Added: 3 years ago
From: DundeeBhoy2007
Views: 689,571
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (215)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he's got a way too

  • y'know, i never thought i would like billy joel when my mother asked for the album, but we were on a trip to see relatives and she put the cd in and i thought to myself, "oh my god im gonna die", but i actually really liked it, i never thought it was a type of music i would be into

  • I started my music collection as a 8yr. old. An aunt & uncle a few yrs. older, really contributed to that. We're talking mid-70's...they were awesome Singer/Songwriters! My collection started with Daddys 8tracks. Brand new blue record player and some 45's, I giggle thinkin bout it. : ) Elton John, Billy Joel, James Taylor, Carly Simon OMG nuff said. Best part, they just get better with age! Blows my mind...God I LOVE MUSIC!

  • A very polished and young Billy Joel. Thank you for putting this up. I would love to buy this Billy wink wink ;)

  • @rollingstone70 Glad you like, i'm sure the show is out there somewhere as torrent download.

  • His voice is so open and beautiful

  • If this song was a waffle, it'd be a very good waffle!

  • This comes from the man who was truly afraid of fame because he saw what it did to so many of his friends, this from a man who got everything, who loved everything, but people like this are destined to live a lonely path because of the society they are forced to live in. The generation of today is more linked to real unplugged talented artists then ever before. Its all over Youtube, believe me when I say there is more respect for raw talent then there ever was, come to Nashville.

  • @boonchili999 I hope you're right!

  • Americas answer to mcCartney

  • 17 people can't appreciate good original music.

  • I love you, Alison!

  • Nobody underrates Billy Joel except todays children who grew up wo a real music industry

  • @TopOfNewYork4 I agree. I am ashamed of the taste of my generation. (me being 13)

  • one of the most underrated vocalists in pop music

  • I'm learning how to play this on the piano. Billy Joel's the whole reason I even bothered teaching myself. I thought "I can play trumpet, guitar, bass, harmonica... It's time to use that ten year old keyboard in the corner." I've only been playing for a couple months, but I love it.

  • Comment removed

  • Great song!!

  • My boyfriend said he was listening to this song, coudn'tn't stop thinking about me and couldn't stop smiling(:

  • @hse2321 you are a lucky girl. Goodluck to both of you.

  • I love him.

  • ...so in love...:D

  • I feel like he's playing the version a tad fast, but whatevs, still one of my favorite songs of all time :)

  • this song makes me smile every time....i love it. :)

  • He sounds a tone higher than he is now.Great live performance, thanks for sharing.

  • @MrHerodogs He probably is a tone lower now. He had to do the same with piano man cause as he got older his voice changed and the song got too high to sing

  • Gulf + Western, whose Family Records originally released Joel's debut album, "Cold Spring Harbor", didn't care as much as the recording industry as CBS did. G+W's main concern was Paramount Pictures. CBS, on the other hand, had a recording division as profitable and prolific as their television network. You'll need a major city-sized phone book to list every album and single on the Columbia label alone!

  • Right I'm really confused. The original cut can be listened to on YouTube and it is in the same key as this live rendition. If his voice is too high on that album then so is the backing track, so all of it should be played faster and in a higher key. But his voice does sound higher, like a chipmunk as BJ puts it, so there is clearly something wrong with the original album release. Can anyone shed any light on this one?

  • Billy your voice sounds perfect at that time!!!!!

  • I miss this kind of music....with actual heartfelt lyrics...the crap that passes for "love songs" today is horrific.

  • @steelerlyn1017 you should listen to should have told you by Sammy Ray, its a great love song.. new music too!

  • and his voice sounds like that without editing.

  • Whoa, triple digit thumbs up! Thanks everyone!!

  • It sucks when Guys actually have a person that they love and subconsciously say "She's got a way" but it doesn't quite plan out that way. Im in New York and she's in London :(.... I really wanna move there and show up at her door like Movies, but reality strikes me and I comment her on Facebook and that's it :(

    Queens, NY

  • @freedomland11 go to fucking london man you can stay at mine if it fucks up REPLY IF YOU WANT TO BREAK FREE

  • @jewmeltintheovens..I would, seriously, but your youtube name kinda threw me off!!! reply back..I want an answer :)

  • @freedomland11 Haha same here

    she lives in adelaide tho

    Perth, Australia

  • @Jagwa3...You and I are on the same boat my friend :)...The good thing about your girl is she lives in Aussie. While I live in Queens, NY and she (London)...I went to london to audition for a theatre school there, and we met, and we spent the whole 3 days together with her friends and just having a blast...drinking wine and conversation the whole way through. I'm here and she's there!! how did u meet her?

  • @freedomland11 I was at a flamenco show in barcelona. We got talking and spent the rest of the night together. She flew home the next day....while i was stuck in Europe

  • I wish this type of music had a life to it. We would all be in a "New York State of MIND" :)....but sadly it isn't

  • What a brilliant voice.

