Continuation: These two realization lead me to wonder: Why were John's instrumental tapes so reduced in his recordings? For example, his acoustic guitar on Jealous Guy is mostly inaudible. He could have played the piano part that Phil Spector plays in that song. I know John was a guitarist primarily, but he could have contributed so much more the instrumental tracks of the Beatles and his own solo career!
I used to think that John had no real skill at the piano and that Paul was the real pianist of the Beatles. These tapes shown me how skilled John really was at the piano. They have also shown me how much John brought into his songwriting. I used to think that John would write a song on his acoustic guitar, bring it into a producer, and then the producer would add the arrangement. But on these piano tapes, I can see that John really knew what he wanted before he entered the studio. Continued...
Lennon tal qual Airton Senna antes da corrida fatal ,parecia advinhar o seu destino .Canção triste ,pungente e linda .Lennon & Airton Senna Heróis do nosso tempo .
John is my Hero.. i love him always did and always will. I will never stop missing his prescence in the world and in my life.. I miss him every single day. Now i just have to say how i feel about this amazing song. First of all the sheer simplistic beauty of John Lennon sitting at his piano with bare feet just singing this ethereal and dark beautiful love song to Yoko .. Not polished just pure raw beauty and magic. The melody is haunting. I always loved when John sang straight from his soul.
@ZZqezza apparently it was written for Paul McCartney - i read on wikipedia that John wrote 'for Paul' on the cassette tape. might not be true but i like to think he did write it for his friend
On October 9th we will all watch "Imagine" in honor of the greatest singer ever's birthday. Let's give him the best birthday present ever: the highest viewed video on YouTube!! Let's give him what he deserves and what Justin Bieber does not deserve to have!
Copy and paste to all John lennon/beatles videos and all music videos let's get this noticed quickly!
@ness1804 Nice idea.. though I don't think that 'old winston' would care too much about them youtube ratings. Listen to a tune and lit up a candle... that's more than beautiful I think. That's how I will be paying my dues the master... (maybe a glass of scotch also)
And who gives a crap of Justin Bieber anyway...? Hardly no-one five years from now.... I hope...
Everytime I listen to this song I try to think how the Beatles felt like when they first listened to this. It must have been some very hard and emotional days for them to work on these tapes and make them into a song..
Probablement une ébauche de ce qui aurait pu être une des plus belles chansons de Lennon. Entre 1'50 et 2'50, c'est inabouti, Lennon cherche. Mais les couplets... c'est tout bon !
I dont want that this audio would be remastered by left 2 beatles because: firstly it would become a beatles song(and its not a beatles song) secondy they would ruin it just lisen how pure and perfect is this song but it only needs to work on it by placing a new piano record with the same playing style on record and leave johns vocal
I know some may disagree with me but. . . Free As a bird real love and this are so much better songs that were on Double Fantasy. Too bad he didn't recorded it.
@comicification I think you're right! I just checked the Wiki entry on this song, & it says "In January 1994, Paul McCartney was given two tape cassettes by Lennon's widow Yoko Ono that included home recordings of songs Lennon never completed or released ... in addition to two other songs was a tape with the words "for Paul" scrawled hastily in John's handwriting, which included "Grow Old With Me" and "Now and Then".
its about yoko silly...they had been apart and john wrote all these songs for yoko and sean..which would be on double fantasy...this one never made it
@ZAPDUNGAA Hmmm, but this demo was made in 1978, when John was back with Yoko. It sounds like it's about someone he's currently separated from & missing. That's why I'd guess it's for someone else, but it's impossible to know for sure.
I couldn't agree more.. this song is simply beautiful the way it is.. absolute perfection. Thank you for having this available, I love it so very much! xox
When I die and my soul goes to haven I hope God will switch on his cd player and will let me listen to all albums the Beatles could record from 1970 untill now...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
First: To make a record by singing and playing over a dead man' s voice is HORRIBLE. Second: this song wasn' t intended for the Beatles so Paul and Ringo shouldn' t do this crap like they shouldn' t have done with "Free as a bird" and "Real Love"
@sophielouisesimon So was Free As A Bird and they did a wonderful work. I think it´s a drag that George refused to do it. I really hope that Paul and Ringo do it.
