ja sama u4jusj na opernom otdelenii i mne o4enj prijatno, 4to estj na kogo ravnjatsja...Elina Garan4a iz moego goroda, i mne tak zhe prijatno osoznovatj, 4to na6i pevci izvestni za predelami Latvii...eto dejstviteljno samoe genialjnoe ispolnenie, kotoroe ja sli6ala...
I hope an operatic recording Offenbach's Barcarolle was among the pieces of music included on the disc NASA sent with the spacecraft Voyager to distant galaxies.
Великолепно поют - но это, очевидно, генеральная репетиция? Не одеты они, как полагаются...Наверное, во время концерта ещё лучше пели, нет сомнения...
I agree that Caballe/Verrett pairing is better in comparison with this performance. However, this seems to be a kind of rehearsal where the singers work on their voices and less on their expression. Anna seems suffering while singing, Elina is beautiful but a bit harsh, like a wild cat. Anyway, they will be diva's when much older and fat... Try to listen to their voices without looking at them (roll the video) . They are really good.
Potència, matisos, força, bellesa... una meravella. Tant l'Elina com l'Anna tenen una veu i una tècnica excelents. I per la seva joventut, un futur esplèndit.
L'orquestra i els cors fantàstics, l'orquestra boníssima, i l'enregistrament perfecte.
@onotuoedaul Shoot? No. Have someone in her place in this piece? Yes. Maybe Renee Fleming... Someone who doesn't just have a good voice and sings but also feels the poetry of music, like Elina.
Garanca and Netrebko are wonderful, beautiful and young. But Sutherland, Horne, Caballé, Berganza shall not be dismissed in front of these two young stars.
Time will say if they will reach the heights of their predecessors. Meantime, let's hear them all and enjoy the wonder of human voice!!
@monicasacco Direi che quelle che ha elencato sono molto meglio di lei, e non dimentichiamo la Verrett, la Freni e la Scotto... questo duetto é passabile e piace soprattutto perché cantano due ben dotate esteticamente.
One always has to remember that we see two of the greatest singers of our time. Singing together in perfection - adding up to almost one multi coloured voice - not acting against each other or trying to exceed the other.
This is outstanding and we all should feel grateful to hear them in their century.
Anna N., is Insuperable, and I also in a punctuation of 1 to 10, with 1 being the lowest note, I give to Anna N. A score of 10 and Elina Garanca a score 8 .
That's very enjoyable- it is interesting to see them singing in a rehearsal setting. The Barcarolle has so much more meaning when it is sung away from the rest of the opera- it's so moving, and I rarely notice it as such during the full "Hoffmann."
@AminaBellini This comment makes me very happy. It's a huge privilege, a unique opportunity, be able to watch such beautiful divas. It is a special time for me.
@AlcidesConstante ..how nice you enjoyed my comment!!! i really admire both singers...besides i love this duet "Barcarolle"...i sang it many times in concerts...it´s so beautifull!!! nice to meet you.
I love this video, thank you, whoever posted it. Such emotion, such co-operative harmony, with both women singing with each other, not trying to out-do one another. I enjoy the informal attire worn by these consummate professionals when they're out of the public eye, but still at work. Gives it a 'Saturday afternoon at the park' look, and let's face it, the price is right! Hats off to the main singers, to the choir, the conductor, and the orchestra. Top Notch!
Ah! I Have listened to these two ladies other duets and they do define great harmony indeed- great match up of voices! I'm a Netrebko fan and will listen to more of Garanca from now on as well. ;-)
Both are amazing... I love their voices!
thonycg93 1 week ago
Space beauty!!! Try also Kristina Bitenc and Monika Bohinec Barcarola.
zevnikov 1 week ago
Kak trudno im pet i kak oni daje ne umeiut skryt etogo
bertoluccio 1 month ago
Oh wow! Breath taking! Beautiful!
elodie0921 1 month ago
Absolute perfection!
