When she wants to actually perform, she does it like a pro. The beginning of the song would be impossible for someone like Adele/Beyonce (who have a good ear) to do. Hell, even Aretha Franklin would have to twist it a lot to make the phrasing sound like that...
after 7 years i can't still get over this song..!!! 6 Christmas had pass but still cant get over this damn fucking song LOVE YOU MARIAH cant live without you...!!!
@suncruiser00 well, that's hardly even in the performance. There is no all-perfect musical ear. While singing live she improvises, she lets the music flow but you can only do so much. Sometimes, there are slips. There is no artist who can escape that... You have to agree, though, the 'scream' is not unpleasant (i.e. it's on pitch and is a natural sound).
@MrDTJones1 ok lets say this was lipped (which it is not) go to "(HD) Mariah Carey - Joy To The World (Live ABC Christmas Special)", and listen to this, it is definitely live, and no disney characters here, maybe then you would not doubt this performance as much
@123465249 i am not at all. i just work in the music business and know when a vocal is not live. lol. i still love the licks from mimi. just prefer live vocals.
@MrDTJones1 it's obviously live Mariah sings this song live all the time. Look at her other Joy to the World live recordings. I'm afraid you are wrong this time mate!
Mariah Carey can do ANYTHING and I mean that! Shes the best singer around-100000 times better than MILEY CYRUS! (i dont even care if i spell that wrong)
@PopCultureVultureTV Mariah's great and all but there's no need to down other female artists to lift her up. Mariah's voice has deteriorated over the years and she's nowhere near as amazing as she used to be. She's a hit or miss.
"During the later periods of Roman history, sun worship gained in importance and ultimately led to what has been called a 'solar monotheism.' Nearly all the gods of the period were possessed of Solar qualities. The feast of Sol and Victus (open unconquered Sun) on December 25th was celebrated with great joy, and eventually this date was taken over by the Christians as Christmas, the birthday of Christ."
Mariah is so wonderful...Igot the opportunity to attend her new christmas special, and it was amazing:D!!!!! ~ I can't wait for it to air on abc dec 13th!!
100% live and very great. She should always sing live no matter what, cause her voice has more emotion when it is pure live. When she lipsync the high belts, it's just pisses me off!!!!
I wish those stupid douchenuggets would not have drowned out her ending note! I am trying to decipher the rest of the adlibbin' that was added to that note, but I can't hear shit!
I go back and forth in my mind trying to figure out if this version or the '94 version is better. I refuse to choose! During this time, Queen Mariah's voice possessed such a husky, soulful tone. In the '94 version her voice soared beyond the mountains and had limitless potential. She's the only woman i know that outdoes herself in everything she does lol! Hate me all you want when i say this but there's a Queen Aretha AND a Queen Mariah now!
thank you to all the people who said this was live because if it was lipped the first verse would have repeated and it did not so it was live. I would love to go to Disney for Christmas.
@drunkdivamariahcarey omg ur cover was so bad i think instead of calling mariah drunk u should call urself taht cuz only someone drunk would post up such a horrible cover...lol god bless ur lol that was way 2 embarassing
This performance is amazing and is 100% LIVE! You can always tell when she is singing live because she always does something a little bit different to every song. I love Mariah and this is amazing.
it wasn't like "94" and actually she did that song like 5 times that afternoon. She sang it one and other time, they were editing the whole thing and actually what you see here is way to different to the real thing but it was an amazing performance considering how dried her vocal chords are now. Her backup singers are or were truly amazing though.
Everyone Need's To Go Get A Copy Of Her New Christmas Album ''Merry Christmas II You''!!! The Album Is Frikking Amazing!! I Bought 2 Copy For Myself Already,Made My Mom Buy A Copy For Herself And Made 2 Of My Friends Buy A Copy Also!! 5 Copies Sold Right Here!! Everybody Should Do The Same! It's Really Woth It!=)) Her Best Vocals In Yearsssssss!!!