@sophielouisesimon I enjoy the simplicity of Lennon's songs as much as the next guy but only if the Beatles worked on this song would it then become an epic
It will never exist. because too many frequencies of the voice and piano overlap. If it was a kick drum, you might have a reasonable chance - but no one will ever be able to extract a multi-track recording from a mono source without obvious problems.
I would love for this to be released. Even though I like what is called the "1995 edit" to here an offcial release by the Beatles would be fantastic and a great thrill if it is on Rock Band or released as a single if the Beatles go on iTunes.
various spots over the internet, they said all four beatles appear on the track and mccartney spent like the past two or three years working on it. just type "now and then finished" on google and read about it
I certainly hope it's true, but I'll keep a healthy level of skepticism. If they release it as a download, that's one download I would buy in a heartbeat. And I normally refrain from doing so.
I was just roaming around on You Tube and than I saw this video on someone's channel! Lennon's voice struck me with unbelievable power! And now I'm left in all that emotional shit.. I don't know whether to cry or smile! I'm just speechless! Great song and a very beautiful melody!
ahi se ve el talento, la capacidad para componer y crear canciones que aun despues de muerto quedan para la posteridad. Una bella melodia, a mi punto de vista se oye mejor solo que con the beatles
Best version of this demo I've ever heard. Why didn't the Threetles have this clean recodring to overdub stuff onto? They claimed the tape they had had bad static that couldn't be removed. Not here!
John didn't learn alot of his piano skills until after The Beatles I believe.
Stevesk0011 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
Continuation: These two realization lead me to wonder: Why were John's instrumental tapes so reduced in his recordings? For example, his acoustic guitar on Jealous Guy is mostly inaudible. He could have played the piano part that Phil Spector plays in that song. I know John was a guitarist primarily, but he could have contributed so much more the instrumental tracks of the Beatles and his own solo career!
epicishness 1 week ago in playlist Uploaded videos
I used to think that John had no real skill at the piano and that Paul was the real pianist of the Beatles. These tapes shown me how skilled John really was at the piano. They have also shown me how much John brought into his songwriting. I used to think that John would write a song on his acoustic guitar, bring it into a producer, and then the producer would add the arrangement. But on these piano tapes, I can see that John really knew what he wanted before he entered the studio. Continued...
epicishness 1 week ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Digital restauranted.
paulc4567 1 month ago 2
Finish the song, Macca ...
Zebonka 1 month ago 18
Lennon tal qual Airton Senna antes da corrida fatal ,parecia advinhar o seu destino .Canção triste ,pungente e linda .Lennon & Airton Senna Heróis do nosso tempo .
lcfa1962 1 month ago
what a sad song to be listening to on the anniversary of his passing. R.I.P. John
whiskersdog77 2 months ago
Wow, me pone la piel chinita esta rola! buenisima!
Hammerandoz666 2 months ago
John is my Hero.. i love him always did and always will. I will never stop missing his prescence in the world and in my life.. I miss him every single day. Now i just have to say how i feel about this amazing song. First of all the sheer simplistic beauty of John Lennon sitting at his piano with bare feet just singing this ethereal and dark beautiful love song to Yoko .. Not polished just pure raw beauty and magic. The melody is haunting. I always loved when John sang straight from his soul.
MermaidPrincess9 2 months ago 2
@MermaidPrincess9 A most beautiful and touching comment. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts with us. You are a princess.
tjcint 2 months ago
I wonder for whom was this song written.
ZZqezza 3 months ago
@ZZqezza apparently it was written for Paul McCartney - i read on wikipedia that John wrote 'for Paul' on the cassette tape. might not be true but i like to think he did write it for his friend
kaiserkeller61 1 week ago
@kaiserkeller61 really? that would make the song even better
ZZqezza 1 week ago
@kaiserkeller61 It is true. This song and "Grow Old With Me".
