm pretty sure the place was completely packed but I could be wrong.
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago 2
It was packed and it was were we first met. Hi again.
FuminaMiyukiMarina 3 years ago 3
lol hey again. you spelled where wrong but I get your point. Hurray for our friendship!
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago 3
Marina's - She does pretty good but this video just proves how far they took the role of moon. Her voice is so wrong for the part. It's not even too high it's too different in pitch from the others. She was extremely hard to get used to. I don't recall a time I went to a Marina musical and had a full audience other than Mugen Gakuen Mistress Labyrinth and Shin Kaguya Shima Densetsu Kaiteiban. Kaguya Shima Densetsu and Kaguya Shima Densetsu Kaiteiban was full audience the when I went to see them.
KurosawaSayo 3 years ago
Hi, Buga. I hope you're well. Tell your father I said, "hello". Now for my verdict:
Marina- Very nice choreography. All of the scouts voices synced together perfectly.
Miyuki- Her version was too short. The scouts didn't even have time to introduce themselves, but all in all their voice were fine, and Miyuki held a note...for once. YAY!
Fumina- Wonderful. Beautiful voices. Great choreography. I love how they end the song with poses.
Bye, Buga. Great video. Make more.
DigiDestined558 4 years ago 7
Wow! I like this song!!
Cookai11 4 years ago 3
I like it too.
emiru411 4 years ago
Is Miyuki in it too? :o
nareshta 4 years ago 4
no she is not
emiru411 4 years ago
Wait yes she is.
emiru411 4 years ago
I don't like so much of Marina but song is one of my favs! ^^
nareshta 4 years ago 4
cool song! ^.~
and those costumes are so cute
sailormercuryfan 4 years ago 3
Thanks. And I so agree about the costumes.
emiru411 4 years ago
Cool!
iluv8boy 4 years ago
Thank you!
emiru411 4 years ago
awesine !! yay sailor jupiter!
jsango 4 years ago 2
Thanks for commenting.
emiru411 4 years ago
Nice vid. I like this song.
Jeo411 4 years ago 2
Thanks.
emiru411 4 years ago
Great vid. Fumina's Everlasting Moonlight is best.
Sassyrecombinantpass 4 years ago
Thanks.
emiru411 4 years ago