@ZakrazakOfTheXMen In December of 2004. she had already finished the Emancipation album. the firs single, "Shake it off" was released i think in the next month on radio... in january or feb of 2005
i've listened to whitneys version, and It was nothing compare to MARIAH's...whitneys version is more on like the heroine version or the cocaine version of this song, LMAO...she must be high when she sang that version....
wow she sounds amazing hear, one of my fav from the xmas album, i play this CD every Dec 1st when i put my xmas tree up (good times) get me in the xmas mood :-)
only an idiot can say this is not live... U can obviously notice it.. Mariah is struggling on reaching the notes... Well its all well done... Amazing performance! im from the phils also... And they say that mariah only needs to restwell before every perfomance,so i guess she rested well here before this live performance!
She was 34 here.. she did record TEOM during 2004. I remember that WBT or q single was gonna be released at the end of this year.. But the album got pushed to early 2005 and WBT was released very soon after. she was skinny in this video
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this is really lipsynch because when she went here in the philippines year 2003 her voice is not already sounds so good so, how much more in the year 2004 right...i'm a great fan of mariah so i know her every moves i know the songs that she lipsynchs....
@teraniel11 You are talking out your ass. Look at her LIVE 2006 Grammy performance. It's incredible, one of her best. And that was later than this. It's obvious that this performance, despite what retards like yourself say, is LIVE. Mariah Carey is the BEST
@teraniel11 You're an idiot. Clearly, this is live. Go crawl back in your delusional hole. Just because she didn't sound amazing (in your opinion) in 2003, does not mean that her voice couldn't have regained it's fluidity, power, range, etc. The voice is ever changing.
@teraniel11 no dear, i was there in that concert and her voice there was perfection. and her voice in 2003 is great. her belting and whistling techniques were effortless
hey,, how sure u are,,, bakit super close b kau ni mariah, i went there in charmbracelet tour,,, last nov 2003 and what can i say is not the voice of mariah,, the sound system is the problem,,, all song that she sang is purely live,, and also im huge fan of mariah carey here in the phil.... i love mariah
I don't know why people are saying what would Mariah be without her whistles. Yes, if she gets her nodes remove she might lose "some" of her whistle range, but obviously only the ones she does in the morning to go into the eighth octave. Most of her seventh octave whistles were naturally part of the great range she achieved through practise. Trust me, if all of her whistle range came from nodes, then the whistles would sound much weaker, and not as effortless as if she had already built up range
@dreamdate Actually I've got vocal nodes, and no Mariah will not lose her range if she gets them removed. But it's VERY risky even with top surgeons so good on her for not trusting them.
@rebornsfan who are you calling a retard? Im not the one who cant even spell a 4 letter word you dumb fuck.
capcomfighter13 3 weeks ago
Timon fell in love in the beginning!
emmanuel11246 1 month ago
its a Bb6.
allykat90 1 month ago
That was sooooooooo good!!!!!
thatshot200611 1 month ago
When she wants to actually perform, she does it like a pro. The beginning of the song would be impossible for someone like Adele/Beyonce (who have a good ear) to do. Hell, even Aretha Franklin would have to twist it a lot to make the phrasing sound like that...
RanjitMorey 1 month ago
i vote mariah become a disney princess...lmaoooo
holla06 1 month ago 3
after 7 years i can't still get over this song..!!! 6 Christmas had pass but still cant get over this damn fucking song LOVE YOU MARIAH cant live without you...!!!
cervejerano 1 month ago
Stil watching this in 2011 ;)
Msstridjuh 2 months ago 8
tears fill my eyes every time i hear this song :')
dianitacarogo 2 months ago
She still got it lol
impactplayer89 3 months ago
Performance mais que perfeita
tanasinh 3 months ago
this is the best version of joy to the world ive seen TILL she screams at the high pitch right at the very end!! ughhh...
suncruiser00 4 months ago
@suncruiser00 well, that's hardly even in the performance. There is no all-perfect musical ear. While singing live she improvises, she lets the music flow but you can only do so much. Sometimes, there are slips. There is no artist who can escape that... You have to agree, though, the 'scream' is not unpleasant (i.e. it's on pitch and is a natural sound).
