Added: 5 years ago
From: NEHOMAS
Views: 2,430,342
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,422)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • WOW.

  • beautiful voice, but I agree, Hayley's pace was a bit different :s

  • There's a reason Lord of the Rings was so great. I'll leave that reason for you to decide.

  • Comment removed

  • Angle-like voice!

  • Her beginning of this song is just electrifying.

  • I love Lisa Kelly's version the best by far..She sings it like it should be sung,,,amazing...Peaceout=)

  • I wish I sounded like her!

  • she is like an angel...

  • Enya's version is MUCH MUCH BETTER!! watch?v=GxN-ph6uc6M

    Hayley Westenra does not keep pace. She sings so fast!

  • @letkbokc You cannot deny how beautiful her voice is though. True serenity listening to this.

  • Like all 3 versions because they are all different and bring something different to a beautiful piece of music.

  • This is nothing compared to Enya or Celtic Woman

  • God bless your voice

  • i can`t believe... it`s so beautiful

  • Hayley is a fantastic singer and beautiful woman :):) :)

  • This song is absolutely ethereal. The singer even looks elvish. Absolutly outstanding. She gives voice to the very root of Tolkien's work.

  • She sings it well and she enunciates the Elvish well. Good job, Hayley!

  • Oh my god...Lord of the Rings...and Hayley Westenra....brain pleasure overload

  • i like enya's version more. :D

  • Beatiful woman, amazing voice and heroic song!

  • I'm a big Hayley fan, but i have to admit i think lisa kelly's rendtion is better.

  • Hayley Westenra=Good singer at this song.

    Enya=Good singer at this song.

    Lisa Kelly=Good singer at this song.

    They all sing it a bit differently but above all they all sing it beautifully. Don't fight over who YOU think is better, I myself enjoy Lisa Kelly more because I heard her sing it first. Doesn't mean that Enya and Hayley suck, I like them too.

  • Why cant you just enjoy music without making stupid comparissions? Hayley does it her way, she is a fucking soprano! Enya is not. She is a songwriter and yes, she uses lots of effects and stuff, just a different kind of musician. I love Enya and I just love how Hayley sings this song. Do we really need to fight to find out who is better? Sometimes some people seem like football supporters fighting. Enjoy music...

  • I just remembered why she is one of my favorite singers.

    What a lovely tribute to this fantastic soundtrack.

  • Enya is still the one who wrote this song..so i respect her for that even though she cant sing live..enya even told in her interviews she rather let other musicans play her music and hayley did a wonderful job..beautiful..

  • wowwwwwwwwww,bravissimaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!che voce divina

  • I heard Hayley's version before I ever heard Enya's, so the Enya version sounds strange to me. lol. I typically like whichever version of a song I hear first.

  • love it, as always. check this one out!!!!! watch?v=xuo5vSTMp9c

  • WOW!

  • Hypnotic!

  • How wonderful is she!

  • She ruined it by rushing it. It's meant to be taken slow, not hurried through!!!!!! Back to Enya.

  • @nonyanb09

    In contrast to the Enya's drone? No, thanks. I rather listen a real person singing, than Enya's computer aided version.

  • Comment removed

  • So beautiful

  • i prefer hayley version than enya :$

  • 0:08-0:35-->Was ist dieses Teils Name?

  • Hayley Westenra singing May It Be. Coming from a Hayley Westenra fan as well as a hardcore Enya fan, I can't comprehend the amazingness of this video. *dies*

  • quelle voix !!!! quand on aime le morceau au départ, on prends vraiment son pied à écouter!

  • Enya is a bad singer live as much as I hate to admit it. Watch any of her live versions and compare it to this.. it's a no brainer. Her studio version is fantastic, but Hayley's live performance blows any of Enya's live performances out of the water.

    An epic song from the epic trilogy. Roll on The Hobbit!

  • Beautiful! Hayley is singing it in a higher key than Enya. That's the difference between the two. I love both. :)

  • beautiful but noone can beat enya

    tolkien fans forever :,D

  • Lisa's is better i think.

  • @cbrme97 Lisa Kelly? Yes, she is much better. I like her voice and her humilty.

  • @mangaoriginal123 ..yes i agree,lisa kelly..the best!!

  • @mangaoriginal123

    Lisa should be humbled by a superior voice.