HappySunshineStar 5 days ago
@ZZqezza "for paul" was written on the tape
jullietjynx 1 week ago
ATTENTION ALL JOHN LENNON FANS
On October 9th we will all watch "Imagine" in honor of the greatest singer ever's birthday. Let's give him the best birthday present ever: the highest viewed video on YouTube!! Let's give him what he deserves and what Justin Bieber does not deserve to have!
Copy and paste to all John lennon/beatles videos and all music videos let's get this noticed quickly!
THUMBS THIS UP
LET'S GET THIS NOTICED
Lets help John!
ness1804 5 months ago 4
@ness1804 Nice idea.. though I don't think that 'old winston' would care too much about them youtube ratings. Listen to a tune and lit up a candle... that's more than beautiful I think. That's how I will be paying my dues the master... (maybe a glass of scotch also)
And who gives a crap of Justin Bieber anyway...? Hardly no-one five years from now.... I hope...
theSugarmonk 4 months ago 2
@xxTitanicRocksxx My friend... where have you read it?
MarcoZucchi81 5 months ago
Everytime I listen to this song I try to think how the Beatles felt like when they first listened to this. It must have been some very hard and emotional days for them to work on these tapes and make them into a song..
RefugeeNL 6 months ago 16
so sad but then again with a twist of hope ..
TheJarnit 7 months ago
Probablement une ébauche de ce qui aurait pu être une des plus belles chansons de Lennon. Entre 1'50 et 2'50, c'est inabouti, Lennon cherche. Mais les couplets... c'est tout bon !
MrMusicause 7 months ago
probably the most gloomy song of John
hwanj 7 months ago
I dont want that this audio would be remastered by left 2 beatles because: firstly it would become a beatles song(and its not a beatles song) secondy they would ruin it just lisen how pure and perfect is this song but it only needs to work on it by placing a new piano record with the same playing style on record and leave johns vocal
BeatleJohnGeorge 7 months ago
@BeatleJohnGeorge In my opinion sean dnd julian should do a record together including this song
MarcoZucchi81 6 months ago
@MarcoZucchi81 I agree.
10995 5 months ago
Who the hell disliked this and why?
Beholdthesharktopus 7 months ago
where did you get this album?
Globalize239 7 months ago
It's wonderful to listen to this raw, I can see him setting up his recorder, sitting at his piano, making sure everything's set and starting to play.
Zimnyification 7 months ago
This song made me shed a tear, and I am not ashamed to admit that.
tylerraysanford 8 months ago 9
Lennon said imagine was probably his best work, this is close, imagine what it would have been like finished
killdeslm 8 months ago
RESTAURED=RETARD
jproducts 9 months ago in playlist The Ultimate Beatles Mix
ami me parece una cancion como las de ahora, osea que si the beatles todavia siguieran aqui hubieran encajado perfectamente en este tiempo
MccartneyLennon09 9 months ago
Una cancion totalmente adelantada a su tiempo!!!
mauroiso 10 months ago
Una cancion totalmente adelantada a su tiempo!!!
mauroiso 10 months ago
this might be the most beautiful song I've ever heard.
kaitlinan 10 months ago 5
This is MUCH better than the "finished" version.. :)
tuippe4 11 months ago 2
thanks for uploading this. he really did have some good songs kicking about in circa 1980. such a shame he never got to finish all of them.
stofstg 11 months ago 3
"Сейчас и после"-лучшая песня Леннона из всего творческого наследия!!!
kilbeyshannon 1 year ago 2
good in a raw state besides it wouldnt be a beatles song anymore since george is dead
endurocatfish 1 year ago
restaurant record, that is funny!
frog33ww 1 year ago
@frog33ww That's a Lennon Joke.
syleriam 10 months ago
John Lennon (restaurant record)
athakirch77 1 year ago
they should do the same thing as a band did with buddy hollys last songs
Vegassman28 1 year ago
it might be lyrics he made right at the top of his head u just never no
painteat 1 year ago
this song is so sad, I wish Paul and Ringo would release Carnival of Light and this one, totally remastered. I'd jizz
ruufeeooh 1 year ago
this song is about and for Yoko... tears beyond tears
leosupercluster 1 year ago
I Miss you ALWAYS Dear John!
cherkestorm 1 year ago
I know some may disagree with me but. . . Free As a bird real love and this are so much better songs that were on Double Fantasy. Too bad he didn't recorded it.
coolmandato 1 year ago
OMG this is simply sublime!!!