RanjitMorey 2 months ago
@RanjitMorey This is not a scream, this is a whistle tone and the note is double high D flat.
rekupp 1 month ago
the vocal runs on joy joy sent shivers down my spine three times in a row. watch 2:03
RanjitMorey 4 months ago
Comment removed
MrDTJones1 6 months ago
@MrDTJones1 ok lets say this was lipped (which it is not) go to "(HD) Mariah Carey - Joy To The World (Live ABC Christmas Special)", and listen to this, it is definitely live, and no disney characters here, maybe then you would not doubt this performance as much
123465249 6 months ago
Comment removed
MrDTJones1 5 months ago
@MrDTJones1 wow, are you hearing impaired?????
123465249 5 months ago
@123465249 i am not at all. i just work in the music business and know when a vocal is not live. lol. i still love the licks from mimi. just prefer live vocals.
MrDTJones1 5 months ago
@MrDTJones1 lets leave at that zzzzzzzzzz
123465249 5 months ago
@MrDTJones1 it's obviously live Mariah sings this song live all the time. Look at her other Joy to the World live recordings. I'm afraid you are wrong this time mate!
whitireia 5 months ago
@whitireia totally agree, but some people can't or will not be convinced
123465249 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrDTJones1 wow, are you hearing impaired????? or just a plain asshole
123465249 5 months ago
those vocal runs in 1:25 :D makes me so happy :D i love her voice :D and mariah carey ^_^
NiRie017 7 months ago 3
Comment removed
MrDTJones1 8 months ago
@MrDTJones1 it is sooo live u can tell
Shazni1409 8 months ago in playlist Mariah carey 12
@MrDTJones1 so obviously w/o a doubt live, it's ridiculous!
cersus 6 months ago
@MrDTJones1 Girl. shut the fuck up. if you're gonna say someone's lip-syncing at least do it right.
bfhfsuruyw 6 months ago
@MrDTJones1 You have no idea of what you are talking about so just shut the fuck up!
capcomfighter13 6 months ago
Mariah Carey can do ANYTHING and I mean that! Shes the best singer around-100000 times better than MILEY CYRUS! (i dont even care if i spell that wrong)
popstar704 9 months ago 4
I lose my mind when she hits that soft note at 2:23!!!!
Yahslick89 9 months ago 6
Such a soulful whistle at the end xD
This is my favourite version of this song. This particular performance was outstaaanding
gloomyoutlook 10 months ago
Good job Mary Ann !!!!
vetsflavio 10 months ago
JEJEE LA AMO ES LA MEJOR ESTE ES EL ESPIRITO NAVIDEÑO
jinchurikiipein 10 months ago
i cant stop watching this probably one of her best live performances go mariah, sang girl!!!! :-) and the whistle!!!!! heaven she's an angel!!!
kiki86no1 1 year ago 3
i cant stop watching this probably one of her best live performances go mariah, sang girl!!!! :-)
kiki86no1 1 year ago
damn her voice was good back then , only 6 years ago.....
darrin1701 1 year ago
@darrin1701 her christmas vocals from her recent album are verry good. probably because shes resting more now
jaypaidincash 1 year ago
Muito bom, parabéns!
SELVOMANIACLUBE 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MERRY CHRISTMAS FROM SERBIA ....
024yasmina 1 year ago
merry chrismas from serbia .. maria h you are the best :....
024yasmina 1 year ago
MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL!
mikswell 1 year ago
OUR QUEEN
xXxmissemmaxXx 1 year ago
Merry christmas from Japan with love.
hosi2007 1 year ago
All hail the queen!!!