  • umbreon is right, it actually is better than enya's I don't know why people have so much trouble admitting that just because a song even though composed for/by someone to sing can be outperformed, and that version automatically becomes the best one, come one guys, hayley's voice is astronomically better than enya's, the thing is you are used to enya's version, ..

    pd: btw, I love enya, and im wondered by her music, but, lets be honest this is a better performance, is HEAVEN

  • this is actually better than enya's version

  • @umbreon123456 Nothing is better than Enya's version! It's her song, afterall. : ) But I admire the other ladies who are following in her footsteps.

  • @TheLiviaRules yup your right lad because these people wouldnt be singing this song if it wasnt for enya

  • @TheLiviaRules lisa kelly sings it best hands down.i love enya but she always has this computer kind of sound.just my opion,so no anger just talking....peace and godbless.

  • love it

  • Oh my God...I love her voice.. ><

  • It sends shivers down your spine... so beautiful.

  • I have no words, only emotions...it's like listening a voice from heaven!

  • My favorite author, My favorite singer = Heaven. Nothing more to say.

  • increible

  • LET THE MOTORBOATING BEGINS!!!

  • LOTR, music and boobs, the final combination...

  • I hear it again and again and again and again. wunderful voice.

  • thank you for this lovely video...makes my day!

  • Beautiful, just beautiful. Not my favorite version and the elvish isn't quite right but still, Hayley has a beautiful voice and is extremely talented!

    She actually gave me goosebumps with the first few lyrics =D

  • Just play this before you go sleep and you'll have beautiful dreams

  • @Khalipse its tru I've done it to Lisa's rendition.

  • @Khalipse last night i played a playlist of hayley and i had really fun dreams :)

  • @Khalipse I was just about to go to sleep anyway and then i saw your comment lol :D

  • no hay como enya

  • Hayley is a Star and lights her own way.....

  • 197 are justin bieber fans

  • she's like sunshine

  • i like both versions... this one is a little bit easier to understand the Enya's... but both are remarkable in their own way

  • Hayley is truly an artist, a musician and a singer, in the full extent of the word. There is simply no comparison with pop artists.

  • One of the world's most beautiful young women and a killer song---thanks for this.

  • clearly comparing live versions to studio recordings is not justified. Listen to this /watch?v=YqAan2oZHno....the studio recording of may it be :) I think Hayley's touches my heart the most.

  • aaaaaa fuckin love it

    im a thrasher but

    i love it

  • amazing - a voice like an angel -

  • I'd like to see Lorenna McKennitt give this a try. However, Hayley is really good too!

  • Comment removed

  • what a beautiful voice!!

  • 1. Look at face

    2. Look at boobs

    3. Enjoy the singing

  • @Tears0faShadow Please give her the respect she deserves.

  • @Tears0faShadow that is really disrespectful and degrading to women.

  • @Tears0faShadow buhahahahaha!........XD

  • Haley and Enya are both great in singing this song. I believe they both have similar styles of singing. I think that they should do a Duet. That would be a must see event.

  • @IchigoMatrix

    Hayley would embarrass Enya if they did a live duet.

  • goosebumps at the first hearing of the intro

  • Put Enya on stage like Hayley and then we can compare the versions.

  • @Ardalla555

    Don't think Enya would/could ever do a live version. Doubtful there would ever be a comparison. 

  • The Celts, Memory of Trees, Shepherd Moons, Watermark, A Day Without Rain, Amarantine....... NUFF SAID

  • Chaque chanteuse a sa propre voix,moi j'aime tout.Et cette voix et MAGNIFIQUE,remplie d'emotion,de douceur et d'amour.Bravo Haley!

  • so wonderful.

    Tears in my eyes as I listen to an angel, and thank the composer of this lovely song.

    Thank you so much for posting.

    Brian Jacobi.

    NZ

  • hayley westenra's version of world in union is where its at

  • Божественный голос!

  • @igo5243 Я совершенно согласен с вами. Она просто чудо.

  • Why this song is suggested by you tube after MoonBoy hardstyle dance?? From hell to heven :D

  • she reminds me of jessica biel

  • She has a wonderful voice,World in Union is testament to that. But she does not do this song justice,Enya's version is how it should be sung. And @broden76 Enya can sing this live,I've seen her perform it.

  • She's a good singer, but her voice is too sharp for the song. This song is more deeper, soothing. her's is very sharp.