Babyhowdy233 1 year ago 4
actually the original version (with strange sound on background) has more charm
k0stil 1 year ago
This is like the saddest song ever - I wonder who it's about? Maybe May Pang?
MarieNC2 1 year ago
@MarieNC2 its about paul i think
comicification 1 year ago 3
@comicification I think you're right! I just checked the Wiki entry on this song, & it says "In January 1994, Paul McCartney was given two tape cassettes by Lennon's widow Yoko Ono that included home recordings of songs Lennon never completed or released ... in addition to two other songs was a tape with the words "for Paul" scrawled hastily in John's handwriting, which included "Grow Old With Me" and "Now and Then".
How tragic.
MarieNC2 1 year ago 4
@comicification I share your opinion
ZZqezza 8 months ago
@MarieNC2
its about yoko silly...they had been apart and john wrote all these songs for yoko and sean..which would be on double fantasy...this one never made it
ZAPDUNGAA 1 year ago
@ZAPDUNGAA Hmmm, but this demo was made in 1978, when John was back with Yoko. It sounds like it's about someone he's currently separated from & missing. That's why I'd guess it's for someone else, but it's impossible to know for sure.
MarieNC2 1 year ago
@MarieNC2
maybe Julian?
danny3flip 1 year ago
I couldn't agree more.. this song is simply beautiful the way it is.. absolute perfection. Thank you for having this available, I love it so very much! xox
ThisBirdHazFlown 1 year ago
When I die and my soul goes to haven I hope God will switch on his cd player and will let me listen to all albums the Beatles could record from 1970 untill now...
SN5N 1 year ago 3
@SN5N lolwut?
ThomMac777 1 year ago
@SN5N I'm with you there, some new doors and zeppelin would also be awsome.
themaskedbassplayer6 1 year ago
simply one of the greatest songs ever written, his melodies in this are completely hauntingly beautiful.
flarbton 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
mp3iffy now lets you grab cd-quality VEVO videos and HD YouTube videos to convert into mp3s. AWESOME> google mp3iffy.
patiencefibrosi 1 year ago
Learn the lyrics and chords at,ultimateguitar.Tabbed by thesquire1.
Enjoy!!
TheThesquire 1 year ago
how could they release with just paul and ringo george is dead so where's his part in it?
grundy901 1 year ago
This...is absolutely beautiful.
mileyisgod 1 year ago
great song...
JohnLennonLover9 1 year ago
piano lesson please..
jlengfan 1 year ago
hermosoo!! *-*
Veliove 1 year ago
I know it's true
It's all because of you
And if I make it thru
It's all because.....of you
And now and then
If we must start again
Well we will know for sure
That I...I...love you
markmvt 1 year ago 5
The song is already finished
bruceleeC64 1 year ago 2
If and when Paul and/or Ringo finish this song, I just hope they include John's beautiful piano solo as a coda.
abigar93 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
First: To make a record by singing and playing over a dead man' s voice is HORRIBLE. Second: this song wasn' t intended for the Beatles so Paul and Ringo shouldn' t do this crap like they shouldn' t have done with "Free as a bird" and "Real Love"
MarcoZucchi81 1 year ago
If this song is ever finished by Paul and/or Ringo, I just hope that they have coda at the end of the song with John's piano solo.
abigar93 1 year ago 2
Just been to NYC to where he was shot - Already been to his house in Scouseland.