Ihateeminem1985 1 year ago 2
3:21 was a bit embarrassing but the rest of the video was great.. :)
tesorome8 1 year ago
@tesorome8 i diddnt see nothing at that time LOL what was it?
jaypaidincash 1 year ago
she look so beautifull!!! aw i love you mariah, plus your voice is AWESOMEE!! GREAT PERFORMANCE ♥
funnygurlz666 1 year ago
A big CHILLY MERRY CHRISTMAS from way up here in Canada eh???/
lewandlo 1 year ago
merry christmas to all.....from philippines..
edantolin1 1 year ago
merry christmas to all.....
edantolin1 1 year ago
mariah carey amazing voice!!!!
edantolin1 1 year ago
Merry Christmas from the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland :D Peace and Love <3 Joy to the World for the Lord has come.
gleefanatic2011 1 year ago
Merry Christmas
From the kingdom of Thailand
yokowich 1 year ago
Merry Christmas from Thailand :D
thoasis 1 year ago
i like 1:55 to 2:08
foxeylover 1 year ago
talent... is not enough to describe Mariah. Great, not quite there... fabulous getting closer. Diva is more like it.
Majiwe24 1 year ago 4
Tears pop up in to my eyes!! beautifull(L)
xxx
Lizzylo146 1 year ago 2
merry christmas
may02288 1 year ago
wow at 00:51...very smooth transition :-D
apocalypsis7 1 year ago
OMG that moose next to mickey mouse is giving some evil stares O_O
theovanua 1 year ago
@theovanua you are so right! either that or the moose is cross eyed lol
txdiamond01 1 year ago
lol Mickey Mouse... Dancing... XD
theovanua 1 year ago
NAME ONE 34 YO THAT SOUNDS LIKE THIS?? BEYONCE COULD NEVER...
LADY GAGA COULD DAMN SURE NEVER....
WHITNEY COULD NEVER.....
PopCultureVultureTV 1 year ago 21
@PopCultureVultureTV Mariah's great and all but there's no need to down other female artists to lift her up. Mariah's voice has deteriorated over the years and she's nowhere near as amazing as she used to be. She's a hit or miss.
G2red89 1 year ago
@PopCultureVultureTV dere not 34 years old yet..duhhh
TheSam524942 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2:11 MY GOD !!!!!!!!! IT LITERALLY SOUNDED LIKE A VOICE FROM THE HEAVENS!!! GOD BLESS MARIAH !!!!!!
PopCultureVultureTV 1 year ago
Comment removed
PopCultureVultureTV 1 year ago
Comment removed
PopCultureVultureTV 1 year ago
I love this song!!! Especially that part "Let earth, receive, her King."
7777Ralph 1 year ago
espectacular, una voz como de angel
carhidalgo1 1 year ago 2
She sing and move just like she did in 90s
humanoid34 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Encyclopaedia Britannica, Volume 11 ; page 390.
"During the later periods of Roman history, sun worship gained in importance and ultimately led to what has been called a 'solar monotheism.' Nearly all the gods of the period were possessed of Solar qualities. The feast of Sol and Victus (open unconquered Sun) on December 25th was celebrated with great joy, and eventually this date was taken over by the Christians as Christmas, the birthday of Christ."
derekdb2 1 year ago
DAMN!!! She has a legendary voice.
DieWharheit 1 year ago 4
amazing
violinmusicfan 1 year ago
Lol Mickey shaking his head like "Girl you better sing!" That was an amazing performance.
MoesTube1 1 year ago 5
Her voice is amazing and I love Joy to the World! The Savior Reigns!! Merry Christmas!
GodsServant05 1 year ago
WOAAAAH 3:11
saywhaatuk26 1 year ago
YOU BETTER SINGGGGGG!!!!!
TheMickj23q 1 year ago
Everyone sing and enjoy
DanielPSchultz59 1 year ago
hey theres duffy next to timon
eishly 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow, what a voice,
poweful vocals, she did like 10 years ago(1994) and sounds still the same.
love you mariah =)
MarishcaJade 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow, what a voice,
poweful vocals, she did like 10 years ago(1994) and sounds still the same.
love you mariah =)
MarishcaJade 1 year ago
Comment removed
MarishcaJade 1 year ago
God bless her new family
s00uz 1 year ago 2
This ANGEL could sing her grocery list and I would buy it! Beautifully done in the magical city of Walt Disney! Love Mariah!
MsKattyKatKat 1 year ago 53
@MsKattyKatKat lmao, i would pay to hear her sing the alphabet...