  • @Devdas4221992

    Her voice is better than Enya's.

  • How can you all fight after listening to this beautiful song? I feel so calm and have tears in my eyes..May it be any version by anyone :)

  • You should check out her new number for the Ruby World Cup "World in Union".. amazing singer.

  • My favorite book, my favorite movie, and my favorite singer= my favorite song!!!

  • pięknie, czyściutko, ale oryginał chyba lepszy

  • to me it sounds like shes rushing a bit but still awsome

  • How the hell does she do that violining?

  • Great voice but I didnt get goosebumps like I did listening to Enya

  • omg hayley rocks!

  • Linda canção!!!

    love, love, love

  • I really pray that they can have her do a song for The Hobbit. That's coming out next year if you didn't know. She would be perfect.

  • Comment removed

  • @Senistrognata

    You obviously can't appreciate a pitch perfect voice.

    OTOH, you're ears has been ruined listening to fakes such as Enya.

  • imho, I prefer Lisa Kelly's version on the first CW album, it's more emotional than either Hayley's or Enya's, but as ipb7883 said, voices are a matter of taste. And none of these artists are trying to 'top' each other, their gifts are way beyond that.

  • @EwolDJ

    Lisa couldn't even carrry Hayley's sheet music.

  • there's something with this girl!! I really like her!! seriously!! oh my god!... but she should be careful with these songs... for example Wuthering heights!!... Some songs need something else behind technique talent and a pretty face...... just sayin!!.

  • Enya's record is heavily digitized and compressed, that's what she does. It's her thing and she does it skillfully, but I'm not so sure if she can do it live. Westenra's version, or Celtic Woman version for that matter are live, that makes a big difference.

  • Comment removed

  • I enjoy her songs, but this was not a great performance.

  • or... mafia?

  • medal of honor? ...

  • Beautiful girl, with a beautiful voice.

    Amazing

  • so peace....

  • Very  beautiful !

    This song is always sung by the Heart !

    Thanks for sharing.

  • Hayley is my favourite singer in the world, but Enya is better on this song...

  • @TiagoHikaru

    Enya is better on the computer.

  • brb im going to watch lord of the rings now

    

  • See kid's? this is music, scrap your so called "good music" and watch your heart die. Just so you know, I'm 14 and I wouldn't listen to anything else =).

  • She's fucking hot

  • there's no warmth in this performance...no interpetation. Pretty voice but it seems like she's singing AT us rather than TO us.

  • Her voice is pretty but she lacks dynamic.

  • I don´t need sound to listen this video ;)

  • que linda cancion !!!

  • NZ talent

  • im not a fan of this one . to high pitch

  • This lady can sing! But I prefer Lisa Kelly in this song. Lisa her timing is perfect!

  • @beaucat10 I totally agree. This one's nice, but flawed in timing and—in my opinion—emphasis. Lisa Kelly's, I would say, even tops Enya's.

  • @torrita01

    It's not hard to better a computer.

  • Her's is the best version of this song. And btw, The Hobbit is coming out next year if you didn't know!!!

  • GREAT composition, but she sings a little too fast, and in too uniform a way.

    The transition between the intro in particular was a little brutal......

    I did quite like her dress though.

  • Comment removed

  • ohmygoodness WHAT A VOICE! incredibly amazing :D

  • Hayley, take a bow for the wonderful effort. I loved the way you sang it. :)

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I think it makes no sense whatsoever comparing Enya's and Hayley's respective versions. This is art, built on very personal feelings and means of expression. Both Enya and Hayley do their exquisite best, and it's just a matter of audience's taste to incline for one or the other. Sincerely, I love both, each one in its own way...

  • @ipb7883 Of course it makes sense, your comparing two versions of the same song. You prefer a cover artist to the original composer. Its not really a matter of taste. If hayley had the soul of Enya she would be writing her own material.

  • @deathmetalhippy That's strange allright. I never said whom do I prefer, and yet you assume it's Hayley! Why?

    If it is not a matter of taste, then what is it? Mathematics maybe, where 2+2=4 always? No, sir.

    Why do you expect Hayley to be identical to Enya and even to have her soul? We are all unique. If you had my soul, you would think the same as I do, right?