What a tragic end his life had...wonder if he would be revered so much had he not been murdered...who knows?
rumtumbugger 2 years ago 2
The raw emotion of this song tears at my heart!!! John's music is true love, true conviction, true emotion, true heart and soul!!!
whiskersdog77 2 years ago 2
Beautiful. Thanks John. R.I.P.
unnuevosiglo 2 years ago 3
Lennons demos are so good , its tough for the threetles to create a better version
bruceleeC64 2 years ago 13
This wasnt restored , this was the original take, with the other take damaged..
bruceleeC64 2 years ago
the year?
k0stil 2 years ago
Really great song....
JohnLennonLover9 2 years ago 3
This is such a beautiful song of his. Even if they could, I don't think they should make this into a Beatles song. It's perfect raw, the way it is.
sophielouisesimon 2 years ago 56
I agree sir.
MindGamesForAll 2 years ago
@sophielouisesimon I totally agree, this one is extra special..pure Lennon..
bruceleeC64 1 year ago
@sophielouisesimon I agree, Lennons demos/songs were so good most couldnt be improved on
bruceleeC64 1 year ago
@sophielouisesimon So was Free As A Bird and they did a wonderful work. I think it´s a drag that George refused to do it. I really hope that Paul and Ringo do it.
PERROMALDO 9 months ago
@sophielouisesimon I enjoy the simplicity of Lennon's songs as much as the next guy but only if the Beatles worked on this song would it then become an epic
BeatlesLover39 5 months ago
Comment removed
MarcoZucchi81 5 months ago
Paul has said how he'd like to finish this song with Ringo...
beatlejim64 2 years ago 3
This would be GREAT as a new Beatles song.... if only the Threetles completed it in 1995.
McCartnee 2 years ago 3
How sound recording people long for a technology that can separate vocals from instruments, even on a demo tape like this...
Falenas 2 years ago
It will never exist. because too many frequencies of the voice and piano overlap. If it was a kick drum, you might have a reasonable chance - but no one will ever be able to extract a multi-track recording from a mono source without obvious problems.
famachris 2 years ago
Celemony Melodine exists already it does exactly that. Never say never my friend.
SIGNATURESOUNDZ 2 years ago
@famachris True, But if you had Retouch by Cambridge posibly you could which is impossible to get without request from them
JoGeogiRiPaul 2 years ago
@Falenas i did it
JoGeogiRiPaul 2 years ago
That's really wonderful!I played it on the guitar, and it sounds great too! Great Lennon song!
surduburdu 2 years ago 2
what are the lyrics of this song?
itsnotgoodforme 2 years ago
Lennon will live on for centuries like Beethoven
eyeknou2 2 years ago 7
still love u lennon... ur the best always.. ur fan # 1 wherever u are....
Lveronica79 2 years ago 2
where is this version from?
bruceleeC64 2 years ago
Sean and Julian TOGETHER should do a cover... a duet!
MarcoZucchi81 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think Julian is not a very good musican or singer.
ToaKopha 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ToaKopha, I think you're a tosser.
Keruaran 2 years ago
N00b...
ToaKopha 2 years ago
lol... comment fail, I rest my case.
Keruaran 2 years ago
Comment removed
ToaKopha 2 years ago
Come on Paul, if this is genuine do your best to release it! Only you could clean it up, help your old mate with the high notes!
jocknyono 2 years ago 84
this is a really good job! wow
guywithguitars 2 years ago
i kinda like it all scratchy and dirty
thecolorblack3 2 years ago 4
sweet darling
Esta então dói no coração de tão linda!
Veralucy 2 years ago
I would love for this to be released. Even though I like what is called the "1995 edit" to here an offcial release by the Beatles would be fantastic and a great thrill if it is on Rock Band or released as a single if the Beatles go on iTunes.
jericho360 2 years ago
can someone send me this song
fandino123 2 years ago
I want to fall asleep to this. (I need music to go to sleep)
SusannaKaysen1 2 years ago 4
Wow, this is the cleanest version I've heard of this song vocally!
weatherman15 2 years ago
never heared this b4,...nice ...!!!
carlos7217 2 years ago
I guess Mccartney finished work on this song and a Beatles version is comming out soon
WorkingKlassHero 2 years ago
Where did you hear that? It's awesome if true. I know he has said recently that he wants to finish it.