Jessikia527 1 year ago
simply amazing
YZ250113 1 year ago 2
31 dislikes? 31 idiots! xoxo
ScandalBLamb 1 year ago 3
she's one of a kind total performer....such a gifted voice woman!
zitrojerk2 1 year ago
I like this version and the 2001 and the 1994 ones too
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
I get goose bumps when i hear her sing, Amazing voice, Shame to all u that dislike this!!!!!!!
bunnylea84 1 year ago 5
I always cry hearing this as is it so incredibly beautiful as Mariah's voice penetrates my soul, my bones and my every pore!!
originaldeftom 1 year ago 5
What gift GOD gave her as a blessing... :::sigh:::
Razzbarrizz 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
Razzbarrizz 1 year ago
Mariah is so wonderful...Igot the opportunity to attend her new christmas special, and it was amazing:D!!!!! ~ I can't wait for it to air on abc dec 13th!!
Lilriah29 1 year ago 2
100% live and very great. She should always sing live no matter what, cause her voice has more emotion when it is pure live. When she lipsync the high belts, it's just pisses me off!!!!
theoneandonly2503 1 year ago
omg i heard a horse at 3:21 AHHAHAAHAHHAHAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHA
mcabingan1 1 year ago
@mcabingan1 Hahaha...thats mean though...
jesusluvsme12345 1 year ago
WHat is she doing with her face? She looks constipated!
jesusluvsme12345 1 year ago
@jesusluvsme12345 everyone makes some type of face when singing.
jordanlandrum 1 year ago
@jordanlandrum She should of did number 2 before performing...ugh>.>
jesusluvsme12345 1 year ago
@jesusluvsme12345 LOL
jordanlandrum 1 year ago
I wish those stupid douchenuggets would not have drowned out her ending note! I am trying to decipher the rest of the adlibbin' that was added to that note, but I can't hear shit!
aussiechic06 1 year ago
I think it's so cute how all the animal characters are dancing along too! :D
MusicallyUbiquitous 1 year ago
She was so cute during this performance! This woman is always adorable :)
BrokenButterfIy 1 year ago
I go back and forth in my mind trying to figure out if this version or the '94 version is better. I refuse to choose! During this time, Queen Mariah's voice possessed such a husky, soulful tone. In the '94 version her voice soared beyond the mountains and had limitless potential. She's the only woman i know that outdoes herself in everything she does lol! Hate me all you want when i say this but there's a Queen Aretha AND a Queen Mariah now!
capcomfighter13 1 year ago 73
@capcomfighter13
hahaha, Queen Mariah xD
gloomyoutlook 11 months ago
@capcomfighter13 I knoooow! I'm torn between these 2 performances too! :D
lorddennisjoplin 3 months ago
thank you to all the people who said this was live because if it was lipped the first verse would have repeated and it did not so it was live. I would love to go to Disney for Christmas.
mariahthebest1 1 year ago
Comment removed
drunkdivamariahcarey 1 year ago
@drunkdivamariahcarey omg ur cover was so bad i think instead of calling mariah drunk u should call urself taht cuz only someone drunk would post up such a horrible cover...lol god bless ur lol that was way 2 embarassing
mcjms23 1 year ago
This performance is amazing and is 100% LIVE! You can always tell when she is singing live because she always does something a little bit different to every song. I love Mariah and this is amazing.
jvalderaz18 1 year ago 2
it seems magical!
Telma1987 1 year ago
she's like the queen of disneyland lol
koolangeldude1 1 year ago
it wasn't like "94" and actually she did that song like 5 times that afternoon. She sang it one and other time, they were editing the whole thing and actually what you see here is way to different to the real thing but it was an amazing performance considering how dried her vocal chords are now. Her backup singers are or were truly amazing though.
baretreemty 1 year ago
y u think she lip synching?....cuse itz perfect....this 100% LIVE!!!!!