    By the way, are you a fan of that noise called metal? :-)

  • @ipb7883 i wonder if justin beiber did a cover of it, if you would still call it art, a means of expression, etc.

  • @winggoddess :-) No, don't wonder! I say Justin B. is (sorry) a teenager prick and 100% just a marketing product, period. He is sooooo dumb, so immature, so self centered he thinks he is already a star. Well, actually he is, for the very simple minded teenage fellows.

    But this is not Hayley's case. She sings and she plays piano, violin, guitar. She has a solid musical background and musical education. This in not just talent, this is hard work too. Nothing to do with Justin's meowing...

  • @ipb7883 i figured. but whether u like someone or not shouldn't change things. if all music is art and expression, then so is justin b's. whether the music/lyrics is personal for the singer is unknowable to the audience. they may all be in it for the money for all we know. how do u know justin b. is dumb, immature, and self-centered? do u know him personally?

    i'm glad to hear hayley is so talented. she is worthy of fame and fortune. but she could still be those negative things u said ~ JB

  • @winggoddess :) No, of course I don't know J.B. personally. Although I'm not a follower of this marketing phenomenon, I can't help hearing or seeing media's comments about him, describing his arrogance, being so full of himself, and so high handed that he wrote (hahaha) his first book!!! :-D Actually, other people are taking advantage of him, and when J.B. will no longer be of interest to them, he will fatally fall. Actually, other people ruined his life for good.

  • @ipb7883 all i see about him is people who love him and people who hate him because others love him. most famous people *do* write books about themselves, including people in politics. it's a way to make more money. i don't know the guy personally, and i'm not a fan, but i'm guessing that adults (parents, agents, etc.) have more to do with his book and other marketing stuff than he does.

  • 1.Enya

    2.Celtic Woman

    3.Haley W.

    (not saying haley is bad, but i like the other versions better)

  • @yesidono

    Agree... but if i have to be honest, enya version is the only one i really like.

  • @yesidono omg enya is crap compared to haley

  • @yesidono hayley blew my mind fucking away, she is an angel, enya and celtic, are just great but this turns out to be too outstanding

  • She's good but Lisa Kelly is WAY better

  • @selena91130 So true!! Compared to Lisa this sounds just like a nice try...

  • its my dream to hear her in concert one day

  • What a gift

  • Amazing beauty

  • I love her celtic beauty and voice! After Wales and Ireland are most celtic people in Czech Republic, the land of Boii!

  • i love how well done this is, including the added Orchestra in the back. it makes the whole thing just perfect!, PLUS her voice is amazing!!

  • cant get any better! love her voice and her nice boobs

  • i really love to listen to the voice of hayley it made me calm and relax..

    splendid voice and she is indeed stunningly beautiful.

  • Ireland, this New Zealand girl is giving a hell of a more than she needs to, so respect her, and sort your island shit, whwnever it comes from. The bullshit and self-attention has to stop. This girl is singing her heart out from a one ireland, don't you realise that?

  • Get she she get exported to parts of North of Irland to talk sense?

  • Her intention may not have been to top Enya, but did she ever accomplish just that! Hayley has a beautiful voice and I love listening to her when I write. So inspirational.

  • Lisa Kelly > all

  • I can't wait to see the original story of Bilbo Baggins. After reading the book a hundred million thousand billion umm well, I read it a bunch before the movie came out. The Hobbit is coming out next year btw!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • @smallfry8199 Thats good to know, LOTR was the best movie ever, I cant wait for the Hobbit. Thanks for that info.

  • Yesterday she did an amazing performance here in Malta with out international Tenor Joseph Calleja. She's just amazing.

  • theofficialdawn locked pm theprincesskairi locked pm to friend only gamemik76 locked pm fruitymcgayman lock pm confuse lock pm shrinemaidensayochan lock pm reihinochan1 lock pm reihinochanpriestess lock pm janiceocean lock pm i am super scientist i am conducting experiment to see how stupid people are i am curious monkey business pioneer. i wanna find out what is going on with the world. why so many moron or immature ppl in our society??? the world is fucked.
  • Hayley's intention here was never to top Enya. It's just her version. Lisa Kelley, formerly of Celtic Woman, also has a very nice version. It's a song that can be performed many times by any artist who has the proper voice to pull it off.

  • Her voice is so gorgeous it gives me goose bumps and shivers. Hauntingly beautiful.