THEum3k 2 years ago
various spots over the internet, they said all four beatles appear on the track and mccartney spent like the past two or three years working on it. just type "now and then finished" on google and read about it
WorkingKlassHero 2 years ago
I certainly hope it's true, but I'll keep a healthy level of skepticism. If they release it as a download, that's one download I would buy in a heartbeat. And I normally refrain from doing so.
THEum3k 2 years ago
It should be released just the way it is as it's already perfect.
easternshorefilamsoc 2 years ago 4
completely agree.
PleaseDontBeLong 2 years ago 2
I was just roaming around on You Tube and than I saw this video on someone's channel! Lennon's voice struck me with unbelievable power! And now I'm left in all that emotional shit.. I don't know whether to cry or smile! I'm just speechless! Great song and a very beautiful melody!
kreeepyy 2 years ago 4
wow..... i really cease to adore this song..... i feel the same way as when i heard it for the first time...
i love it...
JohnLennonLover9 2 years ago 3
woow it is asome john 4ever
nano952 2 years ago 3
B-E-A-U-T-I-F-U-L
i ADORE this song....makes me sad yet kind of happy at the same time...sounds very emotional
JohnLennonLover9 2 years ago 7
Does anyone actually have this "At Home" album? If so, how are the other songs in this album? decent?
spikypirate 2 years ago
yes indeed they are, it's half acoustic guitar and half piano.
it's great, he has such nice melodies.
streetgeezer 2 years ago 3
yeah i just got it a few days ago. Cant believe some of these were never released.. very good melodies indeed
spikypirate 2 years ago 2
That' s one of the best songs by John Lennon, isn' t it?
MarcoZucchi81 2 years ago 2
lennon will never die
JohnStick22 2 years ago 6
VERY GREAT !!!!!!!
Stefer77 2 years ago 3
haunting
mickeybelfast1969 2 years ago 4
i love this, i really do
toneDeFguitar 2 years ago
Where can I get this "At Home" album?!
shoolie3333 2 years ago
it's a bootleg CD.. it came out in February, so try googling it to track it down.
johnnyspork 2 years ago
ahi se ve el talento, la capacidad para componer y crear canciones que aun despues de muerto quedan para la posteridad. Una bella melodia, a mi punto de vista se oye mejor solo que con the beatles
abogadopenalista 2 years ago
This is great quality! so awesome that all the background noise is gone.
thegloaming09 2 years ago 2
Awesome
Yesterday2294 2 years ago
i though the lyrics would be a lot more clear, but it really shows that it's still missing a few words
ultimanovaful 2 years ago
So moving...We miss you,John!
ParaskeviKoutouba 2 years ago 5
Man this is GREAT!! I have been listening to the grainy version for ten years!! You rock!
valmorris 2 years ago 3
This is nothing short of miraculous. Far superior quality to other versions. Was it a lucky find or great audio technical skill?
AlexWatchingVids 2 years ago 3
@AlexWatchingVids this is the original version. Others were copies prob. Yokos one she gave to Paul
bruceleeC64 1 year ago
How did you remove the buzzing noise. This is great!!! Thanks for posting :)
LennonForever38 2 years ago 2
Best version of this demo I've ever heard. Why didn't the Threetles have this clean recodring to overdub stuff onto? They claimed the tape they had had bad static that couldn't be removed. Not here!
tamioftroy 2 years ago 2
I was wondering the same thing, maby technology has come a long way in 14 years
WorkingKlassHero 2 years ago 2
It'd be interesting if they took apart the Free as a Bird multitrack too... they might be able to reclean the original vocals.
BlueDiscProductions 2 years ago
They should do that for the new remasters comming out
WorkingKlassHero 2 years ago
Yeah, it'd be a nice include on Past Masters - I don't like loading the entire Anthology Collection onto my MP3 player, it's not for casual listening
BlueDiscProductions 2 years ago