999ploop 1 month ago
How can two women be so lucky to be double blessed.Mind you we have lovely and a most beautiful singer,the welsh nightingale Katherine Jenkins.
boz1929 2 months ago
yes! Melts my heart!
zjbeast 2 months ago
ja sama u4jusj na opernom otdelenii i mne o4enj prijatno, 4to estj na kogo ravnjatsja...Elina Garan4a iz moego goroda, i mne tak zhe prijatno osoznovatj, 4to na6i pevci izvestni za predelami Latvii...eto dejstviteljno samoe genialjnoe ispolnenie, kotoroe ja sli6ala...
Anastasija261 2 months ago
Это гениально! Пожалуй лучшее из лучших исполнений!!!!!
MsTastylife 2 months ago
Kudos Kudos, what a very beautiful, heavenly performance. I like a great deal of songs / genre. Not a lot *really* toches me. This DOES.
kdfrkdfr 2 months ago 4
Levanten la mano los que quieren que Netrebko grabe SALOME de Strauss!!
nicolashrv 3 months ago
2:16 :)
jaquijaquijaqui 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Exquisite! I have to watch this several times a week; even several times a day often.
Houdi2 3 months ago
I did only dare to breathe a few times while watching and listening to this, honest!
tomhits 3 months ago
Божественно!
fromUrals 3 months ago
I have a dvd of Elina as Carmen playing in/with the MET-NewYork.
There is simply no better Carmen available.
Carmen full of fire, as she should be.
I recommend it to everyone.
paparkstad1 3 months ago
anna e muito bonita
e Elina tambem
EMANUEL5692 3 months ago
Netrebko's voice is as pure as water.
tumtillia 3 months ago
Once again Netrebko proves to be the greatest opera singer ever!
tumtillia 3 months ago
@tumtillia
Then you must not have heard or seen much Opera!
prince2000ful 3 months ago
Bravo!
kaboodle24 3 months ago
Брависсимо!!! Это просто бесподобно!!! Только такая красота спасёт мир... Дай Бог Вам, девочки, дай Бог!!!
Bard671 4 months ago
DIVINAS, LAS AMO, LAS ADORO!!
Calaf120 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Netrebko has a face like a pig.
Baritanist 4 months ago
@Baritanist безусловно, эти красивые. Слушайте музыку. идиот. I am currently in Russia and I can tell you she is beautiful.
THESPINTO 4 months ago
@THESPINTO After a liter of vodka maybe.
Baritanist 4 months ago
@Baritanist lol
GANGSTAELPASO 3 months ago
Magnificent simply magnificent
MultiProffessor 4 months ago
Piękny utwór, piękne wykonanie, mógłbym słuchać bez końca, zachwycające !!!
jaras1410 4 months ago
they're great! thanks!
sgerianda 4 months ago
still wonderful!!
Sabine0707 5 months ago
Muzykę należy umieć słuchać, dostrzec w niej treść, zrozumieć a nawet zobaczyć. Utwór ten i jego wykonanie jest czystą formą piękna.
Arkadiusz991963 5 months ago
first time i heard them.... BRAVO!!!!
sisodongcan 5 months ago
Hermoso, que belleza!!
fasalamancagu 5 months ago
I hope an operatic recording Offenbach's Barcarolle was among the pieces of music included on the disc NASA sent with the spacecraft Voyager to distant galaxies.
CDMOOVEE 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The melody is absolutely beautiful. The voices are great. What a great operatic piece of art. Such a romantic melody.
VIRIATO1942 5 months ago
Великолепно поют - но это, очевидно, генеральная репетиция? Не одеты они, как полагаются...Наверное, во время концерта ещё лучше пели, нет сомнения...
CiboCeleste 6 months ago
@CiboCeleste Я думаю это съемка с записи диска "Souvenirs". Вся сцена уставлена микрофонами.
channikll 5 months ago
Anna Netrebko Forever !!