  • my broken heart.The first song that comes to my mind.

    ♥♥♦(o→ܫ←人→ܫ←o) ♦♥♥

  • My all time favourite singer. He doesn't even need music. His voice is true and pitch perfect.

  • you now, these actual people comment on their on video. they watch it too.

  • ugh so beautiful! why can't music be this heartwarming

  • i actually wish music like this was in my era. i love Billy Joel and his music and is very much an inspiration to me. i hate being 16 and when i turn on the radio its some load of auto tuned rubbish with the exception of very few

  • Bless all the Long Island couples still together who took this song to heart!

  • my bf used to sing this song to me... then he died and now I have this beautiful memory, thanks Billy

  • @TheCapirena I am very sorry for your loss.

  • @TheRoland2222 me too... ty Roland

  • "she comes to me when im feeling down inspires me ,with out a sound she touches me and i get turned around", you cant find lyrics like that anymore.

  • billy is nasty. dont why it is

  • Bill Joel is a perfect example of a gifted, phenomenally talented individual musician. Unfortunately, the majority of mainstream musicianship today consists of writers writing for vocalists with a polished aesthetic and good PR rather than being a talented, original songwriter/musician. The term 'play what you write' doesn't seem to exist in the same way as it did in Billy Joels era.

  • his beautiful young voice....

  • Hopelessly Lovelorn Looking for someone!

  • love this man,genius songwriter

  • I would definitely sing this song for someone I really like

  • goosebumps

  • Cheers for the excellent post...brings back teenage / underage seedy pianobar drinkin'...

  • @willmillr6 amen brother

  • I once had a guy who thought of me that way. I miss that!!!!

  • Artie Ripp pressed dislike 9 times after hearing this.

  • A song that a very good friend dedicated to me.

  • @mskitco Friend? Beautiful song.

  • unglaublich schön!!

  • Man that's fast lol Still great though. My dad played guitar on that album. His name is in the liner notes (remember liner notes?!) Sal DiTroia.

  • Love the sounds, I can listen to this stuff all the time.Watch out for new artist BRANDON JAROD. This guy is the next superstar! Release OCT. 2010

  • I sang this to my wife at our wedding and my one of former-criminal buddies cryed.

  • @onetime504

    ohhh lol sorry to grab a chuckle, But I so understand. Good for you, May love carry you beyond. This is a great song.  Had to speak up, and more power to you both, Keeping the love, Keeping the Faith!!!

  • he looks pissed off the whole time, i can't blame him.......making .50 on his first album. because of some jackass record producer. he still performed.

  • I sang this song to our pomeranian Maggie May , when we first got her back in `07 I played this song , and everytime I hear it I think of her!

  • so good live

  • WHAT HAPPENED TO MY CHILDHOOD AND ALL THE GOOD SONGS ? THUNDER IN THE DISTANCE. MISS YOU ALL !

  • Thank you for the emotion !!!!!! Billy

  • cool

  • coo

  • Where was this performed? Anyone know?

  • This is real music

  • My 15 year old son said recently that this is one of the best song ever wrriten. He sings it very well too...

  • Billy Joel is the best ever in history!

  • All ways makes me tear up, classic.

  • Jane

  • i hope my boyfriend feels this way about me. i love this song!

  • @MsAshleywarren  If he doesn't I do.

  • What has happened to all the videos of the songs I listen to? It just isnt the same without them. I know some songs dont have a studio video but somewhere there must be an inconcert video.

  • @Iseeme63 I know I'm wondering the same too? None of them have an actual concert video or any video of this song...

  • I was in high school when this song came out, I am lucky that I got to see many things in my life, and I too also say that I wish I had been born earlier, I guess every generation says the same thing.

  • i do like this song..during this time god has plan for me....to get born..anyway not yet born...i like it much.

  • @jusvenfin what the fuck does that mean? Wierd comment !

  • music today sucks what happened to talent... or real artists..?

  • @foreverblunted718 The thing is, not all music today sucks. Susan Boyle's voice is totally gorgeous and everything she sings hits the soul directly. Amazing singer.

  • to my darling wife krystal i love you always and forever

  • That light is god i think we take everything thing our parents do and things they give for granted but when they are gone the emptiness reveals how much they touched us .

  • I really love the piano run at 2:22-- Can't find it on any other version of this song...

  • Billy, he's got a way about him.

  • Love It!

  • AWESOME!!! Great audio on this!!

  • to my Jane

  • WOW, he's a ventriloquist!

  • Any guy that listens to this and thinks "that's my girl!" Hold on to her, she's priceless.

  • Nice comment.  You are right.

  • @willmillr6 she wont let me

  • @willmillr6 God damn I let her go.

