Out of the three girls i find Bebe's voice to be the more attractive and well controlled voice.. Sheila's so much...Having played Maggie before, i and it being my favourite role, i have high standards , so this girl really doesn't cut it for me, her vibrato was all over the place, she couldn't hit the high notes very well and her attempt was very cracky. Overall Bebe was the best one out of the three.
yeahh was a little bit off on the harmonies but otherwise it was very helpful for me, cause i'm playing the part of Bebe in my group's production in a week. :) good effort.
ok the girl who plays bebe needs to stop trying to sound like a pop star and trying to riff.. none of you'revoices are srong and you all fucked up a simple harmony.
I'm doing this show in the fall (playing Maggie) so I've been watching a lot of versions of this song and Ihave to say you're my favourite non-professional Bebe so far. You're the only performer who's got the emotion just right. The look on your face on "if not to her...well then to me" gave me shivers. Excellent job.
I don't want to get involved, but this fight is a bit petty, why don't you just agree that someone's poor physique doesn't apply to your opinions of these girls singing, they clearly aren't professional, but it is always good to seek the best in somebody and i myself being a tone deaf monkey think they did well but i prefer the pro version
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
blah blah blah fat cat....You're boring the hell outta me. Get over it. Get a life an quit harassing me. Your replies have really devastated me. Love you....me
Hmmm...fat can be temporary. Unfortunately for you, being an asshole is forever!
Actually, taste is subjective. Being a dickhead, on the other hand, is not. Thank you providing irrefutable evidence. Thank you for being a fine example of being "that guy."
These women are to be commended for being brave enough to lead their lives as they see fit, regardless of whatever commentary might be made about their bodies.
And, no, Ass, I'm not fat. But you ARE stupid. Thanks for the laughs!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
First of all...You don't know me bitch. Second... this a crappy off off off main street redention of a treasured musical. Third....Once someone posts this video on a public site, I have every right to voice my opinion about it, as honest as it may be. Fifth...usually only fat girls say that they aren't fat. Sixth...you're an ugly ddddumbass, permanenty fat, wannabe have you called Jenny yet, operators are standing by to talk to you.
Really, why all the venom? Did I hurt your teeny little feelings? Sorry that no one told you is was impolite to name call. Maybe your Mom was busy tending to other things - like apologizing to anyone who would listen about the placenta she was left to raise. Poor lady. My condolences go to her. Probably wishes to this day that she had given birth to a son... it's just sad.
Ohhhh, but look - you were able to count up to SIX. Good.For.You. (using small words so you can keep up!)
BTW, if you'll scroll down to MJHxoxo, you'll see an example of someone who was able to express that he was underwhelmed by this posting, yet able to also remain civil. Take lessons. I wasn't impinging upon your "rights" to post your opinions. Just know that they do not exist in a vacuum.
Lastly, re-read your last sentence. Your childlike shrillness oozes with every misspelled, incorrectly punctuated thought you attempted. Slowing down and gathering your thoughts will make it clearer. LOL
You three girls did a terrific job on this number...exceptionally good...especially notable was "Maggie", your high E was so strong, good for you...really enjoyed your rendition from both a musical and staging pov..
@amiNuse NO! You guys were great:) That person is just jealous and annoying! I'm being honest I loved the acting and singing! This is one of my favs:)
I can't believe bennie-whatever made that comment.
first of all, you shouldn't think that weighing whatever you weigh means you can't play a dancer. Have you ever seen Hairspray? Don't worry, I'm not saying you have the same appearance as tracey turnblad, but she is a phenominal dancer. when you sing your last solo line ("so beautiful...") you had so much passion in your voice, it was beautiful.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The high note is the most essential part of this song and you sing it well. The harmony parts show potential, but focus on singing your own part - treat each line as a separate melody. The 3-part harmonies were excellent. I hate to say it, but sorry, but you can't be this heavy and play a dancer.
I think she's wonderful, and the fact that she's a little fleshy gives plausibility to the character. There's nothing wrong with having curves, jackass.
Am I the only one who can't help but laugh when the thick one says "I WAS pretty"???
thehappyphantom84 3 weeks ago
@thehappyphantom84 ...probably.
amiNuse 3 weeks ago
Completely mad. There are NO overweight gypsies.
thisherecat2 6 months ago
the harmonies during the chorus are a little off
lesmizwicked55 8 months ago
the girl in the red (after sheila) was one of the best I have ever seen
InaKatsCanne 10 months ago
honestlyy, i think thety did a great jobb!