Higbby 6 months ago
an exellent mix of brilliant voices and a harmonyfull orchestra
mahuubao 6 months ago
божественный голос!
dimast007 6 months ago
Realy superbe
rubisi57 6 months ago
Sweet Child Of Mine
TRANQUILLUS88 6 months ago
just great, words are no t enough this time
lafabricadelcielo 7 months ago
I have many times watched and listened "Barcarolle" by Anna Netrebko and Elina Garanca, and every time I look and listen to it as a miracle ...
modrisdraba 8 months ago
I agree that Caballe/Verrett pairing is better in comparison with this performance. However, this seems to be a kind of rehearsal where the singers work on their voices and less on their expression. Anna seems suffering while singing, Elina is beautiful but a bit harsh, like a wild cat. Anyway, they will be diva's when much older and fat... Try to listen to their voices without looking at them (roll the video) . They are really good.
eilonj 9 months ago
Don't forget the fantastic musical introduction to this masterpiece.
eilonj 9 months ago
Wow! This is just superb! What a marvelous oasis of "life". Just terrific....
altongrimes 9 months ago
The tempo is far too fast, it doesn't feel like languid romance as it should. Prefer Caballe/Verrett pairing.
FoggyRoad81 9 months ago
love it so much when they sing together.
avnoimportance 9 months ago
OMG is the first time that i listen that voice. Very wonderful!
TuningBoy320Ci 10 months ago
OMG! Magic really exists!!! So beautiful! Perfection in art (& earth!) is possible!!!
karine357 10 months ago
Potència, matisos, força, bellesa... una meravella. Tant l'Elina com l'Anna tenen una veu i una tècnica excelents. I per la seva joventut, un futur esplèndit.
L'orquestra i els cors fantàstics, l'orquestra boníssima, i l'enregistrament perfecte.
Un autèntic plaer .
tonijuanet 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Life is really beautifull listening to them sing most reflective and soul searching
Satishsathyanarayana 1 year ago
Life is really beautifull listening to them sing most reflective and soul searching
Satishsathyanarayana 1 year ago
Prekrasno!!!! Bravo!!!
oksana116 1 year ago
Buona la Garanca, troppo scura la Netbreko
numetutelare 1 year ago
Uau ..amazing
blanc124 1 year ago
2 of my favorite sopranos:) yay. lol
bookysipod 1 year ago
could anyone please shoot anna for me please?
onotuoedaul 1 year ago
@onotuoedaul Shoot? No. Have someone in her place in this piece? Yes. Maybe Renee Fleming... Someone who doesn't just have a good voice and sings but also feels the poetry of music, like Elina.
espritlibre96 10 months ago
Garanca and Netrebko are wonderful, beautiful and young. But Sutherland, Horne, Caballé, Berganza shall not be dismissed in front of these two young stars.
Time will say if they will reach the heights of their predecessors. Meantime, let's hear them all and enjoy the wonder of human voice!!
monicasacco 1 year ago
@monicasacco Direi che quelle che ha elencato sono molto meglio di lei, e non dimentichiamo la Verrett, la Freni e la Scotto... questo duetto é passabile e piace soprattutto perché cantano due ben dotate esteticamente.
numetutelare 1 year ago
Simply beauttiful singing
Sebastian740 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Quiero llorar
I feel my tears go out
The2011dreamcatcher 1 year ago
Quiero llora
I feel my tears go out
The2011dreamcatcher 1 year ago
hermosas voces...Me hicieron soñar por un momento...:)
rosubea22 1 year ago
One always has to remember that we see two of the greatest singers of our time. Singing together in perfection - adding up to almost one multi coloured voice - not acting against each other or trying to exceed the other.
This is outstanding and we all should feel grateful to hear them in their century.
krainermich 1 year ago 53
Куанто кабен лас карас, лас персоналидадес... Сон ун дуо перфекто, муи сенсуал е интенсо!
Riverplatista 1 year ago
Perfect. They sing this piece as one just as Caballe and Verrett.
muatlas 1 year ago
braviiiiibellas
camtep2you 1 year ago
This is more than music, it`s balm for my soul. Yes, medicine from another world. Thanks for posting it.
demirham 1 year ago
Well, damn!! Damn!!! That was just so exquisite!! Just perfection!
Peppi94 1 year ago
magnifique!!
defda94 1 year ago
Maravilloso
vicmancop 1 year ago
FANTASTIQUE!!!
cuoylyf 1 year ago
Sehr schön!!! magnifica interpretación!!! beautifull performance!!!! Elina Garanca & Anna Netrebbko!!!!!!
AminaBellini 1 year ago
Heavenly. Anna and Elina, always beautiful together.