  • @willmillr6 thats really sweet and thats how I want my man to feel about me, if he doesn't, its time to let go......and find one who does!!

  • one of my fav ever ever ever:D

  • Bella

  • i love my girl this way, forever.

  • you see, this is back when being "famous" actually required an exceptionally good skill or talent...tweeting what you had for breakfast doesnt count!

  • WELL SAID!

  • Very well said!

  • @xJustDontBiteItx so true.

  • @xJustDontBiteItx Like Susan Boyle today. What an amazing talent that woman has!

  • @xJustDontBiteItx "famous" required more than looks!

  • @xJustDontBiteItx

    YEP....exactly....shame that is not the way it is anymore.....

  • @xJustDontBiteItx

    I could not agree more. Billy Joel is an example of a truly talented musician.

  • @xJustDontBiteItx Here Here! Fucking twitter!!!!!

  • @xJustDontBiteItx I disagree, i believe that the tweeted size of Kim Kardashian's bowel movement is grounds for being famous.

  • @xJustDontBiteItx i had a bagel with a little cream cheese

  • ///....wondrfl in masters performance at any speed/we just learn to breath quicker after 30 years of love and respect in the FORMER USSR//

  • thanks both for understanding///

  • His voice is so cute and his songs are magic to my ears! :)

  • this is such a sweet song and is so uplifting

  • slower album version blows you away

  • billy joel rocks my socks

  • This song explains why God created women. Epic lyrics.

  • i've always wanted to be this girl.

  • song always makes me tear up when im with my girl - billy joel is a genius ....... period .

  • this is an amazing song!!

  • Perfect !

  • His musical logic is so much better than mine

  • <3 <3 <3

  • great song, i love it

  • mom is my strength as was dad . strength comes in all forms friends family all kinds of places. rodygirl33 indeed you are someones muse because you effect those who love you .

  • Comment removed

  • wow I rekckon i listened to this like 7 times in a row amazing

  • Is he playing the Beatles' 'Let It Be' around 00:28? Or are those relatively common chords and he's just screwing around? It's rather a short one-second clip, so maybe I'm just employing my hyper-active imagination, but I know that he's a Beatles fan....

  • ya it did

  • Aervane: I think that first chord is a D7 which is extremely common and COULD be the opening chord of 'Let It Be' but the second chord is not. Yes, Billy screws around on the piano a lot, including during his live shows. And yes, he is a huge Beatles fan. After stadium shows he used to play "Good Night" as sung by the late George Harrison over the PA system.

  • ringo sang good night

  • whatwhatwhat is the other instrument in this song? is it synthesizer?? I DONT KNOW! can someone please help me out?

  • It's a nasty ol' synthesizer.

  • sounds like an accordion.

  • One of the greatest songs of all times.

  • ... dont what it is. but there doesn't have to be a reason anyway.

  • Someone, please post an original version because this isn't a patch on it. I still love the song though.

  • how can you go wrong with billy joel? you can't.

  • How come there aren't versions of the original recording on youtube?

    Anyway, this is great. Fantastic stuff.

  • the original recording is messed up because the album "Cold Spring Harbor" was sped up.....the re-release in the 80's tried to fix some things but it still sounds funky.....this version is amazing.

  • Sooo beautiful.

  • amazing song and musician

  • this is a good song i have to do a solo for choir

  • great song!

    my friend is singing this song as well in choir, and he is so good

  • Rare, if this is real audio. Humm? I believe it's real! This is great stuff.

  • Awesome.

  • Beautiful song though. Sho nuff.

  • It's a show, not just a jukebox. True fans are not only fans of the music, but fans of the artist.

  • He gives out tid bits that I find very interesting. Who wants to listen to a robot that will just sing. Be a human during a concert.

  • Gotta be the dumbest comment i've seen all day... actually in a while....

  • nah , i don't like it =(

  • His voice is amazing =]

  • johnboy song...

  • this is totally a "Johnboy" song!!!

  • googling "johnboy". The only Johnboy I know is from the "Waltons".....goodnight, Johnboy.

  • I saw them in Atlanta last night 3-14-09

  • for what?

    ...

  • that man has a ""GREAT"" voice

  • im seeing billy joel (and elton john!) this summer and i can now die happy. i love it i love it i love it

  • LUCKY!

    where are you seeing them?

  • You have officially made me very jealous

  • ME TOO!!! I'm going to see them in DC July 11!!

  • i just saw them both last night in charlotte. it was amazing

  • I love this song!

    About a week ago I recorded myself singing this song and I gave it to my friend. I then had him give it to someone I like. Now I'm 15 and I now have a girlfriend!!

    This song changes people! I love it! Sing it in front of a girl and you'll have a great life!

  • i love this song my dad gave me my first billy joel cd and i loved this song hes amazing

  • Beautiful

  • Perfect. Check out my rendition also....