MrFantastic1028 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Everyone Need's To Go Get A Copy Of Her New Christmas Album ''Merry Christmas II You''!!! The Album Is Frikking Amazing!! I Bought 2 Copy For Myself Already,Made My Mom Buy A Copy For Herself And Made 2 Of My Friends Buy A Copy Also!! 5 Copies Sold Right Here!! Everybody Should Do The Same! It's Really Woth It!=)) Her Best Vocals In Yearsssssss!!!
RiPcOrDz83 1 year ago
am I the only one that thinks she's lip synching in certain small parts to the original lowered to one semitone?
JPhillippeMusic 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
cant wait for her new album
supermariah 1 year ago
Love this song! The Lord is come!I Love this rendtion- Can't wait for MCIIU!!
JoyBella89 1 year ago
What year was this?
ZakrazakOfTheXMen 1 year ago
@ZakrazakOfTheXMen In December of 2004. she had already finished the Emancipation album. the firs single, "Shake it off" was released i think in the next month on radio... in january or feb of 2005
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
@DanielAvilaAGT umm the first single was "It's Like That".
dafuture93 1 year ago
@dafuture93 oh i know.. i was thinking of ,"it's like that" but somehow i wrote out "shake it off" :s thankx for clear in that up
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
@DanielAvilaAGT - The first single was It's Like That lol
MusicallyUbiquitous 1 year ago
love mariah carey and more love her when december ..haha
Ruzzful 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
mariah with that red gown always remind me of miss patti labelle ... heheheh ^__________^
cervejerano 1 year ago
mariah with that red gown always remind me of miss patti labelle ... heheheh ^__________^
cervejerano 1 year ago
The blonde hair suited her but so did the dark brown and light brown :P
HoorahMonster 1 year ago
i've listened to whitneys version, and It was nothing compare to MARIAH's...whitneys version is more on like the heroine version or the cocaine version of this song, LMAO...she must be high when she sang that version....
mabuhaymc 1 year ago 5
Mariah will be back in 2010.... Check her out singing at Disney for Christmas
babymariah 1 year ago 3
I love her new song, OH SANTA! and this too :)
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
joy to the world...ohhhhhhhh so amazing and so good to listen to even it is just in the early of october...
0928calmshadow 1 year ago 3
The beginning of the end of the end, and the start of the new start.
Ineddiblehulk 1 year ago
Woah... she had slept the night before.
MrSpears82 1 year ago
27 do not like christmas ...
TiFFANYSREYES 1 year ago
wow 3:12 that is a low note. lol
jlilcutie 1 year ago
2:59 is fantastic jooooyyy, jooooyyy, JOOOOOOOOOOOOYY
all34adam 1 year ago
i got shivers down my spine
TheRicanDelight 1 year ago
i love you mariah
ivinlovemariah 1 year ago
amazing
lemonchel0 1 year ago
FLAWLESS. Never will you hear this song sung this great, again.
caszidy215 1 year ago
@caszidy215 well your wrong about that just watch her abc christmas cancert in november
elihyah 1 year ago
@elihyah :| u dont know if it will be this great so how can u say i am wrong?
caszidy215 1 year ago
she sounds like a horse in the last part (whistle part) but still loved her. :) love you mimi.
rain03x 1 year ago
@rain03x like a horse !!! LOOOOL!
pastcineo 1 year ago
@rain03x a hoarse cant even hit a note that high LMAO
jaypaidincash 1 year ago
The raspiness of her voice gives me goosebumps
AustinWilliam2009 1 year ago
SHE DID DIS SONG UP 100 PERCENT LIVE SOOOO PROUD OF HER
Jamaalq7 1 year ago 41
no other voice will ever sound this great
jakey1126 1 year ago 2
Wow. She is such a powerful performer.
fanwuren 1 year ago 42
wow she sounds amazing hear, one of my fav from the xmas album, i play this CD every Dec 1st when i put my xmas tree up (good times) get me in the xmas mood :-)
jamiem553 1 year ago
i loveeee mariaahhhhh
edsssooonnn 1 year ago
If it was my turn to go on Space Mountain and I had waited 3 hours, I would give it up and go see her perform.
varevshatian23 1 year ago
@varevshatian23 duuuuhhhhh if i waited 163 hours and she came i would leave without even thinking!
iiAmitx3 1 year ago
@iiAmitx3 hahaha i would've done the same!!