Gigglez482 1 year ago
Out of the three girls i find Bebe's voice to be the more attractive and well controlled voice.. Sheila's so much...Having played Maggie before, i and it being my favourite role, i have high standards , so this girl really doesn't cut it for me, her vibrato was all over the place, she couldn't hit the high notes very well and her attempt was very cracky. Overall Bebe was the best one out of the three.
Zanadu95 1 year ago
I saw all three at Olive garden the night after this performance
wonkavite 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
wonkavite 1 year ago
yeahh was a little bit off on the harmonies but otherwise it was very helpful for me, cause i'm playing the part of Bebe in my group's production in a week. :) good effort.
OhhMiiGosh22 1 year ago
wow - this is just terrible...talk about ruining a great piece of theatre - where was this...Des Moines?
jymbuss 1 year ago
ok the girl who plays bebe needs to stop trying to sound like a pop star and trying to riff.. none of you'revoices are srong and you all fucked up a simple harmony.
passodia2 1 year ago
they butchered that song!!
carly3579 2 years ago 4
i know its maggie and bebe in this song but who is the third girl?
RentHead711 2 years ago
@RentHead711 sheila :)
Mikkilov 2 years ago
these girls have flabby thighs
pheobedog 2 years ago
r u serious for curvy girls their thighs look pretty nice
sandee12341 2 years ago
love it<3 beautifully song
lwantsex85 2 years ago
Jellicle- I know. I thought it was too busy!
AJKLOPOTOSKI 2 years ago
I was Bebe! in performance of this! [: Whomever Bebe is sounds amazing!
rmines17 2 years ago
COOL!
jemimajellicle 2 years ago
Vocally brilliant,
blocking not so much.
Good job : )
AJKLOPOTOSKI 2 years ago
this song isn't suppossed to have much blocking..
JellicleCatsX 2 years ago
Really? they did a good job actually of basically using the iconic original Bennett staging so not sure which version you mean.
EricMontreal22 2 years ago
wow, maggie was fantastic!
aliauthor 2 years ago
I love your voice! It suits this piece perfectly, and it's rare to find singers that keep clarity of words even in their high registers.
minibkwrm 2 years ago
I'm doing this show in the fall (playing Maggie) so I've been watching a lot of versions of this song and Ihave to say you're my favourite non-professional Bebe so far. You're the only performer who's got the emotion just right. The look on your face on "if not to her...well then to me" gave me shivers. Excellent job.
Megfly 2 years ago
omg Amy I didnt know you were so talented. Gosh!
roxynikko2 2 years ago
That was REALLY good =]
TheTumblewheed 2 years ago
I didn't mind this performance.
Griffinrox999 2 years ago
I don't want to get involved, but this fight is a bit petty, why don't you just agree that someone's poor physique doesn't apply to your opinions of these girls singing, they clearly aren't professional, but it is always good to seek the best in somebody and i myself being a tone deaf monkey think they did well but i prefer the pro version
crossleyphoto 2 years ago
You guys are being ridiculous. They did good. They aren't broadway performers. Give em a break guys :D
BroadwayKing15 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
blah blah blah fat cat....You're boring the hell outta me. Get over it. Get a life an quit harassing me. Your replies have really devastated me. Love you....me
BDaviWA 2 years ago
Bored enough that you just HAD to make a reply? If you're really bored, then this post will just go unanswered by you. Well, see.
kittennyc 2 years ago
quite average singing and girls who couldn't really pass as dancers...
MJHxoxo 2 years ago
Was this the Ain't Misbehavin' gall back??
BDaviWA 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what is this? Chorus Line Supersize?
BDaviWA 2 years ago
... none of these girls are fat.
hannahbanana0094 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you must be blind...no there not fat...they're really fat
BDaviWA 2 years ago
These women are living their dream and doing their thing. There's one pig here....and it's YOU!
Grow up. *yawn*
kittennyc 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hmmmm...you obviously have no taste in real art, and you must be fat too you.
BDaviWA 2 years ago
*yawn*
Hmmm...fat can be temporary. Unfortunately for you, being an asshole is forever!
Actually, taste is subjective. Being a dickhead, on the other hand, is not. Thank you providing irrefutable evidence. Thank you for being a fine example of being "that guy."
These women are to be commended for being brave enough to lead their lives as they see fit, regardless of whatever commentary might be made about their bodies.
And, no, Ass, I'm not fat. But you ARE stupid. Thanks for the laughs!
kittennyc 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
First of all...You don't know me bitch. Second... this a crappy off off off main street redention of a treasured musical. Third....Once someone posts this video on a public site, I have every right to voice my opinion about it, as honest as it may be. Fifth...usually only fat girls say that they aren't fat. Sixth...you're an ugly ddddumbass, permanenty fat, wannabe have you called Jenny yet, operators are standing by to talk to you.