YT102008 1 year ago
Anna N., is Insuperable, and I also in a punctuation of 1 to 10, with 1 being the lowest note, I give to Anna N. A score of 10 and Elina Garanca a score 8 .
Both women are beautyful .
Vencvic 1 year ago
That's very enjoyable- it is interesting to see them singing in a rehearsal setting. The Barcarolle has so much more meaning when it is sung away from the rest of the opera- it's so moving, and I rarely notice it as such during the full "Hoffmann."
LondonLite02 1 year ago
And, again...
I love Elina Garanca, her beauty and sensuality...
Anna Netrebko is wonderful...
Both singers are virtuoses and her voices are heavenly.
The video is a perfection.
Bravo!!! Bravo!!! Bravo!!!
AlcidesConstante 1 year ago
@AlcidesConstante ....yes both are perfect...I agree with you!!!! beauty and talent!!!!! charm and sensuality!!! and of course excellet voices!!!!
AminaBellini 1 year ago
@AminaBellini This comment makes me very happy. It's a huge privilege, a unique opportunity, be able to watch such beautiful divas. It is a special time for me.
AlcidesConstante 1 year ago
@AlcidesConstante ..how nice you enjoyed my comment!!! i really admire both singers...besides i love this duet "Barcarolle"...i sang it many times in concerts...it´s so beautifull!!! nice to meet you.
AminaBellini 1 year ago
@AminaBellini It's a pleasure to meet you, Andrea!
AlcidesConstante 1 year ago
@AlcidesConstante Meravigliosa!!! grazie Alcides!! Love Isis
cuoylyf 1 year ago
@cuoylyf Really, they are wondrous!!!
AlcidesConstante 1 year ago
I haven't seen a better version and can only aspire to match the greatness of this performance! Bravissimo!
GogoYobari 1 year ago
Their voices really complement each other here.
C'est un vraiment beau chant;))) Offenbach would be very pleased, i think;)
AlexV1408 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ASS ALERT!! ASS ALERT !!
StriKER9410`s ASS ODOR HAS BEEN DECLARED an International Environmental Hazard !!!
STRIKER9410 IS GAY, FAG, SISSY AND HIS ASS IS DISGUSTING.
Royhorse1 1 year ago
Molemmat ovat mahtavia ja ihastuttavia solisteja kuulla.
pipariitta 1 year ago
I love Elina Garanca, her beauty and sensuality...
Anna Netrebko is wonderful...
Both singers are virtuoses and her voices are heavenly.
The video is a perfection.
Bravíssimas!!!
VideosAlcides 1 year ago 92
@VideosAlcides Elina's voice is like butter, and she's perfectly intonated.
leoniemikele 1 year ago
@VideosAlcides
"Both singers are virtuoses and her voices are heavenly!" - I suppose, there isn't possible to say better!
MrModrisdraba 9 months ago
Comment removed
MrModrisdraba 9 months ago
@VideosAlcides
"Both singers are virtuoses and her voices are heavenly!" - I suppose, there isn't possible to say better!
MrModrisdraba 9 months ago
@VideosAlcides
I love this video, thank you, whoever posted it. Such emotion, such co-operative harmony, with both women singing with each other, not trying to out-do one another. I enjoy the informal attire worn by these consummate professionals when they're out of the public eye, but still at work. Gives it a 'Saturday afternoon at the park' look, and let's face it, the price is right! Hats off to the main singers, to the choir, the conductor, and the orchestra. Top Notch!
kidfromberlin 9 months ago
BEAUTIFUL !! Elina was magnificent in the MET's CARMEN. and Anna is always my favourite.
farasheh 2 years ago
@farasheh Yes! I was at the Met for the Jan 16 matinee. Heard her Sophie in "Werther" at the Vienna Staatsoper last May, too.
KozenaFan 2 years ago
maxpowermezzo 2 years ago 2
Ah! I Have listened to these two ladies other duets and they do define great harmony indeed- great match up of voices! I'm a Netrebko fan and will listen to more of Garanca from now on as well. ;-)
7thViking 2 years ago
Maravilloso !!!!!!!!!!!!
andaluciabrava 2 years ago
Excellent singing!
balaurusu 2 years ago