THAiLLESTCHiCK 1 year ago
@THAiLLESTCHiCK lol i would have go even if i was in the middle of the ride! XD
iiAmitx3 1 year ago
Aaaah too bad I went in 2003 and missed the best singer to grace planet earth!!!! Mariah =Legend !!!!!! =D
Da1uLyK 1 year ago
lucky ass kidz
applmac2009 1 year ago 2
projection, style, and emotions that transmit you mariah are not unique will have another equal mc is unique
cinkey8 1 year ago
true! this made me smile too! love you mariah no matter what!
domrob13 1 year ago
only an idiot can say this is not live... U can obviously notice it.. Mariah is struggling on reaching the notes... Well its all well done... Amazing performance! im from the phils also... And they say that mariah only needs to restwell before every perfomance,so i guess she rested well here before this live performance!
martymart25 1 year ago 2
She sounded superb! i like how she sustained some notes.. i like this performance.. it was like her 1994 performance fused with her 2001
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
She was 34 here.. she did record TEOM during 2004. I remember that WBT or q single was gonna be released at the end of this year.. But the album got pushed to early 2005 and WBT was released very soon after. she was skinny in this video
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
Omg I have goosebumps :@
MEareCAT 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is really lipsynch because when she went here in the philippines year 2003 her voice is not already sounds so good so, how much more in the year 2004 right...i'm a great fan of mariah so i know her every moves i know the songs that she lipsynchs....
teraniel11 1 year ago
@teraniel11 You are talking out your ass. Look at her LIVE 2006 Grammy performance. It's incredible, one of her best. And that was later than this. It's obvious that this performance, despite what retards like yourself say, is LIVE. Mariah Carey is the BEST
MEareCAT 1 year ago
@teraniel11 are you blind?! or just dumb? probably both!I have nothing to say except may the Lord rid the world of stupid people!
cersus 1 year ago
@teraniel11 You're an idiot. Clearly, this is live. Go crawl back in your delusional hole. Just because she didn't sound amazing (in your opinion) in 2003, does not mean that her voice couldn't have regained it's fluidity, power, range, etc. The voice is ever changing.
FurImmerLamm 1 year ago
@teraniel11 no dear, i was there in that concert and her voice there was perfection. and her voice in 2003 is great. her belting and whistling techniques were effortless
drjcrmt 1 year ago
hey,, how sure u are,,, bakit super close b kau ni mariah, i went there in charmbracelet tour,,, last nov 2003 and what can i say is not the voice of mariah,, the sound system is the problem,,, all song that she sang is purely live,, and also im huge fan of mariah carey here in the phil.... i love mariah
mimi3178 1 year ago
@teraniel11 it's pure live! :)
DarKStalkeR19 1 year ago
@teraniel11
if you're a real lamb, you must know that this is 100% LIVE!!! 2004 is a good year of mariah's voice.
PreciousMariah22 1 year ago
Her voice was great here! I hope she can regain it :)
ATreshawnV 1 year ago
I don't know why people are saying what would Mariah be without her whistles. Yes, if she gets her nodes remove she might lose "some" of her whistle range, but obviously only the ones she does in the morning to go into the eighth octave. Most of her seventh octave whistles were naturally part of the great range she achieved through practise. Trust me, if all of her whistle range came from nodes, then the whistles would sound much weaker, and not as effortless as if she had already built up range
TheDeathsAdvocate 1 year ago
@TheDeathsAdvocate you must be her doctor, right? just shup up if you don't know what you're talking bout
dreamdate 1 year ago
@dreamdate Actually I've got vocal nodes, and no Mariah will not lose her range if she gets them removed. But it's VERY risky even with top surgeons so good on her for not trusting them.
TheDeathsAdvocate 1 year ago
@TheDeathsAdvocate she stated herself that her vocal cords are unique, so they are not comparable with yours
dreamdate 1 year ago