BDaviWA 2 years ago
Brent,
Really, why all the venom? Did I hurt your teeny little feelings? Sorry that no one told you is was impolite to name call. Maybe your Mom was busy tending to other things - like apologizing to anyone who would listen about the placenta she was left to raise. Poor lady. My condolences go to her. Probably wishes to this day that she had given birth to a son... it's just sad.
Ohhhh, but look - you were able to count up to SIX. Good.For.You. (using small words so you can keep up!)
kittennyc 2 years ago 2
BTW, if you'll scroll down to MJHxoxo, you'll see an example of someone who was able to express that he was underwhelmed by this posting, yet able to also remain civil. Take lessons. I wasn't impinging upon your "rights" to post your opinions. Just know that they do not exist in a vacuum.
Lastly, re-read your last sentence. Your childlike shrillness oozes with every misspelled, incorrectly punctuated thought you attempted. Slowing down and gathering your thoughts will make it clearer. LOL
kittennyc 2 years ago
Nice job Maggie!
Woo hoo!
tarynactress 2 years ago
¡Bravo!
Hedda1982 2 years ago
Harmony needs a little work. Way to go, Maggie! You'd make Kay Cole (the original Maggie on Broadway) proud!!!
Pugmomtammy 2 years ago
Maggie, you belted the number better than most Broadway casts than I have seen!
maxblddd 3 years ago
You three girls did a terrific job on this number...exceptionally good...especially notable was "Maggie", your high E was so strong, good for you...really enjoyed your rendition from both a musical and staging pov..
jotheodorou 3 years ago
WOW! that was amazing! this would be such a difficult musical to cast!
tvaholic 3 years ago
wow u are all really good!!!
YouCantPullMeDown16 3 years ago
work on ur voices you sound like your not comfortable belting, or singing high, try finding a good middle
tangomarueen 3 years ago
i think you were good your solo was so much like bebe
319FBMZ319 3 years ago
hey, i'm sing as bebe too! you sound good.
the camera angle is iffy (home video(?)) but the sound is good.
Kamami7 3 years ago
Yes! Maggie actually belted the high E! Yay! XD
gaarasandchick 3 years ago
Great staging, especially having the dancers revealed by slow lights, nice casting, lame direction & great orchestra.
inkforhire 3 years ago
Not bad. :)
Harmonies are iffy though.
ZorraTheExplora 3 years ago
You're Beautiful!!
tarzanDavidrocks 4 years ago
am I listening to the same thing? The pitch on the harmonies is terrible......yikes.
jpc2005 4 years ago 12
i do agree with that actually. too late to fix unfortunately haha.
amiNuse 4 years ago 3
@amiNuse NO! You guys were great:) That person is just jealous and annoying! I'm being honest I loved the acting and singing! This is one of my favs:)
NYCprincess7 5 months ago
the harmonies are hard. I also struggle with the 'do do dodo' bit, personaly.
my favorite bit (in general )is the 'up a steep..., to a voice...' bit :)
Kamami7 3 years ago
WOWOWOWOW. I loved it! :)
Nice job you guys! :D
dreamsofbroadway 4 years ago
Size makes makes no difference look at Elaine Stritch!
princessgothika 4 years ago
Great job!
BwayJnky 4 years ago
you guys are seriously amazing. thanks!
amiNuse 4 years ago 2
Bah, you can be ANY size that you want to and dance, and it'll still look great! More power to you, you sounded great!
TRoderick 4 years ago 4
that was great!
xDracoMalfoy 4 years ago
maggie's high note was great! reminded me of kay cole quite a bit!
nyactor926 4 years ago
watch the pitch...especially on the harmonies.
yeahurjealous22 4 years ago
I was bebe in acl this past summer also!
I can't believe bennie-whatever made that comment.
first of all, you shouldn't think that weighing whatever you weigh means you can't play a dancer. Have you ever seen Hairspray? Don't worry, I'm not saying you have the same appearance as tracey turnblad, but she is a phenominal dancer. when you sing your last solo line ("so beautiful...") you had so much passion in your voice, it was beautiful.
sugardancingstar 4 years ago
oh lol, ok thanks. :/ haha
amiNuse 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The high note is the most essential part of this song and you sing it well. The harmony parts show potential, but focus on singing your own part - treat each line as a separate melody. The 3-part harmonies were excellent. I hate to say it, but sorry, but you can't be this heavy and play a dancer.
bennie1955 4 years ago
fuck you... theyre wicked good, who are yu to say anything
shorterac989 4 years ago
I think she's wonderful, and the fact that she's a little fleshy gives plausibility to the character. There's nothing wrong with having curves, jackass.
theredsmileyface 4 years ago 20